Kate Bernheimer - Fairy Tale Review, The White Issue (2009)
Kate Bernheimer - Fairy Tale Review, The White Issue (2009)
Kate Bernheimer - Fairy Tale Review, The White Issue (2009)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
:U]fmHU`YF Yj]Yk
H\YK\]hY=ggiY
.
9X]hcf
?UhY6Yfb\Y]aYf
5gg]ghUbh9X]hcfg
7\f]ghcd\Yf<Y``k][
5bXm>c\bgcb
GUfU\AW7`ib[
KYV9X]hcf
>">c\bgcb 8Yg][b:Ufa
5Xj]gcfm6cUfX
8cbU`X<UUgY KUmbYGhUhYIb]jYfg]hm
@mX]UA]``Yh HiWgcb 5N
AUf]UHUhUf <UfjUfXIb]jYfg]hm
AUf]bUKUfbYf Ib]jYfg]hmcZ9ggYl
>UW_N]dYg Ib]jYfg]hmcZA]bbYgchU
7cjYf5fh]bg]XYZfUaY
?]_]Ga]h\ ¾6cfb¿
WcifhYgmcZh\YUfh]gh
8Yg][bYf
>">c\bgcb 8Yg][b:Ufa
@Umcih
AY]_Y@Ybn
HUfUFYYgYf
9b[`]g\8YdUfhaYbhÁgDiV`]WUh]cbgIb]h =``]bc]gGhUhYIb]jYfg]hm
5Wc!diV`]WUh]cbcZ:U]fmHU`YFYj]YkDfYgg
UbXH\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaUDfYgg
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
:U]fmHU`YF Yj]Yk
kkk"ZU]fmhU`YfYj]Yk"Wca
7cdmf][\h&$$,
:U]fmHU`YFYj]YkDfYgg
H\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaUDfYgg
HigWU`ccgU 5`UVUaU')(,+!$',$
5``f][\hgfYgYfjYX
AUbiZUWhifYX]bh\YIb]hYXGhUhYgcZ5aYf]WU
:U]fmHU`YFYj]Yk=GGB.%))*!*%)']gUbUbbiU`Wc!diV`]WUh]cbcZ:U]fmHU`Y
FYj]YkDfYggUbXH\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaUDfYgg"GiVgWf]dh]cbfUhYgZcf&$$,UfY
&$"$$Zcf]bX]j]XiU`g &)"$$Zcf]bgh]hih]cbg UbXUbUXX]h]cbU`,"$$ZcfZcfY][b
XY`]jYfm"GiVgWf]dh]cbcfXYfgUbXW\Ub[YgcZUXXfYggg\ci`XVYX]fYWhYXhc5``]Y
<UfdYf H\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaUDfYgg 6cl,+$',$ HigWU`ccgU 5@')(,+!
$',$"7\YW_gg\ci`XVYaUXYdUmUV`YhcH\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaUDfYgg"
:U]fmHU`YFYj]Yk]gXYjchYXhcWcbhYadcfUfm`]hYfUfmZU]fmhU`YgUbX\cdYghc
dfcj]XYUbY`Y[UbhUbX]bbcjUh]jYjYbiYZcfkf]hYfgkcf_]b[k]h\h\YUYgh\Yh]WgUbX
ach]ZgcZZU]fmhU`Yg"<ckWUbZU]fmhU`Yg\Y`dighc[ck\YfY]h]gkYUfY[c]b[ `]_Y
>YUb7cWhYUiÁgaU[]WU`\cfgY3KY\cdYhcX]gWcjYf"D`YUgY_bckh\Uh:U]fmHU`Y
FYj]Yk]gbchXYjchYXhcUbmdUfh]Wi`UfgW\cc`cZkf]h]b[ VihfUh\Yfhccf][]bU`kcf_
h\Uh]b]hgjYfmckbkUm]g]aViYXk]h\ZU]fmhU`Yg"
Bcdcfh]cbcZ:U]fmHU`YFYj]YkaUmVYfYdf]bhYXk]h\cihdYfa]gg]cb"
=G6B!%$.$!,%+'!))'%!* =G6B!%'.-+,!$!,%+'!))'%!-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
8Uf_YbYXfc``]b[É[ifYgacjYh\fci[\df]gagcZbcWc`cf"
<UbX]b\UbX h\YmkU`_h\Yb][\h
6ihbYjYf_bckYUW\ch\Yf"
DUgg]cbYXdUghY`bYcb`][\hg`][\hidh\Y^YkY`YXhfUjÁ`Yf
K\c `cgh]bgWYbYgcZgac_YÉ``YXXfYUag
:]bXeiYgh]cbg VihbcUbgkYfg"
½H\YAcb_YYg Zfca¾8U]`mB][\h`m¿
DYfZcfaYXcbH\YAcb_YYg 9d]gcXYBc"(, ¾:U]fmhU`Y¿
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
:U]fmHU`YF Yj]Yk
H\YK\]hY=ggiY
.
5BBCH5H98H56@9C:7CBH9BHG
?UhY6Yfb\Y]aYf
3RWb]`Âa<]bS!
¾5`` [fYUh bcjY`g UfY [fYUh ZU]fm hU`Yg ¿ kfchY J`UX]a]f BUVc_cj aUbm
mYUfg U[c UbX :U]fm HU`Y FYj]Yk Wcbh]biYg hc VY`]YjY h\Uh U`` [fYUh
`]hYfUfmkcf_gckYYjYfmh\]b[hcZU]fmhU`Yg"
=jm5`jUfYn
/cb]PW]U`O^Vg]`a]7eOab]ZRS#
g\Yd]W_YgamYZcchYidVmh\Y\YY`Y
XfU[[Yg\]fÉb[fYdUXXY
U`cb[ambUfW\Y
gY]h\ibhcaY
h\ck\Uh\UbcV`YkcaUbÁgZcchY
h\c=kUgVihUW\m`XY
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
D\]`]d6Y]X`Yf
/[S`WQOÂa4OW`gBOZS'
5W\UfUWhYfhf]YghcYgWUdYW]j]`]nUh]cbVm^cifbYm]b[]bhcbUhifY k\YfY
\YZU``gUg`YYd]bh\YdUghUbXkU_Ygid]bh\YZihifY":cfh\UhW\UfUWhYf
\]ghcfmVYWcaYgUbibVcibXYXdfYgYbhk\YfYU``h\]b[gUfYdcgg]V`Y"
AUf[c6YfXYg\Yjg_m
EW\R]e!
G\Y\UhYXGU]bhJU`Ybh]bYÁgXUm"5kcaUb]bU[UfhYfVY`h"
5bXUach\k\cZYYXgcbgd]WY"
5bb:]g\Yf!K]fh\
DO`WObW]\a]\bVS@]PPS`0`WRSU`]][!
Hcbm:f]YX\cZZ
BV`SS>]S[a!&
5aUbVYWcaYgh]YXhch\Y[fcibX"Ch\Yfh\Ubh\Y[fck]b[cZ[fUgg
h\YfYÁgbch\]b[aiW\ Vih=bYjYffYU`]nYX\ckf\mh\a]WU``m
h\]gWUb\UddYb UbXU``h\Yk]`XUb]aU`ghYUW\]b[\]ahcXUbWY
]bh\YacjYaYbhgcZcbYk\c]gh]YXhch\Y[fcibX
]bh\YacjYaYbhgcZcbYk\c]gVY]b[YUhYb"K\c]gVY]b[_]bX\YfY3
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5f]Y``Y;fYYbVYf[
4]c`>]S[a"
H\]g]gh\YZc`_hU`YjYfg]cb]bk\]W\mcif]XYcihhcgYUcbh\YVUW_cZU
hifh`YUbX]hZYY`g`]_Yacggcbh\YVUW_gcZmcifhYYh\"Mci\Ub[UW`cW_
]bh\Ygib"
MciUfYh\YZc`_!hU`Yj]f[]b"
9jUb<Uff]g
BVS4cbc`S]T2Sa^OW`"$
H\YZihifY]gU`ckghcbYkU``cVgWifYXVma]gh"=hfibgh\YZUfYbXcZUb
ibhYbXYXaYUXckh\Uh[fckg]bkYU_gWfiVVmdUhW\Yg dU`YWcjYf UbX
\][\hUbb]g\[fUgg"5VcjYh\YkU`` a]gh[Uh\Yfgk\]hY[fUm gcZh`mcdUeiY"
H\Y ghcbYg cZ h\Y kU`` aUgg YX[Yg aYYh]b[ UbX a]gg]b[ UWWcfX]b[ hc
g\UdY cfXYfcZd`UWYaYbh Ub[`YcZVU`UbWY";UdgZcfaViZZYfgVYhkYYb
ibaUhW\YXgc`]X]h]Yg"
A7<m`UbX
¿0W`RV]ePSOcbWTcZZgg]caW\UÀ$%
CaU_YgU\c`Y]bh\YÉfaUaYbhkYhfYV`Yh\fci[\"
IbXYfWcjYfcZ\][\bchYg h\Yg_]bg`]dgibXYfWcjYfg"H\Ykc`Z\]X]b["
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
@Yg`Ym>Yb]_Y
BV`SS3\bS`bVS2O`YE]]R$&
=hÁgh\YcbYUVcihh\YVYUfgUbXh\Y]fV`cbXY.
=bh\Y]faUbmVYXg=`YZhaUbmWY``g
WU``YXamai`h]d`YdYfgcbU`]h]YgXckb
h\Y]fZUWYghch\Yg_m
Ug`]XYg\ckcZW\YUdfYZYfYbWY W\UbhYigYg
cfd\UbYXVmUkUjYcZVYUf"
@]ZYg\ci`X\UjYd]UbcUWWcadUb]aYbh½
?Ua]`U@]g
Be]>]S[a$'
H\UhÉfghh]aY=gUkamgY`Za]fUWi`cig kYVU_YXgkUb!ZUh
]bhcVfYUXk\YbGUhUbk\]gdYfYX ¾=WUbÁhh\]b_cZUbmh\]b[
h\UhWUbaU_YaYga]`Y`]_YmciWUbUbXU`h\ci[\mciUfYdYfZYWh
mci\UjYWcaYhccYUf`mUbXUfY\YfYk\YfYgcaYh\]b[`Ui[\]b[
k]``VYg\UdYXXY`]VYfUhY`m VU``cZUdU`adfYggYX]bhcac]ghW`Um"¿
5g\`YmAWKUhYfg
ASdS\>]S[a%
=kYUjYUhfU]b]hgbUaY`YgghfUW_g
`UhYUbXW`U]a`Ygg gWiaV`YXh\]aV`Y
ZcfV`Ygg]b["Bcck`cfVf][\hVf]XY
=kYUjYamgY`Zhc`UWY hc`Yh]bU]f"
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
6UfVUfU>UbYFYmYg
BVS2cg]\UAS`WSa%'
5ha]Xb][\h h\Yc`XaYb[Uh\Yfk]h\c]``UbhYfbgUVcUfXh\Y]fÉg\]b[
VcUhg"K]h\fcgUf]Yg]b\UbX h\YmghUVh\YkUhYfk]h\aUW\YhYg"H\Y]f
gcbggUm ¾8cbchVYZcc`]g\"H\YfYUfYbcacfYaYfaU]Xg\YfY"=h]gh\Y
WfcWcX]`Ygk\cUfYghYU`]b[cifmcib[cbYg"¿
H]ach\mGW\UZZYfh
BVSG]c\UEWR]e]T0O`QSZ]\O&"
?ifhGW\k]hhYfg
HfUbg`UhYXVm>UW_N]dYg
BVSAeW\SVS`RO\RbVS5`SOb7ZZcab`W]caE`WbS`'#
5gk]bY\YfXkUghYbX]b[\]gd][gUbXd`Um]b[\]gÊihYUhh\YgUaYh]aY.
¾HkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh"¿
?Y``]YKY``g
@OPPWb1ObQVS`]T9W\UR][1][S
CbY giXXYb gdf]b[ k\Yb hfYYg UbX ÊckYfg VUaVccn`YX Vm kUfah\
VY[UbViXX]b[]b>UbiUfm h\YdfYaUhifY`m\cb]YXU]fÊUh`mfYZig]b[hc
W\]`` U[U]b ibh]` `UhY 8YWYaVYf h\Y hckb cZ ?]b[Xca 7caY ?UbgUg
kUg VYgYh Vm U d`U[iY cZ V`UW_!hU]`YX ^UW_ fUVV]hg h\Uh kYfY bch cb`m
aUbmVih^iaVc V][[Yfh\Ub[fYUhXUbYgh\YmkYfY [UfUO\hiUbfUVV]hg
gigd]W]cig`mkY``!ZYX g`UjYf]b[cjYfh\Yncmg]U d`iada]XX`Yg\YUj]b[
VUW_ZYYh`cb[UbXVfUkbmUgUgU]`cfÁgZcfYUfaUbXYUfgmciWci`XZUbU
ZU]bh]b[df]bWYggk]h\"
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
8UfUK]Yf
BVSEWhO`R "
5hXUkbUbXUhXig_=`YUjYh\Y\cigYhc[fUnY]bh\YaYUXckVYmcbXh\Y
f]jYf"H\YfYÁgUhfU]`=ÁjYWcjYfYXk]h\ghfUkhcZc``ckUbXUWcbjYb]Ybh
ghf]b[cZVci`XYfg=WUbigYhcaU_YamkUmUWfcggh\YkUhYf"=g`YYdU``
h\fci[\h\YXUmUbXkcf_h\fci[\h\Yb][\h"
=aUbhgN]YXcb]g
HfUbg`UhYXVm6]h]hYJ]b_`Yfg
Be]BOZSa $
H\Y gib `]_Y U Vf][\h [c`XYb Y[[ [`YUaYX ]b h\Y g_m" H\YfY kUg `]ZY
k]h\]bh\Ygib.VUVmW\]W_g U```][\hmY``ck XYgWYbXYXhcYUfh\U`cb[h\Y
gibÁgfUmg"@UhYfcbh\YW\]W_gk]``ghfihUVcih]bch\YfWc`cfg Vihh\YmU``
Uff]jYUgibbmmY``ck"
1]\b`WPcb]`<]bSa!
/QY\]eZSRU[S\ba"
/\\]c\QS[S\ba"
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
9X]hcfÀgBchY
4]`[7a4OW`gBOZS4OW`gBOZS7a4]`[
)
¾5``[fYUhbcjY`gUfY[fYUhZU]fmhU`Yg ¿kfchYJ`UX]a]fBUVc_cjaUbmmYUfg
U[c UbX:U]fmHU`YFYj]YkWcbh]biYghcVY`]YjYh\UhU``[fYUh`]hYfUfmkcf_g
ckYYjYfmh\]b[hcZU]fmhU`Yg"=bh\]g]ggiY Ugk]h\U``dfYj]cig]ggiYg mci
k]``ÉbXkcf_fYdfYgYbhYXh\UhXfUkgZfcah\YgdYWhUWi`Uf c`XhfUX]h]cbcZ
ZU]fmhU`Yg]bVf]``]UbhbYkkUmg":U]fmhU`Yg"K\Yb=igYh\]gd\fUgY =]aU[!
]bY mcigYbgY]bh\YhYfaUib]eiYZcfakYgh]``fYWc[b]nYUbXbUaY¾ZU]fm
hU`Y¿YjYbUZhYfaUbmWYbhif]YgcZaUb]di`Uh]cbhc]hgX]gWfYhYhYW\b]eiYg"
H\YZcfagifj]jYgh\YgYaihUh]cbg½]bghcf]Yg bcjY`g dcYag YggUmg aig]W
UbXUfh"=h]gU`gcUXUdhUV`YhcUX]jYfgYfUb[YcZghm`]gh]WbUffUh]jYacXYg
UgYj]XYbWYX]bh\Yk]XYUffUmcZkcf_]bh\]gjYfm]ggiY":U]fmhU`YgaU[bY!
h]nYkf]hYfgk\c]XYbh]Zmh\YagY`jYgUgfYU`]ghgUgaiW\UgGiffYU`]ghgUbX
8UXU]ghgUbXacXYfb]ghgUbXZUVi`]ghgUbXYl]ghYbh]U`]ghg bchhcaYbh]cb
fcaUbWYbcjY`]ghgUbX[fYYh]b[WUfXUih\cfgUbXhUV`c]X\YUX`]bYkf]hYfg"
MYh]bkf]hYf`mWcbjYfgUh]cbgUbUddfYW]Uh]cbcZh\Y]fjYfmW`Ugg]WU`Zcfa]g
cZhYbgiV`]aUhYXhcUbUddfYW]Uh]cbcZh\Y]fcVj]cigk]`XUbXghfUb[Yac!
aYbhg"H\UhaUbmkf]hYfgXcWY`YVfUhYh\YXUf_!ZUbhUgh]WWcgacgcZZU]fm
hU`Yg ]g kcbXYfZi` Vih = kci`X U`gc `]_Y hc gYY Ub ]bWfYUgYX UddfYW]Uh]cb
Zcfh\YUfh]gh]WXYlhYf]hmUbXX]jYfg]hmUh\UbXcjYfh\YWYbhif]Yg"=VY`]YjY
U`cb[k]h\BUVc_cjUbXch\Yfg h\UhZU]fmhU`Ygkcf_cbU``cZigUgUih\cfg
UbXfYUXYfg/h\YmÁfYgciV]ei]h]cig"MYhUWf]h]WU`ibXYf!UddfYW]Uh]cbcZh\Y
dfYW]gYUfhcZZU]fmhU`YggcaYh]aYg`YUXghch\Ya]g]bhYfdfYhUh]cbcZh\YgY
VYUih]Zi``mXY`]VYfUhY[YghifYgUgXfYUa!`]_Y gcabc`YbhacaYbhg/UbX`]_Y
gcaiW\kf]h]b[UggcW]UhYXk]h\kcaYb k\]W\ZU]fmhU`YgibXYb]UV`mUfY
hc ZU]fm!hU`Y kf]h]b[ VY]b[ Wcbg]XYfYX [Ya!`]_Y UbX cZ gaU`` ]adcfhUbWY
ib`Ygg]hfYUW\YgUaUgg!aUf_YhfYUXYf"=bghYUXcZ`cc_]b[Uh\ckh\YmÁjY
VYYbX]gdUfU[YX \ckYjYf =kUbhhchU_Yh\]gh]b]YghacaYbhhcVf]YÊmWY`!
YVfUhYh\Y]fZcfa k\]W\fYg]XYgVYUih]Zi``m]bÊUhbYgg UVghfUWh]cb ]bhi]h]jY
`c[]W UbXbcfaU`]nYXaU[]W"%5b]bWfYUgYXibXYfghUbX]b[cZh\YgYdfYW]gY
UbX]bWfYX]V`YZU]fm!hU`YhYW\b]eiYg gckcbXYfZi``mY`iW]XUhYXVmcbYcZam
\YfcYg h\YgW\c`UfAUl@ih\] VihYldUbXYX ]bh\YUYgh\Yh]WcZ:U]fmHU`Y
%'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
FYj]Yk hcWcbhYadcfUfm`]hYfUhifYUWfcggh\Yghm`YgUbX[YbfYg aUm\Y`d
fYgc`jY h\Y ibZcfhibUhY gW\]gag h\Uh gcaYh]aYg Uf]gY VYhkYYb gc!WU``YX
aU]bghfYUaUbXUjUbh[UfXYkf]hYfgUbXWf]h]Wg"=bh\]g]ggiY Ugk]h\YjYfm
]ggiYcZ:U]fmHU`YFYj]Yk mcik]``ÉbXkcf_UWfcgggcaUbmgiW\VcfXYfg/
gcaYcZh\Ykf]h]b[fYZYfghcgdYW]ÉWZU]fmhU`Yg VihaiW\cZ]hg]ad`mZYY`g
`]_YUZU]fmhU`Y/UbX\ck]hZYY`g`]_YUZU]fmhU`Y]gh\fci[\`Ub[iU[Y h\fci[\
Zcfa"K]h\aYd`YUgYgdfYUXh\YkcfXh\UhZU]fmhU`YgUfYh\YbYkYghUbX
c`XYghUYgh\Yh]W/UbXh\Ym[]jYcif`]jYgZYUfZi` VYUih]Zi`g\UdY":cfa]gZU]fm
hU`Y ZU]fmhU`Y]gZcfa"<YfY =gYY_hc[]jYh\YaUaU[]WU`\caY"
?UhY6Yfb\Y]aYf
HigWU`ccgU 5@
/dOabZgSf^O\RSRdS`aW]\]TbVWa3RWb]`Âa<]bSeWbVbVSaO[SbWbZSeWZZO^^SO`W\H\YKf]hYfÁgBchY!
Vcc_BW\6]caS0]]Ya '
%(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
=JM5@J5F9N
/cb]PW]U`O^Vg]`a]7eOab]ZRS
)
;gST]]bS
g\Yd]W_YgamYZcchYidVmh\Y\YY`Y
XfU[[Yg\]fÉb[fYdUXXY
U`cb[ambUfW\Y
gY]h\ibhcaY
h\ck\Uh\UbcV`YkcaUbÁgZcchY
h\c=kUgVihUW\m`XY
gYY\ck\]hWifjYh\gc\][\Y
h\cikm`hbYjYfVYdccfY
h\cikm`hbYjYfghUm\]YfY
Vmh\]gYZfY__`Y\]YfY
h\cik]`hhfUjY``YZUf
Zfcah\YgYackbhUmbYgg_mYg
\]fbU]`YXmXYgWfUhW\YamYb`mhY`g_mbbY
gcambZcchYX]XXYWif`Yg\f]b_Y
`m_YUkcfaYYj]WhYXZfcah\YYUfh\Y
g\YXmXYga]`Yamach\YfÁgaUmXY
ambckbYbifgY
k\cX]XXYkcf_YZcf\]f_YYdY
h\Y]fY]gbcd`Ughc[c
ib`YgghÁkYfY
h\YVchhcacÁh\Ykcf`XY=h\c[\hY
%)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
=kc`XYfYaU]bYghYXZUgh\]YfY
Vihh\YaUmXYkUgf][\hY
=kUgkfcb[
%*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
/\bVWZZSa
ÀXUfYbYjYfh\fcghcbbYgUhUbh\]``Yg Á=kUghc`XY
h\UfhcXfmYXaiXXYg`cdgXmXYf]gYZfcah\Y[fcibXY
h\Ymfg\UXckgÊcUhmb[YUVcjYbh\YX]fhY
ÀXU``mbchk\YfYXkUfZZYg`]jY
h\YmÁfhVc`XYYbc[\YhcZmbXYmY
hU__YmYZcfh\YmfckbY
mYk]`bYjYfVYbYZcibXYU[UmbÁ
%+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
1V]YYS
=kUgUgYU!W\]`XYgiffckbXYXVmkUhYfY
=YhgYU!gbUm`Yg cmghfYg g\f]addY dfUkbYg UbW\cZZmg\Ygei]XXY
=`cjYXacghYh\YaY`_Zmg\Ygkmaa]b[Y
]bUVfch\YcZ[]b[Yf\YfVYggYfjYXk]h\f]WYcfdchUhcgY
VihkUfYh\ciVYZcfZmg\YUfYÉW_`Yh\mb[Yg =kUghc`XY
kmh\VcbbYgh\UhWUbbYW\c__YUmcb[Yh\fcUhY
=kUghUi[\hYUhf]W_Y UZcif!Éb[YfXYgWccdY
UgaU`YVU``cZf]WYhcdig\YXckbYh\iaVY
Xmg`cX[Yh\YVcbbYdUghhmfg ZYUfYcZW\c__mb[Y
aUm\Udg`]jYhcYUhZmg\YUbch\YfbXUmY
%,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
D<=@=D69=8@9F
/[S`WQOÂa4OW`gBOZS
)
A W\UfUWhYfhf]YghcYgWUdYW]j]`]nUh]cbVm^cifbYm]b[]bhcbUhifY
k\YfY\YZU``gUg`YYd]bh\YdUghUbXkU_Ygid]bh\YZihifY":cf
h\UhW\UfUWhYf \]ghcfmVYWcaYgUbibVcibXYXdfYgYbhk\YfYU``h\]b[g
UfYdcgg]V`Y"
KY_bckh\Yh]h`YcZh\]gghcfm"=h]gh\Y[fYUh5aYf]WUbZU]fmhU`Y
WU``YX ¾F]d JUb K]b_`Y"¿ 5g U ZUV`Y cZ ]bX]j]XiU` UbX bUh]cbU` gY`Z!
]bjYbh]cb ]hkf]hYgh\YXfYUacZi`h]aUhYZfYYXca cZ`]VYfUh]cbZfca
h]aY"5gUZUV`YcZdc`]h]WU`fYjc`ih]cb h\YcjYfh\fckcZWc`cb]U`aUg!
hYfm ]hkf]hYgUbYkjYfg]cbcZh\YZU``]bhc\]ghcfm Zfcac`XU[YVUW_]bhc
YhYfbU` mcih\" =h ]g g]ai`hUbYcig`m U ZUV`Y gcaY\ck UVcih ]aU[]b]b[
UbXZcf[Yhh]b[":fcah\YcihgYh kYWUbbchXYW]XYUgUdYcd`Y]ZkYg\U``
i`h]aUhY`mVYghm`YXfYXYYaYfbUh]cbcfUabYg]UWbUh]cb"
5a]XghgiW\kYUj]b[gcZamh\UbXUfW\YhmdY kYWUbU`gc_bckU
`chcZch\Yfh\]b[gUVcihh\Yghcfm \ckYjYf.fYU`UbXhfiYh\]b[ggcaY!
\cka]lYXidk]h\]aU[]bUfmUbXaUXY!idh\]b[g UbXj]WY!jYfgU":cf
h\]g]gk\Uh¾F]dJUbK]b_`Y¿]gfYU``mUVcih.h\YYbX`YggfYW]dfcW]hm]b
5aYf]WUcZ\]ghcfmUbX]aU[]bUh]cb"Hcdihh\]gacfYX]fYWh`m ]b¾F]d
JUbK]b_`Y¿kYÉbXcifgY`jYgZUWYhcZUWYk]h\U`Y[YbXUfmYlUad`YcZ
\ckUbW]Ybh`mWcad`Ylh\YdfcWYggcZaU_]b[]hbYk½cZYb^cm]b[k\Uh
9aYfgcbWU``YX¾Ubcf][]bU`fY`Uh]cbhch\Yib]jYfgY¿½U`kUmghifbgcih
hcVY"
Cb h\Y aUhhYf cZ Wi`hifU` cf][]b kY _bck Zcf ]bghUbWY h\Uh Ub
5aYf]WUbUih\cfbUaYXKUg\]b[hcb=fj]b[ U`h\ci[\WfYX]hYXk]h\h\Y
hU`Y X]XbchfYU``m]bjYbh]h"BcfUgk]``VYgYYb Zfca]hgÉfghdiV`]WU!
h]cbcbkUfX X]X\YYjYbW`U]ahc\UjYkf]hhYb]h XYjY`cd]b[]bghYUXU
Wcad`Yl ZUV`Y cZ Uih\cf]U` hfUbga]gg]cb UbX Uhhf]Vih]cb½UbX h\YfYVm
gi[[Ygh]b[UhgcaYcZ]hgXYYdYgh`YjY`g]ha][\hbchVYUb5aYf]WUbZU]fm
hU`YUhU``VihgcaYh\]b[acfY`]_YUjcmU[Y]bhch\YWc``YWh]jYZc`_`cf]W
ibWcbgW]cig" 5bX cb h\cgY dc]bhg U`cbY h\Yb UbX bck Wcbh]biYg hc
%-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
Uf]gYaUbmU`]hYfUfmUbXWi`hifU`Wcad`]WUh]cb":]fgh h\YfYkUgh\YaUh!
hYfcZh\YY`UVcfUhYÉWh]cbU`[YbYU`c[m"=bXYYX UgcbYcZhkc[YaghcbY
¾5aYf]WUb¿Zc`_bUffUh]jYg½h\Ych\YfVY]b[UWcadUb]cbYbh]h`YX¾H\Y
@Y[YbXcZG`YYdm<c``ck¿½]bUb%,%-hkc!jc`iaYdfcXiWh]cbcZWU`!
Wi`UhYX`mhfUbgUh`Ubh]WUddYU` UWc``YWh]cbcZei]hYa]gWY``UbYcighU`Yg
Uhacgd\Yf]Wd]YWYg UbXdcdi`UfYggUmgYbh]h`YXBVSAYSbQV0]]Y]T5S]TT`Sg
1`Og]\5S\b½bchcb`mkUg]hbchUKUg\]b[hcb=fj]b[ghcfm VihU`gc]h
kUgbchYjYbU;YcZZfYm7fUmcbghcfm"FUh\Yf 7fUmcb \]agY`ZUdihU!
h]jYhfUjY`]b[mcib[`]hYfUfmhmdYhfm]b[hcgWcfYU\]hVma]l]b[h\Yjc]WYg
cZh\YfYhifb]b[5b[`cd\]`Yd]`[f]ak]h\h\YViadh]cigbYk5aYf]WUb
jcmU[Yf gYYaYX Uh Wcad`Yl dU]bg ]b Uhhf]Vih]b[ ]h ZWYS ]hg WcibhYfdUfh
UbXc\ZWYSU``h\Ych\Yf`Uf[Y`m9b[`]g\d]YWYg]bh\YVcc_ hch\YaiW\
c`XYf bUh]jY Wi`hifU` fYgYUfW\Yg cZ cbY 8]YXf]W\ ?b]W_YfVcW_Yf½h\Y
`UhhYf VY]b[ U dfYj]cig WfYUh]cb cZ =fj]b[ ]b Ub YUf`]Yf hYlh cZ acXYgh
WY`YVf]hm Ybh]h`YX/6Wab]`g]T<SeG]`YT`][bVS0SUW\\W\U]TbVSE]`ZRb]bVS
>`SaS\b UbXgYfj]b[UgUbY`UVcfUhYdUfcXmcZ5aYf]WUb[i]XYVcc_gUbX
Wc`cb]U`\]ghcf]Yg"
6ihYjYb\YfYh\YdUdYfhfU]`]b[X]XbchYbX"=bh\YWUgYcZ¾F]d
JUbK]b_`Y ¿dUfh]Wi`Uf`m h\YYbhYfdf]gYkUgUhhYbXYXk]h\Wcd]cigUh!
hYghUh]cbg VYZcfYUbXUZhYfh\YbUffUh]cbcZh\YhU`YdfcdYf hc?b]W_!
YfVcW_YfÁg TOQbcOZ jYfUW]hm UbX gWfidi`cg]hm" 5 ZcfYkcfX `U]X Xckb \]g
`Yb[h\mWfYXYbh]U`gUgU\]ghcf]Ub bch]b[h\Y]adf]bh]b[cZ\]g`]_YbYgg
Vm5aYf]WUb¾V]gWi]hVU_Yfg¿cbh\Y]f¾bYkmYUfWU_Yg¿½¾UW\UbWYcZ
]aacfhU`]hm ¿kYUfYhc`X ¾U`acghYeiU`hcVY]b[ghUadYXcbUKUhYf`cc
aYXU` cf U EiYYb 5bbYÁg :Ufh\]b["¿ 5 dcghgWf]dh Zifh\Yf UhhYghYX hc
h\Yhfih\cZh\YbUffUh]jY jYf]Zm]b[]hgYggYbh]U`WcbhYbhVmUZÉXUj]h½hc
k]h UdYfgcbU`gkYUf]b[cZh\YghcfmVmh\Ycf][]bU`F]dJUbK]b_`Y]b
h\YZcfacZU`Y[U`XYdcg]h]cb k]hbYggYXVm?b]W_YfVcW_Yf UbXWYfh]!
ÉYXVmUdfYgiaUV`m]``]hYfUhYWcibhfm^igh]WY¾k]h\UWfcgg]b\]gckb
\UbXkf]h]b["¿AYUbk\]`Y \ckYjYf 7fUmcbX]XÉbX\]agY`ZZcfWYXhc
UXa]h hc U dcgg]V]`]hm cZ h\Y fYUXYfÁg X]gWYfb]b[ U WYfhU]b g]a]`Uf]hm cZ
amh\]Wcih`]bYdYf\UdgVYhkYYbh\YhU`YUbXUkY``!_bckb;YfaUbUb!
hYWYXYbh" 5bX \Y WU``YX ]h Vm bUaY½0O`PO`]aaO cf4`SRS`WQYRS`@]bVPO`b.
h\Y;YfaUb`Y[YbXcZh\Y<c`mFcaUb9adYfcf ZU``]b[Ug`YYd]bUWUjY
cZh\Y?mZZ\}igYfAcibhU]bghcUkU]hh\Yh]aYcZfYhifbk\Yb\Ykci`X
&$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
aU_Y\]gbUh]cbh\Y[fUbXYghUbXa][\h]YghcbYUfh\":cffYUXYfgcZh\Y
YfU h\]gaigh\UjYgYYaYXU[ccXXcX[YUbXUbYbhYfhU]b]b[cbY"F]dÁg
YbW\UbhYX hkYbhm mYUf g`YYd Vfci[\h cb Vm hcc aiW\ <c``UbXg ;]b
WcbgiaYXk\]`YX]gdcfh]b[UhVck`gk]h\h\Y[\cgh`mWfYkcZ<YbXf]_
<iXgcb½gYYagUXY`]W]cig gaU``!W\Ub[YdUfcXmcZh\Y[fYUh`Y[YbXcZ
h\YfY!Uf]gYb9adYfcfgcaYYbj]g]cbYXUdfcd\YWmbch`cghcb5Xc`Z
<]h`Yf k\cigYXh\YbUaY6UfVUfcggUZcf\]g%-(%]bjUg]cbcZFigg]UUg
fYhifb]b[hcVf]b[[`cfmhc7\f]ghYbXcah\fci[\h\YfYghcfUh]cbcZh\Y
<c`mFcaUb9ad]fY"H\YdfcV`Ya]gh\Uhbch`YUghX]X]hU`gcWcbWYU`
UgcifWYcZUh`YUghYeiU`]adcfhUbWY"H\Uhkci`X\UjYVYYb>SbS`9ZOca
acgh`UhY`mcZh\YD]ZYaaOUS\cZ>";"Ch\aUf h\YZUfacfYfY`YjUbhhU`YcZ
U[cUh\YfXk\c `ifYX]bhcUacibhU]bWUjYk\YfY\YÉbXghkY`jYb][\hg
d`Um]b[Uhb]bYd]bg Xf]b_gk]bYUbXZU``g]bhcU`cb[g`YYd"5hhYadh]b[U
fYhifbhc\]gYUf`]Yfkcf`X \YÉbXg\]g\cigYfi]bYX \]gZUa]`ma]gg]b[
UbX\]gc`XZf]YbXgXYUX"5h`Yb[h\ YbWcifU[YXVmUgmadUh\Yh]Wmcib[
k]ZYUbXach\Yf k\chifbgcihhcVY\]gW\]`X \Y]gkY`WcaYXVUW_]bhc
\]g\caYj]``U[Y"
K\UhYjYf h\Y Vcffck]b[g hc VY XYhYWhYX ]b giW\ U gmbh\Yg]g cZ
cf][]bg h\Y]adcfhUbhZUWh]gh\Uh]hVYWcaYgUbU``cmUhcbWY]bhYfZigYX
k]h\ X]gh]bWh`m 5aYf]WUb Y`YaYbhg bYk Y`YaYbhg cZ h\Y YaYf[Ybh`m
amh\]WUbXZc`_`cf]W]XYbh]ÉUV`YXckbhcbUaY d`UWY XUhY UbXbUhifU`
UbXXcaYgh]WXYhU]`"5bXaiW\cZbVWa Uh`YUgh]bh\YVY[]bb]b[ XYf]jYg
ZfcaUfhgch\Yfh\UbhfUX]h]cbU``]hYfUfmghcfmhY``]b["H\YW\UfagcZh\Y
`UbXgWUdY dU]bghU_]b[`mVfig\YX]b h\Yd]WhifYgeiYg\UX]b[gcZWc`cf
cZ`][\hUbXXUf_ h\YXYhU]`gcZZcfYgh W`YUf]b[ UbXacibhU]b h\Y`cfX`m
<iXgcbghfib[k]h\XfckgmWc`cb]U`VUW_kUhYfg fYdcg]hcf]YgcZ`cWU`
WighcaUbX`cfY UfYh\YW\UfagcZh\Y5aYf]WUbGiV`]aY h\Y<iXgcb
F]jYfGW\cc`cZdU]bh]b[dYfZYWhYXVmgiW\WcbhYadcfUf]YgUgH\caUg
7c`Y UbX 5g\Yf 8ifUbX" Gc cb h\Y XcaYgh]W WUbjUg cZ dfY!FYjc`i!
h]cbUfmKUfhfUbei]`]hm h\Y]b\UV]hUbhgUfY]bjYghYXk]h\UWhiU` `cWU`
XYYd`mVWab]`WQOZ5aYf]WUb[YbYU`c[]YgcZZUV`YUbXamh\"H\YacXYcZ
¾g_YhW\¿\YfY]bBVSAYSbQV0]]Y ]bXYYX ]gdfYW]gY`mh\UhcZh\Y_]bXcZ
gcW]U`\]ghcfmUhk\]W\?b]W_YfVcW_Yf ]b\]gckbdfYj]cigjc`iaYVm
%,%-h\f]WYfYdf]bhYX\UXU`fYUXmdfcjYb\]agY`ZbchUV`m[ccX k]h\
]hg ckb dYWi`]Uf W\Ufag UbX ]bhYfYgh ]b h\Y Wcaacbd`UWY kcf_UXUm
&%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
kcf`XcZh\YYUf`mWc`cb]U`YfU"9jYbh\Y JUb K]b_`YgkYfYfYU`dYc!
d`Y" =adcjYf]g\YX [Ybhfm kY kci`X \UjY WU``YX h\Ya ZU``Yb cb \UfX
h]aYg"=fj]b[_bYkUbiaVYfcZh\YadYfgcbU``m"CbYcZh\Ya 7cf!
bY`]ig JUb K]b_`Y kUg\]gdiV`]g\Yf":cf[ccXaYUgifY ]bh\Yghcfm
Uh\UbX ?b]W_YfVcW_Yf]gU`gcUhdU]bghc\Y`dh\Yacihk]h\U\Yfc]W
dUgh fYWU``]b[ dUfh]Wi`Uf`m h\Y]f a]`]hUfm dfYgYbWY bchYX k]h\ hmd]WU`
acW_!Yd]W[fUj]hm ]bgWYbYgZfcah\Y6Wab]`gaYacf]U`]n]b[h\Ya][\hm
G]Y[YcZ:cfh7\f]gh]bU"
AYUbk\]`Y h\YghcfmVig]YX]hgY`Zk]h\fYbXYf]b[Zc`_`cf]W]aU[Yg
cZUWcbhYadcfUfm5aYf]WUUgkY``"Bch`YUghcZh\YgYkUgh\Yamh\cZ
Zfcbh]YfUXjYbhifY YaYf[Ybh]bh\YhfUX]h]cbgcZhU``!hU`Y5aYf]WU½cZU
aU`Ykcf`XcZ\ibh]b[ Ég\]b[ Xf]b_]b[ [UaV`]b[ VfUk`]b[ UbXch\Yf!
k]gYX]gdcfh]b[ bYUf`mU`kUmg]bh\YUVgYbWYcZa]lYXWcadUbm/UbXcZU
kcf`XUWWcfX]b[`mfYd`YhYk]h\fiaVigh]cig VUW_kccXg [ccX!c`X!Vcm
\iacf ^Uk]b[UbXmUfb]b[ bchhcaYbh]cbYaVY``]g\]b[UbXYlU[[YfUh!
]b[ cbYa][\hgUm U`acghVYmcbXfYW_cb]b[cfVY`]YZ"<YfYF]d]gUb
YUf`mYlYad`UfcfWca]WdfchchmdYcZh\YVUW_kccXg\Yfck]h\h\YV][
VfU[ gccbhcVY^c]bYXVmamf]UXch\Yfg½bch`YUgh¾B]afcXK]`XÉfY
H\Y@]cbcZh\Y KYgh ¿h\YWfYUh]cbcZ=fj]b[ÁgZY``ckaYaVYfcZh\Y
?b]W_YfVcW_YfZWbS`ObW >UaYg?]f_YDUi`X]b["H\Y[fYUh5aYf]WUbVcm!
aUb F]ddifgiYgU¾`]ZYghm`Y¿UgkYa][\hbckWU``]h Wcadf]g]b[UZi``
]bjYbhcfmcZhU``!hU`YWcaacbd`UWYgWca]b[XckbhchcXUmÁg5aYf]WUb
gYliU`UbXWi`hifU`dc`]h]Wg"
=ZF]d\UgU¾7\f]gh]Ub¿cf¾dfcdYf¿ÉfghbUaY hcW\ccgYUbcVj]!
cigdc]bh kYbYjYf`YUfb]h"<Y]g¾Uf]d ¿]bh\YgYbgYh\Uh<iW_:]bb]g
¾U\iW_`YVYffm¿UbX8U]gmA]``Yf]g¾UXU]gm ¿cfUÉ[\h]b[Xc[]gbUaYX
¾5bXfYk>UW_gcb¿UbXU^iad]b[Zfc[]gbUaYX¾8UbÁ`KYVghYf"¿<Y]g
h\YghiZZcZ`cWU``Y[YbXUbXh\YWfYUh]cbcZh\Y`cWU``Yl]Wcb"<Y]g UgkY
a][\hgUm U¾f]d!gbcfhYf ¿U¾d]YWYcZkcf_"¿5`hYfbUh]jY`m \YaUmVYU
aUghYfd]YWYcZVUW_kccXgibXYfghUhYaYbh UWcc`WUgYcZd`Um]b[]hW`cgY
hch\YjYgh ]bh\YkUmh\Uhh\Yg`ckYgh[imcbh\Ykcf_WfYk]gbUaYX
¾`][\hb]b[¿cfh\YV][[YghcbY]gbUaYX¾h]bm¿½cfh\Y`Un]YghaUb]bh\Y
j]``U[Y gcZUfUh`YUghUg\]gckbXcaYgh]W`UVcfgUfYWcbWYfbYX ]gbUaYX
¾F]d"¿@]_Yh\Ycf][]bU`@]cbcZh\YKYghUbXU``h\Ych\YfghcWcaY \Y
]g\iacfcig`ma]gc[mb]gh"<Y`]jYg]bWcbX]h]cbga]`X`mXYgdch]W k]h\
&&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
eich]X]UbXcaYgh]WX]gWcaZcfhg½bch`YUghdYhh]WcUhhmfUbbmcZUXca]!
bYYf]b[k]ZY h\Yg\fYk]g\j]fU[c8UaYJUbK]b_`Y"
=bjYghYX k]h\ g\UX]b[g cZ ;YfaUb Zc`_ `Y[YbX UbX h\Y fcaUbh]W
giV`]aY fYXfUkbk]h\eiU]bh dfcj]bW]U` Ubh]eiUf]UbW\Ufag½UbXh\Yb
\Udd]`mfYWcbÉ[ifYX]bUbYkfcX!UbX![ib`Y]gifYdc`]h]Wg½F]d!kcf`X
UgkYa][\hWU``]h ]gUb5aYf]WUbkcf`Xhch\]gXUmgh]``iba]ghU_UV`Y"8Y!
j]gYX]bh\Y]aU[YcZh\Yh]hi`Uf\Yfc ]h]gh\UhcZh\Ydfchchmd]WU`[ccXc`X
Vcm g]l!dUW_^cY h\YViVVU"K]h\cbYÁgXc[Ugh\YWcadUb]cbcZW\c]WY]b
h\Ycf][]bU` k]h\h\Y`UhhYfUghYff]ÉYX cZ\]gj]fU[c!a]ghfYggUg\]gaUg!
hYfcbYaU_YgcZZZcfh\YhUjYfb h\YÉg\]b[ghfYUa h\Y\ibh]b[kccXg/
cfbck dYf\Udg h\Y[c`ZWcifgY h\YghUX]ia h\YgdcfhgVUf h\YVck`]b[
U``Ym"5XjYbhifYg]bgiW\aU`YdfYW]bWhgVYWcaYh\YaUhYf]U`gcZ[`cf]cig
dfYjUf]WUh]cb"=bgcaYWUgYgh\Y`m]b[]gZcfh\YdfYgYfjUh]cbcZW`cgY!fUb[Y
XcaYgh]W hfUbei]`]hm. YlWigYg Zcf a]gVY\Uj]cf cf ibYld`U]bYX UVgYbWYg"
=bch\Yfgh\Ym[YhZUg\]cbYXZcfh\Yd`U]b^cmcZ]h]bhcU[ccXghcfmh\Uh
gcaY\ck[YhgVYhhYfk]h\YUW\hY``]b[ h\YacfYY`UVcfUhYh\YWfYUh]jYfY!
gWf]dh]b[UbXYaVY``]g\aYbhh\YVYhhYf"¾H\UhÁgamghcfmUbX=Áagh]W_]b[
hc]h ¿]ggiWWYYXYXVm¾MciU]bÁh[cbbUVY`]YjYh\]gg\]h Vihµ¿
H\Yg][bUhifY5aYf]WUbhcbY]gh\UhcZ^c``mXYamgh]ÉWUh]cb"HU`Yg
cZh\YZcfYgh amghYf]cig[\cghg YbW\UbhaYbhg gdY``g acibhU]bWUjYg
UfYV`ckbcZZ]bhch\YVcm]g\mYUfb]b[ZcfYgWUdYZfcakcf_UbXfYgdcb!
g]V]`]hmWcid`YXk]h\UZfcbh]YfUb]aigU[U]bghh\YW\UghYb]b[ ¾g]j]`]n]b[¿
]bÊiYbWYgcZXcaYgh]WWi`hifY"=bZYfbU`dYfgYWih]cbgcZ\Y``]bh\Yg\UdY
cZUkcaUb h\YYj]`eiYYbcZGbckK\]hY h\Yk]W_YXghYdach\YfcZ
7]bXYfY``U h\YW\]`X!XYjcif]b[k]hW\cZ<UbgY`UbX;fYhY` fY!]aU[YX
Ugh\YbU[[]b[gdcigYk\cX]Yg k]h\gkYYha]gc[mb]gh^igh]WY cZUbUdc!
d`Ylmk\]`YeiUffY``]b[k]h\UMUb_YYDYXX`Yf"5gUZUbhUgmcZaU`YYg!
WUdYh\Uh]g\UfXhcVYUh"
=bh\Ycf][]bU` hcVYgifY kYÉbXcifcdYb]b[ghch\YZihifY]bU
jYfmdUfh]Wi`UfZUV`YcZWi`hifYg]bYjc`ih]cb Vch\\]ghcf]WU`UbX`]hYfUfm
]bh\YZi``YghgYbgY"6YZcfYcifYmYg h\YYUgm[c]b[ gcaYk\Uhg`cjYb`m
hfUX]h]cb!VcibX8ihW\UfYW`YUf`mcbh\YkUmcih]bh\YUgWYbXUbWmcZ
h\Y Vigm ]bXighf]cig dfc[fYgg]jY 5b[`c!5aYf]WUbg" =bXYYX ]Z cbY ]g
`cc_]b[Zcfdc`]h]WU`U``Y[cfm h\YfY]gd`YbhmcZh\Uh/UbXU`chcZ]hhifbg
cihhcVYbchbYUf`mgcVf][\h W\Ufa]b[ YjYbZibbmUg]haUm`cc_"
&'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
CbY aUm VY[]b k]h\ h\Y ZUacig YbWcibhYf ]b h\Y ZcfYgh UbX U
eiYgh]cb cZ ghUhifY" 6Y[]bb]b[ k]h\ F]dÁg cXX`m aYbUW]b[ [i]XY h\Y
[\cghYa]ggUf]YgcZ\]ghcfmUfYX]gh]bWh`mXkUfÉg\ [fchYgeiY g]`Ybh ib!
ga]`]b[ ghfUb[Y a]b]UhifYg Zfca Ub c`X dU]bh]b[" H\]g aUm VY U b]WY
Zc`_`cf]WhciW\ cZh\YUbW]YbhgXf]b_]b[UbXVck`]b[]bgcaYdfcj]b!
W]U` 9`mg]ia cf JU`\U``U/ Vih ]Z h\Ym UfY ]bXYYX <YbXf]_ <iXgcb UbX
\]gaYb h\YmU`gchifbcih\]ghcf]WU``mhcVYZi[]h]jYgZfcaUjYfmVUX
`Y[YbX"CbYfYaYaVYfgWcb[Yb]U``mh\Uh<iXgcb Ub9b[`]g\aUbgU]`]b[
Zcfh\Y8ihW\ aU_Yg\]ghcfm]b]h]U``mh\fci[\\]gjcmU[]b[]bh\YfY[]cbg
cZh\Ya][\hmf]jYfgcbUaYX/cbYfYaYaVYfg`YggkY`` ]ZUhU`` h\Uhh\Y
jcmU[]b[WUfYYfYbXgZUfhch\YWc`Xbcfh\ ]bU`Uf[Y `UbX`cW_YXVUmgc
bUaYX½k]h\h\Y`YUXYfWcfX]U``mWUghUXf]ZhVmUWfYkcZgWUfYX gWifjm
aih]bYYfg"@]_Yk]gYa][\hVYbchYXF]dÁgckbUbW]YbhWcbX]h]cb Ug\]g
ckbghfUb[YXfYUaZUXYg]bhc\]ghcfm"<YkU_Ygidc`X VYUfXYX f]W_Yhm
k]h\Ua]gg]b[Xc[UbXUfchhYXkYUdcb/\]gfYgiffYWh]cb giW\Ug]h]g ]g
UacaYbhcZU[Y XYWfYd]hiXY UbXXYWUm"
5bXh\Ybh\YfY]gh\YYeiU``mZUaciggWYbYcZfYhifb"H\Ydf]WY
cZ h\Y k]`X XfYUa cZ ZfYYXca U \]ghcf]WU` Xfib_ cbY a][\h WU`` ]h½
]b h\]g WUgY g`YYd]b[ h\fci[\ h\Y 5aYf]WUb FYjc`ih]cb½]g YlUWhYX ]b
ei]hYUbUghm`]hh`Y\Ub[cjYfWcaYXmcZY[U`]hUf]Ubdc`]h]Wg"H\YdUghcfU`
kcf`X h\Y `UbXgWUdY cZ ÉY`X UbX WchhU[Y h\Y h]Xm j]``U[Y \UjY U`` VY!
WcaY d`UWYg cZ ibWYfhU]bhm UbX ghfUb[Y aYbUWY" H\Y jYfm d`UWY ]hgY`Z
h\YgWYbYcZ`]ZY \UgVYYbhfUbgZcfaYX"H\YghifXmc`X¾j]``U[Y]bb ¿kY
UfY hc`X k\YfY F]d \Ug gkUddYX [Yb]U` WcbjYfgUh]cb k]h\ \]g ZcfaYf
hckbgaYb \UgVYYbfYd`UWYXVm¾U`Uf[Y f]W_YhmkccXYbVi]`X]b[ µk]h\
[fYUh[Ud]b[k]bXckg gcaYcZh\YaVfc_Yb UbXaYbXYXk]h\c`X\Uhg
UbXdYhh]WcUhg¿UbXk]h\df]bh]b[cjYfh\YXccfUbbcibW]b[¾H\YIb]cb
<chY` Vm>cbUh\Ub8cc`]hh`Y"¿5g][bdfYj]cig`mXYd]Wh]b[h\YfcmU`j]g!
U[YcZ?]b[;Ycf[Y\UgbchVYYbfYd`UWYX½]h]gcbYcZh\YghcfmÁgVYgh
hciW\Yg½Vihg]ad`mdU]bhYXcjYf.¾H\YfYXWcUhkUgW\Ub[YXZcfcbYcZ
V`iYUbXViZZ/UgkcfXkUg\Y`X]bh\Y\UbX]bghYUXcZUgWYdhYf/h\Y\YUX
kUgXYWcfUhYXk]h\UWcW_YX\Uh UbXibXYfbYUh\kUgdf]bhYX]b`Uf[Y
W\UfUWhYfg;9B9F5@K5G<=B;HCB"¿@]_Yk]gY ]bd`UWYcZUg\Y`!
hYf]b[hfYY h\Y]bb]gbckdfYg]XYXcjYfVmUÊU[ghUZZ½¾UhU``bU_YXdc`Y
k]h\gcaYh\]b[cbhcdh\Uh`cc_YX`]_YUfYXb][\hWUd UbXZfca]hkUg
&(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
ÊihhYf]b[UÊU[cbk\]W\kUgUg]b[i`UfUggYaV`U[YcZghUfgUbXghf]dYg"¿
H\YghfUb[YVUbbYf cZWcifgY ]gh\YbYkbUh]cbU`ÊU["H\YÉb]U`XYWc!
fUh]cb]gh\Y`]VYfhmWUd V`ccX]`mhfUbgac[f]ÉYXVmh\Y:fYbW\>UWcV]bg
]bhch\Y]aU[YcZfYjc`ih]cbUfmaUgg!aifXYf"
5bYeiU``mghfUb[YWcaV]bUh]cbcZUVgifX]hmUbXaYbUWY]gdfc!
^YWhYXVmh\YWi`hifU`UWhcfg]bh\YgWYbY"H\Yj]g]cbcZUkcf`XhfUbg!
ZcfaYXdYfaYUhYgh\YW\UfUWhYfcZh\YdYcd`Yh\YagY`jYg"H\Y]XYc`c[]!
WU`acaYbhWci`XbchVYacfYWfiW]U``mcfdfYW]gY`mXYd]WhYX"=h]gUb
Y`YWh]cb UWUWcd\cbmUbXW\UcgcZ\UfUb[i]b[ VfcUXg]X]b[ gdYYW\]Zm!
]b[ VU]h]b[UbXVi``m]b["=bd`UWYcZ¾h\YgU[YB]W\c`UgJYXXYf¿cf¾JUb
6iaaY`h\YgW\cc`aUghYf ¿kYUfYhc`X F]dÉbXgcbWYbhYfghU[Y¾U`YUb
V]`]cigZY``ckk]h\\]gdcW_YhgZi``cZ\UbXV]``gµ\UfUb[i]b[jY\YaYbh`m
UVcih f][\hg cZ W]h]nYbg½Y`YWh]cbg½aYaVYfg cZ 7cb[fYgg½`]VYfhm½
6ib_YfÁg \]``½\YfcYg cZ gYjYbhm!g]l½UbX ch\Yf kcfXg k\]W\ kYfY U
dYfZYWhVUVm`cb]g\^Uf[cbhch\YVYk]`XYfYXJUbK]b_`Y"¿
H\YhYfagcZgcW]U`]bhYfWcifgY\UjYW\Ub[YX ]bXYYX" F]dÁg jYfm
UddYUfUbWYXfUkgUWfckX"H\Yb k]h\]bacaYbhg h\Y¾cfUhcf¿UbX\]g
Wc\cfhgUfYWcbXiWh]b[Ub]bei]g]h]cb XYaUbX]b[hc_bck¾cbk\]W\
g]XY\YjchYX ¿¾:YXYfU`cf8YacWfUh ¿YhW" YhW"GcaiW\ UddUfYbh`m
ZcfgYWfYhVU``chgUbXh\YgUbWh]hmcZh\Ydc``]b[d`UWY"F]d cZWcifgY
\Uj]b[ g`Ydh h\fci[\ h\Y FYjc`ih]cb ]g VUZÊYX" 5 ¾gY`Z ]adcfhUbh c`X
[Ybh`YaUb ]b U WcW_YX \Uh¿ aYUbk\]`Y UWWigYg \]a cZ kcfgY h\Ub ][!
bcfUbWY UbX#cf U f][\h hc dc`]h]WU` df]jUWm XYaUbX]b[ hc _bck ¾k\Uh
Vfci[\h\]ahch\YY`YWh]cbk]h\U[ibcb\]gg\ci`XYfUbXUacVUh\]g
\YY`gUbXk\Yh\Yf\YaYUbhhcVfYYXUf]ch]bh\Yj]``U[Y3¿
HcU``h\]g h\YbYk`mdcgh!FYjc`ih]cbUfmF]daU_Ygh\YkcfghcZ
U``dcgg]V`YUbgkYfg"¾5`Ug [Ybh`YaYb ¿\YV`ifhgcih ¾=UaUdccfei]Yh
aUb UbUh]jYcZh\Yd`UWY UbXU`cmU`giV^YWhcZh\Y?]b[½;cXV`Ygg
\]a¿
¾<YfY ¿kYUfYhc`X ¾U[YbYfU`g\cihVifghZfcah\YVmghUbXYfg½
ÀUhcfmUhcfmUgdmUFYZi[YY\igh`Y\]aUkUmk]h\\]aÁ¿CfXYf]g
VUfY`mfYghcfYX"H\Y]bhYffc[Uh]cbWcbh]biYg"F]dÁg]XYbh]hm]gYjYbhiU``m
YghUV`]g\YX½UXUi[\hYfYaYf[YgcihcZ>SbS`9ZOcahcjciW\Zcf\]a/]b
Ub]WY5aYf]WUbVUW_kccXghciW\ UbYÁYf!Xc!kY``XciV`YcZUgcbUbX
bUaYgU_Y`YUbgU[U]bghUbYUfVmhfYY"H\YZUWhgcZh\Ydc`]h]WU`acaYbh
&)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
^igh dUggYX fYaU]b g\cW_]b[ UbX iba]ghU_UV`Y. F]d h\Y fYjYbUbh \Ug
bYUf`mVYYb`mbW\YX"
=bU``h\YgYfYgdYWhg =fj]b[ÁggUh]fYcZ`]ZY]bh\YYUf`mfYdiV`]WVY!
WcaYgdfcd\Yh]WcZh\Y]adYbX]b[YfUcZfci[\UbXhiaV`Y>UW_gcb]Ub!
]ga U d`UWY k\YfY h\Y `]bY VYhkYYb XY!acWfUWm UbX acV!cWfUWm WUb
giXXYb`mfibjYfmh\]b"6ihh\YfY]gacfY\YfYh\Ub^ighh\YZibcZh\Y
hcfmbcghU`[]gh cfUhh\Y`YUghUZYXYfU`]ghk]h\UWYfhU]b`cmU`]ghbcghU`[]U"
H\YfY]gU`gcUdf]acfX]U`j]c`YbWY`if_]b[ibXYfh\YgifZUWYcZh\]b[g
bcaUhhYfk\ch\YcV^YWhcZh\YdYhhm>UWcV]b]ga"=bh\YgUaYWYbhifm
7`YaYbgÁdfYXUhcfmVUW_kccXg]X`Yfg h\Y8i_YUbXh\Y8Uid\]b aUm
ÉbU``m[Yhk\Uh]gWca]b[hch\YaZcfh\Y]fg]bg fibb]b[Ua]ggcZUgaU``
hckbacV `UghgYYbVY]b[hUffYXUbXZYUh\YfYXUbXf]XXYbcihcZhckb
cbUfU]`"6ihh\]g]ghccaiW\Zcf<iW_½YjYbUhacaYbhk\Yb\Y\Ug
YjYfmfYUgcbhc\UhYh\YafcibX`m"¾<iaUbVY]b[g ¿\YWcbW`iXYg ¾QO\
VYUkZi`WfiY`hccbYUbch\Yf"¿
H\igcbYgYbgYgh\YaccXUgkY`` ZcfUh`YUghUXfYUXZi`acaYbh
]b¾F]dJUbK]b_`Y ¿cZdUghcfU`ZUbhUgmgiVgiaYX]bhcdc`]h]WU`b][\h!
aUfY"K\UhgUjYgh\Yghcfm UgZUfUgh\YaU]bW\UfUWhYf]gWcbWYfbYX ]g
h\Uh]h]gbchUghcfmgcaiW\UVcih\]ghcfmcfYjYbW\UfUWhYfgcaiW\Ug
UVcihhYadYfUaYbhcfdYfgcbU`]hm"5bXh\Uh]gk\YfYh\YY`YaYbhcZZU]fm
hU`YfY!UggYfhg]hgY`Z^ighk\Yb]hbYYXghc"H\YfY]g\iacf ]hgYYaghchY``
ig/Vihh\YfYUfYgh]``\iacfg½Ug]bh\YghcfmUh\UbX k\YfYÉ[ifYgUfY
UWhiU``m`UVY`YX¾V]`]cig ¿¾d\`Y[aUh]W ¿UbXh\Y`]_Y"HcgYYgcaYh\]b[
UgbYk`m\iacfcig ]gU`gchcgUmgcaYh\]b[c`XYfUVcih\iaUbbUhifY
[YbYfU``m"=bUb5aYf]WUVigm]b[]hgY`Zk]h\bUh]cbU`YldUbg]cbUbXh\Y
Vig]bYggcZdc`]h]WgUbXYWcbca]WUWei]g]h]jYbYgg ]h]ggiddcgYXhcVY
]adcfhUbhhcig kYgYY h\UhF]d]gibUaV]h]cig U`hfi]gh]W YUgm[c]b[
[ccX bUhifYX UbX h\Uh \Y ]g Zifh\Yf X]gh]b[i]g\YX Vm \]g bchUV`Y `UW_
cZ ]bXighfm cb aUhhYfg cZ \cigY\c`X UbX ZUa]`m dfcgdYf]hm UbX kY``!
VY]b["=bUb5aYf]WUk\YfYh\Ycf][]bU`XUi[\hYfgcZh\YFYdiV`]W h\Y
[YbYfUh]cbcZ5V][U]`5XUagcfAYfWmCh]gKUffYbUfYVY]b[giWWYYXYX
Vmh\Y]facfYWi`hifU``mWcbgYfjUh]jYUbXWcad`]UbhXUi[\hYfg h\Y]XYU
cZdYhh]WcUhhmfUbbmXYgYfjYgU[ccXdUfh]b[`Ui[\"5a]Xghh\YgibXfm
hifVi`YbWYgcZUkcf`X]bÊil F]d]gUVcjYU``^ighbUhifU``mdcdi`Uf½
d`YUgUbhYbci[\ UXUdhUV`Y ÊYl]V`Y Vihdcdi`Uf]bh\Uhib]eiYgYbgYcZ
&*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
h\YhYfacb`mUb5aYf]WUba][\hibXYfghUbXh\YbUbXbck½dcdi`Uf
hcVYcVj]cig ]bh\YkUmU6]``7`]bhcbcfU;Ycf[Y6ig\]gdcdi`Uf/cf
WcbjYfgY`m ]bh\YkUmUb5`;cfYcfU>c\b?Yffm]gbchdcdi`Uf½cf Ug
]adcfhUbh`m ]bUkUm<]`Ufm7`]bhcb]gZYUfYXbchhcVYdcdi`Uf k]h\h\Y
Yad\Ug]gcbZYUfYX"K\YbZfYYXcaWcaYg h\YXccfcZZUa]`mfY`Uh]cb
`ccgY`mhYfaYX k\YfYVm\YkYbhcih ]ggh]``cdYbZcfF]dhcWcaYVUW_
UbX Ugh\YmgUm fY!WcbbYWh"5gh\YJUbK]b_`YgU[UhfUbg`UhYg]hgY`Z]bhc
U bYk Wca]W ZUV`Y cZ [YbYfUh]cbg ]h ]g gcaY\ck U`` f][\h h\Uh `YUb]b[
U[U]bghh\UhhfYY]gF]d >f" ]b\Yf]hcfcZh\Uh`Y[YbXUfmbUaY UbYk`Y[!
YbXUfmj]``U[Y]X`Yf]b\]gZUh\YfÁg]aU[Y"=h]gUWWYdhUV`Yh\Uh8UaYJUb
K]b_`Y \Ug VYYb hfUbgac[f]ÉYX ]bhc \Yf _]bXYf [Ybh`Yf [YbYfUh]cbU`
giWWYggcf½U XUi[\hYf U`fYUXm VYWcaY U k]ZY UbX ach\Yf ]b \Yf ckb
f][\h cVj]cig`m gW\cc`YX ]b \Yf ckb ]fUgW]V]`]hm k]h\ aU`Y ZU]`ifY UbX
]adfcj]XYbWY Vih dUh]Ybh Ybci[\ hc jciW\ Zcf h\Y c`X aUb UbX hU_Y
\]a]b"
:cfh\cgYgW\cc`YX]bUWUXYa]WacXYgcZfYUX]b[ ]h\UgVYYb\UfX
cjYf h\Y mYUfg bch hc fYg]gh []j]b[ F]d gcaY ÉbU` dcg]h]jY UfW\YhmdU`
gd]b hcY`YjUhY\]gghcfmcZfYV]fh\]bhccbYacfYYldfYgg]cbcZ[fYUh
mYUfb]b[ 5aYf]WUb amh\ ]b h\Y gYbgY igYX Vm 8"<" @UkfYbWY ]b \]g
XYgWf]dh]cbcZ7ccdYfÁg@YUh\YfghcW_]b[HU`Yg UWmW`YcZWcbhYadcfUfm
WfYUh]cbg X]gh]bWh`m UbU`c[cig hc h\Y ?b]W_YfVcW_Yf bUffUh]jYg. ¾µh\Ym
[cVUW_kUfXg Zfcac`XU[Yhc[c`XYbmcih\ ¿\YkfchY"¾H\Uh]gh\YhfiY
amh\cZ5aYf]WU"G\YghUfhgc`X c`X kf]b_`YXUbXkf]h\]b[]bUbc`X
g_]b" 5bX h\YfY ]g U [fUXiU` g`ci[\]b[ cZ h\Y c`X g_]b hckUfXg U bYk
mcih\"=h]gh\Yamh\cZ5aYf]WU"¿
H\UhaUmVYgc"6ih]h]gU`gc\UfXbchhcfYUXh\YhYlh½UgcddcgYX
hch\Y]bhYbgY`mgYf]cigUbXX]XUWh]W7ccdYf½Ugk\Uh]hUgYUg]`mWci`X
VYaYUbhhcVY"5bXh\Uh]gUgU\caY[fckbZU]fmhU`Y½]bh\]gWUgY h\Y
ghcfm cZ U Vcm UbX \]g Xc[ k\c [Yh h\YagY`jYg ]bhc h\Y a]XX`Y cZ Ub
YlhYbXYX[c`ZcfÉg\]b[cf\ibh]b[cfXf]b_]b[^c_Y ]bjc`j]b[h\YXY!
a]gYcffYg][bUh]cbcZUgdcigY"AU`YUbXZYaU`YU`]_Y kYWUghcifYmYg
idkUfXUbXX]gUddfcjY hih!hih cZh\YZUbhUgmcZYgWUdY cZF]dfYhifbYX
UbXfYVcfb gUbgXcaYgh]WfYgdcbg]V]`]hmhcVcch"6ihYjYbhch\YYbX
kYUfYYbWcifU[YXhcYb^cm]hdfYW]gY`mVYWUigY]h]gh\Y\iacfcig Wca!
aib]hUf]Ub ghcfmhY``]b[_]bXcZghiZZcZk\]W\\iaUbXfYUagUfYaUXY
&+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
dUgh dfYgYbh UbXZihifY"H\YYad\Ug]gfYaU]bgcbF]dÁgfY!Ugg]a]`Uh]cb
]bhch\Yhf]VY \]gX]gWcjYfmcZUZYk¾ZcfaYfWfcb]Yg ¿VihU`gc\]gYl!
d`]W]h`mbchYXdfYZYfYbWYZcf¾aU_]b[Zf]YbXgUacb[h\Yf]g]b[[YbYfU!
h]cb k]h\k\ca\Ygccb[fYk]bhc[fYUhZUjcf"¿<Y]gUdYfgcbU`]hmk\c
\UgVYYbUWhiU``mU``ckYXhcVYWcaYU`Y[YbX]b\]gckba]bX kYUfY
Zifh\Yfhc`X U`cWU`ÉlhifY gcaYh\]b[cZUhcif]ghUhhfUWh]cb"5bXk\Yb
\Y]g[cbY h\YbUffUhcfWcbW`iXYg Uacb[h\YUbW]YbhZc`_cZh\Yd`UWY
UbXfY[]cb \Yk]``VYVfci[\hU`]jY]bh\YhY``]b[UbXfYhY``]b[cZ\]ghU`Y"
¾9jYbhch\]gXUm ¿h\YbUffUhcfWcbW`iXYg ¾h\YmbYjYf\YUfUh\ibXYf
ghcfacZUgiaaYfUZhYfbccbUVcihh\Y?UUhg_]`` Vihh\YmgUm<YbXf]W_
<iXgcbUbX\]gWfYkUfYUhh\Y]f[UaYcZb]bYd]bg/UbX]h]gUWcaacb
k]g\cZU``\YbdYW_YX\igVUbXg]bh\YbY][\Vcf\ccX k\Yb`]ZY\Ub[g
\YUjmcbh\Y]f\UbXg h\Uhh\Yma][\h\UjYUei]Yh]b[XfUZhcihcZF]d
JUbK]b_`YÁgÊU[cb"¿
H\Y]aU[YUhh\YYbXcZh\YYbW\Ubh]b[gcdcf]ÉW]gWfiW]U`"=bUb
5aYf]WU VYWcaY U hifVi`Ybh \chVYX cZ Zc`_]g\ bUh]cbU`]ga Zcf U`` ]hg
UW]Xdc`]h]Wg¾F]dJUbK]b_`Y¿Wci`Xgh]``VYUghcfmZcfh\YÉfYg]XYcZ
h\Y_]hW\YbWcfbYf"=bUVfUk`]b[ hiai`hicigdiV`]Wkcf`XcZ`Y[YbX!
UfmVfU[[]b[ VfUk`]b[ Vccn]b[ Vigm!bYgg ZcfU``]hg]adc`]hY\iacf ]h
Wci`Xgh]``VYUghcfmZcfh\YhUjYfbcfh\YWcifh\cigYgeiUfY"H\YfY]gU
`chcZ5aYf]WU]bh\Yghcfm/h\YfY]gU`chcZh\Yghcfm]b5aYf]WU"
H\]g kUg fYWc[b]nYX Zfca h\Y cihgYh" 5 VYgh!`cjYX h]h`Y U VYgh!
`cjYX ghcfm U`cb[ k]h\ ]hg WcadUb]cb!d]YWY ¾H\Y @Y[YbX cZ G`YYdm
<c``ck ¿]hVYWUaYdUfhUbXZUVf]WcZWi`hifU`]bgh]hih]cb½k]h\]hgXY!
g][bYlhYbXYX Ug]gcZhYbZcf[chhYb ]bhcUk\c`Y?b]W_YfVcW_YfWmW`Y
YaVfUW]b[giW\Ybgif]b[bUffUh]jYgUg¾8c`d\<Ym`][Yf ¿¾Kc`ZYfhKYV!
VYf ¿ ¾H\Y 8Yj]` UbX Hca KU`_Yf ¿ U`` a]l]b[ dUghcfU` bcghU`[]U k]h\
XYYdYfY`YaYbhgZfcah\Ykcf`XcZaU[]W kcf`XcZW\Ufag caYbg dcf!
hYbhg gdY``g"=bghUbhZc`_`Y[YbXh\UhWcbh]biYXh\Ykcf_cZYaVcXm]b[
UigUV`YdUgh"
AYUbk\]`Y F]dÁgghcfmkUghfUbg`UhYX]bhcdcdi`UfXfUaU k\YfY
]hei]W_`mVYWUaYUghU[YZUjcf]hY"5gYUf`mUg%,&- UbUXUdhUh]cbVm>c\b
?YffV]``YX]hgY`Z`if]X`m ¾F]dJUbK]b_`Y/cf h\Y8YacbgcZh\Y7Uhg_]``
AcibhU]bg5BUh]cbU`8fUaU"=bHkc5Whg"¿BYlhWUaYUddfcdf]U!
h]cbcZh\Yamh\UbXh\Yh]h`Yfc`YVmU`Y[YbXUfmUWhcf >cgYd\>YZZYfgcb
&,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
cbY cZ h\Y [fYUh 5aYf]WUb dcdi`Uf ZUjcf]hYg cZ h\Y U[Y" GhUfh]b[ k]h\
>YZZYfgcbÁg ghU[Y gWf]dh cZ %,)- UbX h\Yb fY!Yjc`j]b[ h\fci[\ Ub %,*)
Wc``UVcfUh]cb k]h\ WY`YVf]hm UWhcf!d`Umkf][\h 8]cb 6ciW]WUi`h k\c ]g
gU]Xhc\UjYhU_Yb]bgd]fUh]cbZcf\]gjYfg]cbZfca9W\U:SO` ¾F]d JUb
K]b_`Y/cfh\YG`YYdcZHkYbhmMYUfg¿VYWUaYh\YghUbXUfXfYbX]h]cb"
>YZZYfgcb\]agY`ZVYWUaYWcad`YhY`m]XYbh]ÉYXk]h\h\Yfc`Y UWh]b[]h
ZcfbYUf`mZcifXYWUXYgibh]`\]gfYh]fYaYbh UbXaU_]b[UgYf]YgcZg\cfh
É`ag]b%,-*h\Uhgh]``gifj]jY"
=bh\Y\]ghcfmcZdcdi`Uf]``ighfUh]cb h\YhU`YVYWUaYUW`Ugg]W]b
giWWYgg]jYfYbXYf]b[gVm:Y`]lC"7"8Uf`Ym 5fh\ifFUW_\Ua UbXB"7"
KmYh\"=bU`UhY%-h\WYbhifmaig]WU`jYfg]cb ]h[YbYfUhYXUbcdYfYhhU"
Acgh]adcfhUbh ]bdf]bhh\YghcfmfYaU]bYXUbYbX`Ygg`mUbh\c`c[]nYX
dcdi`UfUbXWiff]Wi`UfW`Ugg]W cbYcZh\YZYkkcf_gcZ5aYf]WUb`]hYfU!
hifYUddYUf]b[UhYjYfmdcdi`UfUbXYXiWUh]cbU``YjY`ZfcaY`YaYbhUfm
gW\cc`hcWc``Y[YUbXib]jYfg]hm"
5hh\YYbXcZh\YfYWYbhWYbhifm `Y[YbXUfmghUhigkUgWcbZYffYX
cb h\Y hU`Y U[U]b h\fci[\ ]hg ]bW`ig]cb½Ug h\Y gc`]hUfm 5aYf]WUb h]h`Y
]bUfcghYfcZhkYbhm!d`igUXUdhUh]cbgZfca9ifcdYUbhfUX]h]cb½]bh\Y
kY``!_bckbG\Y``Ym8ijU``hY`Yj]g]cbgYf]Yg4OS`WSBOZSBVSObS`"BchYkcf!
h\mUVcihh\YfYj]jU`kYfYh\YX]fYWh]cb½Vm:fUbW]g:cfX7cddc`U½UbX
h\YWUgh]b[ UgYhcZkU`_!cbWY`YVf]hmWUaYcggiffcibX]b[F]d d`UmYXVm
h\YW\UfUWhYfUWhcf<Uffm8YUbGhUbhcb k]h\8UaYJUbK]b_`Y\YfY
_bckbUg¾K]`aU ¿k]h\UbcXhc:fYX:`]bghcbYd`UmYXVmHU`]UG\]fY
cZ@]QYgUbXBVS5]RTObVS` UbXh\Ydcgh!FYjc`ih]cbUfmaUmcfcZh\Yj]`!
`U[YVmH]a7cbkUm cZ;Q6OZSÂa<OdgUbXBVS1O`]Z0c`\SbbAV]e"H\YfY
kUg U`gc giVghUbh]U` ¾WiffYbh YjYbhg¿ idXUh]b[" H\]g h]aY K]`aU JUb
K]b_`Y[chUhcffYbhcZ`]bYg\YUd]b[UVigYcbh\YZYW_`YggF]d/h\Ydc!
`]h]WcgUhh\YYbX\YUXYXVm7cbkUm`cc_YXgUh]gZUWhcf]`mViaV`]b[UbX
ghid]X"F]d[chhcXY`]jYfUd`YUZcfYbj]fcbaYbhU`UkUfYbYgg \UbXYX
Xckbhc\]aZfcaUXfYUa!WcbjYfgUh]cbk]h\<YbXf]_<iXgcb"5hh\Y
VY[]bb]b[UbXh\YYbX h\Ygd]f]hcZUBUh]jY5aYf]WUbWci`XVYgYYb
\cjYf]b[^ighk]h\]bh\YZfUaY"
5hUVcihh\YgUaYh]aY h\YghcfmkUg\cbcfYXVmBVS<ObW]\OZ3\
_cW`S`k]h\UdifdcfhYXYldcgYcZUhfiY\]ghcf]WU`jYfg]cb VUgYXcbh\Y
fYgYUfW\YgcZGhYd\YbDfYgg UdfcZYggcfUhbYUfVm8ihW\Ygg7caaib]hm
&-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
7c``Y[Y k\]`Y kf]h]b[ U aig]WU` cb h\Y giV^YWh" <YUX`]bYX ¾F]d JUb
K]b_`YÁg6][G`YYd]gU@=9½<YKUgUFYU`!@]ZY8fib_ ¿k]h\]bkUg
U``Y[YXh\YYl]ghYbWYcZU[Ybi]bYF]d Vcfb]b%,&+ ]b;UfX]bYf BYk
Mcf_ UbXh\YZUh\YfcZhkc >iX]h\UbXF]d >f"H\YZcfaYf U\cdY`Ygg
`UmUVcihUbXVccnYf Uh`Yb[h\YgWUdYX\]gk]ZYÁgbcbghcd`]hUb]YgcZWca!
d`U]bhVmfibb]b[UkUmhcBYkMcf_7]hmUfcibX%+*+ k\YfY\YaUXY
UgaU``WUfYYfhY``]b[ghcf]YgUbXg]b[]b[gcb[g]bhUjYfbg ]bhYfgdYfgYX
k]h\a]bcfUWh]b[fc`Yg"=bh\Y`UhhYfWUdUW]hm \YkUgX]gWcjYfYXVm\]g
XUi[\hYfcbUj]g]hhch\YW]hm ]``UbX\ia]`]UhYXVmh\YYZZYWhgcZUhkYbhm
mYUfVYbXYf"=hkUg]bZUWhhcX]g[i]gY\]gg\UaYh\Uh \]gk]ZYXYUX \Y
WcbWcWhYX\]ghU`YcZUgidYfbUhifU`g`YYd k\]W\\YU``Y[YX`mhc`XZcfh\Y
fYghcZ\]g`]ZY]bWcibhfmhUjYfbg"<]gXYUh\WUaY fYaUf_UV`m UhU[Y-%
h\YghcfmWcbW`iXYg/^ighcbYmYUfVYZcfY=fj]b[fYbXYfYX\]a]aacfhU`
]bh\YZUacigghcfm"
H\Uh hcc ]gh\YghcfmcZ5aYf]WU"<]ghcfmUbXamh\fYdYUhh\Ya!
gY`jYg Ug dUm!Zcf!j]Yk HJ UbX hUV`c]X YldcgY" 5bX YjYfm h]aY ]h VY!
WcaYgUjYfg]cbZcfWbah]aY UghfiYUgUbmcfUgZU`gYUgUbm"Hch\]gXY[fYY
cbYa][\hgUmh\Uh¾F]dJUbK]b_`Y¿\UgVYYb:U]fmHU`YH\YUhYfU`cb["
H\YaYUgifYcZh\YghcfmÁgUddYU`]gh\Uh]h]ghfiYVYWUigY]haU_Ygig[Yh
fYU`UVcihcifgY`jYgUgkYUfY"H\YZU]fmhU`YY`YaYbhgcZh\YghcfmfY!
aU]bhcd]WU`cfWi`hifU`]bh\YZi``YghgYbgY.UbYbX`Ygga]b]b[cZ\iacf
Zfca U a]gc[mbm h\UhkcaYb ci[\h hc ÉbX ]bZif]Uh]b[/ Ub UXc`YgWYbh
]aU[YcZaU`YbYggh\UhaYbci[\hhcÉbXXYYd`mdfcV`YaUh]W/UXYd]W!
h]cbcZh\YbUh]cbU`dc`]h]WU`W\UfUWhYfUg]b\YfYbh`mgY`Ég\UbXj]W]cig/
h\Y YbXcfgYaYbh cZ U WYfhU]b _]bX cZ \]ghcf]WU` UbX Wi`hifU` YgWUd]ga
h\UhYbWcifU[YgighcfYj]gYh\YdUghgcUghcaU_Yh\YZihifYkcf_ cfUh
`YUgh`cc_dfca]g]b[Zcfh\YacaYbh"6ih Ug]adcfhUbh`m h\Yhcd]WU`cf
Wi`hifU`Y`YaYbhgcZh\YghcfmfYaU]bZU]fm!hU`Y]bh\YZi``YghgYbgY"5g]h
dfcdY`gigZcfkUfX]bh]aY ]hhU_YgigVUW_"=h]gbchZcfbch\]b[h\Uh:"
GWchh:]hn[YfU`XYbXgBVS5`SOb5ObaPgk]h\h\Y]aU[YcZUghfUb[Y kcb!
XfcigjcmU[]b[ cZUkcf`X¾h\UhÊckYfYXcbWYZcf8ihW\gU]`cfgÁYmYg¿
k\YfY]b kY cifgY`jYg bck ¾VYUh cb VcUhg U[U]bgh h\Y WiffYbh VcfbY
VUW_WYUgY`Ygg`m]bhch\YdUgh"¿
'$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
A5F;C69F89G<9JG?M
EW\R]e
)
S \Y\UhYXGU]bhJU`Ybh]bYÁgXUm"5kcaUb]bU[UfhYfVY`h"
5bXUach\k\cZYYXgcbgd]WY"
H\YkcaUbghUbXg]bh\YVY][Y`UWYVY`hk\]W\]gU[]Zhh\UhkUg]b
\YfaU]`Vclh\]gacfb]b["G\Y\UXgU]X ¾=k]``bchWY`YVfUhY`cjYÁgXUm
UbmacfY ib`Yggcfibh]`gcaY[ccXaUb`YUjYgaYVYUih]Zi``]b[Yf]Y]b
am`YhhYfVcl"¿
5bXh\Yb]h\UddYbYX"G\Y]gghUbX]b[Uh\Yfk]bXck kYUf]b[h\Y
[]Zh"
Cihg]XY ]h]gKYXbYgXUmbccb UbXVYUih]Zi``m XY`]WUhY`m gbck!
]b["=bg]XY g\Y]gkUfaUbXg\Y]gUh\Yfk]bXck"6Y`ck]bh\YÊm]b[
gbck \Y]gkUhW\]b["G\YaU_YgUg][bk]h\h\YÉb[YfgcZcbY\UbX `]_Y
UVihhYfÊm UbX\Y_bckg\YaUmj]g]h bck"
K\Yb\YYbhYfg\Yffcca ]h]gk]h\Ubch\YfgaU``[]Zh UgeiUfY
h\]b[ kfUddYX h\fYY h]aYg ]b h]ggiY dUdYfg h\Y Wc`cf cZ W\fmgUbh\Y!
aiag"H\YaUijY h\Yd`ia h\YXYYdYghfYX"G\YcdYbg]h`]_YUbYU[Yf
W\]`X"5h]bmWf]W_YhWU[Y `]_Yh\YcbYg]bghfYYhaUf_Yhg]b<cb[?cb["
BchUWf]W_Yh]b]h h\ci[\/Ugd]WYach\"
5kcaUb]bU[UfhYfVY`h"5aUbk\cibXYfghccX\YfbYYX"
G\YhU_Ygh\YkcbXYfZi`bYk[]ZhUbXWUff]Yg]hhch\Yk]bXckUbX
g\YcdYbg]hei]W_`m/gYbXgh\Yach\cih]bhch\YÊihhYf]b[k\]hY"¾=hk]``
X]Y ¿\YgUmg"
G\YZfYYgh\YaUb Ugg\YW`cgYgh\YV`]bX"
<Yk]``ZcfYjYfgdYU_cZh\]gkcaUb"
Bck]ZYWUbVYUfhc`]ghYb"
'%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5BB:=G<9F!K=FH<
DO`WObW]\a]\bVS@]PPS`0`WRSU`]][
)
'&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
=aUff]YXh\Y\UbXgcaYVU_Yf"
=WUbbchg`YYd `cb[]b[Zcfh\YkccXgh\UhXUm
`cb[]b[`]_YUZcc`ZcfamfcVVYfVf]XY[fcca"
=hfUddYX\]a :Uh\Yf_]``YX\]a"
5`kUmg=XfYUacZ\]g\UbXg U`kUmg=\YUfamjc]WY½
4ObVS`^`S^O`Sg]c`[S\
/bbVSPO\_cSbeVS\[gP`WRSU`]][
Q][Sab]QZOW[[S7ÂZZZcZZVW[eWbVeW\S
ZOgVWaVSORW\[gZO^O\RbSZZVW[bVWaab]`g(
=WUaYhcU\cigY]bh\YZcfYgh
k\YfYUmY``ckV]fX]bUWU[YgUb[
¾HifbVUW_ hifbVUW_ h\ciVcbb]YVf]XYµ¿
5bc`XkcaUbghfi[[`YXhc\YfZYYh
dig\]b[\Yf\UbXgVYZcfY\Yf"
G\Y\iff]YXaY]bhch\YVUgYaYbh
\]XaYVY\]bXUk]bYWUg_"
½K\mXcmcighUfh am`cjY3
=hkUgcb`mUXfYUa"
GccbfcVVYfgUff]jYX amVf]XY[fcca
Uacb[h\Ya"H\YmVfci[\h]bU[]f`
h\Ym\UXZcibX]bh\YZcfYgh
UbXaUXY\YfXf]b_k\]hYk]bY
mY``ckk]bY fYX"5h`Ugh\Yf\YUfhVifgh"
½K\mXcmcighUfh am`cjY3
=hkUgcb`mUXfYUa"
7ckYf]b[VY\]bXh\Yk]bYWUg_
=\]XZfcah\Y_b]jYgUbXgWfYUa]b["
H\YfcVVYfgf]ddYX\YfVcX]WYUbXg_]fhg"
H\YfcVVYfgWih\Yf]bd]YWYg"
''
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
<YfÉb[YfÊYkhcam`Udk\YfY=
WfciW\YX\]X]b["
½K\mXcmcighUfh am`cjY3
=hkUgcb`mUXfYUa"
5bX\YfY
]gh\YÉb[Yfµ
'(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
!
Gc kYaYYhU[U]b mcik\cWUaYh\fci[\h\YW`cgYXgWfYYbXccf
h\cgYb][\hg]b7U`]Zcfb]U"Mcif\U]f]gkYh½XUf_kUhYf"
Gg\½amZUa]`m]gg`YYd]b["@UmmcifWcUhcbamVcc_g
dig\mcifVcchgVYbYUh\amVYX"H\YfYk]``VY`cjY"
H]``h\YYbXcZam`]ZYmciÁ``WcaYhcaY"
H\Ybh\Yg_mk]``gd`]h`]_YUa]`_kYYXdcXUbXcihk]``ÊmamjUb]g\YXW\]`XfYb"
')
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
"
=`YZhh\Y\UbXgcaYVU_Yf"
9UW\b][\h=g]h]bh\YXUf_
]bamZUh\Yfh\Ya]``YfÁg\cigY
UbXgWUbh\YkccXgZcfaccb`][\h
hcdf]W_aYUdUh\h\fci[\h\YZcfYgh
cZh\YgYXYUX"Hc`YUXcbWYU[U]b
dUghh\YV]fX h\Y[UVV`]b[kcaUb
h\Yj]Wh]a \YfÉb[Yfh\UhgcUfgh\fci[\h\YU]f
V`ccX]Ygamg_]fh UbXgYUfgamh\][\"
=k\]gdYf]h`]_YU`]hUbm.
EVWbSeW\SgSZZ]e`SR
RSO`5]RaVSVOaPSS\QV]aS\ZSbVS`R`W\YWb
ZSbVS`VSO`bPc`abUbX]hXcYgVifgh½
=Z=Wci`XUff]jYUhh\UhhUV`Y
=ÁXhifbhcamVf]XY[fccak]h\hYbXYfbYgg.
BOYSSOb[gP`WRSU`]][
O\ReVWZSg]cQVSebVSU`WabZS]T[gVSO`b
7eWZZbSZZg]c[gR`SO[]TOUW`Z
eV]ZcZZag]c`aca^WQW]\aeWbVeW\S
eV]aSYW\a[S\eOWbP`WabZW\UeWbVY\WdSa
eV]R`OeaT`][VS`^]QYSbOË\US`¾
'*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
#
=\UjYWcaYVUW_k\YfYh\YUnU`YUWUghg]hgg\UXck"
CjYfh\YaiXXmÉY`Xg UZfch\cZkYYXg"
GibUZhYffU]b h\YVYUih]Zi`igY`YggW\Ub[Yg"
Am`cjY =k]g\=\UXYUhYbU``hkY`jYgYYXg"
'+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
HCBM:F=98<C::
BV`SS>]S[a
)
BOZS]T1S`bWbcRS
5aUbVYWcaYgh]YXhch\Y[fcibX"Ch\Yfh\Ubh\Y[fck]b[cZ[fUgg
h\YfYÁgbch\]b[aiW\ Vih=bYjYffYU`]nYX\ckf\mh\a]WU``m
h\]gWUb\UddYb UbXU``h\Yk]`XUb]aU`ghYUW\]b[\]ahcXUbWY
]bh\YacjYaYbhgcZcbYk\c]gh]YXhch\Y[fcibX
]bh\YacjYaYbhgcZcbYk\c]gVY]b[YUhYb"K\c]gVY]b[_]bX\YfY3
5fYh\YfY[cXgcfZU]f]Yg3=Zcf[Yh"H\Y^UW_U`aUmVY½
\]g`YZhYmYfYÊYWhgU`]hh`YacfYh\Ubh\Y[f]gh`YmciÁXYldYWh"
=ibXYfghUbX Vihcb`mU`]hh`Y h\Y`YhhYfg\YdfYhYbXghcfYUX
]bYUW\V`UXYcZ[fUgg h\Yd`chgh\UhdfYhYbXhcibZc`X
Ug]h[fckg"H\Y^UW_U`gYhgh\YhYadcVmgWfUhW\]b[h\YYUfh\
UbXVUfY`mfYaYaVYfg\ckkYVfci[\h\]ahch\]ggdch
U`cb[k]h\\]gZY``ckXUbWYfg"5aUbVYWcaYgXYUX"
H\Y^UW_U`VYWcaYgUh\]b_]b[WfYUhifY"<]gÉfghfYU`]nUh]cb
]gh\Uh\YVfci[\h\]agY`Zhch\]ggdch"<YfYUXgYjYfmh\]b[
\YWUb`Um\]gYmYgcb UbXhYUfggcaiW\cdYbh\Uh\]gYmYg
UfY[`UggmUbXV`ccXg\ch"H\Y^UW_U`VYWcaYgWif]cig"
H\Y[fcibXVYWcaYgg`]W_k]h\h\YV`ccXcZh\Y^UW_U`Ág]bei]fm"
5bh`YfgXUbWYk]h\hfYYVUf_"H\YfY]gUgk]f`]b[hc[Yh\Yf
cZh\YÊi]Xgcbh\Yd`U]b½d`UbhÊi]Xg Ub]aU`Êi]Xg
XighÊi]Xg½]bUV`UW_diXX`Yg`]dd]b[Zfcah\Y^UW_U`Ágacih\"
8cYgh\Y^UW_U`fYaYaVYfh\YaUbh\UhVfci[\h\]a\YfY3
8cYg\YfYaYaVYfig kYk\cVfci[\hh\YaUbUbXh]YX\]a3
8cYgh\Y^UW_U`fYaYaVYfch\YfXUbWYfg cfYjYbh\Y`][\h
]b\]gckb`YZhYmY3Bc"MYg"=bYjYffYU`]nYX\ckf\mh\a]WU``m
h\]gWci`X\UddYb"H\Y[fcibXVYWcaYgU`cc_]b[[`Ugg"
',
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BOZS]T0`]\hS
H\YfYkUgUf]b[UbX]hWcbgiaYXaY"Cf]g]hVYhhYfhcgUm.
=dUggYXh\fci[\]h/h\YfYkUgUf]b[UbX]hV]fh\YXaY
]hgg\UXckWfcgg]b[amZUWY []j]b[aYUW\]`X]g\`cc_3
K\Uh]gVYhhYfhcgUm.h\Uhh\Y_]b[ÁgXUi[\hYfZY``]b`cjY
cfh\Uhh\Yg\UXckcZh\Yf]b[dUggYXcjYfaY UbXh\Yb=_]``YX
UbXh\Yb=_]``YX UbXh\Yb=_]``YXibh]`g\YkUga]bY3
h\YV`ccXcZh\fYYXc[gcbamZUWY cfh\YdUhfcbgU]bhcZW\]`XfYb
WckYf]b[]bamdfYgYbWY3H\YX]UacbXVcUhgYU`g]hgdUh\
VY\]bX]h UbXh\YWcU`VcUh`YUjYgUhfU]`h\Uhh\YkUjYg
fYZigYcfZU]`hcgWUhhYf"K\]W\]gVYhhYf3
H\YaYfW\UbhgYU`g\]gdfYgYbWYk]h\UVUg_YhZi``cZfYXÉg\"
KYU``Xck\Uhh\Yk]hW\hY``gig"H\YaYfW\UbhVimgUdUh\
hch\Yf]b[Ágg\UXck UbX=UaZUfUkUm VihaiW\`YggW\]`X]g\"
=UaZUfUkUm Vihg`][\h`mW`cgYfhcXYUh\"K\mXcYgYjYfmh\]b[
\UddYbk\Yb=ghYdUkUm3KYU``Xck\Uhh\Yk]hW\hY``gig
UbXh\YWUfdYhcZ`YUjYgibXYfZcchhY``gaY=UabchWYbhfU`hc\Yfd`Ub"
H\YaYfW\UbhgY``g\]gdfYgYbWYZcfh\Yg\UXckgcZ\]gÉg\"
KYU``Xck\Uhh\Yk]hW\hY``gig UbXZcfh\]gfYUgcbh\YV`ccX
k]``cjYf`UdcbamZUWY.Éfghh\Yk\]hY h\Ybh\YV`UW_ h\Ybh\YfYX"
H\YaYfW\UbhgY``g\]gdfYgYbWYZcfamVfcbnYf]b[
UbXamg\UXckghYdgUkUm"K\]W\]gVYhhYfhcgUm.
h\Uhh\Ydf]bWYgggc`Xamf]b[ cfh\Uh=kUgh]fYX
UbXZUfUkUm h\Uh=ghcddYXWUgh]b[g\UXck3
'-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BOZS]T@SRcQbW]\
K]``]Uaghf]b[g\]gVck"=ZkYYjYfdUfh ]hg]b[g"
=ZkYYjYfdUfh h\YbUh]cbgk]``f]gYU[U]bghig"
K]``]UaXfUkgidhch\YWUgh`YkU``gcb\]gV]WmW`Y"
=ZkYYjYfaYYh K]``]UagUmg"=ZkYYjYfaYYh
h\Ygibg\]bYk]``kUjYfgckYWUbgYYk\UhkYÁjYa]ggYX"
8fUdYX]b\]gaY`cXm K]``]UaZcf[YhghcdfcdYf`mdUf_
h\YV]WmW`Y":UfYkY``Zcfbck ]hgUmghc\]a UbXhiaV`Yg
]bhch\Y:cibXF]jYf":UfYkY``Zcfbck"
=UaUbibZU]fUXjUbhU[Yhcmci"
H\Yf]jYfÁgaY`cXm[]jYgK]``]UagcaYh\]b[hch\]b_UVcih"
=hdig\Ygh\YdYXU`gUbXh\YW\U]bWcaYg`ccgY/
]hd`iW_gZfcah\Ygdc_Ygh\YXfYUabchYgcZU\Ufd"
=hhifbgh\Yk\c`Yh\]b[hcgYX]aYbhUbXYfcXYg]hUkUm"
K]``]UaghUfYgUhh\YgibhcVf]b[Zcfh\h\YdfcdYfhYUfg"
H\YfYUfYbcg\cfhWihgh\]gh]aY h\YgibhY``g\]a
UbXh\Yb]hghf]_YgK]``]UaV`]bX"<YÉbXgh\YWUgh`YkU``
dfYggYgh\YÊYg\cZ\]gW\YY_U[U]bgh]hgghcbY"
H\YkU``WUb\YUfh\UhK]``]Ua]ggh]``h\]b_]b[
cb`mf]jYfh\ci[\hg WUb\YUf]hgjU[fUbhaY`cXm
cb\]gVfYUh\"=Uabchmcif`cjYf h\YkU``YW\cYgUh\]a"
=Uabchmcif`cjYf/Yfcg]cb]gUg\UaYZi`YbX"
Ghib[ K]``]UaXfckbg\]gVck"=ZkYYjYfdUfh
($
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
]hg]b[g"=ZkYYjYfaYYh K]``]Uak\]gdYfg
UbXh\YWUgh`Y\UgVYYbWcbeiYfYXbckZcfWYbhif]Yg"
(%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5F=9@@9;F99B69F;
4]c`>]S[a
)
>]S[eWbVB`]RRW\UW\7b
BccbYUXj]gYg`UhY!b][\hkU``Wc`cfg"H\YmÁ``g\ihmci]b h\YmgUm"
?YYdmcifbUaYUaYUg`m[c`X"?YYd]hgYWfYh"
8i``]Zm]h"GUaYUggdYbX]b[dckYf"GUaYUgh\YVcbY
=WUbÁhmUb_Zfcaamkf]gh h\ci[\h\YV]fh\aUf_
h\UhkUgUbU`Ufa]bYjYfmY`YaYbhUfmgW\cc`=UhhYbXYX\UgjUb]g\YX
Ug]ZWihUkUm"5g]Z=dfYggYX]hUg\UfXUg=`]_YXk]h\h\YYX[YcZambU]`
ibh]`kYkYfYYl\UighYX aYUbXh\YZcfY][bYfibXYfamg_]b
h\Y`]hh`YV`]b_Yf"Bck=kUbhhcdU]bhamkU``g
h\YWc`cfcZh\Uha]ghU_Y"BckYjYfmcbYX]ghfighgaY
h\ci[\=bYjYf[chXYhYbh]cb"Bck=g]b_`]_YUVfYUX`cUZ
g_]d`]_YUZfc[ kYUfUb][\h[ckbk]h\bch\]b[ibXYfh\YUfag"
=bamg_]b ]bh\YUVgYbWYcZ`UWYcf`]bYb =WUffmh\Yaig_mdU]bh
ZcfamhcUX!\cigY]bh\YgkUad"=`]jYk]h\cih`][\hgh\YfY"
=h[fckgcbaY"9jYfmmYUf=`]_Y]hgcaYacfY"
(&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
C^/`]c\R1W\RS`SZZO
@cjY#\UhYh\YZUWY]bh\Yk]bXckk\YfY
]bgcaYWUgh`Y WUff]U[Y WcUW\!`YXZUbZUfY
\]XXYbVY\]bXUj]c`YhgeiUfY.
Udf]bWYgg\Y`XU`cZhVmh\YU]f"
K]``mcifmUfXWcbhU]bUk]g\]b[kY``3
6fUaV`YXfcgYg3:U]fmVY``g3
H\YdYUk]``bYjYf_]ggUbXhY``"
:UbhUgmVYXgaU_Yh\Y]fckbZfYg\\Y``"
@cjY#\UhYh\YghUh]b[cZh\YcVj]cig"
;YhcbVcUfXk]h\h\Ycab]Vig"
MciÁ``[fckidU[]f` h\Y_]bXcbYWUbhfigh"
GYhmcifWcifgYVmghUfgZcfig"
HfiggYXVmUWUbcdm ZY``YXZfcaUhfYY
h\YVci[\]gVfc_YVmYUW\[]f`VUVm"
H\Ygcb[=ÁjYgib[]gg]ad`YUbXWfYYdm.
h\Yghcf]Yg\UjYUlYg"7ihmcifgY`ZZfYY"
('
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
4]`U]bbS\
5g]bUZU]fmhU`Y h\YfYÁgU\c`Y]bamVcc_k\YfYUach\Yfg\ci`XVY
U\c`Y]bam\YUX WUi[\h]bamh\fcUh
U\c`Y]bamÉbYZY`h\YUfhkcfbcbUZcV"
H\YfYÁgU\c`YV][Ybci[\hcdig\amÉb[Yfh\fci[\
UbXÊYlhcZYY`h\YÊccXcZU]f=UaXUaa]b["
H\]g\c`YX]Y!Wih]bam`]ZYUbXdYYfYXcih
hcUb]``ia]bUhYXdU[Yk]h\UWUgh`YUbXUfcc_
h\]gfcibX jc]XYXgdUWY am[]bVS`"
H\Y\c`Yh\Uh\]``gmY``h\fci[\"
=Z=Zc``ckYXh\YZUa]`]UfdUh\g½kUgcfd\UbYX
hU_Ybhch\Ykc`jYgcfh\Yk]hW\Ygcf`YZh]bgd]bX`YX_bchg½
kY`` OaW\=Ua`]j]b[h\Y[ccX`]ZYk]h\cih
ÊccXYXk]h\fY`]YZh\Uhh\Y\c`YkUgWih
bYUhUbXhUih hcU``ckZcfh\Yd`YUgUbhXUab]b[cZama]`XYmYg"
K]h\cihh\UhdUfhcZh\Yd`ch =WUbgYYh\YbYlhdU[Y UbXh\YbYlh
kccX`UbXWfYUhifYg h\fYYZU]fma]Xk]jYgW`cU_YX]bV`iY
UbXh\Yd`UWYk\YfYh\YfY]gbckU\c`YigYXhcVYUVUXkcfX
Vih]gbcacfY g\Y]gg\YUfYXZfcaamVcc_ `cc_
=UakUj]b[]bUWfmghU`[ckb]bfcmU`dfcWYgg]cb \Udd]`m
`cc_ =Ua`YXVmghYYXgUhUhfch \Udd]`m `cc_
amWfUX`Y]g[cggUaYf!jY]`YXUbXgUZY`mWUi[\h ÉbU``m
h\ci[\cihg]XYh\Y`YUX[`Uggk]bXckgh\YVfUaV`Yg[fckh\]W_UgaigW`Yg
UbXUWfck]gWUk]b[W\OPaS\bWO U]\SPcb\]b"
((
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BVSAVO^S]TbVSAc\
H\]g]gh\YZc`_hU`YjYfg]cb]bk\]W\mcif]XYcihhcgYUcbh\YVUW_cZU
hifh`YUbX]hZYY`g`]_Yacggcbh\YVUW_gcZmcifhYYh\"Mci\Ub[UW`cW_
]bh\Ygib"
MciUfYh\YZc`_!hU`Yj]f[]b"
<ckXcmci_bckk\Ybh\Yd]WhifYcZUh\]b[\Ugh\YaYUb]b[cZh\Y
h\]b[3H\YW`cW_]bh\Yd]WhifYVcc_ h\YW`cW_cbmcifkU`` h\YW`cW_]b
mcifkY`` h\YW`cW_ZU]`]b[]bmcifVYXg]XYWUXUjYfgY`Z"Mci^igh_bck"
9jYbk\Ybh\Yghcfm\UgmYhhcVYhc`X UbXmciaU_YbcgYbgY"
GYbgY]gh\Yg]`jYf`]bYh\Yhifh`YXfUkgh\fci[\h\YcWYUb"=Z]hÁgVfc_Yb
]bh\YkU_Y mciWUbbchZc``ck]h"=ZUgYU]gWU``YXh\YcWYUb \ckXcmci
_bck]h]gh\YgUaY mcifbYk\caY35bXmYhmci[c VUX`mg`Udd]b[Uh
h\Ykcf`X"8fU[[YXVmmcifghcfm UX]UacbXbYW_`UWYcZgU`]jU]bh\Y
bUffUh]jY UjUgha]ffcfgdc]`YXVmYjYfmgYWcbX"9jYfmgYWcbXmci[YhU
`]hh`YV]hW`cgYfhc_bck]b[gcaYh\]b[ hcfYWc[b]n]b[]hghk]b"K\]W\]g
gUX UWhiU``m \ckh\YW`cW_gUfYZU``]b[VUW_Zfcah\Y]fjUf]cigg\Y`jYg
gd]_]b[h\Y]f[YUfg]bhcmcifkY``!kcfbÊYg\"
()
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
9J5B<5FF=G
BVS4cbc`S]T2Sa^OW`
)
/TbS`/TbS`[ObV
H\YZihifY]gU`ckghcbYkU``cVgWifYXVma]gh"=hfibgh\YZUfYbX
cZUbibhYbXYXaYUXckh\Uh[fckg]bkYU_gWfiVVmdUhW\Yg dU`YWcjYf
UbX\][\hUbb]g\[fUgg"5VcjYh\YkU`` a]gh[Uh\Yfgk\]hY[fUm gcZh`m
cdUeiY"H\YghcbYgcZh\YkU``aUgg YX[YgaYYh]b[UbXa]gg]b[UWWcfX!
]b[hcg\UdY cfXYfcZd`UWYaYbh Ub[`YcZVU`UbWY";UdgZcfaViZZYfg
VYhkYYbibaUhW\YXgc`]X]h]Yg"H\YgifZUWYgcZh\YghcbYgUfYgacch\
kcfbUbXkcfbUbXkcfb `UmYfgcZgUaYbYggfYjYU`YX XUadk]h\h\Y
`]b[YfcZa]gh"Ac]ghifYdi``gU[fiX[]b[[`YUaZfcah\YXi``XYdh\cZ
Wc`cf XfUkgcihjYfg]cbgcZ[fUm"GhYU` W\UfWcU` Ug\ ghcfa g`UhY d]hW\
g]`jYfg\ihcZ[`]hhYf";fUmgh\Y[fUmcZUVgYbWY gh]``V]fh\ Wc`XgkYUh g_]b
`cb[XYUX dU]b ZYUf \cdY`YggbYgg"
H\YZihifY]gU`ckghcbYkU``cVgWifYXVma]gh"
6WUVBW[S
(*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
H\YacaYbhgacibh UXXid"H\Yh]aY]g\][\"KYU``VihWfUbY"
=hWUbbchVYXYb]YX"<][\h]aY"
<YUjYbg \ck ]h \Ug Êckb FUh\Yf cih cZ \UbX" ;]jYg ig dUigY
UbXUgkYghcdhcWcbg]XYf kYUfYWcbWYfbYX X]ghifVYX"5`UfaYX WcaY
hch\]b_cZ]hH]aYÊm]b[3H]aY]bÊ][\h ÊYY]b[ ]hkci`XgYYa ÊYY]b[
h\YgWYbY"Fibb]b["Fibb]b[UkUm"Fibb]b[UkUmhcYgWUdY"DifgiYX3
<ch`m difgiYX fibb]b[ UkUm hc YgWUdY XUb[Yf cVj]cig`m h\fYUhYbYX"
H\Yh\fYUhcZWUdhifY/h\Yh\fYUhcZj]c`YbWY"5ggUi`h3AifXYf3
K\cWci`XghUbXUWWigYXcZ_]``]b[h]aY3Cfg]h Ugh\YWUgYaUm
VY"KYdc]bhbcÉb[Yf`Ygh]hdc]bhVUW_"
DYf]g\h\Yh\ci[\h"Dih]hcihcZa]bX"H\YfY [cbY"KY\UjYbch
YbhYfhU]bYXh\Yh\ci[\hcZ\UfaVY]b[XcbYhch]aYZcfcjYfUacaYbh
cfhkc acaYbhgh\Uh\UjYVYYbUbXdUggYX"H\YfYh\YmkYbh"5bXbc
\UfaXcbY"GUZY ibgWUh\YX"5``]gkY``"BcbYYXZcfÊighYf"=Z]bXYYX
h]aY\UgVYYbfibb]b[ ]h\Ugg]ad`mVYYbfibb]b[`UhY hU_Yb]hidcb
]hgY`Zhc[U]b aU_]b[idZcfh\Y`cggcZ]hgY`Z"Cfbc ]adcgg]V`Y"7`YUf`m
bch=hkci`X bYWYggUf]`m VYh\Ych\YfdUfhmh\Uh]ghUfXm">ighU`]hh`Ycb
h\Y`UhYg]XY VihgifY`mUff]j]b[UgkYgdYU_"5bmacaYbhbck"9f[c.
H]aY]gfibb]b[cih"
H\UhÁg]h bch\]b[acfY"Cifa]ghU_Y"G]``mig"KYaigh[Yhidhc
gdYYX"BcgYbgY]bUhhYadh]b[gcaYhmdYcZZcfYghU``]b[aUbYijYf"H\Uh
kci`XbchXcUhU``"5kUghY g]ad`mdih"=hWUbbchVYXY`UmYX"=h]g UZhYf
U`` h]aY"
H]W_ hcW_ gYUgcb UZhYf gYUgcb" KY Xc bch XYbm ]h. 5ZhYfaUh\ ]g
bchYlYadhZfcah\Yfi`YcZh\YW`cW_ \ckYjYffYacjYXZfcah\YigiU`
WcifgYcZh\]b[g"<ckYjYf`cb[h\YUddfcUW\ \][\h\YghcbYkU`` UbX
gYWifYh\Y[UhYhch\YAUbcf W`]aV]b[[fYYbYfmei]hYcjYf[fckb hk]gh!
YXcjYfh\Yhk]gh]b[cZ]hgY`ZhcZcfaUhYbXf]``cW_h\UhÉlYgh\Y`UhW\cZ
h\Y[UhY]bdYfdYhiU`d`UWY"5hU`cbVfckb[f]d]bh\]g h\YghUf_gYUgcb/
UXYYd[fYYbW`ihW\]bh\Ych\Yf h\YfU]b]b["CbYcfh\Ych\Yf/h\]gcbY
cfh\UhcbY/Wca]b[cf[c]b["
H\Y\UbXgcZh\YW`cW_k]``bchhifbVUW_kUfX/h\Y[UhYk]``bch
gk]b[ cdYb" 5 \YUfhm fUd cb h\Y bUffck kccXYb Xccf gYh ]b h\Y kU``
UX^UWYbhhch\Y[UhYk]``\UjYhcXc"H\Yj]g]hcfk]``_]bX`mZcf[]jYh\Y
XccfÁgX]gfYdU]f._bcV`ccgY]b]hgWUg]b[ \]b[YgÊU_]b[figh"FUdfUdfUd
(+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
cbh\Ygd`]bhYf]b[gifZUWY"5ghYdVUW_ Ug\]Zh]b[cZghUbWY UbUX^igh!
aYbhcZh\YgUhW\Y` dYf\Udg"H\YdccfdcghU`WUff]Yf]gigYXhch\Yg]hi!
Uh]cb"GYUgcbUZhYfgYUgcb"5bXh\Ych\Yfg cffUh\Yfh\Ych\Yf h\YcbY
Zcfk\cakYdfYgYbh`mkU]h kY`` \Yk]``_]bX`mkU]hZcffYgdcbgYZfca
k]h\]bh\YWcbÉbYgcZ5ZhYfaUh\AUbcf"
KY Udc`c[]nY ]Z h\Y ghUZZ ]g U V]h g`ck cb h\Y idhU_Y" 5 V]h g`ck
hcfYgdcbX" KYcifgY`jYg\UjYjYfmbYUf`m ZU``YbVY\]bX]bh\Y h]aY`m
YlYWih]cbcZXihm"=bXYYXkY^c`hhcei]hYh\YkU_YidWU``Cifkcf_
]gWihcih"6ihcZWcifgY ]hÁgVYYbWihcihZfcah\YghUfh"Cfh\YZc``ck!
]b["H\YZc``ck]b[ hcVYacfYgdYW]ÉW Uhk\]W\dc]bhkYhcc_cbcif
kcf_"5WWYdhYXcifcZÉWY"H\Y7ighcX]UbgcZ5ZhYfaUh\½Ubca]bUh]jY
dcg]h]cb"Ei]hYU`Y[UWmhc`cc_UZhYf":c``ck]b[U`cb[\]ghcfmcZZc``ck!
]b[ h\Uh]g"BcgaU``ZYUh fYU``m _YYd]b[h\YV][d]WhifY]ba]bX"6ihcZ
WcifgY_YYd]b[hfUW_cZcifW\Uf[Y]g Uhh\]gacghWf]h]WU`dc]bh h\YÉfgh
cfXYfcZVig]bYgg"5``dUdYfkcf_YhW"Ug]XY g\Y]gh\YUVgc`ihYdf]cf]hm"
<UbXgXckb"
KYaighhU_Y\YfUg]XY"KYaigh\UjYh\YW\Uh \UjYh\YWcbjYfgU!
h]cbk\]W\ UXa]hhYX`m `ccag WUghgUbcVgWif]b[g\UXck"
DYf\UdgkYUfYgcaYk\Uh]bh\YXUf_"6ihkYg\U``gYY"KYhU_Yh\Y
`cb[j]Yk"5kYYV]hcbh\Y`UhYg]XY dYf\Udg Vihh\YdU]bhYfk]``gccb
Uff]jY UbXh\YibXYfhU_]b[aUmh\YbWcaaYbWY
KY]bhYbXhcgdYU_k]h\cifW\Uf[YdfYgYbh`m"G\Y\UgVYYbU`YfhYX"
H\YghUZZ½h\YhkccZh\Ya½\UjYVYYbgYhhch\YhUg_cZgiaacbg";Uf!
XYbYf\UggY]nYXh\YVY``di`` U_bchhmÉb[YfYX[f]dUfcibXh\Yh\]W_`m
VfU]XYXW\cfX"6YbhUfaVYUh]b[ \Y\UggYbhh\YVY``hcf]b[]b[ dYY`]b[
cihhcdYbYhfUhYh\YZUfh\YghfYUW\YgcZ5ZhYfaUh\AUbcf hcdYbYhfUhY
h\]gYUf`m\cifk]h\]hg`cb[hc`` k\]W\k]``giaacbcifW\Uf[Y WU``\Yf
]bhcVYgYbhid idhch\YhckYf"
;UfXYbYf\UgghU`_YX\]g[fUmWcjYf!U``W`UXZfUaYXckbh\YfY!
jYfVYfUh]b[Wcff]Xcf g\ci`XYfgfc``YX]bUgh]ZZ\ibW\ ZcfYUfaggk]b[!
]b[ Zfca \]g Y`Vckg ]b ghUWWUhc cddcg]h]cb h\Y h]aY _YYd]b[ cZ h\]g
acjYaYbh dibWhiUhYX Vm cWWUg]cbU` ÊYl cZ Y]h\Yf cf Égh" <Y dUggYg
h\Y_]hW\YbXccf"5gc`YabbcXZcf;fY]jU k\cghUbXg]bh\Yh\fYg\!
c`X Ufaghf]Ub[i`UhYX Uad`Y\]dg\cghhch\YghiadgcZ\Yf\UbX`Ygg
kf]ghg"
(,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
;UfXYbYfacjYgcb";fUm`]dg [UhYhch\Y[fUjYcZ\]gacih\ `cW_
]bU`]bY"<]ghcb[iY`cb[g]bWY`U]XcihXYUX"KYkU[Yf]hkUggcaYh\]b[
\YgU]X"GcaYh\]b[kYX]XbÁhWUhW\"KYWUbbchWcbWYfbcifgY`jYgk]h\
YjYfm `]hh`Y h\]b[" Mcif [iYgg ]g bYUf`m Ug [ccX Ug cifg" 5 ZUhU` g`]d3 5
dfYZYfYbWYbUaYX35dUgg]cbW`U]aYX3
6ih bYjYf a]bX h\Y XUi[\hYfg cZ 5ZhYfaUh\ UbX h\Y]f W\Ufag
h\Y]f ^YU`cig]Yg" BcbY cZ h\cgY []f`g kUg YjYf U []f` k]h\ Ubm \YUX Zcf
fYUgcb"H\YhcfaYbh h\YhfUiaU h\Y`cgg"H\YacXYgcZYgWUdY"H\Y
dUhhYfb cZ Ê][\h" AYacfm dUggYX ]bhc \]ghcfm" H\cgY []f`g aUXY h\Y]f
VYhg hcc_h\Y]fW\UbWYg"H\YmaUXYh\Y]fVYXg UbXh\igh\Ym`]Y gbi[]b
h\YXUabYX!]Z!kY!_bck!k\UhÁg!VYWcaY!cZ!h\YaWUhY[cfm"H\YfYWcfX
]gh\YfYWcfX.bchUg]b[`YdcfhfU]h\Ub[g]bcif;U``Yfm<U``"H\Y;U``Yfm
<U`` cZWcifgY"H\Y<U``"F][cfaighVYaU]bhU]bYXcbaUhhYfgcZ[fUa!
aUf \ckYjYfUh\caYkYZYY`\YfY]b5ZhYfaUh\ \ckYjYfWcaZcfhUV`Y
kY\UjYVYWcaY fYaU]b]b["FYaU]b]b[UgkY\UjYVYYb"FYaU]b]b[Ug
]g"7cbh]bi]b[hcfYaU]b"KYUfYkcf_]b[k]h\k\UhkY\UjY"
5bXh\YfY;UfXYbYf\Ug[cbY UVcih\]gVig]bYgg Xckbh\YWcf!
f]Xcf jYYf]b[cZZUhh\YdUggU[Yh\Uh`YUXg]bhch\Yk]bX]b[fYUW\YgcZh\Y
eiUfhYfgVYmcbX"
H\YWcff]XcfYadh]YgcZh\YVY``ÁgÉbU`hc``"
H\Yg][\cZ;fY]jU\YUjYgcih\YUjm XfcdgXckbidcbh\YV]V ZU``g
]bUacb[ghh\YZc`Xg]bh\Yg_]fhcZ\YfUdfcb"H\YdcghifYcZ;fY]jU
UX^ighgk]h\UXfcdcZh\Y\YUjm\]d UbUXjUbW]b[cZh\YZcch"H\YhcYcZ
;fY]jUhUdg"DUhdUhdUhcbh\Yd`Ub_"DUigY"H\YUfacZ;fY]jUfU]gYg]b
U\UbX`Ygg\U]`UbXVYW_cb"
KYaigh\UjYh\UhW\Uh"H\UhWcbjYfgUh]cb h\UhX]U`c[iY"H]aY]g
fibb]b[cih"=hWUbbchVYXY`UmYX"KU]h]b[]gYbh]fY`mcihcZh\YeiYg!
h]cb"KYaYUbhcgdYU_k]h\\YfX]fYWh`m"KYaYUbhcdfYdUfY8YgdU]f
Zcfh\YibXYfhU_]b[cZ\YfZihifY"
BVSAbO`YASOa]\BVS@OW\W\U
7caY]b 8YUf"KYkYfY^ighYldYWh]b[mci";ccXcZmcihcWcaY
cbgiW\g\cfhbch]WY Vihh\YgYh\]b[g\UjYUkUmcZWfYYd]b[id"<cdY
(-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
]h]gbÁhhccaiW\cZUb]bWcbjYb]YbWY"CfUb]bhYffidh]cbcZUbm_]bX"
7caY]b d`YUgY"5bXg\ihh\YXccf":]fa`m]Zmcikci`X"H\Y`UhW\cZ
h\YXccfci[\hhcWUhW\"
H\]g kYUh\YfÁg ei]hY gcaYh\]b[ ]gbÁh ]h3 Hkc hfYYg Xckb Uh h\Y
YX[YcZh\YkccXhccifWiffYbh_bck`YX[Y UbXh\YhYadYfUhifYd`ia!
aYh]b[ UgkY``"9`YWhf]W]hmcihZcfgcaYh]aY½acaYbhg]aaYacf]U`½
UXXghch\UhghcfamZYY` XcYgbÁh]hbck38fUdYgXfUkbU[U]bghh\YXfUZh
UbXkccX`cUXYXidcbh\YÉfY`YghkYWUhW\UW\]``"
5 hYff]V`Y W\]``" 5 hYff]V`Y g\]jYf hc h\Y aUffck h\Uh kfUW_g
hfUddYXk]h\]b":fUWhifY/gd`]bhYf"7fmghU``]bYg\]jYfg`]jYfgd]YfWYcih!
kUfX d]YfWYVUW_h\fci[\jY]b YbhYfh\Yg]`jYfmV`iYghfYUa hifb]h]Wm
dU`Y h\YbhcbY`Ygg hfUbg`iWYbh"H\YZf][]XgdfYUXcZV`ccXfibb]b[Wc`X"
=WYV`ccXgY]nYXVm]hgckbZfYYnY"5Wc`X\c``ckgh]``cZh\Y\YUfh"
GiW\UfYh\YWcbX]h]cbgkYaigh[iUfXU[U]bgh/giW\kYUh\Yf]b!
XYYX<Ufg\]bh\YYlhfYaY"DfUWh]WU``mZcfYVcX]b["
FYWcfXgYjYf]hm dYf\Udg½h\ci[\kY\UjYbchVYYb_YYd]b[hfUW_
dYfgY"KY\UjYbchWc``YWhYXXUhU XfUkbidhUV`YgcfW\Ufhg Yb[U[YX
]bghiX]YXWcadUf]gcb"Hck\UhYbX UZhYfU`` WUbgiW\WcadUf]gcbdcg!
g]V`mVYUdd`]YX3DfYX]Wh]cb3BcbYYXhcWfYUhYVigmkcf_"AYacfmUbX
YldYWhUh]cbgYfjY"
FYhfcgdYWh giddcg]h]cb" FYaYaVfUbWY Uggiadh]cb" FYWc``YW!
h]cb Ubh]W]dUh]cb"
KY\UjYU``kYfYei]fYZcfUdYfZYWh`mfY`]UV`YZcfYWUgh.H\YkYUh\Yf
XcYgUg]h\UgXcbY/Ug]hk]``Xc"H\YfY`Uh]jYXY[fYYcZgYjYf]hmXcYgbch
g][b]Zm"8cYgbch]bX]WUhY XcYgbchdc]bhhcUh\]b["KYk]``bchXfUk
WcbW`ig]cbg cfYjYbg_YhW\h\Ya"KYk]``bchgcaiW\UgYjYfgc`][\h`m
hfUWYk]h\h\YhUdYf]b[h]dcZUÉb[Yfh\Ycih`]bYh\UhhfU]`g gd]bX`YgcjYf
h\UhZYbWY`YggÉY`XcZh\Ya]bXÁgYmY"H\YfYUfYUVgc`ihY`mbcWcbW`i!
g]cbg]bg][\h"5``]gWiffYbh" KYfYa]bXcifgY`jYgh\UhgYjYf]hm]g^igh
dfYW]gY`mk\Uh]ghcVYYldYWhYX []jYbh\YgYUgcb"
H\Y ghUf_ gYUgcb. ZYYV`Y [fUm `][\h ibX]ZZYfYbh]UhYX h\Y W`cW_Ág
k\c`YW]fW`YVihZcfUXUf_Yf[fUm UX]aa]b[Uhh\YcXX\cifg"H\Yg_m
U`ckghYY`mhfUdVYbYUh\k\]W\k]bX\if`g WfUg\Yg fc``g `]Zhg hk]ghghc
WfYUhYcihcZ]hgY`ZUbYX[Yh\Uhhifbg k\]dg gk]hW\Yg g\UfdYbgh\YWc`X
]b]hgXckbkUfXghUVh\YbkU]`gVUW_k\YbWY]h\UgWcaYhcgif[YU[U]b"
)$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
GiW\ UWfcVUh]Wg Wcid`YX k]h\ ZcfWY Ug ]h VUhhYfg h\Y dccf ibZcfhibUhY
YUfh\ k\]W\ U`fYUXm VfihU`]nYX ibhc biaV bYUf gYbgY`YggbYgg WUjYg
VYUhYb"HU_]b[WcjYfZfcah\YkY][\hcZ]hgY`Z ]h]gc`UhYg`UmYfVm`UmYf
Zcf\cdYUhdfchYWh]cb YZZYWhgWcad`YhYfYhfYUh"
BUhifU``m ]hk]``U```Yhid"CjYfkcf_YX h\YWc`Xk]``Xi`` V`ibh
cih `cgY]hgYX[Y [cg`UW_"@]ad ]hk]``WYUgYhchcfaYbhh\YYUfh\ `YUjY
h\YVfUbW\UbXVig\hch\Y]fVf]hh`YbYgg UbXZU``hcg`YYd"
5bXh\Yk]bXk]``Yl\UighUgkY`` X]YXckbhcUÉbY jUf]Y[UhYX
VfYYnY ^ighYbci[\hc[]jYh\YdUdYfkY][\hggcaYh\]b[hcXc"=hk]``
ÊUd ÊihhYf h\YbgYhh`Y WcUhh\Y[fcibX X]g]bhY[fUhY]bhch\YYUfh\ g]b_
UbXghcfY]hgY`ZXYYd]bZibbY`]b[\c``ckg"5bXh\YYUfh\k]``\UfVcfh\Y
k]bX VY[]bhckUfah\fci[\h\Y`UhYbhYbYf[mcZ]h"6Y[]bhcib\ib_Yf
ib\ibW\ dig\cihkUfX idkUfX"9l\U`Y5bXZcfWYh\Y\UfX`ckg_mhc
ibWfckX hcf]gY"
H]aYUZhYfh]aY"GYUgcbU`W\Ub[YUZhYfgYUgcbU`W\Ub[Y"8cYgfYd!
Yh]h]cbbchU``ckZcfigYcZh\YdfYgYbhhYbgY3
@]Zh]b[ h\Yg_mgdfYUXgcih h\]bg [fckghfUbg`iWYbh"Gch\]bUbX
ZfU[]`Yh\Yg_m"BcaUhW\ bck Zcfh\Y`][\h"BcaUhW\ZcfXckbkUfX
hfU^YWhcfm"8YbgY [c`XYbg\UZhgcZ`][\hdibWhifYh\Yg_m"
JY`jYhmV`UW_![fYYbW`ciXgZc``ck dcif]bUfcibXh\Y[c`XYb`][\h
h\YbgigdYbX X]aYbg]cbU`]bh\Y]fZi``bYgg"H\YW`ciXgZUhhYbUgh\Ym
`UmYf ZcfaUf]W\V`UW_![fYYbcdUW]hmh\Uhgiddcfhgh\YX]ghUbh[fYmg_m
UVcjY"5bXh\Yb h\YfU]b"H\YkUfa [fYYb `Uf[YXfcddYXfU]b fU]b fU]b"
G\UZhgcZ`][\hWcbh]biYhcWcaY hcVfYU_h\fci[\ dUfh]b[h\YW`ciXg"
8YbgY [c`XYb Xfm" H\Y `][\h VYUag h\fci[\ ibhciW\YX ib!kYhhYX"
;fYYbfU]bfU]b]b[hch\YYX[YgcZh\Y`][\h";c`XYb`][\h`][\hgh\YfU]b
]bZigYg]h WUigYg]hhcZU``h]bWhifYX hcgcU_h\YYUfh\[fYYb![c`X"
H\Y VfUbW\ UbX Vig\ fYgdcbX k]h\ ViXg/ h\Y [fYYbYfm ibZif`g"
5bXh\YfY"H\YfU]b]b[gYUgcbk]``VYidcbigcbWYU[U]b Vf]b[]b[fY!
bYkYXcddcfhib]hmZcfcifW\Uf[YhchU_Y\YfYlYfW]gYcihcZXccfg"
MYg mYg \ck 8YgdU]f \Ug U`kUmg ZUjcfYX \Yf kU`_g UVcih h\Y
[fcibXg Xif]b[ h\Y kUfah\ cZ h\Y fU]b]b[ gYUgcb bYjYf a]bX]b[ h\Y
kYh"<ckkYfYWc``YWh\YfjYfmÉfghghYdgH\YjYfmÉfgh ]bUbmYjYbh
h\Uhhcc_\YfgcaYd`UWY"H\Ych\Yfg h\YkYYVc`gUbXkccV`Yg½kY`` hc
VYZfUb_ kYX]XbÁhbch]WY"KYWUbbchWcbWYfbcifgY`jYgk]h\YjYfm`]hh`Y
)%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
h\]b["5\\\Vih`]hh`Y8YgdU]f gcXUf`]b[]b\Yf`]hh`Yacifb]b[d]bUZcfY
UbX[U`cg\Yg cihh\Y_]hW\YbXccfg\YkYbh Xckbh\Yg`cdYcZh\Y`Ukb
Zc``ck]b[U`cb[]bh\YXfmdfchYWh]cbcZUg\UZhcZ`][\h `]hh`YUfag\i[!
[]b[UVcih\Yf XfUkb^ighk]h\]bh\Y[c`XYbYX[Yg gUZYZfcah\Y[fYYb
fU]bZU``]b[\YUjmcbY]h\Yfg]XY"H\Y`][\hhcc_\YfW`YUfUWfcggh\YdUf_
UbXhch\YYX[YcZh\YkccX k\YfYh\YghfYUakUgU``]bUÊccX VUb_
aiXXmUgmcid`YUgY hcfbidUbXhfYUW\Yfcigk\YfYUhfYY\UXidfcchYX
UbXZU``YbUWfcggh\YghfYUa"H\Yg\UZhcZ`][\hXYdcg]hYX8YgdU]fUhh\Y
ZcchcZh\]ghfciV`YgcaYVf]X[YUbXh\Yb Ugh\YWUdf]WYcZ]hkci`X[c
h\Uh`][\hg\]ZhYX]hg[c`XYbdUh\]bUbU`hc[Yh\YfX]ZZYfYbhX]fYWh]cb `YUj!
]b[\YfghfUbXYXk]h\h\YfU]bZU``]b[ZU``]b[ZU``]b[U``UVcih\Yf"6ihg\Y`!
hYf]bg][\h<ckcifXYUf`]hh`Y8YgdU]fYb[]bYYfYXUWfcgg]b[cjYfh\Y
g`]W_VUf_cZh\YhfYY YjYfgcbYUf`mg`]dd]b[Ugg\YaUXY\YfkUm"9jYfgc
bYUf`m`cg]b[VU`UbWY"6ihg\Y[U]bYXh\Ycddcg]hYg]XYUZhYfU`` gWfUaV`YX
idh\YVUb_"5bXk]h\h\YdUgg]b[h\fci[\cZh\Yd]W_Yh[UhYUbXh\Yhf]d
hf]dhf]dd]b[idh\YkU`_ h\YfYg\YkUg Uff]jYX"H\Yd`Um\cigY
5a]b]UhifYWchhU[YgYhUhh\YYX[YcZh\YXYYd XUf_kccX"KY``"
Bchgcib_bckbUbXib_bckUV`YUgU``h\Uh"=bdc]bhcZZUWh h\YUWfY!
U[YbY][\Vcf]b[h\YBcfh\YfbVcUfXYfcZ5ZhYfaUh\\UXUhh\Uhdc]bh
VYYb h\cfci[\`m dUWYX d`chhYX UbX ÊU[[YX" GifjYmYX h\Uh ]g Ug h\Y
fYgi`hcZU`cb[XY`]VYfUhYXfYU`YghUhYXYU` YjYfcbh\YjYf[YcZVY]b[
gYU`YX"=bg\YkYbhh\fci[\h\Y`]hh`YXccf UbX]bhch\Y`]hh`YgdUWY"5
kUg\cZV`iY/h\Y\YUXmgaY``cZc]`dU]bh"8YUf`]hh`Y8YgdU]f ZUWYhcZUWY
k]h\Ug]b[i`Ufkcf_cZUfhh\Uhh\cfci[\`mXca]bUhYXh\Yd`UWY"
<UXh\YÉ[ifY]bh\YdU]bh]b[VYYbfYbXYfYXghUbX]b[ h\YWUbjUg
Wci`XbYjYf\UjYZcibXU\caY]bh\Yd`Um\cigYUhU``"6ihbc h\YÉ[ifY
g]hg VY``mV][k]h\dfY[bUbWm UbX^ighÉhg É``]b[h\YgdUWYÊccfhcWY]`]b[
UbXkU``hckU`` ]adfYgg]jYh\ci[\]bWcad`YhY"G_YhW\m h\Uh]g ]bh\Y
\UbXgUbXZYYh \U]fhYbXf]`]b[cihhcUX]gg]dUh]cbcZk\]hY"5bXg]`jYfm
[fUmYmYgibÉb]g\YX [UnY ibÉlYX"
8YgdU]fgYUhYX\YfgY`Z]bh\Yk]bXckgYUh VUW_hch\YdU]bg fUdh
Vmh\Y]aU[YVYZcfY\Yf gh]`` ]bhYbh"DfYgYbh`m U`][\hg][\cZkY`WcaY
YlhYbXYXh\fci[\h\YV]bX]b[\ig\"5bXh\Yb k]h\VfYUh\XfUkbcjYf
Ugh]``\YUfh h\Ygacch\ fY[i`UhYXjc]WYUfY`]UV`YbUffUhcf hcjYbhifYU
[iYggVY[Ubk]h\cbWYidcbUh]aY"
)&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BVS1]\QS^bW]\]T2Sa^OW`
CbWYidcbUh]aY]b5ZhYfaUh\ UacaYbhWfUW_YX]b\U`Z"5bX
Zfcah\Ygd`]h UdU]fcZhk]b[]f`gWUaYhcVY"H\YdU]fcZh\Ya[fYk
hifb]b[ Éhh]b[WcbjYl]hmhcWcbWUj]hm \YUXhc\c``ck]bh\Yg\]Zhk]h\]b
h\YW`cgYXUf_Wifj]b[gdUWY"
?]W_]b[YbgiYX"
DYf\Udg]hkUg8YZYUhh\UhghUfhYX]h"@cc_]b[ZcfUÉ[\h"Cbh\Y
ch\Yf\UbX ]hkUg8Yg]fYh\Uh\UXVY[ibhcWUhW\cih d`iW_]b[Uhh\Y
\YUfhcZ\Yfg]ghYf";fUVVm mcia][\hgUm"
H\cgY[]f`gkcff]YXUhcbYUbch\Yfibh]`8Yg]fYaUbU[YXhcd]bW\
UkUmUfU[[YX\c`Y]b8YZYUhÁgÊYg\ Yldcg]b[h\YWUj]hmVYbYUh\"H\Uh
XcbY g\YÊYkVUW_k]h\\YfÉb[YfgUbXgbUhW\YXUkUmUd]YWYcZh\Y
\YUfhcZ\Yfg]ghYf Ud]YWY`]jYk]h\h\Y]bg]ghYbhXf]jYhcVYUh½XYZYUh
XYZYUhXYZYUh">iV]`Ubh`m 8Yg]fYWcbgiaYX\Yf_YYdgU_Y dcddYX]h]bhc
h\YfYXCcZ\Yfacih\UbXgkU``ckYX"8YZYUhgaUW_YXcih]bUdU]bYX
Zifm Vih h\Y d]YWY kUg [cbY" =h fc``YX h\fci[\ W\ihYg ]bg]XY hfUjY`YX
h\fci[\ hfUjY`YX Xckb ]bhc h\Y ghcaUW\ cZ 8Yg]fY" H\YfY h\Y d]YWY
W\ifbYX g`ci[\YX]hgf\mh\aibh]`di`gY[UjYidhcUcbYkUm]bkUfX
giW_"H\Yd]YWYhcc_]bUbXUVgcfVYXh\YV`ccXcZ8Yg]fY V`ccXXYbgY
k]h\h\Yj]gWciggYYdcZ`cb[]b["
BUhifU``m 8YZYUhkci`Xbch`Yh]h[cUhh\Uh"Hk]gh]b[]bUghfi[[`Y
ZcffYWcjYfm cbY\UbXW`UddYXcjYfh\YkcibX]b\YfW\Ygh g\Yh\figh
h\Ych\Yf\UbXcih [fcd]b[]bh\YXUf_"G\YZcibXUbcdYb]b[ fYUW\YX
id]bhch\Y]bbUfXgcZ\Yfg]ghYf UbXgWfUdYX]bgYUfW\ibh]`g\Yhcc_
\c`XcZh\Yd]YWY UbXkfYbW\YX]hcih []j]b[`ccgYUhf]iad\Ubhk\ccd
h\UhfUb[]bWUWcd\cbmk]h\\Yfg]ghYfÁgg\f]Y_"
5bXh\Yb g]`YbWY Ugh]``Wcad`YhY"6ch\cZh\cgY[]f`gZfcnY Uf!
fYghYX"
5hfYUgifY[`ckYX]b8YZYUhÁg[f]d"
5d]YWYcZh\Y\YUfhcZ8YZYUh]aViYXk]h\h\YV`ccXcZ8Yg]fY"
H\Uhd]YWY\UXhfUbgZcfaYXh\fci[\Ubib_bckbU`W\Yam bY]h\YfYb!
[]bYYfYXbcf]aU[]bYX"5`ighfcigWcfY"=f]XYgWYbh]bWc`cf hYUfXfcd]b
g\UdY"H\Ygacch\ ÉfagifZUWY"H\YgYbgYcZjc`iaYhf]WXYdh\"H\Y
kY][\h" 5g ]Z ;fUj]hm \UX VYYb gYXiWYX Vm gcaY WY`Ygh]U` VcXm" H\Y
)'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
`ia]bcigXfUkcZ]h"H\YaU[bYh]gacZdYfZYWhWcbhU]baYbh"
CZ WcifgY YUW\ cZ h\cgY []f`g kci`X \UjY ]h Zcf \Yf ckb" H\Y
kUbh]b[cbY"H\YVUhh`]b[cbY"H\YhiaV`YUbXh\YhfciV`Yh\YmkYbh
hc gbUhW\]b[ cih Zcf ]hg [`ck ]b h\Y XUf_ gYWif]b[ h\Uh hfYUgifY Zcf U
acaYbh/h\YZYfcW]hm]bkfYgh]b[]hUkUm"DYf\Udgh\Yd`UWYkUgbÁhV][
Ybci[\Zcfh\YdU]fcZh\YahcVY[]bk]h\ UbX]bh\YYbX ibfi`mUgh\Ym
[fYk h\Y WcbÉbYaYbh Wci`X \UfX`m VY gighU]bYX" 7`Uk]b[ Uh cbY Ub!
ch\YfZcfdcggYgg]cbcZh\Uhg]b[i`UfhfYUgifY h\YmhcfYf][\hh\fci[\h\Y
Wifj]b[kU`` XYghfcmYXh\YgdUWYcZh\Y]fWca]b[hcVY `YZh]h`UWYfUhYX
fi]bYX"8Yjc]XcZUbmZihifY3
<ckdfYhhmh\Yach\Yf\UXVYYb"GiW\d`YUgifYZcfh\YdU]bhYfhc
ghiXm"<Y``c mYg g\U``kYWcbh]biY3H\YmaYhgUZY`mfYacjYXZfcah\Y
k\]dUbXg`Ug\cZh\YGhUf_gYUgcbXif]b[k\]W\h\Yach\YfÁghYfacW!
WiffYX"@cb[gYgg]cbgVYg]XYh\YZfYg\bYggcZh\YZcibhU]b]bh\YdYfdYh!
iU`VU`acZh\Y[UfXYbgcZ5ZhYfaUh\ k]h\cb`mh\YYjYfgcibfYaUf_]b[
W\UdYfcbYcZh\Yc`X[fcibXgaUb":UfVY]hZfcaUaUb`cb[g]`YbWYXhc
WcaaYbhk\Yb\YWUaYUfcibXcWWUg]cbU``mhcdihhYfk]h\\]gW`]ddYfg
[i]X]b[[fckh\]bXYYdVYXgh\UhfY[YbYfUhYgYUgcb`YggÊckYfg"
;fUWYZi``m g\Y gYUhYX \YfgY`Z aUhW\YX \YfgY`Z hc h\Y W\UfWcU`
aUf_gZcfhcY Y`Vck kf]gh"DYUWYZi``m g\YgYhh`YX \Yf[UnYYjYb`mÉlYX
cbh\Ya]XX`YX]ghUbWY"DYfZYWh`m g\Yhcc_\YfdcgY"
<ckh\YdU]bhYfhcc_bchYcZh\Yach\YfÁg[YghifY.H\Y]bW`]bYcZ
\Yf\YUX h\YZUbcZ`cb[ghfcb[Éb[YfgcjYf\YfVY``m"<ck\Y`YUfbYX\Yf
Wcbhcifg \]g\UbXdfUWh]W]b[\YfZcfa [fYUh]bdfchfig]cbh\UhgkY``YX
UbXWifjYXVUW_hc]hgfYgc`ih]cb`]_Yh\Y`UghZYkbchYgcZU[ccX`cjY
gcb["5bX\ck\YWcbWY]jYX\YfWc`cfg"<U]fdifYk\]hYZfca]bZUbWm"
9mYgh\Yg]`jYfm[fUmcZUaYhU`hccdfYW]cighca]bY"G_]b^ighh]b[YXh\Y
V`iYcZV`ccXÊck]b[k]h\]b"
H\Ygh]``/h\Yh]aY`Ygg\UfacbmcZ\Yf"G\YkUgdfYhhmUgUd]WhifY
UacXY`giV^YWh fYU``m VihcZWcifgY h\YfYkUgbcgYbgY]bdU]bh]b[]h
bck"
6YZcfYUbXUZhYf \ckYjYf aYUbhbch\]b[hch\cgY[]f`g"
Cih h\Ym WUaY cih ]b Vifgh]b[ \YUjY" Hcc_ bc dUfh ]b \Y`d`Ygg
]bZUbWm"H\YmkU`_YX h\YmhU`_YX UbXh\Ymg_]ddYXbchUVYUh]bhcf!
aYbh]b[YUW\ch\Yf"9UW\\ck`YX\YfÉfghkcfX]bh\YXfYUXUWWigUh]cb
)(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
cZbUa]b[½8Yg]fY 8YZYUh½UbX`YUdh\YfÉfghghYd]bUggUi`h gifYh\Y
ch\Yf\UXkcbh\YhfYUgifY hU_YbUbXgk]Zh`mgYWifYX]hgcaY\ck]bh\Y
`UghacaYbhcZghfi[[`Y]bh\YXUf_"H\ci[\]bZUWh bc"H\YhYUfXfcd
\UXg`]ddYXZfcah\Y[fUgdcZYUW\g]ghYf]bhifb UbXkci`XkU]h gh]`` ]b
UXYYdXYZYbgY`YggXUf_"
8Y`iXYXUbXbU_YX]bh\Y[UfXYb 8Yg]fYUbX8YZYUhZci[\hh\Ya!
gY`jYg]bhcUV`if"5ZibbY`]b[k\]f` h\cgY[]f`gk\]ddYXUkUmZfcah\Y
dfcbYZcfacZh\Yach\Yf h\YkfYW_cZUj]g]cb"HUV`YUiXYÉYXUgg\Y
kf]h\YX]bh\YdU]bhYfÁg`Ud \]g\UbXggigdYbXYXcjYf\Yf]bUhfYaV`]b[
\cjYfUg]ZhcaihY`mkcf_gcaYXYgdYfUhY]bWUbhUh]cb"
HUbXYahcfbUXcYg]bbYW_UbXbYW_W\UgY h\cgYhk]b[]f`ghcfY
cihcZh\Y[UfXYbg `YUj]b[h\YgcZhVU`aVY\]bX"Cbh\YmfUWYX \if`]b[
UhcbYUbch\Yf WUfYYb]b[h\fci[\h\Yk\]dUbXg`Ug\cZh\YghUf_gYUgcb
h\fci[\h\YdUf_UbXidh\Yg`cdYcZh\Y`Ukbibh]`h\YghcbYUbXacfhUf
cZ 5ZhYfaUh\ AUbcf kUg VYZcfY h\Ya UbX h\cgY hkc bU_YX ZfYbn]YX
h\]b[gZY``hcVYUh]b[idcbh\Y_]hW\YbXccf"=hkUgh\Y\cigY_YYdYfh\Uh
`Yhh\YdU]fcZh\Ya]b `Yh]bh\YXciV`Ygci`cZfY`Ybh`YggbYggh\Uhf]jU`YX
h\YZcfWYgcZbUhifY"
KY``"H\Y\cigY_YYdYfgWfiVVYXh\Y[]f`gidUgVYghg\YWci`X k\Uh
k]h\h\YdfcZig]cbcZbcb!Wcad`]UbhVY\Uj]cf ]bW`iX]b[V]h]b[ Ugmci
WUb]aU[]bY"8Uibh`Ygg g\YgYUfW\YXh\Y[]f`gg_]bgcbdifdcgYhcXYhYf!
a]bYh\YX]ZZYfYbWYVYhkYYbh\Ya"6ihUgh\YgWUfg\UX[cbY]bhYfbU`
h\Y\cigY_YYdYfZcibXbch\]b[½bcX]ZZYfYbWY½UbXXYW]XYXh\Uhh]aY
kci`XaU_Y]hgckbX]gh]bWh]cbg"G\YXfYggYXh\Y[]f`g]bc`Xacifb]b[
d]bUZcfYg UbXhifbYXh\cgYhkck]`Xh\]b[g`ccgY]bh\YAUbcf"
Bc `cb[Yf WU``YX Zcf h\Y dU]bhYf dUW_YX id \]g YUgY` UbX \]g
Vfig\Yg"H\UhXcbY \YaUXY\]gkUmh\fci[\h\YVU`acZh\Y[UfXYbg
hcUacXYgh[UhYUhh\Y]fcih`m]b[YX[Y"<YdUggYXh\fci[\h\Y[UhYUbX
]bhc Ub ibhYbXYX aYUXck VYmcbX" H\YfY Uh h\Y aYUXckÁg YX[Y \Y
WUaYidcbh\Yc`X[fcibXgaUb k\cghccXk]h\\]gg\cjY`g\ci`XYfYX
UbX\]g\YUXVckYX YjYfaihY U`cb[bUffckacibXcZV`i]g\X]fhUh
\]gZYYh"5ddfcUW\]b[h\Y[fcibXgaUbUhh\Yg]hYcZh\Yach\YfÁg[fUjY
h\YdU]bhYfcZZYfYX\]g\UbX V`iYdU]bhZU]bh`mhfUW]b[h\Y`]bYgcZ\YUfh
UbX`]ZY"H\UhXcbY \YgYhcZZhckUfXU`ckghcbYkU``cVgWifYXVma]gh
k\]W\ fUb U`cb[ h\Y ZUf YX[Y cZ h\Y aYUXck" <Y `YZh h\Y WcbÉbYg cZ
))
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5ZhYfaUh\VY\]bX"G\YÁXVYYbdfYhhmUgUd]WhifY Vih]h\UXVYYb\]g
cV^YWhhckcf_Zfca`]ZY bchaYacfm"
5bXh\YibÉb]g\YXdcfhfU]h37`YUf`mibgi]hUV`YZcfh\YAUbcfÁg
;U``Yfm<U`` ]hkUgWUff]YXVmh\Yc`X[fcibXgaUbhcUjUWUbhfcca]b
h\YgYfjUbhÁgeiUfhYfg"<Y`YUbYXh\Y`Uf[YWUbjUgU[U]bghh\YkU``UhU
g`]aUb[`Y dU]bhmYhkYh"5bXgh]``mYh.h\YWUbjUgX]XbchgYYahcXfm
dUgg Ug h]aY a][\h" 5bX h\Y \cigY_YYdYf k\c cWWid]YX h\Y UX^UWYbh
fcca kUgdYfZYWh`mk]h\]b\Yff][\hghcWcad`U]bcZh\YZiaYg UbXhc
]bg]ghh\Uhh\YWUbjUgVYacjYX"Cih@Yhh\YdcfhfU]hÉbXU\caYcZ]hg
ckb=hkUggigdYWh bcacfYUbXbc`Ygg \ckg\YÁXXYjY`cdYXUWUgYcZ
h\Y g]b_]b[ X]nn]Yg YjYf g]bWY h\Y h\]b[ \UX hU_Yb id fYg]XYbWY ]b h\Y
fccabYlhXccf"H\YbU[U]b Ugh\Y\cigY_YYdYfkci`XfYUX]`mWcbWYXY
h\ci[\dYf\Udgbchk]h\h\]gYlUWhd\fUgY UbUhacgd\YfYcZjYfh][]bcig
XYgdYfUh]cb\UXU``VihYb[i`ZYXh\YAUbcf"
8Yg]fYUbX8YZYUh"H\cgY[]f`gkYfY[]XXm]bh\Y]fkUff]b[kUmg"
H\]g cbY `cW_]b[ h\Uh cbY ]bhc U Wc`X [fUm kUg\fcca/ h\Uh cbY g\ih!
h]b[h\]gcbYid]bh\YgcifgaY``]b[W`cgYhibXYfh\Y_]hW\YbghU]fg"5bX
k\YbcbY\UXfYbXYfYXh\Ych\Yf\Y`d`Ygg \ckg\YfUbgUW_YXh\Yd`UWY
]b^YU`cigdifgi]hcZh\UhhfYUgifY gifY]h\UXVYYb\]XXYb \cUfXYXVm
h\Ych\Yf"<ckh\YdU]fcZh\YahcfYidh\YWUfdYhg cjYfhifbYXh\YV]bg
]bh\YdUbhfm fUbgUW_YXh\Y`]bYbW\Ygh"<ckh\YmX]gUffUb[YXh\YZifb]!
hifY]bh\YXfUk]b[fccagch\Uh]hWci`XbYjYfVYgYhhcf][\hg h\Ycf][]!
bU`WcbÉ[ifUh]cb`cghhch\YZYfjcfcZh\Y]fUbh]Wg"5bXk\Yb]hWci`Xbch
VYZcibX3H\Yd]bW\]b[ h\Y\U]fdi``]b[ h\YkfYhW\YXbUaYWU``]b["
H\YkUbh]b[gUkbcdUigY"H\YVUhh`]b[gUkbcYbX"
G\f]Y_]b[ fUb[ cih ]b YjYb h\Y cXXYgh \cifg YUW\ cZ h\cgY []f`g
]bhfiX]b[]bhch\Ych\YfÁgXfYUag"8Yg]fYg`ck`mgach\Yf]b[8YZYUhib!
XYfUbcihg]nYXVY``^Uf"8YZYUhZcfWYZYYX]b[8Yg]fYg\UfXgcZ[`Ugg"5bX
h\YhfYUgifY h\Y`ia]bYgWYbhhYUfXfcd[`ck]b[]bdYfZYWhWcbhU]baYbh
U`kUmgcihcZfYUW\ XYYd]bh\YhcaVcZ]hgckbWcibgY`"
H\YhkccZh\Ya aYUbk\]`Y kYfY`YZhhch\Y]fckbXYj]WYg"K\Uh
\cigY_YYdYfkci`XbchkUg\\Yf\UbXg `YUjYh\cgY[]f`ghch\Y]fZUbUh]W
Vig]bYgg"@YUjYh\Yahch\Y]fkUbh]b[UbXVUhh`]b[ h\Y]fVUhh`]b[UbX
kUbh]b["<]fYUbifgYaU]X3K\UhZcc`kci`XhU_Ycbh\Y^cV UbXVY!
g]XY h\cgY[]f`g\UXaUXYg\cfhg\f]ZhcZW\]`X\ccX dUW_YXh\YagY`jYg
)*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
f][\hcihcZd]bUZcfYgUbX]bhcZfcW_gk]h\bchUacaYbhkUghYXcbh\Y
hfUbg]h]cb YUW\Ujc]X]b[[fck]b[dU]bgVm]bÊ]Wh]b[h\Yacb\Yfg]ghYf"
CihcZh\Y567gUbX]bhch\cgYZUg\]cbaU[Un]bYg"
<ckh\YmWcbgiaYXh\Y[`cggmdU[Yg Ê]dd]b[h\fci[\k]h\h\Y
hcggcZU^YhV`UW_VfU]X h\Yfc``cZU[YaV`iYYmY h\Y`]W_cZUfYXfYX
`]d"
H\cgYjUd]Xjc`iaYg`]hhYfYXh\Y[`ccacZh\Y`]VfUfm"=``![chhYb
[U]bg cZWcifgY"Ghc`Yb bcacfYUbXbc`Ygg Zfcah\YDcghU`7Uff]Yf"
DccfWfYUhifY cV`][YXhcWU``Uhh\YAUbcfcbWY]bYUW\gYUgcb h\YghUf_
UbXh\YfU]b]b[ hcaU_Yh\Y`cb[XYhcifVmkUmcZWcbÉfaUh]cbh\Uh
h\YfYÁgbch\]b[hcXY`]jYf"Bch\]b[Wca]b[ bch\]b[[c]b["Bcgc`UWYVih
Uj]g]h]bh\Y_]hW\Ybk]h\h\Y\cigY_YYdYfVYZcfYhU_]b[idh\YgUhW\Y`
\YUjmk]h\aU]`Zcfh\YfY[i`UffcihYh\Uh`]YgUZUfWfmZfca5ZhYfaUh\"
@][\hYfh\UhgYUgcb mciWUbVYgifY"=bXYYX h\Ydccfh\]b[XcnYXcZZUg
h\Y\cigY_YYdYfW\]hW\UhhYXcb VUW_hifbYX Vigmk]h\h\YdihhYf]b[g
cZid_YYd"5bXh\cgYVUX[]f`gdcibWYXidcbh\Ycddcfhib]hmhcf]ÊY
XYdfUjYXk]h\h\Y`cb[]b[WcbeiYghcZUWei]g]h]cb"
Df]bhYXaUhYf]U`kUgh\Y`YUghcZh\Y]fh\]Yj]b["CihfU[Ycig h\cgY
aU]`cfXYfcihÉhgh\YdU]fcZh\Yahcc_hckYUf]b[UVcihh\YAUbcf"
Difd`YZYUh\YfgUbX[c`X`UaY/W\YUdfYX`UWYUbXhfUbgdUfYbhgYei]bg"
HUghY`Ygg gWUbhm UbX gccb fYXiWYX hc fU[g Zifh\YfacfY h\Y kUm h\Y
dU]fcZh\Yagei]fa]g\YXcjYfcbYhUkXfm]hYacfh\YbYlh `YUj]b[V]hg
U``hcfbUbXfi]bYXUg]ZUZYUh\Yf!hU]`YX gYei]b!gWU`YXVYUgh\UXVYYb
g`Ui[\hYfYX d`iW_YX UbXfUjYbcig`mWcbgiaYX"
MYh\ckh\YhkccZh\YadUfUXYX gh]`` YUW\U\]gg]b[UiX]YbWYhc
h\Ych\Yf"
H]aY h]W_YX cb ]b 5ZhYfaUh\" H\Y ghUf_ gYUgcb [UjY kUm hc h\Y
fU]b]b[ h\YfU]b]b[VUW_hch\YghUf_ UbXk]h\]bh\YkU``gcZh\YAUbcf
h\YkUbh]b[UbXVUhh`]b[fU[YX h\YVUhh`]b[UbXkUbh]b[ jUb]hma]ffcf!
]b[ XciV`]b[ XciV`]b["
K\Uh\cigY_YYdYfWci`X\cdYhcaU]bhU]bh\Y_]hW\Yb]bUbm_]bX
cZcfXYf k\Uhk]h\h\Yd]`ZYf]b[cZh\]g]hYacfh\UhZcfUbYbX`YgggiWWYg!
g]cbcZXc!]h!mcifgY`Z!Uh!\caYVYUihmfY[]aYg"<ckh\cgY[]f`gaUXYcZZ
k]h\aYUgif]b[gdccbgUbXa]l]b[Vck`g"H\YacfhUfUbXdYgh`Ybc`Ygg
7Ui[\hfYX\UbXYXMYhbcg`UdcZh\Ykf]ghkci`XXYhYfh\cgYÉ`W\]b[
)+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
[]f`g"<ckh\YmW`c[[YXidghfU]bYfgUbXfi]bYXgdUhi`Ugk]h\h\Y[ib_cZ
WcbWcWhYXc]bhaYbhg ZUWYaUg_g \U]fdUW_g"K\Uh\cigY_YYdYfWci`X
aU]bhU]bh\Y[`Uggib!gaiX[YXUbXh\Yg]`jYfdc`]g\YX h\YkUmh\cgY
[]f`ggY]nYXidcbh\Yg`][\hYghfYÊYWh]jYgifZUWYhcdfYYb hckUhW\h\Y
dfc[fYggcZWc`X`cjY`]bYggUg]hgWi`dhYXk]h\\Uffck]b[Wihg"
6ihk\m`]b[Yfcbh\Y]fVYUihm3K\mÉb[Yfk]h\h\Yhcb[iYh\Y
ÊUk`Yggk\]hYg_]bh\Uh[`YUaYXUg8Yg]fYhifbYXg`ck`mh\]gkUmUbX
h\UhVYZcfYh\YkUg\fccaa]ffcf WUfYZi``mdcg]b[UhYUW\Ub[`Y \Yf`cb[
gacch\bYW_h\YdYfZYWhdYXYghU`hc\Yf\YUXhcddYXVmh\Y]bhf]WUhY
gWi`dhifU` id!XcbY Wc]Z cZ \Yf \U]f V`UW_ Wc]`g VfU]XYX h\Yb hk]ghYX
VcibXfcibXUbXfcibX]bU\][\d]`Y"G\Y`]ZhYXUk\]hYUfa Éb[Yfg
UffUmYX W]fW`]b[h\YaU^Ygh]WUZZU]f"8YZYUhkUhW\YXUhh\Y_Ym\c`Y gifY
gifYUggd]hh\Uhh\Y`ia]bYgWYbhhYUfXfcd h\YhfYUgifYcZkU_]b[UbX
XfYUa]b[ghfi[[`Y `Umk]h\]bh\YaUXXYb]b[Xc gYWfYhYX dfchYWhYXVm
h\YUifUcZV`iY!V`UW_[`cgg"
HYUfgcZZfighfUh]cb[UjYkUmhcUgW\Ya]b[fU[Y"8YZYUhXYgWYbX!
YX]bgYUfW\cZUkYUdcb"5V`ccXmX][fYgg]cb"9Wcbca]WU``mghUhYX h\Y
\cigY_YYdYf k\cÁXVYYbVig]`mgb]dd]b[h\YhfiggZfcaUV]fXUVcihhc
VYWUfjYX hcc_h\Ykfcb[ghUbXUhh\Ykfcb[h]aY"G\Ykci`Xbchgif!
fYbXYf\Yfhcc`g bchcbUbmUWWcibh"5bXg\YdU]XZcfh\]gYffcfk]h\
\Yf\UbXghch\Ykf]gh \Y`Xk]h\h\YghfYb[h\cZ8YZYUh[cbYaUb]UW
h\YbgYjYfYXk]h\UWfUnYXk\UW_cZh\YWUfj]b[_b]ZYidcbh\YW\cdd]b[
V`cW_"Kci`Xh\Uh]h\UXVYYbh\Y\UbXgcZh\YW`cW_"
8Yg]fYYaYf[YXZfcah\YkUg\fccahcYbWcibhYf8YZYUh k\c `Yh!
h]b[cihUWfm`]_Yibhch\YkU]`gcZh\YaU`Yjc`YbhXYUX½=Á``\UjYmcif
\YUX½UhhUW_YX\Yfg]ghYfk]h\h\Uh]``![chhYbdU]fcZ_]hW\Ybg\YUfg"8Y!
g]fYÊYX UbX8YZYUhW\UgYX gbUdd]b[j]W]cig`m \Yfckb\U]fÊm]b[cih U
ghfYUa]b[V`UW_VUhh`YÊU["H\fci[\h\YWcff]Xcfg Xckbh\YghU]fg ]bhc
h\Y _]hW\Yb dUgh h\Y ibZcfhibUhY \cigY_YYdYf Wfiad`YX cb h\Y Êccf
]bg\cW_UbXUg`]W_cZV`ccX"=hkUg]bh\YgYfjUbhÁgeiUfhYfgkUg\fcca
h\Uh8YZYUhWcfbYfYX\Yfg]ghYf hfUddYX\YfidU[U]bghh\Yk]bXck"=b
h\YZfYbnmh\UhYbgiYX UhhUW_UbXXYZYbgY]bX]gh]b[i]g\UV`Y h\cgYhkc
\Y``]cbg g`Ug\YX ]b j]W]cig hUb[`Y ibh]` h\Y XciV`Y aUgg cZ h\Y]f V`UW_
\U]fgbUf`YXcbh\YdUbhfmÊccfUbXh\Yg\YUfgkYfYUVUbXcbYX]bZUjcf
cZh\fchh`Y"6]h]b[ g\f]Y_]b[/h\YWfUg\cZ[`UggUbXcihh\Yk]bXckh\Ym
),
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
\if`YX ]bhch\Yk\]dUbXg`Ug\cZh\YghUf_gYUgcb hkcaUX g\cfb[]f`g
\YUj]b[UWfcggh\Y`Ukb Xckbh\Yg`cdY UbXcbhch\YdUf_]bUgd]_]b[
gd]hh]b[ Wc`XghUVVYXd`ib[Y"
Cbh\YmWUfYYbYX `YUj]b[h\YWfiY`kYUh\YfcZ5ZhYfaUh\VY\]bX
Wca]b[hch\YgcZhVU`amWcbX]h]cbgcZh\Y[UfXYbg]bhYfbU` h\cgYZUf
fYacjYX"DUghh\YZfYg\Êck]b[ZcibhU]bUbXUbW]YbhÊcfUÊcif]g\]b["
GhYaUbX`YUZcZU[fYYbibW\U``Yb[YXVm^YU`cigm"6`cggcagh\Yk\]hY
cZUVgYbWYib^iX[YXVm`cgg"5bXh\YgWYbhcZ\cdYk]h\cihXY`ig]cb"
H\YVUhh`Y aYUbk\]`Y VY[UbhcYl\Uigh `UdgYX]bhcdig\]b[UbXg\cj!
]b[ h\YbUV]hcZbUaYWU``]b[h\Uh`]_Yk]gYdYhYfYXcih XYjc`jYXhcU
`]gh`Yggg]`YbWY"H\Ymg\iZÊYXcb hfUadg]bh\YfU[gkfci[\hVmX]gWcfX
kUbXYf]b[ Yadhm"9adh]bYgg ÉbU``m UgUb]aU`ibXYfghUbX]b[.H\Uhh\Y
hfYUgifYcjYfk\]W\h\Ym\UXYjYfZci[\hkUgYjYf`cgh cfUh`YUgh bYjYf
ZcibX"
5 d]YWY cZ h\Y \YUfh cZ XYZYUh ]aViYX k]h\ h\Y V`ccX cZ XYg]fY"
H\Uh`ia]bcigWcfY `YZhVY\]bX"@YZhhc`UmYfZcf]hgckbdfchYWh]cb"@YZh
hc]hgckb[YghUh]cb"
8YYdYfh\YkUbXYf]b[hcc_h\Ya ibh]`h\YmfYUW\YXh\YacXYgh
[UhY Uh h\Y cih`m]b[ YX[Y cZ h\Y [UfXYbg UbX dUggYX h\fci[\ ÉbX]b[
h\YagY`jYg[]jYbidhch\YibhYbXYXaYUXckk]h\h\Uh`ckghcbYkU``
cVgWifYXVma]ghfibb]b[U`cb[]hgZUfYX[Y"
=hkUghckUfXh\YghcbYkU``h\Y[]f`g\YUXYX hfiX[]b[ei]hY\YYX!
`Ygg`mcjYfh\Yach\YfÁg[fUjY bckgdchh]`m[fckbcjYfVmhUbb]g\[fUgg"
H\ig8Yg]fYUbX8YZYUhWfcggYXh\Y`]aYbcZ5ZhYfaUh\"K\UhVYWUaY
cZY]h\YfcZh\Ya VYmcbXh\YkU`` ]gUaUhhYfcZgcaYgdYWi`Uh]cb"
=h kUg h\Y c`X [fcibXgaUb h\Uh \YUfX h\Y Wf]Yg" <Y hfUW_YX h\Y
gcibX cffUh\Yf`Yh]hdi``\]a h\fci[\UbXh\fci[\h\Y[UfXYbg UbX
h\Ybh\fci[\h\Y`]hh`Y[UhYhch\Yg]hYcZh\Yach\YfÁg[fUjY"<Y_bY`h
Vfc_Y[fcibX"<YVY[UbhcX][k]h\\]ghfckY` h\Ybk]h\h\YfU_YcZ\]g
\UbXgUgh\YWf]Yg[fYk`ciXYf":U]h\Zi``m \YXi[ fYacj]b[V`i]g\YUfh\
ibh]`h\YVcXmcZh\Yach\YfkUgfYjYU`YX½Wcc`UbXWUg_Yh`Ygg \YfUfag
fcibXYX \UbXgW`UgdYXUg]ZhcZfUaYh\Y[Ud]b[WUj]hmcZ\YfVY``m"
K]h\]b Ub]bZUbhghfi[[`YXZcfjc]WY"
)-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
0cb6]e2Wab`OQbSRES0SQ][S
8YgdU]f X]X bch fYaU]b ]b h\Y d`Um\cigY k]h\ \Yf ghcfm ZcfYjYf"
Bc bc h\YVY``fUb[cihhcgiaacb\Yf giaacb\YfVUW_hch\YAUbcf
UbXg\YaUXY\YfkUm [Yhh]b[ UgkYfYWU`` ei]hYgcU_YXh\fci[\ kYh
UgkYhWUbVY bchhfciV`]b[hcgYY_cihh\YXfmdfchYWh]cbcZh\Y`][\h"
BYjYfVch\Yf]b[hchU_YWcjYf"G\YdfYZYffYX ]hgYYaYX hcgiZZYf\YfgY`Z
hcVYXfYbW\YXfUh\Yfh\Ubµ6ihkYXcbchdfYgiaYhcUfh]Wi`UhYh\Y
dfYZYfYbWYgcZ8YgdU]f"
KY WUbbch fYUX \Yf a]bX WUbbch \c`X h\Y jc`iaY cZ \Yf Wcb!
gW]cigbYgg cfd`UWY]hXckb VcibXk]h\]bUW]fW`YcZ`][\hidcbh\YhUV`Y"
KYWUbbch`]Zhh\YWcjYfcZ8YgdU]f"7UbÁhWfUW_\Yf"KYWUbbchcdYb
h\iaVcf`YUZcfdU[Yh\fci[\ WUbbchÉbXh\YfY`YjUbhgYWh]cb h\YdUg!
gU[Y]beiYgh]cbcZh\Uhib]XYlYXkcf_]bdfc[fYggh\Uh[fckgacfYYl!
hYbg]jYXU]`m"KYWUbbchg_]a"KYWUbbchgWUbZcfaYUb]b["Ei]hYh\Y
`]hh`YamghYfm]b\Yf`]hh`YkUmg"
5\\ kY`` []f`gk]``VY[]f`g"5`]hh`YfU]bbYjYf\ifh"BYjYfX]XUbm
dYfaUbYbhXUaU[Y"=h\Ugbc]``]bhYbh]cbg"
=bZUWh ]h\Ugbc]bhYbh]cbgUhU`` bcdfc^YWhVihhcZU`` hcfib]hg
gcU_]b[WcifgYibh]`h\cgYZUhV`UW_![fYYbW`ciXgUfYXfU]bYX [fckg_]b!
bm dU`Y k]gd]g\ kUg\YXcih k\]gdYfgcZh\YagY`jYg bc`cb[YfUV`Yhc
giddcfhh\Yg_mUVcjY"H\YW`ciXgUfYWfig\YXUgh\Yg_mXfcdg W`cgYg]b
V]bXg \UfXYb]b[Ug]hWcaYg"H\YYUfh\g\f]b_gVUW_Zfcah\Y`ckYf]b[
`cW_]b[g_m XfUkgVUW_ VUfYg]hg\c``ckg"9ldcgYX h\Y`YUj]b[gcZh\Yk]bX
VY[]bhcZfYh hc_]W_id hckU_Ybh\YWc`XZfca]hgg`YYd]bh\YVfUbW\UbX
Vig\ hcgk]hW\UbXhifb hcWihh\Y`iVV]g\`UmYfcZXi``Zfcah\YWc`XÁg
g]XYgUbXÊUb_g"H\YWc`X]gh\ig\cbYXZcfh\YghUf_gYUgcbÁgkcf_"H\Y
[fYYbYfmfYgdcbXgk]h\fUd]Xg\f]jY` X]gWc`cf]b[VfckbhcZUkbhcUg\Yb
h\YbX]g]bhY[fUhYgYbh]fY`m `YUj]b[VUfYh\YVfUbW\UbXVig\"
5bXh\Y`][\h3BcaUhW\Zcfh\Yg_mÁgghYY`mgifZUWY"G\UZhgh\Uh
WcaYVfYU_cbWcbhUWh g\UhhYf [f]bXcih[fUmk\]hY ghfYb[h\XUg\YX"
G`ck`m g`ck`m kYU_`m kYU_`m kYU_`m h\Y [\cgh`m `YUj]b[g cZ h\Y `][\h
É`hYfh\fci[\h\Yg_m []j]b[bckUfah\hch\YfYhfYUh]b[YUfh\ VUfY`m
fYUW\]b[h\YYUfh\UhU``VYZcfYVY]b[hU_Yb gkYdhUkUmVmh\Yk]bXcf
g`]WYXhcbch\]b[Vmh\YWc`X";fYmbYgg h\Yb h\YW`cW_Ágk\c`YW]fW`Y"
*$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5bXh\YfY"
H\YWmW`YWcad`YhY"H\YfY"<YfYkYUfY ]bh\YghUf_gYUgcb"
KYk]``kYUh\Yf]h"
=hk]``VY[chhYbh\fci[\ UbX[chhYbh\fci[\U[U]b"GiZZYfYXUbX
YldYWhYX"
KYk]``Wcbh]biY fYaU]b" KYhU_Yh\Y`cb[j]Yk" KYd]WhifY]h"
H\igkYÉ``h\YYadh]bYgg";]jY]hWc`cf"G\UdY"7cadcg]h]cb"6ih`Yhig
bch^iadU\YUX"@Yhigbchg_]dhch\YZihifYk\Yb8YgdU]f\Ugcb`m^igh
Uff]jYXZcfcif`]hh`YW\Uh"@Yhigcf]Ybh"@Yhig[YhcifVYUf]b[g"@Yhig
hU_Yh\]gcddcfhib]hm"@YhigfY`]g\h\]gdfcl]a]hm"@YhigWcbg]XYfW`cgY`m
UbXUhW`cgYfUb[Y"BcbYYXhcXYaifY 8YUf"@Yhig`cc_Uhmci"@Yhig
hU_YUb]WY`cb[`cc_"
BVS4WUc`S]TbVSAcPXSQb
Bch hc d`UWY ibXc ]adcfhUbWY cb UddYUfUbWYg" Bch hc cjYfYa!
d\Ug]nYh\YaUhhYf"Bchhc`UmibXcghfYgg Vih8YgdU]fWUb\UfX`mVYgU]X
hcVY`cc_]b[kY``"D]hm"5bXUhgiW\Ub]bcddcfhibYacaYbh"KY\UhY
hcgYY\Yfh\ig"Hcd]WhifY\Yfh\ig"
KY [f]YjY Zcf h\Y jUb]hm cZ 8YgdU]f" <Yf g_]b½bUhifU``m dU`Y U
hfUbg`iWYbh dcif`Yggk\]hY \UghU_YbcbUdU``cf"5kYU_[fYYb]g\hcbY
gdfYUXgVYbYUh\h\YgifZUWY"5[`ccam`ia]bYgWYbWY"H\YWcad`Yl]cb
cZh\YkfU]h\cZ\YfgY`Z"@YbXgUXfUaUhch\cgYXUf_W]fW`YgibXYf\Yf
YmYg"DiZZYXgaiX[YgcZXYYd d]hW\mdifd`Y"
G\UXckVfi]gYg"G\UXckVfi]gYgcZh\Y\YY`gcZ\UbXg"<YY`gh\Uh
dig\YX\UfXU[U]bghh\Yf]X[YgcZVcbYh\UhXYÉbYh\Y`ckYfgcW_YhgcZ
\YfYmYg"H\YdU`agcZh\cgY\UbXgWcjYfYXXiY`XfcddYX`]Xg Widd]b[
dfYgg]b[ d]bb]b[h\YjY`jYh`Yb[h\gcZ\Yf`Ug\Yg]bU`cW_U[U]bgh`]Zh"
6YbYUh\ h\YÉb[YfcZh\YYmYfYUXcjYfh\YaUdcZUX]ghUbhcfV
]g`UbX hfUWYX`][\h`mcjYfh\]bg_YhW\mfYXhfU]`gh\Uhgd]bX`YXYgh]bUh]cb!
`Ygg]bV`iY!k\]hYgiffcibX V`iY!k\]hYgiffcibX]b[h\Yf]b[YXViZZYf
hcUV`UW_jc]XWYbhYf"H\YÉb[Yf`]b[YfYXUhUgd`]h UhUX]j]XY]bh\Y
fYXhfU]`/Y]h\YfkUm`YUjYgcZZ UVUbXcbYX]bh\YV`iY!k\]hY"H\YÉb!
[Yf\cjYfYXUhh\YZcf_"H\Yb k]h\h\YYX[YcZh\YbU]` VY[UbhcdfcVY
*%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
XckbkUfX ]bkUfX"=hVY[UbhcVcfY hibbY`]b[hckUfXh\Yjc]Xk\YfY
h\Yj]g]cbcZh\Y`Ugh]bh\Y`]bYcZh\Y8Ui[\hYfgcZ5ZhYfaUh\g]hg Zcf!
YjYfg]hg Uach]cb`YggUbXdYfZYWh`]_YbYggcZ\YfgY`Z"
HfYacf ZcfY\YUX eiU_]b[ g]`_m YmYVfckg gY]nYX ]b U j]c`Ybh
diW_Yf"<UbXgÊ]b[]b[UkUm/`]Xggdf]b[]b[cdYbhcVUfYYmYgcZUaVYf
WcddYf fYg]b ]b U dckXYfYX Wfig\" 9mYg h\Y `][\hYgh XUf_ h\Y XUf_Ygh
`][\h"9mYgXfckb]b[ hYad`YgghfU]b]b[ aU\c[UbmcjU`cZUacih\[Ud!
]b[k]XY Wc``Udg]b[ [Ugd]b["HgibUa]]bZfcacZZh\YWcUgh":`ccXfYY_g
\UjcW":YUhifYgkfUW_YX"G_]bUfi]bk]h\gU`hXUaU[YYhW"
8YgdU]f UddYUfg hc \UjY a]ggYX \Yf VYUihm fYgh" G\Y UddYUfg hc
\UjY`cghg`YYd ZcibX]h]adcgg]V`YhcÉbX]bh\YkfYW_U[YcZh\UhWfm]b[
^U[ ZcibX]hbcd`UWY\]XXYb]bh\YhUb[`YcZVYXW`ch\Yg"Hcgg]b[UbX
hifb]b[hcbcUjU]`"
6ihkYdfYgiaY"KYXcbch]bZUWh_bckk\UhXYUf8YgdU]faUm
cf aUm bch \UjY VYYb `cc_]b[ Zcf" =b Ubm WUgY g\Y X]XbÁh [Yh U k]b_"
Ib`Ygg cZWcifgY kYV`]b_YX";]jYcfhU_Yh\]gcfh\UhibgiVghUbh]UhYX
]bghUbh \ckh]fYXh\YdccfXYUfaighVY"9jYbWcbg]XYf]b[U`cb[Yf`UdgY
]bcVgYfjUh]cb \ckacfhU``mYl\UighYX"<ckYbh]fY`mXfU]bYX"
KYWUbcb`m]aU[]bY"KYaUmkY``g\iXXYfhch\]b_"KYdih]hcih
cZa]bX"
MYhk\UhU`]hh`YhfccdYf"8YgdU]fg]hgVYZcfYig h\Ygci`cZWca!
dcgifY"G\Yg]hgidf][\hVihbchgh]ZZ U`YfhVihWU`a dfYgYbhVihYjYfgc
bcb!WcbZfcbhUh]cbU`"5bXgh]``"GhcW_gh]`` VfYUh\fY[i`Uf":YUhifYggYh
[UnYYjYb`mÉlYXcbh\Ya]XX`YX]ghUbWY YldfYgg]cbbYihfU`mYhcdYb
cdYb hc ]bhYfdfYhUh]cb" 5 g`][\h h]`h cZ h\Y \YUX U g`][\h hk]gh ]b h\Y
hfib_"5\UbX]bh\Y`Ud U\UbXWif`YXcjYfh\YUfacZh\YW\U]f"
5`cjY`mdcgY"Dcg]h]jY`mZfUaUV`YG\YÁgUbUhifU`
@iW_mig"KYWci`XcVgYfjY\Yfh\]gkUmZcfYjYf"5bXfYaU]bdYf!
ZYWh`mWcbhYbh"GdYU_]b[ghf]Wh`m]bhYfagcZZcfa"=bXYYXidcbYlUa]bU!
h]cb h\YWcbhYbh]gbch^ighYlUWh`mUgkYa][\h\UjYk]g\YX"=bh\YgYbgY
UZcfYaYbh]cbYX"
Bchhc]bUbmkUmcV^YWh]ZmcfZcfWYh\YZUa]`mfYgYaV`UbWY Vih
g\Y`cc_g`]_Y8YUh\kUfaYXcjYf"Bchhc\Ufdcbh\YbY[Uh]jY Vihh\Y
[]f`]gUdcg]h]jYZf][\h UbUVgc`ihYghfib[!cihkfYW_ UbXh\UhbYk\U]f!
Wih kYaighYad\Uh]WU``mghUhY XcYgbch\]b[Zcf\Yf"Bch\]b[UhU``"
*&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
Hcgg]b[UbXhifb]b[`YZhcZZ"6YXW`ch\Ygh\fckbVUW_/h\Yghf]_YcZ
aUhW\ k]W_`]hZc``ckYXVmacjYaYbhhckUfXh\YW\UaVYfXccf"CdYb
g\ih/gcZhW`]W_Zc``ckYXVmg]`YbhghYdgU`cb[h\YWcff]Xcf"
Achh`YXXUf_YbWfcUW\]b[UbXcjYf`Udd]b[h\YYX[YgcZh\YW`cgY
X]aÊ]W_YfcZh\YWUbX`Y"H\YÊUaYÁgÊ]W_YffYÊYWhYX Ê]W_Yf]b[`m]``i!
a]bUh]b[h\YfYÊYWh]cbcZVfck hYad`Y ^Uk bYW_"H\YgYg\]Zh]b[ hifb!
]b[VYbYUh\XUf_cihWfcdUb[`Yg^ihh]b[]bU``XY[fYYg YjYfmk\]W\kUm
Ukfm gUk]b[ ]b ghUWWUhc UbX dUigY" =h kUg X]ZÉWi`h hc gYY Uh h\Uh cXX
\cif k]h\`]hh`Y`][\hidcbh\YgiV^YWh"8]ZÉWi`hhcaU_Y]hcih"6ihgifY
Ybci[\"H\YfYg\YkUg.KU_YZi`8YgdU]f \UW_]b[UkUm]bh\YkUg\fcca
a]ffcfk]h\UdU]fcZ_]hW\Ybg\YYfg"
DYf\Udg;fY]jUk]``g]ad`mbYjYf`YUfbhc_YYdVYhhYfhfUW_cZh\Uh
ZUhYZi`]hYa gcWcadY``]b[ ]hgYYag hc[]f`gUhUWYfhU]bghU[Y]b`]ZY"
=bXYYX h\Y \U]fWih ]g U d]hm" H\cgY gUjU[Y`m W`cgY WfcddYX VUfY
dUhW\Yg"H\UhWfcc_YX ^U[[YXVUb["H\YcXXgh]W_]b[Wck`]W_g"H\Yj]W!
h]a `cc_" 5 ZUg\]cb ghUhYaYbh cZ gcaY _]bX3 5g ]Z 5ZhYfaUh\ AUbcf
kYfYgcaY_]bXcZVYUihmgW\cc`[cbY\Umk]fY"7if]cig"KYUfYWif]cig
VYWUigYh\Y\U]fWih]gUXckbf][\hg\UaY"Ibg][\h`m fYU``m"8]ZÉWi`hhc
[YhcjYf]h"8]ZÉWi`hhc`cc_dUgh]h"FYU``mgh]W_g]bcifWfUk"
5 XYW]XYX`m `Ygg h\Ub UhhfUWh]jY Xc" FUh\Yf ibZcfhibUhY h]a]b[
k\Uhk]h\h\YdU]bhYfXiYhcUff]jY"MYhUddYUfUbWYgUfYbchYjYfmh\]b["
5 dfcZYgg]cbU` gYYg k]h\]b gYYg dUgh h\Y kfYW_ cZ U Wc]Z h\Uh hcdg \Yf
hfciV`YXVfck dUghh\Ygib_YbdU``cfcZ\YfWcad`Yl]cb dUghh\YV`ccX!
g\chk\]hYgUbXUVUbXcbYXXYdh\gcZ\YfWcddYfYmYg"BchhcaYbh]cb
h\Yg\]jYfm \UibhYXeiU`]hm"H\Y[fUma]gh]Yg W`]b[]b[UVcih\Yf Ug]Zh\Y
[]f`kYfYhU_YbVmUhYff]V`YW\]``"
6ihcZWcifgY giW\UW\]``kci`Xbchgifdf]gYig"5ZhYfU`` 8YgdU]f
WUbbchUVgYbh\YfgY`ZZfcah\Y`UkgcZWUigYUbXYZZYWh"5W\]``kci`X
bchgifdf]gYigUhU`` []jYbk\YfYg\Y\UgVYYb UbXUhk\Uh\cif UbX
ibXYf k\]W\ Uhacgd\Yf]W WcbX]h]cbg" Cih cZ Xccfg" H\Y acgh cXX cZ
\cifg"H\YghUf_gYUgcb"
H\Y kUg\fcca `YZh ]b XUf_bYgg a]ffcf `YZh hc fYÊYWh Wc`X V`UW_
UVgYbWY"
6UW_hfUW_U`cb[h\YWcff]Xcf"7\UaVYfXccfdUggYX giaa]hcZh\Y
[fUbXgkYYdcZh\YghU]fkUm[U]bYX"H\YXYgWYbhcZ8YgdU]f VUfYZYYh
*'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
g`]dd]b[cihZfcaVYbYUh\\Yf[ckb"gYY_]b[ghU]fUZhYfghU]f"Ei]hYh\Y
[ch\]W`]hh`Yj]g]cbk]h\h\cgY_]hW\Ybg\YUfg[f]ddYXUh\Yfg]XY"5[`]bh
cbh\Yg\ihaYhU`^Ukg"
H\Y`UbX]b[\]h"<YfY UdUigY WUbX`YW`ihW\YXUhW\Ygh`YjY` ÊUaY
ghYUXm]bh\YXfUZh`YggdfchYWh]cbcZ]bhYf]cfgdUWYZcfaYXUbXViZZYfYX
Vmh\YdfiXYbhWcbghfiWh]cbcZ5ZhYfaUh\"Bch\]b[gcXifUV`YUgghcbY
bch\]b[gcfY`]UV`Y bch\]b[gcgYhcb]hgfYgdcbgYhch\YhYghcZh]aY.Gh]``
ghUbX]b["
5bXcZWcifgY h\YghUZZd`Umg]hgfc`Y ;fY]jUUbX;UfXYbYf \cigY!
_YYdYf UbX [fcibXgaUb" AU]bhYbUbWY UbX dfYgYfjUh]cb 7YfhU]b`m ]h
\UgWcaYhccifUhhYbh]cbh\UhVch\h\Y\cigYUbX[fcibXgUfY]bfUh\Yf
UgcffmghUhYcZX]gfYdU]f"MYhkYXcbcha]Wfc!aUbU[Y"KYWUbbchWcb!
WYfbcifgY`jYgk]h\YjYfm`]hh`Yh\]b["5bXh\Ydccfh\]b[ghfm"HcaU]b!
hU]b"HcdfYgYfjY"H\YmdihhYfUVcihh\Y]fhUg_g"
;fY]jU ZcfYlUad`Y b][\h`m]bh\YXfUk]b[fcca k]h\cihZU]` Ug]Z
g\Y\UXUghUbX]b[Uddc]bhaYbh"H\YfYg\Y]g idibh]`h\YcXXYgh\cif
`UVcf]b["5ffUb[]b["CfUWhiU``m fY!UffUb[]b["FY!UffUb[]b[h\YZifb]!
hifY" FUh\Yf Wcadi`g]jY ]b cif j]Yk" @]_Y ibhc U dYfgcbU` WfigUXY cZ
gcaY_]bX"
<YfY g\Y kUg \YfY g\Y \Ug VYYb \YfY g\Y ]g dig\]b[ chhcaUbg
k]h\h\YVfcUXg]XYcZ\YfZcch Viad]b[gcZUgU`cb[k]h\\YfVUW_g]XY
\Ui`]b[YbXhUV`YgZfcacbYg]XYcZh\Yfccahch\Ych\Yf]bh\Yhcb[
[f]dcZ\Yf\UbX`Yggkf]ghg"8c[[YXYhW"
<ckkYfYaYaVYfk\Ybcif`]hh`YW\Uf[YÉfghWUaYidcb\Yfh\ig"
8YgdU]fkUg^ighUg`]dcZUh\]b[ UbX\UXkU_YbYX]b\YfW\UaVYf k\]W\
kUgU``[fYYb[c`Xk]h\h\Y[`ckcZ`][\hZfcah\YfU]bk]h\cih"Ei]Yh`m
UbXk]h\cihdfYUaV`Y g\Ydig\YXh\YWcjYf`YhUg]XY fcgY UbXWfYdhXckb
hc h\Y XfUk]b[ fcca" G\Y ghccX Uh h\Y h\fYg\c`X cVgYfj]b[ ;fY]jU Zcf
gcaYh]aY"5bXh\Yb k\Yb;fY]jU\UXfYUW\YXUacaYbhcZfUh\YfX]fY
ghfi[[`Y]bjc`j]b[U`Uf[Yk]b[W\U]fUbXh\Yg\Ufd`mWfYgh]b[kUjYcZWUf!
dYhhfUddYXVYbYUh\]h XYUf8YgdU]fUddfcUW\YX hifbYX\YfYmYgidkUfX
UbXihhYfYX\YfÉfghkcfX"CfUh`YUgh h\YÉfghkYWci`XXYW]d\Yf"H\Y
ch\Yfg h\YaU!aUgUbXXU!XUg kYX]XbchVch\YfhcXYWcXY"KYWUbbch
WcbWYfbcifgY`jYgk]h\YjYfm`]hh`Yh\]b["6ih]bXYYXUbXUh`Ugh \ckUXcf!
UV`Y]hkUghc\YUf\YfihhYfUfYWc[b]nUV`Ygm``UV`YH\UhVY]b[.½<Y`d"
*(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
AcghWYfhU]b`m \YfjcWUVi`Ufm\Ug]bWfYUgYXg]bWYh\Yb"5bXh\Y
ghYU`h\cZ\YfWfYYd]b[3FYhU]bYX"
5 [`]XY dUgh h\Y h\fYg\c`X cZ h\Y XfUk]b[ fcca ;fY]jU \iZÉb[
k]h\]b Zi``mYb[U[YX]b\Yfhc]`"Cbh\Yb h\fci[\h\YXUf_Wc`XWcf!
f]XcfgcZ5ZhYfaUh\ h\Y[fYUhAUbcfcZ\YffU]g]b["
Cf\YfidVf]b[]b[ kYci[\hhcgUm"IdVf]b[]b[]gjYfmaiW\h\Y
VYhhYfkUmhcd\fUgYcifaYUb]b[ `Yghibd`YUgUbhbch]cbgcWWif WcaY
WUhUdi`h]b[cjYfh\YkU``cZ5ZhYfaUh\ WcaYghcfa]b[h\Yd`UWYk]h\
h\YZi``dckYfcZgi[[Ygh]cbUbX`YUdhca]bXUfaYXk]h\UVUhhYfmcZ
W\]``]b[ ]aU[Yg. 5ZhYfaUh\ AUbcf XYac`]g\YX fYXiWYX hc fiVV`Y fY!
XiWYX hc U \YUd cZ Wc`X ghcbYg" KY UfY bch ]b g\cfh ]aaibY hc h\Y
dckYfcZh\Y\cacbma"
Cbhch\Y_]hW\Yb"H\Y_]hW\Ybg\YUfgXYdcg]hYX]bUXfUkYf k\YfY
XciVh`Yggh\Ym\UjYU`kUmgVY`cb[YX"=bXYYX k\UhU[ccX[]f`"KY\UjY
U`kUmg\UXUgcZhgdchZcf8YgdU]f"BYjYfa]bX\ck`]hh`YkYibXYfghUbX
\Yf cf \Yf b][\h kUbXYf]b[g \Yf h\fYUX]b[g h\fci[\ 5ZhYfaUh\ \Yf
ei]YhdUXX]b[cihcZh\Y_]hW\YbUbXcbhch\YgYfjUbhgeiUfhYfg ]bhc
h\Y]fk]bX]b[fYUW\Yg"
G\Y\Ub[gUf][\h]bhch\YkUg\fcca"
5bXh\Yb ZcffYUgcbgYbh]fY`mib_bckbhcig 8YgdU]fYl]hgh\Y
Vi]`X]b[ j]U h\Y kUg\fcca k]bXck" G\Y \]hg h\Y [fcibX UbX gYhg cZZ
UWfcgg h\Y `Ukb b][\hXfYgg d`UghYfYX hc \Yf Zcfa Vm h\Y k]bX k\]W\
k\]dg UbX ZibbY`g d`ib[]b[ \Yf hc h\Y Vchhca cZ h\Y g`cdY ]bhc h\Y
dUf_ h\Ybcb hch\Y[UfXYbgk]h\]b"
5bXZfca\YfY Zfca\YfY]bk\UhaUbbYfXcYg8YgdU]fWcbh]biY3
K\UhkUmXcYgg\Yd]W_ UbXhck\UhYbX3K\]W\WcifgYXcYgg\YZc`!
`ckh\fci[\h\Y`UbXgWUdYcZh\YdUf_/\ckXcYgg\Yk]bXUacb[gh]hg
ZYUhifYg3
G][\h X]aaYX"
Idcbk\]W\kU`_gXcYgh\YVcchYXhfYUXcZ8YgdU]fZU``3H\fci[\
k\]W\[UhYgXcYgg\YdUgg3H\YhfUW_ cVgWifYX"H\YacjYaYbhcZ8Y!
gdU]fV`ifg"=b\YfkU_Y h\YV`ifhfUWYg YlhYbXgcihhch\YV`iff]b[V]`!
`ck cZ \Yf b][\hXfYgg" 5h gcaY hifb gcaY W\Ub[Y cZ X]fYWh]cb gcaY
U`hYfUh]cb cZ \Yf WcifgY h\fci[\ h\Y \YX[Y!aUnY kY `cgY \Yf" J]g]cb
ZU]`YX"
*)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
C\h\Y`]a]hgcZ7ighcX]Ubg\]dKYaU_YbcYlWigYg kYg]ad`m
ghUhYh\YWUgY"8YgdU]fUddYUfghcjUb]g\"K\UhhmdYcZh]aYh\YbdUggYg3
KYWUbbchgYYUbXkYWUbbchgUm"K\UhXcYgg\Yh\]b_g\YÁgXc]b[3KY
XcbchWcb^YWhifY"Bc kYXcbch\UnUfXU[iYggUghck\Uhg\Y]bhYbXg
k\Uhg\YWci`Xdcgg]V`maYUbhcUWWcad`]g\ f]g_]b[\YfXYUh\cZUW\]``"
CihcZXccfg/h\YcXXYghcZ\cifg/h\YghUf_gYUgcb"
=hkUgh\YVY``h\UhgiaacbYX\YfVUW_"=bh\Yb]W_cZh]aY dYf!
\Udg":cfk\Uh]g5ZhYfaUh\Vihh\YYggYbWYcZ\Yf3
KYhU_Yh\Y`cb[j]Yk VY[]bb]b[k]h\h\]g[ccX `cb[`cc_Uhh\Y
É[ifYcZcif`]hh`YW\Uf[Y"H\YÉ[ifYcZh\YgiV^YWh"H\YX]aYbg]cbgUfY
mYh hc VY XYhYfa]bYX h\Y accX h\Y fYbXYf]b[" H\Y VUW_[fcibX h\Y
dU`YhhY" 5bX Ufh]gh]W `]WYbgY k]`` cZ WcifgY \UjY hc VY Wcbg]XYfYX" H\Y
ibXYfhU_]b[]gmYhhcWcaaYbWY"H\YZihifYcZ8YgdU]f]gmYhhcVYfYU`!
]nYX mYhhcVYdU]bhYX mYhhcVYZfUaYXUbX\ib[]bh\Y;U``Yfm<U``"
H\YZihifYcZ8YgdU]f.hcfYaU]b]b5ZhYfaUh\"H\YWcbghfiWhgUZY"Bc
W\Ub[Y"GUZYUggUZYWUbVY"
KY kU]h Zcf h\Y dU]bhYf hc Uff]jY Vih bch Zcf `cb[ UbX bch Zcf
bch\]b[" <UgbÁh 8YgdU]f VYYb \Y`dZi` ghf]_]b[ giW\ U dYfZYWh dcgY3
<UgbÁh g\Y VYYb UWWcaacXUh]b[ VUfY`m acj]b[ U aigW`Y3 <UgbÁh g\Y
cV`][YX3<UgbÁhg\YVYYbk]``]b[35bXXcYgbÁhU``cZh\]gVcXYkY``Zcf
h\YZihifY3
AUf_\YfVYZcfYg\YVfYU_g"
**
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
A7<M@5B8
¿0W`RV]ePSOcbWTcZZgg]caW\UÀ
)
CaU_YgU\c`Y]bh\YÉfaUaYbhkYhfYV`Yh\fci[\"
IbXYfWcjYfcZ\][\bchYg h\Yg_]bg`]dgibXYfWcjYfg"H\Ykc`Z\]X]b["
H\]ggcb[Wci`XVYmcifVf][\hVf]X[Y]bhcg`YYd.
]dO`gab]ZS\T`][aZSS^W\UQVWZR
Ì]eS`SbPc`WSRW\bVSP`WROZP]c_cSb
Mcifdccfacih\gcfYZfcaW`YbW\]b["FYXXYfh\Ubh\YfcgY"
]e]ZT[WZZab]\SO\US`SRS\US\RS`SR\WUVbW\UOZS
]ab`Se\S[PZS[dOQc]ca^cZaObWdS
@cb[hibbY`aUXYZfcaV]fXgcb[ h\Yg_mUfW]b[aYUb`m"
=b_mgaY``cihg]XY]bh\Ya]`_mb][\h"
K\YfYUfYmci3HU`_]b[hch\Yk]bX kYXXYXhch\YfcdYaU_YfÁgXUi[\hYf"
H\]gch\Yfkcf`Xcbmci mcifVcXmÉhgghfUb[Y"
*+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
@9G@9M>9B=?9
BV`SS3\bS`bVS2O`YE]]R
)
=hÁgh\YcbYUVcihh\YVYUfgUbXh\Y]fV`cbXY.
=bh\Y]faUbmVYXg=`YZhaUbmWY``g
WU``YXamai`h]d`YdYfgcbU`]h]YgXckb
h\Y]fZUWYghch\Yg_m
Ug`]XYg\ckcZW\YUdfYZYfYbWY W\UbhYigYg
cfd\UbYXVmUkUjYcZVYUf"
@]ZYg\ci`X\UjYd]UbcUWWcadUb]aYbh½
gcUg;c`X]`cW_g]bamXY`ig]cb
=ghU[YXUh\fYY!dUfhaig]WU`":`ckYfgWfccbYX"
=VifbYXh\YgWf]dh]bhcam\UbX.=b[biY
WfcggYgUk\]gh`]b[AUgcb!8]lcb
hckUfXUhcacffckbchhcVYVY`]YjYX
dihgXckbUacb[h\YV`ccag \iagUhibY
`cgYg\Yfa]bX"A]bXkUbXYfghcUghU[Y
VYWcaYgUjc]WY ai`h]ZUf]cig g\ch
hch\YVU`Wcbm"5gcibXYb[]bYYf
Ug_g\YfhcgUm\YfbUaY]bhch\Ya]W"
HYgh"HYgh"HYgh"G\Ykf]hYgh\fYYW\UdhYfg"G\Yg`YYdg
]bh\fYYVYXg"H\YfYUfYh\fYYacjYaYbhghch\]g
cbYhccgcZh hkchcc\UfXVih7\]`X
*,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
?5A=@5@=G
Be]>]S[a
)
2SdWZRSadO\S`
EWZRAeO\a
H\UhÉfghh]aY=gUkamgY`Za]fUWi`cig kYVU_YXgkUb!ZUh
]bhcVfYUXk\YbGUhUbk\]gdYfYX ¾=WUbÁhh\]b_cZUbmh\]b[
h\UhWUbaU_YaYga]`Y`]_YmciWUbUbXU`h\ci[\mciUfYdYfZYWh
mci\UjYWcaYhccYUf`mUbXUfY\YfYk\YfYgcaYh\]b[`Ui[\]b[
k]``VYg\UdYXXY`]VYfUhY`m VU``cZUdU`adfYggYX]bhcac]ghW`Um"¿
=h\ci[\h5bXYfgYbWUfjYXk\]hYUbXUb[i`UfU[U]b `]_Yh\Ygcbg
cZhk]`][\hcf`ia]bcigU`UVUghYfkfci[\hk]h\ÉbYghV`UXY
hccVYUih]Zi`hcWcbhYad`UhYib`YggfYj]gYXUgGUhUbVmh\YV`YbXYf
k]h\h\YWighUfX UbXaUmVY=ÁjY`YZhcZ\]aU`cjY`mVUghUfX
k\c W`ciX!\YUXYXUbXhccXY`]WUhYfYghgUZcfY\YUXcbamkf]gh
UbXk\cgYk]b[gUfYÊ]agm"6ihh\]g]gX]ZZYfYbh h\]gk]```Ugh
UbXgcg\Y`]jYgh\Yd\fUgY ¾h\Y[UfXYbkY``]gh\YfYZcfXfckb]b[¿
Vih=\UjY`cjYX\]a]bh\Y[fchhcg \UjYgYYb[fYYbW\]dgVYbYUh\
gdfUmgcZ^UXYUbX\UjYghUmYXhcgcU_V`ccX]bhc`]bYbghf]dg
hcf]bgYh\Yak]h\h\YVUbXU[Yg"@UhYf \Yk]``di``cbYZYUh\YfYXf]V
Zfcah\fYY ¾UbXk\Ybmcif\UbXgWUbgWUfWY`mX][ =k]``VYbYUfmci¿
k]``gWccdghcbYgYbci[\ZcfUZUWYk\YfYg\Ykci`X`Um\YfgY`Z
hckU]h hcgUm ¾=WUbÁhh\]b_cZUbmh\]b[h\UhWUbaU_YaY½¿
*-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
6O\aSZ
H\YfY]gUVcXm\YfYgcaYk\YfY
U`YYW\k]ZYk\ca]lYg[fYYbÉfY]bh]bXfiag
VmXig_ VfU]Xgh\Yhcifb]eiYhg fYgYhgVcbYg"
6ihh\]g\UddYbYXmYUfgU[c VYZcfY
h\YUgmaaYhfmcZWfmghU`g ¾UX]b`]_Y[`Ugg
=h\ci[\h \ckYUgm]h]ghcX]Y"¿
FYaYaVYfh\Y`YYW\k]ZYUbXh\YXfiag
g\Yhf]YXVihk\Uh]Zh\]g]gCWhcVYf]b6Yg`Ub
]Z]h]gZcfighcVifmcifW\]`XfYb"
H\]b_¾ghfUb[YWibY]ZcfaXUf_bYgg ¿
h\YfchUh]cbcZdc`Uf]nYX`][\h
cfGU]bh@iWmk]h\\Yf_b]jYg"
+$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5G<@9MA7K5H9FG
ASdS\>]S[a
)
/\\c\QWObW]\
5Vcihf]b[]b[h\YVY`` g\Y]gbYUf`mUaV]jU`Ybh"
=b_V`YYXgh\YZc`XgcZ\YfaUd bckfibb]b[
hfUbg`iWYbh bck[`ck]b["H\Y\cigY]gbchWYfhU]b
g\Y]gh\YfY h\Yghcfa`UWYg\Yf]b g\Y]gXUf_"
>`OgO``WdSW\R]USO`SR[gbVWQOZRWaUcWaS
h\Y`YhhYf\UXgYYaYXhcgUm OaeS\SdS`bW`S
]Tab]`WSaeVWZSObbS\RW\Ub]VO\Re]`Y>`Og
RSZWdS`Ë\Sbc\SaT`][O^^ZSadS`aSa
T`][VOb^W\aBVWaWab]USbb]caBVWaWab]PZ]eW\
G\Yhifbgh\YW\]aY \YUfg
h\YWUfdYhghcadcfbUhY`m"H\YUb[`Yk]XYbg
VYZcfY\Yfk]h\]hgÉb[Yfg h\Y]fÉjY!dc]bhYX
kcaUb"GcaYk\YfYVY\]bX\Yf]gÉfY"
KcaUbfYUW\YgU[U]bgh\YfZU`hYf hU_Yg
\Yf\UbXg"BVWaWab][OYS^WSQSa g\YgUmg"
BVWaWaV]eb]V]ZRWbR]e\BVWaWab]SObWbBVWaWa
b]ZSbWbaZ]eZgR`]^B]ZSO`\V]e
b]eSOdSV]eb]]cbeSWUVWbBVWa(
+%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
4SP`cO`g
I0`]e\SZZK
=kYUjYUhfU]b]hgbUaY`YgghfUW_g
`UhYUbXW`U]a`Ygg gWiaV`YXh\]aV`Y
ZcfV`Ygg]b["Bcck`cfVf][\hVf]XY
=kYUjYamgY`Zhc`UWY hc`Yh]bU]f"
HUhhcc]b[h\YgYUa aYUbXUbUbh`YfYX\UfY
k\]hY\cfgY g\YYd"KYaU_YcifkUmXckb
hch\Y\Ya½\ckW\Ufa]b[h\YÊihhYfcb
h\UhZUhYZi`XUm"GiW\cjYffUhYX`]VYfh]Yg
=XfYUah\Ygdf]b[k\YbgcaYcbYghYU`g
UdUfhcZaY"6ih=fYaU]bU\YUfhgcfY j]c`Ybhh\]b[
U``gcifUbXibhibYXcf[Ubg"H\YfY]gbckYXX]b[
h\Yh\]b[gkYkUbh/bch\]b[hchYUW\U`cbY"
=hihcfUÊckYf =[iYgg hc`YUfbh\YfYUW\
cZh\Yaccb/\c`XUbch\YfbYYX`YhcghYah\YUW\Y"
+&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
4SP`cO`g
IAbcRS\bK
5bch\YfUW\YhcghYah\Yaccb h\]gbYYX`Y
XfUkgaYh\fci[\h\YXUf_"<Uj]b[bcigY
ZcfUbmigYZi`h\]b[ =kUgXYYaYXUfYW`igY
gYbhghfU][\hUkUmhcU`UXmÁggW\cc`
hc[Yhd`YUhYX/=Á```YUfbhcmcXY`
dYf\Udg hcdfUm]bg]l`Ub[iU[Yg hcXUbWY
k]h\UdYhXc["=dfca]gYXamUibhg
hcd`YUgYh\Ya"Bck=Á``VYUZcc`
k]h\UZYUh\YfdYbk]dYf YjYfhU_YbUVUW_
UbXgkccb]b["Bc =UaUVYbh!dfcb[YXZcf_
]bghYUX amhYUW\Yfh\Y_b]ZYk]h\Ugif[YcbÁg\YUfh.
g\Yhcc_am\UbXg Vihk\Ybg\YdUfhg
\Yf`]dg =Ubbcmk]h\Ug]`jYf_]W_"
Gc\UjYbcd]hm.=ghUmUbXdf]W_"
+'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
:SbbS`
6Yghk]hW\WfUZh]ghcVYU`]jY½
H\Y`][\hb]b[d`UmYh\½U``h\Yk\]`Y½
5bXacifb]b[gd`]hg\YfdcXgcZÊUaY½
H]``U``h\YaYacfm]gZi``"
=ZY`ham`]ZYk]h\Vch\am\UbXg½
5bXhifbYX]hfcibXUbXfcibXUbXfcibX
5bX½k\Yb=XfcddYXh\UhmY``ckZcf_
=hVif]YXXYYd½VYbYUh\h\Y[fcibX"
=h`YZh½h\Y`]hh`Y[c`XYbh]bh
H\UhaYUbhgcaYbYkghcaY.
=X]YZcf6YUihm½XU]`mgh]``½
DfUm½\UjYbcacXYghbYYXg½
+(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
;SbO[]`^V]aWa
5hÉfgh h\YcWWidUh]cbgYYaYX\Ufa`Ygg"
5VUg_YhUbX]hgfY[i`Uf]ad`YaYbhg.
h\]aV`Y bYYX`Y Êcgg gW]ggcfg gcaYhUdY
ZcfaYbX]b["G\Ykci`XWcibhh\YbYYX`Yg
]bh\YVcc_Uhb][\h/g\YkUgh\Uh_]bXcZ[]f`"
G\Yk\]hYkUg\YXUWYfhU]b`cbY`]bYggk]h\X]`][YbWY"
G\Ykcf_YXibh]`h\YXUmgVYWUaY`]hh`YcjU`g
cZ]bW]XYbhg `]_YÉb[YfbU]`ghcVYg\YX"H\Yb
g\YVY[Ubhcbch]WY\Yf]bghfiaYbhgYjYfmk\YfY.
gW]ggcfg]bUWYfYU`Vck` gdcc`gcZh\fYUX
É``]b[h\YVUh\fccag]b_ Ug]b[`Yh\]aV`Y
VYbYUh\\Yfd]``ck"BYYX`YgibXYfYjYfmVcc_
cb\Yfg\Y`ZUddYUfYXhcVYhfm]b[hcdYW_
h\Y]fkUmVUW_hch\Y]fckbdU[Yg"9jYb
]bh\Y[UfXYb g\Ykci`XÉbXgcaY[`]bh]b[
aYhU`WUghg]XY`cb[]bh\YX]fh"H\YW\U]f
g\YgUh]bhcgYk`cb[\cifgVYWUaY`iadm
k]h\h\]aV`YgUbXÊcgg"G\YVY[Ub
Ufih\`YggWc``YWh]b[ É``]b[[`Ugg^Ufg
UbX\UbXVU[gUbXg\cYVclYgUbXdU]`g
g\cj]b[h\YaibXYfh\YVYXUhb][\h"G\Y[fYk
acfYkcff]YXh\UhUj]g]hcfkci`Xbch]WY
gcaYh\]b[kUgUa]gg gcVY[Ub_YYd]b[
hc\YfgY`Z"H\Y_]hW\Yb\UXVYWcaYUd`UWY
cZgiW\hYffcf k]h\cV^YWhggd]``]b[cih
cZYjYfmWidVcUfX g\YWYUgYXYUh]b[
U`hc[Yh\Yf"Gh]``g\Ykcf_YXXU]`m k]h\acfY
UbXacfYZYfjcf Xf]jYbVmUghiVVcfbfYgc`jY
U[U]bghh\Ya"=hkUg\Yf\UbXgh\YmkUbhYX
cfdYf\Udg\YfYmYg"H\YgcZhibXYfg]XYg
+)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
cZ\YfUfag[fYkdU`YUbXgd]bX`m"<Yf\U]f
[fYkk\]hYUbXUgcZhXckbWcjYfYX\YfVcXm"
<YfVY``mX]ghYbXYX"<Yfa]bXX]ghfUWhYX
g\YkUgcb`mWcaZcfhUV`Y]bWcfbYfg"G\YkcjY
cb`m]bk\]hY"GbckÉbU``mZY`` Vif]YXYjYfmh\]b["
=hkUgd`YUgUbh ZcfUacaYbh kUhW\]b[
YjYfm`Ughbch]cbX]gUddYUfh\YfY"G\YWfYdh
VUW_hch\Y\cigY WYfhU]bh\YghcfmkUgXcbY
hfU]`]b[Uh\]bk\]hYÉ`UaYbhZfca\YfVUW_"
+*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
ESPe]`Y
H\Ym\cigYX]bk]bXck!`cW_g
VYhkYYbgY`Xca!igYXdchg
h\fYUXYXUacb[VUg_Yh!fYYXg ]bc`X
gdcc`!\c`Yg"CbWYg\YXfYUaYXUbYgh
VYbYUh\h\Yd]``ckUbXkc_Y
hcÉbX]hgc"5bXcbWYU\cff]V`YÉfY
ZfcaUWUbX`YÊUfYXUbXVifbYX
h\Yk]Xck`]j]b[h\YfY"GcaYXUmg
g\YZcibXcbYVfU]XYX]b\Yf\U]f"5``
k]bhYfg\Ya]a]W_YXkYVg]b[UinY WcXX`YX
kU_]b[giXXYb`mhch\fYUXYXW`ciXg
ibXYfZcch h\Ykcf`XÁgVcfXYf`Yggk\]hY
]hgZiffYXa][fUh]cbg"Hcc YjYfm
ach\XfYk]bdYfZYWhg]`jYf
hc[fck]b[bYhgg\YYjYfmk\YfY
k]``YX"5``giaaYf"5``ZU``"Bck
gbckÊ]Yg[UiX]`mYjYb]bX]U[cbU`
b][\hZU``UbXg\YVi]`XgacfYgh]``"
<YfY ZcfaU`k\]hYÉ`UaYbhfcUfg
]bk]b[VYUhgZfcaYjYfm
WifjYcZh\Y\cigY"
H\]gc`X\UV]hcZVfcca]b[hifbYX
bYk`cjYcZaYg\]bhYf`UW]b[ acfYÊYg\
acfY_bchgcZZccX"
++
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
9SS^W\U6]caS
?bckh\]g.=Zc`XYXh\Y]bXYW]d\YfUV`Yh\]b[g
]bhcamg\ci`XYfV`UXYg"=a]hYfYXh\YWcfbYfg
cZcifg\YYhgUhh\YZcchcZh\YVYX"=\]Xgcb[g
ibXYfmcifhcb[iY"=gkYdh[`Ugg]bhch\Ygc`Yg
cZamZYYh"=gh]hW\YXambUaY]bhcmcifg\]fhg
ghckYXamZcfhibY]bh\YVUW_cZmcifh\fcUh"
Mcik]``Zcf[Yhh\]g.=Vif]YXmcifhYYh\
Uhh\YVUgYcZamgd]bY"=ghUW_YXV`Ub_Yhg
]bh\YW`cgYh gkU``ckYXh\Y\c``ckg
VYhkYYbh\Y]fYX[Yg"=WihdUhhYfbg
Zfcac`XW`ch\UbXXfYUaYXam\U]f
UWfcggh\Y_]hW\YbhUV`Y kU]h]b[
ZcfgW]ggcfg h\Yg\cfhZU``Xckb h\YXUf_"
+,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
65F65F5>5B9F9M9G
BVS2cg]\UAS`WSa
)
2cg]\U
5ha]Xb][\h h\Yc`XaYb[Uh\Yfk]h\c]``UbhYfbgUVcUfXh\Y]fÉg\]b[
VcUhg"K]h\fcgUf]Yg]b\UbX h\YmghUVh\YkUhYfk]h\aUW\YhYg"H\Y]f
gcbggUm ¾8cbchVYZcc`]g\"H\YfYUfYbcacfYaYfaU]Xg\YfY"=h]gh\Y
WfcWcX]`Ygk\cUfYghYU`]b[cifmcib[cbYg"¿
7fcWcX]`YgF]X]Wi`cig"
7fcWcX]`YgUfYbchg`]W_"AmXc`d\]bg_]bk]h\ghUbXgh\YaYbÁgaUW\YhYg"
6ihaU_Ybca]ghU_Y/h\Yc`XaYb[]jYaYaUbmgWUfg"
:fcahUb[`YgcZbYhg]bh\Yg\U``ckg h\Yc`XaYbWihaY`ccgY"H\Ym
dfUm=aUmei]W_`mÉbXcdYbgYU"6ihXcbchh\]b_h\]g]g_]bXbYgg"
5gZcfh\Y]fmcib[cbYg h\Y]fVcX]YgWcaYg`]dd]b[XYYd]bhcam\caY"
<UbXgUbXZYYh VcibX"8]gg]XYbhVcX]YgZi``cZ\c`Yg V`cca]b[V`ccX
ÊckYfg]bamkUhYf"=g]b[h\Yahcg`YYd]bam[UfXYb"=Zh\Yc`XaYb
cb`m _bYk k\Uh WUfY = hU_Y VYXX]b[ h\Y g`YYd]b[ gcbg cZ Ég\YfaYb
ghfc_]b[gidd`Yg_]b"
+-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
2cg]\U
MciUfYh\YXfYUa]b[[]f`k\ckU`_gcihg]XYcZ\YfgY`Z ]bhch]XY`UbXgÁ
ghUf^Uga]bYj]bYkYUj]b[ Xf]dd]b[gYUgdfUm"H\YU]fdi``gmcifh]bmZYYh
UbXmcik][[`YVUfYhcYg]bh\YWcc`gUbX"
Mci UfY h\Y fcgm!ZUWYX []f` k\c kU`_g cihg]XY cZ \YfgY`Z" Hcb[iYg cZ
accb`][\h dYbYhfUhY VUbUbU `YUZ WcWcbih dU`a WUbcd]Yg" 7\]fd]b[
UVcjYmci XfU[cbÊ]YgVinnUbXÊ]h XYYdaU[YbhUÉfY";c`XYb`YUZV]fXg
UbXZU]fmV`iYV]fXgWU``mciVUW_hcmcifZUh\Yf"MciUfYh\Y[]f`k\cXcYg
bch\YYX\YfZUh\YfÁghk]hhYf]b[aYggYb[Yfg"
Mci`]ghYbhch\YghcfmcZVfUbW\Yg X]dd]b[h\Y]fcjYfgkYYhd]b_Zfi]h
]bhch\YgkY``]b[gYU hciW\]b[gacch\YXkYhghcbY"KUX]b[kU]gh!XYYd
dUghh\Yc`XaYbÁgVcUhg mcihUb[`YmcifaUb[fcjYÉb[Yfg]bh\Yh\]W_
V`UW_fcdYgcZmcif\U]f"MciUfYh\Y[]f`g`ci[\]b[cZZXUadYbYXg_]b
V`cca]b[^UXY[fYYb k]`Xg]`_YbhYbXf]`g"
McifYaYaVYfmcifZUh\YfÁgZU]bhcbWYidcbUh]aY"GcaYh\]b[UVcih
XUb[Yf"GcaYh\]b[UVcihh\YkUhYfk\cUddYUfgUkcaUbVYZcfYmci"
G\YhU_Ygmcif\UbX UbXmcifbYkg_]bf]dYbga]Xb][\hj]c`Yh"MciUfY
h\Y[]f`k\cgYbYkhU]`a]a]WgUg]`jYfg`]W]b[fUncf"
,$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
2cg]\U!
=`5O\U@O^S
=\YUfcZaYbk\c`cjYh\YgYUWck"DU`Y!g_]bbYXaYb `cb[XY`]f]cig
idcbh\YVU`amgYU h\YmWfUk`Ug\cfY\ib[fm Yb[cf[YX"5hh\Yg][\hcZ
h\Ya g\YWf]Yg UbXh\Ymh\]b_h\]g]gUg]fYbgcb["
G\YWf]Yg UbX=UaWYfhU]bamgcb[XcYgbchfYgYaV`Y\Yfg"
,%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
2cg]\U"
H\YfY]gUaUbk\cgY[cXghY``\]ahchU_Yh\YcWYUbUg\]gWcbgcfh"7Uf!
f]YX]bh\YkcaVcZ\]g`UWeiYfYXdU`Ubei]b \YUff]jYgUh\]ggiaaYf
dU`UWY `UXYbk]h\accbghcbYUbXdYUf`"<]gg]`_gdibfcVYgcZVfcWUXY
`chigV`cggcaXfcdidcbh\YgUbX"<YYbhYfg\Yf"
5bX\YkU]hg":cfaUbm\cifg\YkU]hg"
=bhch\YXUkbh\YaUbkU]hg UbXcb`m\]g[cXg_bckk\Uh\YYldYWhg
hccWWif"5`cbYUbXg\]jYf]b[ \YWfUk`gUg\cfY/\YgkYUfg\]gUhhYbXUbhg
hcgYWfYWm"
,&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
2cg]\U#
= Ua h\Y XUi[\hYf cZ U kcaUb [Uh\Yf]b[ gYUkYYX dcXg" 5[U]bgh \Yf
\igVUbXÁg V]XX]b[ g\Y kUXYg hcc ZUf ]bhc h\Y VUm UbX U kUfa kUjY
hciW\Yg\YfVY``m"G\Yk]g\YgZcf]hhcWUfYgg\YfW\YY_"=bfYjYf]Y g\Y
W`cgYg\YfYmYg UbXh\YkUfakUjYdi``gUh\Yfg\ci`XYfg"G`ck`mg\Y
giVaYf[Yg \Yf gkc``Yb VcXm UbX h\]g ]g \ck am ach\YfÁg kcaV VY!
WcaYgh\YgYU"
,'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
H=ACH<MG7<5::9FH
BVSG]c\UEWR]e]T0O`QSZ]\O
)
S cWQWRS\]bS-h\Ya]b]ghYfUg_YX UbX9jYh\ci[\hcZaig]W fYaYa!
VYf]b[ `]ghYb]b[Zcfk]`h]b[bchYgcZgi]W]XY]bgb]ddYhgcZ\Yf`UhY
\igVUbXÁgjc]WY"
H\Y YjYb]b[ cZ h\Y b][\h h\Y hcc!aUbm d]``g X]X \]a ]b GhU[
k\cgY fYU` bUaY kUg GhUb Vih YjYfmVcXm \UX WU``YX \]a GhU[ Zcf Ug
`cb[UgUbmcbYWci`XfYaYaVYf`cc_YXbYjYf acfY VYUih]Zi` ]b ^igh
^YUbgUbXUJ!bYW_H \]gZYYhVUfY \]gWif`gkYhUbXgh]W_]b[hc\]gZcfY!
\YUXUbXW\YY_g"
<YÁXVYYbXf]b_]b[Zcf\cifg YjYb]bh\Yg\ckYfh\YmÁXhU_Ybhc!
[Yh\Yf \]gZcfY\YUXdfYggYXU[U]bghh\Yh]`YXkU``Ug\Ygk][[YXZfca\]g
@kYbVf}iUbXgUb[ \]gYmYgW`cgYX c`XX]gWc`cjYgcb[ghifbYXgi``Yb
Vm\]gg`ck h\fcUhmWfccb"
¾Bc \Y`YZhbcbchY ¿9jY`]YX UbXg\YVYWUaYUkUfYcZh\YVYUh
cZ\Yf\YUfh h\Yei]W_h\iad]b[WUig]b[\Yfg_]bhcgWfUhW\U[U]bghh\Y
gWfUdcZdUdYfZc`XYXUbXhiW_YXVYbYUh\\YfVfUghfUd"Cbh\YdUdYf ]b
]b_ZfcaU`YU_mVU``dc]bh kUg\Yf\igVUbXÁgkUmkUfXbYggk]h\kcfXg
\]g a]ggdY``]b[g \]g d]bW\YX dYbaUbg\]d U`` dccf`m Ufh]Wi`Uh]b[ \]g
gYa]!WUhW\mf]ZZcb¾[ccXVmY WfiY`kcf`X"¿
=bh\YmYUfg]bWYGhU[X]YX dYcd`YcZhYbUg_YX9jY]Zg\YÁXgYYb
g][bg" <UX h\YfY VYYb hYbXYbW]Yg UbX ]bW`]bUh]cbg36S\SdS`P`SObVSRO
e]`R OP]cb Wb g\YÁX gUm h\ci[\ ]b ZUWh gi]W]XY kUg U`` \YÁX gdc_Yb cZ
]b\]g`Ughacbh\gcZ`]ZY"=bh\Yei]YhYjYb]b[g h\Y]fHJ`cb[g]bWY
_]W_YX!]b 9`j]g ghm`Y \Y g_YhW\YX FiVY ;c`XVYf[!]Ub aYh\cXg cZ
XYUh\½]bhf]WUhY UbX dfYhhm dcfhfU]hg cZ gY`Z!XYghfiWh]cb ]bjc`j]b[
]hW\m!hf][[YfYXf]ÊYgUbXVihW\Yf_b]jYg Vfc_Yba]ffcfgUbXh\YfUd]X
V`UXYgcZY`YWhf]WZUbg"=b\]gUfhkcf_ mciWci`XcZZmcifgY`Zk]h\h\Y
XY`]WUhYÊ]W_cZUhcYh\UhgYhcZZdi``YmgUbXWc[g gYbhaUfV`Ygfc``]b[
h\fci[\d]dYg WUigYXZUiWYhghcXf]d!Xf]d!Xf]d ZUhU``mkY][\]b[Xckb
hYUWidg"
,(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
9jYÁga]b]ghYfkUgUkcaUbbiaVZfcah\YkU]ghXckb"<YfYjYfm
gYfacb]bWcfdcfUhYXUfYhY``]b[cZ\YfUWW]XYbh YUW\GibXUmacfb]b[
UVfc_YbfYWcfXcZ7T7ÂR]\ZgbVWaUbX7T7ÂR]\ZgbVOb h\UhhifbYXdYcd`YcZZ
UbX`YZh\Yfk]h\cb`mUa]bcfWcb[fY[Uh]cb"6ih9jYkcfg\]ddYXFYj"
?b]ddÁg dYfg]ghYbh fY[fYh½h\Y fYjYfYbX kUg XYjchYX hc U _]bX cZ ]b!
ghfiWh]cbh\UhWci`XhU_YmYUfghcUfh]Wi`UhY"
FYj" ?b]ddÁg ]adfUWh]WU` UbX Ubh]eiY k\YY`W\U]f \UX U gYUh UbX
VUW_cZk]W_Yfk]h\hcfbWUb]b[UbX\Yf\UbXgkYfY\YUjm!`UXYbk]h\
j]bhU[Yf]b[g"CbYacfV]XcbYhfUddYXUh]bmgd]XYf]bUaVYf!Wc`cfYX
fYg]b"Bc b`O^^SRkUgbÁhf][\h []`PWRkUgbÁhf][\h Zcfh\Ygd]XYfÁgk]gdm
`Y[g ]hgk\c`YZfU[]`YVcXmkUgg\cW_]b[`mibVfc_Yb"H\Uhgd]XYf\UXU
hcaVkcfh\mcZUaiaameiYYb"
=h kUg h\Y Ubb]jYfgUfm cZ h\Y XUm cZ GhU[Ág XYUh\ cbY Zi`` `cbY`m
mYUf[cbY Vih9jY\UXbYjYfaYbh]cbYX]h]bW\ifW\VYZcfY \UXbYjYf
fYeiYghYX Ubm gdYW]U` dfUmYfg" FYj" ?b]dd WcbXiWhYX gYfj]WYg ]b k\Uh
\UXcbWYVYYb6UfWY`cbUÁgacj]Yh\YUhYfcbh\YhckbgeiUfYVYZcfYh\Y
ZUWhcfmW`cgYX VYZcfYdYcd`Y`YZh]bXfcjYg UbXh\YghfYYhgZY``XYUX`m
ei]Yh gk]Zh`m UggiXXYb`mUg]bUncaV]YÊ]W_"
¾5bX\ck]gh\Uh\YUfhcZmcifg3¿Ug_YXFYj"?b]dd"¾Gh]hW\]b[id3
Gh]`` Vfc_Yb3¿ H\Y Ybh]fY Wcb[fY[Uh]cb UVcih gYjYb dYcd`Y gUh ]b h\Y
ZfcbhfckcZh\Yh\YUhYf"FYj"?b]dddig\YX\YfgY`ZZcfkUfX WfYYd]b[
U\YUXWfcc_YX`m]b\YfWf]dd`YXk\YY`W\U]f½]hgkUfdYX`YZhk\YY`kcV!
V`]b["8Ygd]hYh\YghUhYcZh\YfYghcZ\Yf k]h\\YfaUbmfighmf]b[gk]h\
YadhmgYhh]b[g FYj"?b]ddXfYggYX]bUdfcZYgg]cbU`hkYYXgi]h UbXU
V`cigYk]h\UfiZÊm `UWmWc``Uf]bhYfkcjYbk]h\Uf]VVcbUfcV]bÁg!Y[[
V`iY"G\YXU]`mhk]ghYX\Yf`cb[VfU]XgUhcd\Yf\YUX f]XX`]b[\Yf\U]f
k]h\VcVVmd]bgUbX]bWcbgd]WicigWcaVg aU_]b[ZcfUbY`Y[UbhW]b!
bUacbgk]f`"
¾=hÁgVYYbkcfgY ¿9jYgU]X"GhU[\UXhU`_YXU`chUVcihgi]W]XYYjYb
VYZcfY h\YmÁX aUff]YX Vih YUW\ XUm h\Uh \Y \UXbÁh _]``YX \]agY`Z h\Y
h\fYUh cZ ]h \UX gcZhYbYX hifbYX gYlm U`acgh" <]g hU`_ cZ gi]W]XY \UX
WcaYhcfYdfYgYbhbch\]b[acfYhc9jYh\Ubh\Yh\]b[h\UhaUXY\]a
]ffYg]gh]V`mVUXZcf\Yf"Gck\Yb\YÉbU``mX]X]h ]hkUgib]aU[]bUV`Y"
¾=cZhYbh\]b_amUWW]XYbhkUgU_]bXcZgi]W]XYUhhYadh ¿h\YFYj"
gU]X di``]b[UVcVVmd]bZfca\Yf`]dg`]_Yd]W_]b[cihUÉg\VcbY h\Ybg\Y
,)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
d]bbYXVUW_UWif`h\Uh\UXZU``Yb gkYYh`m9jYh\ci[\h hcibWc]`U`cb[
\YfW\YY_"¾=igYXhcXf]jYXfib_U``h\Yh]aY _bck]b[h\Uh=g\ci`XbÁh
U`kUmgkU_]b[]b\cffcfh\YbYlhacfb]b["=_bYkZi``kY``amUWW]XYbh
kUg]bYj]hUV`Y"5dfcd\YWmh\Uh=X]XbÁhXcgeiUhUVcih"¿H\YFYj"?b]dd
\UXVYYbcbh\Y]bhYfghUhY^ighUZhYfXUf_ h\YUihiabb][\hgh]``YUf`m
Vihg\YÁXU`fYUXmVYYbZU``]b[!XckbXfib_"G\YÁXhifbYXcZZcbhcUbYl]h
UbX\]hhkcfcUXkcf_YfgWUffm]b[g`ib[VYhkYYbh\Yah\YWUfWUggcZU
XYYfh\Uh\UXVYYb\]hYUf`]Yfh\Uhb][\h"H\YaYb\UXVYYbaU_]b[h\Y
fcUXgUZY ZfYYcZXUb[YfcigfcUX!_]`` ]bh\Y]fdfchYWh]jY!cfUb[Ygi]hg"
CbYcZh\YaYbX]YX/h\Ych\YfkUg]bUk\YY`W\U]fbck hcc"H\Y]fcbm
cZ]hU``gYYaYXhcgUjYFYj"?b]ddZfcaWcad`YhYXYgdU]f gYYaYXhc
\]bhUhUg]W_UbXX]j]bYgYbgYcZ\iacf"/[SO\a^W`WbSRU]RWaOU]R\]\SbVSZSaa
dfYUW\YXh\YFYj"?b]dd O\RPSbbS`_cWbSV]\SabZgbVO\\]bVW\U"
9jYÁg \U]f kUg gh]`` id ]b d]b_ UbX V`iY gYWcbX!\UbX Wif`Yfg h\Y
g]nYcZZfcnYb`YacbUXYWUbg \YfÉb[YfbU]`gUT`]abSRUW\US`P`SOR^Zc["<Yf
Zf]YbXCd\Y`]UXYaUbXYXh\Ym[ccihhc[Yh\Yf`UhYf ZcfghYU_gUbX[]b
aUfh]b]g hc_YYdh\Yb][\hZfcaZU``]b[]bhcihhYfV`UW_bYgg"H\ci[\9jY
kUbhYXcb`mhcgi`_U`cbYU``XUmUbXb][\h g\YZY`hgcffmZcfCd\Y`]U"
G]bWYh\YZUWhcfm\UXW`cgYX Cd\Y`]U\UXVYYb`]j]b[]bh\Yg`YYdYfcZU
gYa]g\YÁXXf]jYbZcfh\YWcadUbmUbXVci[\hZcfW\YUdUhUbUiWh]cb"
Cd\Y`]U\UXXcbYk\Uhg\YWci`XhcaU_Y]h\caYm dUgh]b[h\YkU``gcZ
h\Yg`YYdYfk]h\dU[YghcfbZfcahUV`c]Xg½U``d\chcgcZWY`YVf]h]Ygcih
k]h\cihaU_Yid"Cd\Y`]U\UXXiVVYX\Yfc`XXY`]jYfmfcihY¾H\Y8Y`i!
g]cbgcZ;fUbXYifHcif ¿Xf]j]b[Ugg\Y\UXh\fci[\a]b]gWi`YBYVfUg_U
hckbgk]h\\]ghcf]WU`bUaYgh\Ym\UXbÁhYUfbYX½7U]fc A]`Ub 7fYhY
;YbcU YjYbKUhYf`cc"
6Y[]bb]b[ aUmVY ]bh\Y%-'$gh\YhckbÁgZUWhcfmW\ifbYXcihU
d]b_ WcWcbih WUbXm Zinnm!`cc_]b[ `]_Y U VYXfcca g`]ddYf" H\Y WUbXm
\UXgcaY\ckVYWcaYdcdi`UfUgUAch\YfÁg8UmgkYYh gc`X]bWc``YWh!
]V`Y[c`X!Zc]`h]bg"H\YWcadUbmkYbh_UdihUZhYfUZYkVchi`]ga!`UWYX
VUhW\YgaUXYh\Y]fkUmhcghcfYWcibhYfg _]``]b[Uh`YUghZcifhYYbUWfcgg
h\YWcibhfm"H\YfYÁXVYYbbcgUj]b[h\YWcadUbmÁgfYdihUh]cb"H\YW\]`!
XfYbcZh\Yach\Yfg YjYbh\Y[fckbcbYg kci`XbchVYWcbgc`YX"
FYj"?b]ddYbXYXh\YgYfj]WYk]h\UfUaV`]b[dfUmYf Vihbckh\Uh
9jY\UXÉbU``mgdc_Yb g\YkUbhYXhcgdYU_acfYUbXacfY"G\YbYYXYX
,*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
h\Y Wcb[fY[Uh]cb hc _bck h\Uh g\Y Wci`X bYjYf \UjY _bckb Ubmh\]b[
XYgd]hYh\Y\ibXfYXgUbX\ibXfYXgcZkUfb]b[g][bg"CbWY g\YkUbhYX
hchY``h\Ya \]gUddYbX]lVifgh UbX\YkUg[Ybi]bY`mhYff]ÉYXVmh\Y
dU]bcZ]h"GhU[jYfmaiW\ZYUfYXXYUh\ g\YkUbhYXhchY``h\Ya"K\Yb
\YWUaYh\fci[\]h 9jYWf]YXUbX`Ui[\YXUbXhU`_YXhccaiW\]bh\Y
\cgd]hU`fcca"¾K\cdihUb]W_Y`]bmci3¿\YÁXgU]Xk]h\Uk]b_ \]gYmYg
U``kYh"
5aUbk\ckfchYdcYhfmZc``ckYX\YfUZhYfh\YgYfj]WY hc\Yf`]!
eicfghcfY k\]W\g\YWci`XbÁhcdYb Vm`Uk ibh]`UZhYfbccb"CbYdcYa
h\Uh\YÁXcbWYfYUX]bW\ifW\\UXVYYbUVcihUdUW_cZaUb[`YXXc[gh\Uh
YgWUdYXUVUgYaYbhk\YfYh\YmÁXVYYbd]hhYXU[U]bghYUW\ch\Yf]bÉ[\hg"
H\YXc[gXYjcifYXh\Yh\fcUhgcZh\Y]faUghYfgUbXYgWUdYXhckUbXYf
mck`]b[h\fci[\h\YgUbX\]``g U``h\YaihhgZUfhcci[`mhcVYhU_Yb]bVm
UbmcbYY`gY"6ih\YÁXkf]hhYbgcaYb]WYdcYaghcc dfYhhmcbYg `]_YcbY
UVcihUkcaUbdYY`]b[UbcfUb[Y]bh\Yk]bhYfh]aY h\Y^i]WYgh]b[]b[
h\YWfUW_g]bh\YXfmg_]bcZ\Yf\UbXg"=bUbch\YfdcYa UkcaUbkYUfg
UV`UW_jY`jYhXfYggcb7\f]ghaUg8Um h\YZfcbhcZ]hgdYW_`YXk]h\h\Y
dckXYfYXgi[Ufh\Uh\UXZU``YbZfcah\YAYl]WUbhYUWU_Yg\YV]h]bhc"
¾=WUbÁhgY``Ubmh\]b[mYh ¿9jYhc`X\]aUgg\Yib`cW_YXh\YZfcbh
Xccf"¾=hÁgcb`m%%.'$"¿
¾K\cÁgUg_]b[hcVim3¿\YgU]X ga]`]b["<YghiW_\]g\UbXgVcm]g\!
`m]bh\YZfcbhdcW_YhgcZ\]gVU[[md`U]XdUbhg UbXg`iadYX\]gg\ci`!
XYfg UbX`cc_YXXckbUhh\YhcYg\Yk][[`YX]b\]gÊ]d!Êcdg"¾MciWci`X
]bj]hYaYhc^c]bmci]bU[`UggcZj]bc"Mcig\ci`XbÁhVYU`cbYcbUXUm
`]_YhcXUm"¿<YkcfYUbc`XZYXcfUmciÁXWU``^Uibhm"
¾=kcbÁhVYU`cbY ¿g\YgU]X"G\YÊ]W_YXUÉb[YfU[U]bghUWif`Yf"
¾AmZf]YbX]ghU_]b[aYcihZcfghYU_ghcb][\h"KYÁfY[Yhh]b[U``Xc``YX
id"¿G\Y\Y`XVch\\UbXgidhc\YfYmYgUbXk][[`YX\YfÉb[Yfg"¾:U_Y
YmY`Ug\YgUbXYjYfmh\]b["¿
¾6ihmcifUZhYfbccbWci`XVYhYff]V`YUbX`cb[ ¿\YgU]X ga]`]b[
U[U]b gei]bh]b[Zfcah\Y`]hh`YV]hcZgib"
,+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
¾MciÁfY`]_YcbYcZmcifmck`]b[aihhg ¿g\YgU]X VYWUigY g\Y^igh
bckfYU`]nYX h\YXc[É[\hXc[gkYfYaYhUd\cfgZcfh\]gk\c`YhckbcZ
jU[fUbhg"
9jY\UX\UXcb`mcbYch\YfWcbjYfgUh]cbk]h\h\YdcYhcihg]XYcZ
W\ifW\ UZYkkYY_gVYZcfY Vch\g]hh]b[Vm\UddYbghUbWYUhh\YX]bYf
WcibhYf\Uj]b[WcZZYYUbXY[[gUhh\fYY]bh\YUZhYfbccb"G\YZY`h^YU`!
cigcZh\YVYUihmcZh\YkcaYb]b\]gdcYag gcg\Yhc`X\]agcaYh\]b[
g\Y\U`ZkUmkUbhYX\]ahcghYU`Zfca\Yf`]ZY"G\YÁXVYYbVcfbk]h\U
W`YZhdU`UhY UbXk\Ybg\YkUgU`]hh`Y[]f`h\YmÉlYX]h ibÊUhhYb]b[\Yf
ZUWYVmdihh]b[Ug\Uj]b[Zfca\Yf\]dVcbYVY\]bX\Yf`]d"H\Ygif[Yfm
`YZhUacgh`mibbch]WYUV`YgWUf Vihk\YbaYb_]ggYX\Yf g\Yhc`X\]a
g\YWci`XZYY`h\Yakcffm]b[h\YgWUfk]h\h\Y]fhcb[iYg h\Y]fhcb[iYg
fYhifb]b[hc]hU[U]bUbXU[U]bXif]b[h\Y_]ggYg `]_Yk\YbmciÁfYU_]X
UbXmci_YYdhciW\]b[h\Yh]dcZmcifhcb[iYhch\Y\c`Yk\YfYUhcch\
igYXhcVY"
9jYX]XbÁhVY`]YjY]b[\cghg VihCd\Y`]UVY`]YjYX]bbch\]b[Vih"
¾5``h\cgYkY]fXYaU]`gUdYfgcb[Yhg ¿Cd\Y`]UgU]X Xcig]b[\YfghYU_
k]h\_YhW\id"¾Bchh\YUXgZcf7UbUX]UbdfYgWf]dh]cbgUbXZcfV][X]W_g
UbXV][h]hh]Yg Vihh\YcbYgh\UhmcicdYbidUbXh\YmXcbÁhkUbhmcihc
VimUbmh\]b[cfXcUbmh\]b[UhU``"H\YmÁfY`]_YfUbXcakcfXg gYbhYbWYg
]b kY]fX cfXYf" @]_Y [cVV`YXm[cc_ Vih bch ei]hY" H\Ym U`acgh aU_Y
gYbgY"=XcbÁh_bck"=^igh_bckh\UhbcbYcZigUfYfYU``m\YfY"¿
GhU[\UXkcf_YXXUmgUhh\Ybifg]b[\caYUbXkci`XWcaY\caY
Uhb][\hk]h\fYg]XYbhgÁbUaYgZcf\]gUW\YgUbX]b^if]Yg"¾Gcd\]YFcV!
]bgcb ¿\YÁXgUm dc]bh]b[Uh\]gVia_bYY"Cf ¾AY`VUDU[Y ¿fiVV]b[\]g
Y`Vck"H\YWf]W_]b\]gg\ci`XYfkUgAf"6U]`Ym"H\YghUV]bh\YgaU``cZ
\]gVUW_kUgAUfmY``Yb6ccbY"H\Ybifg]b[\caYÁgYei]daYbhZcf`]Zh!
]b[dYcd`YXckbZfcah\Y]f\][\\cgd]hU`VYXgUbXidZfcah\Y]f`ck
VUh\hiVg aUW\]bYfmaYUbhhcgUjYh\Ymcib[kcf_YfgZfca[fck]b[c`X
hccgccb kUgZUi`hmUbXibfY`]UV`YUbXgcaYh]aYghcc_hccaiW\aig!
W`YhccdYfUhY"GcGhU[`]ZhYXUbXdi``YXcb\]gckb UbX\YÁXZYY`YUW\
,,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
dU]bh\YgYWcbX]hZcibX]hgd`UWY]b\]gVcXm"GcaYcZ\]g`]b[Yf]b[UW\Yg
kYfYbUaYXUZhYfdYcd`Yk\cÁX`cb[g]bWYX]YX"A]bVObÂaa][SbVW\UZWYSVOdW\U
UV]aba`WUVb-9jYgi[[YghYXhcCd\Y`]U"
Cd\Y`]UbY]h\YfU[fYYXbcfX]gU[fYYX"G\YcfXYfYXUbch\YfaUf!
h]b] k]h\ V`Yi!W\YYgY!ghiZZYX c`]jYg" ¾5h gcaY dc]bh mciÁ`` fYU`]nY h\Uh
GhU[ÁgVYYbk]h\mciU``U`cb[ ¿g\YgU]X"¾GcaYh\]b[h\UhXcYgbÁhgYYa
cXXf][\hbck mciÁ``fYU`]nY\UgVYYbcXXZcfacbh\g"AUmVYUbYW_`UWY
h\UhÁgbYjYf]bh\Y^YkY`fmVclk\YfY]hÁggiddcgYXhcVY"AUmVYUW`cW_
]bmcif\cigYaU_YgUZibbm_]bXcZh]W_"5gmcif[f]YZZUXYgacfYUbX
acfY mciÁ``VYcdYbhcbch]W]b[h\YgY_]bXgcZh\]b[g"=ha][\hVYUfY!
ÊYWh]cb]bUk]bXck cfh\YgaY``cZWc`c[bYa]lYXk]h\W][UfYhhYgac_Y
UbXV`UW_`]Wcf]WYUbX =XcbÁh_bck bYkgdUdYf]b_cfgcaYh\]b[ Ua]l
cZZUa]`]UfgaY``gh\UhÁggiXXYb`m]bh\YU]f Zcf^ighUgYWcbX k\Ybmci
hifbmcif\YUX"Mcif]aU[]bUh]cbk]``ÉbX\]a"¿
Cd\Y`]U `]ZhYX \Yf aUfh]b] [`Ugg ]b U hcUgh hc GhU[" ¾9jY Xc mci
a]bX]Z=gUmh\Uh=a]ggGhU[hcc3A]gg\]agcaYh\]b[hYff]V`Y38c=
[YhhcgUmh\Uh3¿
¾Cb`m]Zmci[]jYaYmcifc`]jYg ¿9jYgU]X kUbh]b[hcW\YYfCd\!
Y`]Uid"
6UW_]b\YfUdUfhaYbhUVcjYh\Y`]eicfghcfY`UhYfh\Uhb][\h 9jY
Wci`X\YUfaig]W]bh\YhYU_Yhh`YUgh\YVc]`]b[kUhYfWcc`YXUbXh\Y
ghYUa`]ZhYXZfcah\Ygdcih h\YViVV`YgcZh\YkUhYfUbXh\Yh]b[cZh\Y
aYhU`cZh\YdchWcaV]b]b[hcgcibX`]_YUgcb[cbUfUX]c]bUbch\Yf
fcca"=hkci`XbÁhVYib`]_YGhU[Zcf\]g[\cghhcd`Umaig]W]bUbc`X
_Yhh`Y 9jYh\ci[\h"G\Yhcc_\YfWidcZb][\hh]aYW\Uaca]`YUbXgUhUh
\YfjUb]hmhcf]ZÊYh\fci[\\Yf^YkY`fm `cc_]b[ZcfU``h\Yd]YWYgGhU[\UX
[]jYb\YfcjYfh\YmYUfg"H\YmkYfY`]_Y[]Zhgh\UhUVcmkci`X[]jY\]g
ach\Yf½YUff]b[gg\UdYX`]_Y`UXmVi[g UaccXf]b[ UbYW_`UWYk]h\U
h]bm hibY`Yggg]`jYfk\]gh`YXUb[`]b[Zfcah\YYbXcZ]h"9jYYjYb_Ydh\Yf
^YkY`fm]bUbc`XAch\YfÁg8UmWUbXmh]b UZUWhcfmfY`]Wh\Uhg\YkUgbÁh
gifY \ck g\YÁX WcaY hc \UjY" =h gU]X ¾Aca¿ ]b gdUf_`m difd`Y Wifg]jY
UWfcggh\Yhcd"9jY\UXbYjYf`]_YXWcWcbih"
H\Y ZUWhcfmÁg Ach\YfÁg 8Um h]bg \UX hfUX]h]cbU``m VYYb gc`X
kfUddYX UfcibX k]h\ U k\]hY f]VVcb ¾AUXY k]h\ `cjY ]b 6UfWY`cbU
BYVfUg_U ¿kf]hhYbUWfcgg]h"H\Uhg]ad`Yf]VVcbaUXYh\Y[]ZhUVY`cjYX
,-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
\c`]XUm ]Wcb U W\Ufa]b[ bcjY`hm k\Uh WUbXm Wcfb kUg hc <U``ckYYb
k\UhDYYdgkYfYhc9UghYf"
9jYWf]YXZcfh\YÉfghh]aYcbh\]ggUXUbb]jYfgUfm W`cgYhca]X!
b][\h bchZfcah\ci[\hgcZGhU[UhU`` VihfUh\YfZfcah\ci[\hgcZ\Yf
ach\Yf gh]``jYfmaiW\U`]jY":c``ck]b[h\Ygif[YfmZcf9jYÁgW`YZhdU`!
UhY h]bmd]YWYgcZ\Yf\]dVcbYkcf_YXZfYYcbhc\Yfhcb[iY"H\YVcbY
W\]dgg\Yd]W_YXZfca\Yfacih\`cc_YXUbXZY`h`]_YWcfU` dcW_YXUbX
fci[\"G\YÁXVYYb]bh\YZcifh\[fUXY UbX\UX`cjYX\ckh\YÊcUh]b[
VcbYgdYW_gaUXY\YfghfUb[Y fYa]bXYX\YfcZ¾HcUXgUbX8]UacbXg ¿
h\YZU]fmhU`YUVcihhkcg]ghYfg.gbU_YgUbXdc``mkc[gZY``Zfcah\Y`]dg
cZ cbY k\Yb g\Y gdc_Y/ dYUf`g UbX fcgYViXg ZY`` Zfca h\Y `]dg cZ h\Y
ch\Yf"
6ihh\Yb]hgYYaYXh\YVcbYkci`XbYjYfghcdVfYU_]b[UdUfh UbX
g\YkcbXYfYXk\ckci`X`cjY\Yfk\Ybg\YkUgc`XYf k\ckci`XkUbh
hc_]gg\Yf3K\ckci`XkUbhhchUghY hcf]g_gkU``ck]b[ ZfU[aYbhgcZ
\Yfg_Y`Yhcb3
¾MciÁ``hY``h\YamciÁfYUaYfaU]X ¿9jYÁgach\Yfhc`X\Yf aUhhYf!
cZ!ZUWh`m"¾McifZUh\YffYgWiYXmciZfcah\YgYU UbXmci[fYk`Y[g"6ih
h\YkUjYggh]```]ZhUbXZU``]bg]XYmci"H\Yh]XYgh]``VYUhgU[U]bghmcif
`ib[gUbXmcif\YUfh"6fc_Ybg\Y``ggh]``kUg\idcbmcifhcb[iY"¿
6mh\Yh]aYg\YkUg]bh\YÉZh\[fUXY h\YVcbYghcddYXW\]dd]b[
UkUm"GhU[igYXhcgUm\YÁXk]g\YX\YÁX_bckb\Yfh\Yb k\Ybh\YcWYUb
hcggYXUbXhifbYX]bg]XY\YfaYfaU]Xgci`"¾8]XmcikYUfU`]hh`YghUf!
Ég\VfU3¿\YÁXgU]XUgh\Ym`Um]bVYXcbUGibXUmUZhYfbccb"<Y[Ybh`m
`]ZhYX\YfH!g\]fhUgg\Y[][[`YX UbX\Y`]W_YX\Yfb]dd`Y h\Yb_]ggYX\]g
kUmXckbhc\YfVY``mVihhcb"¾8]Xmcikf]hY`cjY`YhhYfg]bgei]X]b_3¿
:cfh\YÉfghh]aYg]bWYGhU[ÁgXYUh\ 9jYWci`XfYaYaVYf YlUWh`m
h\YZYY`cZ\]gVfYUh\cb\YfbU_YXg_]b h\YgcZh \chdiZZcZ]h h\YgaY``
cZ]h cZjUb]``U!gWYbhYXhcch\dUghYUbXh\YcfUb[Y!ÊUjcfYX`]eiYif9jY
gc`X]bh]bmVchh`YgUhh\YWUg\fY[]ghYf"6ih9jYX]XbchVY`]YjYCd\Y`]U"
H\YgYkYfYbchh\Yg][bgcZh\YdfYgYbWYcZU[\cghVihfUh\YfgcaYh\]b[
aiW\acfYkY`WcaY"H\]gkUgg]ad`m`iW]X]hm k\]W\g\Yh\ci[\hg\Y
`cghk\Ybg\Y`cghGhU["
¾Afg"5g\Vm ¿h\YdcYhWU``YXZfcaVYbYUh\\Yfk]bXck"¾C\ Afg"
5g\Vm"¿
-$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
9jY kU`_YX hc h\Y k]bXck k]h\ \Yf Wid cZ hYU" ¾;c UkUm ¿ g\Y
WU``YXVUW_"¾;c\caY"7fUk`]bhcVYX"G`YYd"H\YghcfYÁgW`cgYX"¿9jY
\UX ghUmYX idghU]fg U`` UZhYfbccb X]ghfUWh]b[ \YfgY`Z k]h\ BVS 0Sbag U
bcjY`g\YÁXd`iW_YXZfcah\Y`cgh!UbX!ZcibXUhh\Y`UibXfcaUh"DYcd`Y
WU``YXidhc\Yfk]bXckU``XUm`cb[ VUb[YXcbh\Y`]eicfghcfYXccf
UbXg`]ddYXbchYgVYbYUh\]hk]h\if[YbhfYeiYghg"BcbYcZh\YakYfY
WcbWYfbYXUVcih9jYcbh\]gUbb]jYfgUfm"H\YmkUbhYX\YfhcWU``h\Ya
cfaU_YUXY`]jYfm"H\YmWf]YXUbXWf]YXZcfh\Y]fVchh`Yg"
GhU[igYXhc^c_Yh\Uh\YUbXg\YkYfY]bh\Ycb`m[fckh\]bXig!
hf]Yg]bh\Yhckb.h\Ybifg]b[\caYf]XX`YXk]h\ h\Y Y`XYf`m k\c \UX
bck\YfYY`gYhc[c/h\Y`]eicfghcfY`]_YUaYX]W]bYW\Ygh"
¾7Vfci[\hg]cUXf]b_ ¿h\YdcYhgU]X"<Y\Y`XidUgeiUfY!WcfbYfYX
Vchh`YcZgcaYh\]b[\caY!VfYkYX"
¾K\YfYUfYkY[c]b[3¿9jYUg_YX dfcVUV`m`UhYfh\Ubg\Yg\ci`X
\UjY g\YfYU`]nYX"<YXfcjY\]gfYXWcbjYfh]V`Y hcdXckb ZUfdUghh\Y
hckbÁgcihYf`]a]hgUbXcbhc[fUjY`fcUX"9jYX]XbÁh_bckaiW\UVcih
h\Y dcYh Wci`X bYjYf fYaYaVYf \]g bUaY" G\YÁX Éfgh gYYb \]a U ZYk
acbh\gU[c YUf`mgiaaYf UhUXiaVWUfb]jU`cbh\YWcifh\cigY`Ukb
h\Y aUmcfÁg ZYYV`Y YZZcfh hc Vccgh acfU`Y k]h\ fYbhYX [UaYg. U k\YY`
cZZcfhibY Uf]b[hcgg Udcd[ibg\cch]b[fUb[Y"H\YdcYh ]bUVckh]Y
aUbbYXh\YhYghcZghfYb[h\ VihZYkcZh\YhckbÁgaYb\UXUbm]bhYf!
Ygh]bXYacbghfUh]b[\ckkYU_ \ckXYd`YhYX h\YmÁX[fckb"Cb`mh\Y
mcib[ h\i[g k\cÁX VYYb hU_]b[ UXjUbhU[Y cZ h\Y hckbÁg VUX `iW_ Vm
Vi]`X]b[Xfi[`UVg]bh\YVUgYaYbhgcZYadhm\cigYgUbXg\cch]b[cih
h\Yk]bXckgcZdUf_YXWUfgZcfZib cb`mh\Ymkci`XUWWYdhh\YaU``Yh"
H\Y]fgWfUkbm^ib_!g\chUfagWci`X^ighgYbXh\YdiW_idUZYkZYYh Vih
h\UhX]XbÁh_YYdh\YaZfca`Ui[\]b[h\Y]fUggYgcZZk]h\gWcfb"
9jY\UXfibUVcch\Uhh\YWUfb]jU`gY``]b[kUhYfaY`cbaUf[Uf]hUg"
G\YX]XbÁhfYU``mbch]WYh\YdcYhibh]``UhYYjYb]b[WUaY UbXh\YgaU``
WfckXg\fib_YjYbacfY"H\YdcYhUbXh\Ych\Yf`ck!fYbhWUfb]Yghcc_
hifbgUhh\Yghfcb[aUbgWU`Y WihY`mhfm]b[hccihXcYUW\ch\Yf Vihcb`m
-%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
UZYkcZh\YaaUbU[]b[hcW`Ub[h\YVY``"
H\YdcYhX]XbÁhhY``\Yfk\YfY\YkUghU_]b[\Yf"¾MciÁ``gYY]bU
a]bihY ¿\YgU]X"¾MciÁ``gYY"=hÁg[c]b[hcgUjYYjYfmVcXmÁg`]ZY"¿
¾=ÁjYVYYbkUbh]b[hcUg_mci.5fYh\YdYcd`Y]bmcifdcYagfYU`
dYcd`Y3¿9jYUg_YX"
¾MYU\ ¿h\YdcYhgU]X"¾GcaY"DYcd`Y=ÁjYgYYbUfcibX"DYcd`Y=ÁjY
WUi[\h[`]adgYgcZ\YfYUbXh\YfY"¿
9jY h\ci[\h \ck X]gUddc]bh]b[ ]h kci`X VY hc VY U kcaUb ]b U
dcYaUbXhcbYjYf_bck]h hcbYjYffYUX]h"
H\YdcYhghcddYXh\YWUfcbUcbY!WUfWcibhfmVf]X[Y"K\Yb\Y
hifbYXcZZh\YYb[]bY 9jY\YUfXh\YkUhYffc``]b[`][\h`mcjYfh\YfcW_g
VYbYUh\h\YaUbXUV]fXk]h\\YUjmk]b[ggYhh`]b[Uacb[h\Y`YUjYgcZ
UhfYY"
¾K\Uh]ZmciVfci[\haYcih\YfYhc_]``aY ¿9jYgU]X k]b_]b["
¾8]XbÁhUbmcbYYjYfhY``mcimcig\ci`XbÁhkUghYmcif`]ZYkcffm!
]b[UVcihh\Yk\Uh!]Zg3¿\YgU]X k]b_]b[VUW_"<Yhcc_Ugk][Zfca\]g
Vchh`Y h\Yb\UbXYX]hhc\YfZcfUXf]b_½UhUfhUdd`YW]XYfk]h\UÉYfWY
V]hYcZW`cjY"G\YgWfYkYXid\YfZUWYZfca]h ghiW_cih\Yfhcb[iY"
¾AUmVYmciÁ```YUfbhc`cjY]h ¿\YgU]X UbXghYddYXZfcah\YWUf"
¾6ihbckWcaYk]h\aY ¿\YgU]X"9jYZc``ckYX\]aVUW_hch\YYbXcZ
h\YVf]X[Y UbXXckbhch\YYX[YcZUWfYY_ UbUffck]b[jY]bcZUf]jYfU
a]`YcfgccZZ"¾Mci\UjYhcZcf[]jY\]a mci_bck3¿\YgU]X"5bX\YkUg
f][\h":cf[]jYbYggkUgk\UhkUg`YZh"6ih]hkUgbÁhibh]`h\]gUbb]jYfgUfm
h\Uhg\YWci`XgYYg][bgcZ\YfZcf[]jYbYgg^ighg`][\h`mU\YUX ZYY`]b[]h
`]_Yk\YbmciZYY`UbcfX]bUfmWc`XghUfh]b[hcfib]hgWcifgY"
<YfY]bh\YXYYdXUf_ g\Yh\ci[\hg\YWci`XZYY`U`]W_cZVfYUh\
cb\YfbYW_ \Yf]aU[]bUh]cbg`]dd]b[]bhcUbU[Y!c`XghcfmVcc_Ubl]Yhm
h\YgiaaYfk]bXVYWca]b[h\Yg`ckdUbh]b[cZdYWi`]Ufkc`jYgkU`_]b[
idf][\h cfh\YVfYUh\cZdcggiaXUb[`]b[Zfca`ck!\Ub[]b[VfUbW\Yg
Zfcah\cgYgbU_mhU]`g"
¾5gYUacbghYf ¿h\YdcYhgU]X Ug]ZdYY_]b[]bhc\YfVfU]bUbXgYY!
]b[\YfWfYUhifYgh\YfY"¾<UjYmci\YUfXUVcih]h3¿\YUg_YX"9jY`Ui[\YX
dc`]hY`m Vih\YX]XbÁh`Ui[\k]h\\Yf UbXg\Y`Ui[\YXacfY Uggia]b[
\YkUgcb`mZY][b]b[giW\[fUj]hm"¾H\YfY\UjYVYYbg][\h]b[g ¿\YgU]X"
¾H\YfYÁgYjYbUkYVg]hY"¿<Yhcc_Zfca\]gVUW_dcW_YhUdYb`][\hUbXU
-&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
df]bh!cihZYUhif]b[[fU]bm @cW\!BYggm]aU[YgcZgcaYZUV`YX ibg][\hYX
h\]b[`]Zh]b[k\Uha][\hVY]hgbYW_ VfYU_]b[h\YgifZUWYcZaccb`][\h
cbkUhYf"
¾Mci h\]b_ h\Uh acbghYf ]g \YfY3¿ 9jY Ug_YX" G\Y `cc_YX ]b h\Y
dcYhÁgZUWYZcfhYbXYfg][bgcZXfi[!UXX]WhXYWUm.YmYgÉlYXcbdU]bUbX
ZYUf VU[gVYbYUh\h\Ya"6ih\YkUgaYfY`mgYf]cig"
¾MciWci`XUZZcfXhcVY`]YjY]b]h ¿\YgU]X"
¾5bXmciXc3¿g\YUg_YX"
¾Bc ¿\YgU]X"¾MciWUbÁhVY`]YjY]bmcifckb]bjYbh]cb"¿<YVY[Ub
hckU`_UkUmZfca\Yf U`cb[g]XYh\YWfYY_ ghf]dd]b[\]gW`ch\YgcZZ"¾;Yh
bU_YXUbX\Y`daY ¿\YgU]X UbX9jYgh]``VinnYXYbci[\Zfca\YfaUf!
h]b]UZhYfaUfh]b]cZ^ighUb\cifcfgcU[c h\Uhh\YWcaaUbXgYYaYX
kcfh\mcZZc``ck]b["G\Y_]W_YXcZZ\Yfg\cYgUbXibn]ddYXh\YVUW_cZ
\YfXfYgg"G\Y_Ydhcbh\YaUhW\]b[VfUUbXdUbh]Ygg\YÁXVci[\hZfca
U g\cd WU``YX 5bhc]bYhhYÁg cZ CaU\U gd`YbX]X `UWm ibXYfh\]b[g g\YÁX
Vfci[\h\caY]bUdYddYfa]bh!ghf]dYXdUdYfVU["5gg\YkU`_YXhckUfX
h\YdcYh g\YZY`hGhU[Ággi]W]XYbchYgh]``hiW_YXVYbYUh\\YfVfUghfUd"
=hgWfUhW\YXU[U]bUh\Yfg_]b Ug]Zk]h\giXXYbW`UkgcZ]bg]ghYbWY"G\Y
hcc_]hZfca\YfVfUUbXfYhifbYXhck\YfYg\YÁX`YZh\YfXfYgg UbXg\Y
ghiW_h\YbchYZUf]bhch\YhcYcZ\Yfdiad hc_YYdgUZY\Yf`UhY\ig!
VUbXÁgZUacig`UghkcfXg"
5gh\YdcYhdi``YXUhVfUbW\YgUbXg\fiVVYfmWc``YWhYXU`cb[h\Y
VUb_cZh\YWfYY_ Ughf]dcZaccb`][\hg`]ddYXVYhkYYb`YUjYgUbX[`]g!
hYbYXcbh\YgkYUhcb\]gbU_YXVUW_"9jYÁgYmYgZc``ckYXUei]W_!acj]b[
Xfcdfc``]b[U`cb[h\YdcYhÁggd]bY ZU``]b[hch\Y`][\hdYUW\!ZinnmXckb
cZ\]gUgg"<YghccXgh]``h\Yb WcbWYbhfUh]b[cbgcaYh\]b[]bh\Yh\]W_Yh
UbXg\YghccXbYUfUh\]gVUW_ U`acghhciW\]b[\]a Vihbch acj]b[\Yf
Éb[YfgW`cgYhc\]gg_]b"3dS`a]QZ]aS Uga][\hVYkf]hhYb]bUbc`Xghcfm
gcaYh\]b[`]_Yk]h\dfYhhmaU]XghfUbgac[f]ÉYX]bhcg\Y!VYUghg"
H\YdcYhViadYX]bhc9jY VUW_]b[id hi[[]b[cihUWcbhfUdh]cb
h\Uh [fYk UbX [fYk VYZcfY 9jYÁg YmYg Ug ]h kUg kf][[`YX UbX kfYgh`YX
Zfca]hgbYgh]bh\YaiX"
¾HU_Yh\YW\U]b ¿h\YdcYhgU]X UbX9jY[fUVVYXh\YaYhU`Uhh\Y
a]XgYWh]cbcZh\YacbghYf UbXhc[Yh\Yfh\Ymig\YfYXh\YWc``YWh]cbcZ
XYhf]highch\YWYbhYfcZh\YWfYY_ hc]hgXYYdYghgdch hck\YfYh\YkUhYf
-'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
WUaYidhc9jYÁgkU]gh"Cih]bh\]gaU_Y!VY`]YjYgYU h\YaiXkUg\]b[
UkUmZfcah\YacbghYfÁgWYbh]dYXYVcXmcZc`Xh]fYgUbXh\]W_VfU]XgcZ
fcdY 9jYWci`XgYYh\YaUghYfmcZh\YdcYhÁgkcf_"Cbh\YacbghYfÁg
\YUX \Y`XidVmUVfc_YbVfccagh]W_ kUgUXfU[cbÁgZUWY`]_Yh\UhZfca
U_]hY]bU7\]bYgYdUfUXY"9mYgcZa]ffcfYX[`Ugg UaUbYcZg\U[WUfdYh
fYXh]bWc]`]b[Zfca`YUX!d]dYbcghf]`g`]_Yhk]ghgcZUb[fmÊUaY"
¾=WUbcb`m\cdYZcfgcaYcbYhcgYY]hZfcaUX]ghUbWY ¿\YgU]X"
¾5bX]h[YhghU`_YXUVcih UbXbUaYX UbXX]ga]ggYX UbX6UfWY`cbUVY!
WcaYgZUacigU[U]b"DYcd`Y`cjYU\cUl"5[ccX\cUlWci`XfYghcfYcif
ZU]h\ 9jY XcbÁhmcih\]b_3¿
¾=hÁgVYUih]Zi` ¿9jYgU]X ]bghUbh`mWUi[\hid]bh\YdcYhÁghUg_cZ
_YYd]b[h\YacbghYf UbXU``]hggY[aYbhg UVcjYkUhYf Ugh\YmWUff]YX
]hidghfYUa W`cgYfhck\YfYh\Yg`YYdmhfiW_YfgWfcggYXh\YWfYY_cbU
\][\kUmVf]X[Y"G\YgkUaVUW_UbXZcfh\ YbXhcYbX `]Zh]b[ ghYUXm]b[
\Yf`UnmaigW`YgUW\]b[ZfcaU``h\YbYkacjYaYbh"G\YZY`hh\Yg\Ufd
YX[YcZfighYX^ib_aYhU`WihUh\YfÊYg\ hYUfUh]h ZY`hUÉb[YfbU]`WfUW_
UbX\YfZibbmVcbYf]b[k]h\U\UfX_bcW_U[U]bghh\YacbghYfÁg`]jY`m
fiVVYfhU]`"G\YUbXh\YdcYhX]XbÁhgdYU_ VihmYhWcaaib]WUhYXh\Y]f
ghfi[[`Y]b[UgdgUbXhYff]V`Y[fcUbg UbX]Zbch\]b[Y`gY g\YZY`hVYhhYf
_bck]b[]hkUgbÁhYUgmZcf\]a Y]h\Yf"
-(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
?IFHG7<K=HH9FG
HfUbg`UhYXVm>UW_N]dYg
BVSAeW\SVS`RO\RbVS5`SOb7ZZcab`W]caE`WbS`
)
A gk]bY\YfXkUghYbX]b[\]gd][gUbXd`Um]b[\]gÊihYUhh\YgUaY
h]aY.¾HkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh"¿
5[fYUh ]``ighf]cigkf]hYfWUaYVmUbXUg_YX\]ak\Yh\Yf\YkUg
]bXYYX\Uddm"H\Ygk]bY\YfXcdYbYX\]gV`iYYmYgUbX`cc_YXUh\]aUg
h\ci[\\YkYfY[Un]b[XYYd]bhch\YgYU"H\Yb\Ygdc_Y.¾=Ua ]bXYYX
gYfYbYUbXU`gcWcbhYbh Vih=Áabch\Uddm"C\ ]Zcb`m=kYfYUZU]fm!hU`Y
df]bWY>ighh\]b_cZ\ckaUbmgk]bY\YfXgUfYW\]`XfYbcZfcmU`hm<ck
aUbm¿
5bX\Ydc]bhYXhc\]gV]V`Y]bk\]W\\Y\UXfYUXUVcihh\Ya UbX
k\]W\\YigYXUgUd]``ck"KY`` h\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYfkUggcacjYXVmh\Y
gk]bY\YfXh\Uh\Yhcc_\]aUbXgYh\]aPW[PO[f][\h]bhch\Ya]XX`YcZ
\]gaUghYfkcf_ \]gjYfmVYghZU]fmhU`Y"5bXh\YfY\YgUh h\Ygk]bY\YfX
k]h\\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYg UbX\YkUgUfYU`df]bWY h\Y[Ybi]bYgcbcZ
U_]b[ UbX\YhYbXYX\]gZUh\YfÁgd][gUbXd`UmYX\]gÊihYUhh\YgUaY
h]aY.¾HkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh hkYYh"¿
5bX h\Y ]``ighf]cig kf]hYf Ug_YX \]a k\Yh\Yf \Y kUg bck fYU``m
\Uddm"H\Ygk]bY\YfXdf]bWYcdYbYX\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYgUbX`cc_YX
Uh\]aUgh\ci[\\YkYfY[Un]b[XYYd]bhch\YgYUUbXgU]X.¾=Ua ]b!
XYYX gYfYbYUbXWcbhYbh Vih=Áabch\Uddm"C\ ]Zcb`m=\UXU`cjY`m
`]hh`YkcaUbk\cWci`XhYbXh\Yd][gUgb]WY`mUg=Xc">ighh\]b_cZ\ck
aUbmgk]bY\YfXg\UjYUhYbXYf `cjY`m`]hh`YkcaUb¿
H\Y ]``ighf]cig kf]hYf kUg [`UX h\Uh \Y \UX Ug_YX h\Y gk]bY\YfX
U\YUXcZh]aY Zcf\Ygh]``\UXbÁhÉb]g\YXh\YZU]fmhU`Y \]gaUghYfkcf_"
5bXPW[PO[\YfYhf]YjYXUhYbXYf `cjY`m`]hh`YkcaUbZfcagcaYk\YfY
]b\]g]aU[]bUh]cb UaU]XYbk]h\`cb[V`cbXYd][hU]`gUbXk]h\V`iYYmYg
UbXU`]hh`YfYXg_]fh"5aU]XYbk\cWci`XhYbXh\Yd][g^ighUgb]WY`mUg
h\Y gk]bY\YfX df]bWY" 5bX ]h X]X bch hU_Y `cb[ VYZcfY cif gk]bY\YfX
df]bWYZY``]b`cjYk]h\\YfUbXWci`XbÁhhU_Y\]gYmYgcZZ\Yf"=hkUgUg]Z
-)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
\Y[UnYXUhh\Ygib Zcfk\YfYjYf\Y`cc_YX \YgUk\Yfg`YbXYfÉ[ifY
h\YfYXg_]fh UbXh\Y`cb[V`cbXYd][hU]`g"
Gc h\Y ]``ighf]cig kf]hYf Ug_YX \]a k\Yh\Yf \Y kUg bck ]bXYYX
\Uddm"<ckYjYf h\Ygk]bY\YfXdf]bWYVY[UbVmgUm]b[.¾C\ am[fYUh
]``ighf]cigkf]hYf =kUggYfYbYUbXU`gcWcbhYbh YjYbh\ci[\=kUgbÁh
\Uddm"<ckYjYf bck=Uabc`cb[YfgYfYbYUbXXcbÁh\UjYUbmdYUWYcZ
a]bX"5gZcfVY]b[\Uddm½=ÁaWYfhU]b`mbch\Uddm¿
5bXgch\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYfUg_YX\]ak\Yh\Yf\Ykci`XdfYZYf
h\Uh\YfYacjYXh\YaU]XYbk]h\h\YfYXg_]fhUbXh\Y`cb[V`cbXYd][!
hU]`gZfca\]gaUghYfkcf_ h\YZU]fmhU`Y ]bk\]W\h\Ygk]bY\YfXkUgbck
`]j]b["<ckYjYf cifgk]bY\YfXdf]bWYcdYbYX\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYgUbX
[UnYXUhh\Y[fYUh ]``ighf]cigkf]hYf UbX\]gYmYgkYfYgckYh`]_YUgYU
k\]ddYXVmUk\]f`k]bX UbX\YgU]X ¾=Áabc`cb[YfgYfYbYUbXU`gcbc
`cb[YfWcbhYbh"<ckYjYf \Udd]bYggWUbYUg]`mWcaYZfcagiW\Umcib[
aU]XYb"Gc `YUjYaYVY=\UjYh]aY"=WUbkU]h"=Z=WUbYjYfVYWcaY
\Uddm am\Udd]bYggk]``XYdYbX^ighcbamVY]b[k]h\h\]gaU]XYb"¿
5bXcif]``ighf]cigkf]hYfdfca]gYXbchhcfYacjYh\Y`]hh`YaU]X!
YbZfca\]gaUghYfkcf_k]h\cihh\Ygk]bY\YfXÁgUddfcjU`"
5bX bck h\Y gibgYh VYWUaY gc fYX UbX h\Y gib [`]ghYbYX gc
Vf][\h`mUhb][\h UbXh\Yacfb]b[kUggcZi``cZXYkUbXZfYg\bYgg UbX
h\YZc[kUggck]ghZi`UbXVYUih]Zi``]_YUVf]XU`jY]` UbXh\YÉfgh_]gg
kUg`]_YUach\YfÁgV`Ygg]b[UbXkUggcgkYYhh\Uhh\YfY]gbchYbci[\
gi[UfhcXYgWf]VY]h"5bXbckh\Uhh\Ym\UX`YUfbYX\ckhcXc]h h\Ym
VY[Ub_]gg]b[YUW\ch\YfYjYfmhkccfh\fYYa]bihYg UbXh\YmWcbh]biYX
_]gg]b[YUW\ch\YfU``h\Yh]aYYlWYdhk\Ybh\Ym\UXhcYUhUbXXcgcaY
ch\YfbYWYggUfmh\]b[g"
CbWYU[U]bh\Y[fYUh]``ighf]cigkf]hYfUg_YXcifgk]bY\YfXdf]bWY
k\Yh\Yf\YkUg]bXYYXfYU``m\Uddm"=bfYgdcbgYh\Ygk]bY\YfXcdYbYX
\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYgUbXgU]X.¾<Uddm3½=kUg\UddmZcfUacaYbhUh
h\YÉfgh_]gg"Bck]hÁgcjYf UbXamgYfYb]hm]g[cbY UbX=bc`cb[Yf\UjY
UbmdYUWYcZa]bX"9jYfmh\]b[]g[cbY UbX=aighgcaY\ckfY[U]bam
\Udd]bYgg"=aighaU_Yh\Uh`cjY`maU]XYbamk]ZY"5ZhYfU`` acghcZh\Y
gk]bY\YfXgUfYaUff]YX¿
H\Ybh\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYfVYWUaYjYfmgYf]cig Zcf\YWci`XbÁh[]jY
h\Yg]ad`YdYUgUbhaU]XYbk]h\h\Y`]hh`YfYXg_]fhUbXh\Y`cb[V`cbXY
-*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
d][hU]`ghch\YgcbcZU_]b[ UbX\YgU]Xhch\Ygk]bY\YfXdf]bWYh\Uh
\Y\UXhcfYU`]nYh\Uh\YkUgbchU`ck`mUbXg]ad`Ygk]bY\YfX Vihh\Y
gcbcZU_]b[ UbX]hkUgbchUddfcdf]UhYZcfh\YgcbcZU_]b[hcaUffmU
g]ad`YdYUgUbhaU]XYb"K\Uhkci`Xh\Y_]b[ \]gZUh\Yf k\c[fUWYXh\]g
aUghYfZi`UbXVYUih]Zi`ZU]fmhU`Yk]h\\]gY`Y[UbhUddYUfUbWY gUm3K\Uh
kci`Xh\Yc`XX][b]ÉYXaUbgUm3H\Ybh\Ygk]bY\YfX[UnYXUh\]ak]h\
\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYgUbXgU]X.¾K\UhÁgh\YdifdcgYcZamVY]b[h\Y
gcbcZU_]b[3=\UXh\ci[\h=Wci`XaUffmk\caYjYf=kUbhYXhc UbX
bck=ÁabchYjYbgiddcgYXhcaUffmh\]g`cjY`m VYUih]Zi` UbXXY`][\hZi`
aU]XYb VYWUigYg\Y]ghcc`ck`mZcfaY"6ih=XcbÁhkUbhgcaYcbYY`gY
giddcgYX`mZfcaUVYhhYfW`Ugg"=XcbÁh`]_Yh\cgYgWUfYWfckg k\cgaY``
`]_Yj]c`YhgUbXÊUd`]_YÊU[g"@YhaYfYaU]bUg]ad`Ygk]bY\YfX"=ÁjY
\UX]hk]h\VY]b[h\YgcbcZU_]b["¿
H\Ybh\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYfVYWUaYjYfmgUXUbXgU]Xh\Uh\Y\UX
d`UWYXh\Ydccfgk]bY\YfX]bhc\]gaUghYfkcf_UgUZf]YbX`m[YghifYUbX
\UXfU]gYX\]aPW[PO[hch\YfUb_cZdf]bWY UbX\Y\UX[]jYb\]aU
aU]XYbUgU[]ZhZcf\]gUaigYaYbh UbXbckh\]gkUgh\YkUmh\Uhh\Y
gk]bY\YfXh\Ub_YX\]aVmkUbh]b[hcXYghfcmh\]gVYUih]Zi`ZU]fmhU`Y
h\]gaUghYfkcf_"¾GhiVVcfbai`Y¿\YmY``YXUhh\Ygk]bY\YfX"¾<ckWUb
=`Yhh\Y_]b[ mcif\cbcfUV`YZUh\YfVYWcaYUVY[[UfUhh\YYbXcZam
aUghYfkcf_ UbX fYXiWY \]a hc h\Y ZUh\Yf cZ U aYfY gk]bY\YfX3 <ck
WUb=^ighXcgcaYh\]b[`]_Yh\]g3=gbÁhh\YfYWcadcg]h]cbUbXhUWhUbX
f\mh\a]bamaUghYfkcf_ UbXg\ci`XbÁh=aU]bhU]bamkcf_^ighUg]h
]g3<ckkci`X=WcaYcZZUgU[fYUh ]``ighf]cigkf]hYf]Z=kYfYhcfYXiWY
h\Y[ccXc`X_]b[ mcif\cbcfUV`YZUh\Yf hcUVY[[UfUZhYf=gdYbhhkc
\ibXfYXdU[YgU``ck]b[\]ahcVY_]b[UbXh\YbgU]Xh\UhYjYfmh\]b[=
\UXkf]hhYbVYZcfY\UXVYYbUb]``ig]cb XYWYdh]cb UbXaYfYaYgg3>igh
VYWUigY]hkci`Xd`YUgYmci38cmcih\]b_h\Uh=ÁamcifgYfjUbh3=ÁXfi]b
amYbh]fYWUfYYfU``VYWUigYcZmcifghid]XdiVYgWYbh`cjY@YhaYhY``
mcigcaYh\]b[.mciWUbÁhaUffmh\UhkcaUb"G\Y]gbchUhU``VYÉhh]b[
cZmciffUb_"MciWUb`cjY\Yf VihmciaighaUffmgcaYcbYY`gYk\c
]gVYUih]Zi` gaY``g`]_Yj]c`Yhg UbXkYUfg[`cf]cigÊcUh]b[UbXf]dd`]b[
[ckbg"¿
Cif gk]bY\YfX k]h\XfYk gc XYYd`m ]bhc \]agY`Z UbX VYWUaY gc
gUXh\Uh\Y\UXhckYYdk]h\\]gVYUih]Zi`V`iYYmYgUbXgU]X.¾KY``h\Yb
-+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
fYacjYaYZfcamcifaUghYfkcf_ am[fYUh ]``ighf]cigkf]hYf"=Áacb`m
X]ghifV]b[]h"=ÁabchÉhhcVYh\YgcbcZU_]b["Gh]W_aY]bhcUa]bcf
kcf_ Vih`YhaYfYaU]bUgk]bY\YfX"¿
¾K\Uh[ccXk]``U``h\UhXc3¿h\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYffYgdcbXYX"¾=Z
mciUddYUf]bUa]bcfkcf_ mcigh]``kci`XbÁhVY\Uddm]b]h"=ÁjY`YUfbYX
U``h\]gZfcaU``h\YVUXYldYf]YbWYgh\Uh=ÁjY\UXk]h\mciVYWUigYmciÁjY
VYYbgcib[fUhYZi`"MciÁXcb`mXYghfcmh\Uhkcf_UgkY``"Gc =kcbÁhXc
]h¿
¾H\YbgYhaYZfYY ¿gU]Xh\Ygk]bY\YfX"¾@YhaY[ccZZ]bdYUWYUbX
gYbXaYVUW_hcamaYUXckk\YfY=WUbhYbXh\Yd][gckbYXVmam
aUghYfUg=kUgXc]b[VYZcfY UbX`YhaYhU_Yh\YaU]XYbk]h\h\Y`]hh`Y
fYXg_]fhk]h\aY"¿
¾=WUbÁhXch\]g ¿gU]Xh\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYf"¾=WUbWYfhU]b`m[]jYmci
VUW_mcif`]ZYUbX`Yhmci`YUjY]bdYUWY"<ckYjYf h\YaU]XYb]gbch\]b[
Viham]aU[]bUh]cb"=WUbÁh[]jY\Yfhcmci"G\Y]gbÁhYjYbU`]jY"K\Uh
kci`XmciXck]h\\Yf3G\YÁgcb`mUd]YWYcZdUdYf df]bhYXcbVch\g]XYg
k]h\kcfXgh\UhmciWUbÁhYjYbfYUX"¿
¾H\Yb gYh aY ZfYY ¿ gU]X h\Y gk]bY\YfX" ¾= aigh fYhifb hc am
aYUXck"¿
5bX PW[PO[ cif [fYUh ]``ighf]cig kf]hYf fYacjYX \]a Zfca \]g
aUghYfkcf_UbXfYhifbYX\]ahch\YaYUXckUbXh\YYlUWhd`UWY k\YfY
\Y\UXZcibX\]a"5bXbck\YUg_YX\]ak\Yh\Yf\Y\UXÉbU``mVYWcaY
\Uddm"H\Ybh\Ygk]bY\YfXgU]X.¾Am]``ighf]cigkf]hYf =ÁjYVYWcaYgY!
fYbY UbX U`gc WcbhYbh" H\fci[\ mci =ÁjY gYYb \Udd]bYgg" <ckYjYf =
XcbÁhkUbh]h"H\YfYÁg\Udd]bYgg Vih]hWcaYgUhh\YWcghcZamgYfYb]hm
UbXdYUWYcZa]bX"K\Uhg\ci`X=Xck]h\giW\\Udd]bYgg3C\ XcbÁh
Ug_aYk\Yh\Yf=Uabck\Uddm"=XcbÁhkUbhhcVY\Uddm"@YhaYU`cbY
k]h\amgYfYb]hm"@YhaYU`cbYk]h\amdYUWYcZa]bX"K\mXcbÁhmci
`]jY]bh\Y\Udd]bYggcZmcif]aU[]bUh]cb am[fYUh ]``ighf]cigkf]hYf3¿
¾Gk]bY\YfX ¿gU]Xh\Ykf]hYf ¾mciUfYk]gYfh\Ub=Ua"K\mg\ci`X
UaUbfibUZhYf\Udd]bYgg3H\YfYÁgbc\Udd]bYggh\Uh`Ughg`cb[Yfh\UbU
acaYbh";]jYaYgcaYcZmcifgYfYb]hm gcaYh\]b[ZfcamcifdYUWYcZ
a]bX UbX=kcbÁhkUbhhcVY\UddmUbmacfY"¿
Gch\Ygk]bY\YfXhcc_h\Y]``ighf]cigkf]hYfVm\]g\UbXUbX[UnYX
Uh\]ak]h\\]gV`iYYmYgUgh\ci[\\YkYfY`cc_]b[XYYd]bhcUgYUUbX
-,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
gU]X.¾7caY g]hXckbVYg]XYaY"KYÁ``hYbXh\Yd][g mciUbXaY"KYÁ``
YUh Xf]b_ g`YYd `Um]bh\Ygib UbXcifYbh]fYWcbWYfbk]``VYh\YkY`ZUfY
cZh\Yd][g"H\UhÁgbch\Udd]bYgg Vih]h]ggYfYb]hmUbXdYUWYcZa]bX"¿
--
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
?9@@=9K9@@G
@OPPWb1ObQVS`]T9W\UR][1][S
)
O bY giXXYb gdf]b[ k\Yb hfYYg UbX ÊckYfg VUaVccn`YX Vm
kUfah\ VY[UbViXX]b[]b>UbiUfm h\YdfYaUhifY`m\cb]YXU]f
ÊUh`mfYZig]b[hcW\]``U[U]bibh]``UhY8YWYaVYf h\YhckbcZ?]b[Xca
7caY ?UbgUg kUg VYgYh Vm U d`U[iY cZ V`UW_!hU]`YX ^UW_ fUVV]hg h\Uh
kYfYbchcb`maUbmVih^iaVc V][[Yfh\Ub[fYUhXUbYgh\YmkYfY [Uf!
UO\hiUbfUVV]hg gigd]W]cig`mkY``!ZYX g`UjYf]b[cjYfh\Yncmg]U d`iad
a]XX`Yg\YUj]b[ VUW_ZYYh`cb[UbXVfUkbmUgUgU]`cfÁgZcfYUfaUbXYUfg
mciWci`XZUbUZU]bh]b[df]bWYggk]h\"5bXbchUhU``h]a]X bYjYfXUfh]b[
ibXYfdf]jYhcfX]gUddYUf]b[VY\]bXZYbWYgUhh\Y`Ugha]bihY Vih[`Uf!
]b[hUibh]b[`mUhWUhgUbX\cVV`YXWfcbYg k\cah\YhckbZYUfYXkci`X
VYXfU[[YXUkUmhcUbibgdYU_UV`YYbX]bh\Yf]dUf]Ubh\]W_Yhgk\YbWY
h\YgYghfUdd]b[fUVV]hgai`h]d`]YX h\Y]fbiaVYfggYYa]b[hcXciV`YYUW\
kYY_"H\Ym`]W_YXh\Y]fdUkgUbXghfc_YXh\Y]fYUfgUbXk\]g_Yfgk\]`Y
`YjY`]b[UaYbUW]b[YmYUbX`YYf]b[hcch\]`mUhUbmdUggYfVmVc`XYbci[\
hc`cc_h\Ya]bh\Y]fÊYU!V]hhYbai[g"H\YmghccXidcbh\Y]fk\cdd]b[
\cddYfgUbXkU[[`YXh\Y]fYUfg Ugh\ci[\fYWY]j]b[UWcaaib]eiZfca
^UW_fUVV]h<E h\YU]fWfUW_`]b[k]h\Ub]aU`Y`YWhf]W]hm UbXh\Ybh\YmÁX
W\Uf[YUbY][\VcfÁgW\]\iU\iU h\Y^UjY`]bcZh\Y]fYUfgUhUXYhYfa]bYX
h]`h UbXh\Yfibhaihhkci`X`YUdk]h\Ug\f]Y_h\fci[\]hgXc[[mXccf"
H\Ym\cddYXXYÉUbh`m]bhcVigm]bhYfgYWh]cbg UbXghUh]cbkU[cbgUbX
d]W_!idhfiW_g UZfU]XUWc``]g]cbk]h\cbYcZh\YgYghifXm`U[cacfd\g
kci`XgifY`mWUigYh\Y]fjY\]W`YghcWfiad`Y`]_YVYYfWUbgU[U]bghUbcV!
XifUhYZcfY\YUX \]hcbYUbch\YfUbXfc``YX]bX]hW\Yg]bghYUX Wca]b[hc
fYghh]fYg!idUacb[h\YWUhhU]`g"5hb][\hh\YfUVV]hgXfiaaYXh\Y]fZYYh
gcf\mh\a]WU``mh\YYUfh\gYYaYXhc[fck`UbXh\Yg`YYd`YggW]h]nYbgcZ
?]b[Xca7caY`cW_YXUbXfY`cW_YXh\Y]fXccfgUbXk]bXckgibh]`h\Y
h\iad]b[WYUgYXUhgibf]gY"H\YhckbkUg]bUd]W_`Y \UXUV][!YUfYX
Wf]g]gcb]hg\UbXg ZUghai`h]d`m]b[dYgh]`YbWY Wchhcb!hU]`YXYd]ncch]W
UbX kY`` ]hZYUfYXZcf]hggUZYhmUbXgc`]hiXY"
%$$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
K\]W\]gk\mk\Ybh\YaUb]bh\YdUfh]!Wc`cfYXWcUhUddYUfYX
UbXW`U]aYX\YWci`X ZcfUbca]bU` cbY!h]aYZYY f]Xh\YhckbcZh\]g
bi]gUbWYZcfYjYf h\YXfckgmVif[\YfgZY``[fUhYZi``mUh\]gZYYh"
<Ydi``YXZfca\]gd]YXdcW_Yhh\Y`Uf[YghWUffchUbmcbY\UXYjYf
gYYb/YjYb:UfaYf6UiYf _bckbWcibhm!k]XYZcf\]gdf]nY!k]bb]b[Wi!
WiaVYfgh\Yg]nYcZ\cW_Ymgh]W_gUbXdchUhcYgh\UhZfYeiYbh`mfYgYaV`YX
dUghdfYg]XYbhg kUgU[c["5bXZfcah\]gWUffch h\YaUb]bh\YWc`cf!
Zi`WcUhk\]hh`YXUÉZY k\cgYaig]Wh\YhckbkUgXYUZhc h\ci[\Xc[g
\ck`YXUbXk\]adYfYXUbXg\]aa]YXibXYfgcZUgk\Yb\YV`Yk"
H\]gaUb `Yhig\YfYUZhYffYZYfhc\]aUg<YffDZY]ZZYf hYgh]b[h\Y
]ffYg]gh]V`Yd]hW\cZh\Yd]dY d`UmYXUWUgiU`hibYcbYb][\h ghfc``]b[]b
h\YibgYUgcbUV`YUbX[`]ghYf]b[kUfah\cZh\Yaccb`][\h UbXh\Yf]hiU`
fiaV`]b[kUgfYd`UWYXk]h\U\][\!d]hW\YX_YYb]b[h\UhWUigYXdYcd`Y
hcÉ``h\Y]f_]hW\Ybg]b_g Y^YWh]WYZfcaaYhU`hfUmg UbX]aaYfgYh\Y]f
h\fcVV]b[bccX`Yg]b]WYkUhYf"
H\Y bYlh XUm <Yff DZY]ZZYf VY[Ub hc g]`Ybh`m i`i`UhY ]b YUfbYgh
UbXh\Yk]`X!YmYXfUVV]hgkYfYhi[[YX hU]`Éfgh hckUfXk\YfY\YghccX
d]d]b[]bh\Y[UnYVc/UdmfUa]XcZfYgYbhZi`fUVV]hgVY[Ubhckf][[`Y]b
ZfcbhcZ\]a h\Y[fcibXgWUffYXk]h\W`UkaUf_gUgh\Ymhf]YXhcfYg]gh
h\YgcbcfcigaU[bYh]gacZ<YffDZY]ZZYfÁg6OaS\!gcb["H\]gVig\Y`cZ
V`UW_!hU]`YX^UW_fUVV]hgkf]h\YXUbX_]W_YX \YUdYX\][\Yfh\UbU\Um!
ghUW_ Vihk\Yb<YffDZY]ZZYf`ckYfYX\]gÉZY h\YmU``kYbh`]adUbX
VY[Ub ei]Yh`m hc gbcfY" H\Y dYcd`Y cZ ?]b[Xca 7caY Wci`XbÁh Vf]b[
h\YagY`jYghck]hbYggh\Yfiadigh\fci[\`cW_YXk]bXckgUbXg`]X]b[
[`UggXccfg Vihh\YmWUih]cig`mdUfhYXh\Y]fXfUdYgk\Ybh\YU]f[Ybh`m
h\ibXYfYXk]h\h\YgcibXcZg`YYd]b[fUVV]hg UkY`WcaYYgh]jUh]cbh\Ym
\cdYXkci`X`Ugh"
5ZhYfUkYY_ dYcd`YVY[UbhcYaYf[YZfcah\Y]f\cigYgUbXW\]`!
XfYbghc`YUkUmUhb][\hhcgYWfYh`mghfc_Yh\Yg]`_YbZYYhcZh\YfUVV]hg
Ugh\Ymg`iaVYfYX UbXcWWUg]cbU``mcbYkci`XgbcfhUbXhifbcb]hgg]XY
UbXVY`ck]hUbYUfcfUdUkkci`Xgh]fhc`]ZYUbXkUjYkYU_`m mY``ck
hYYh\W\cad]b[k]h\XfYUag UbXh\YW\]`XfYbkci`X[UgdUbXVUW_UkUm
ibh]`h\YacibXU[U]bgbiZÊYX]bib]gcb"GcaYfUVV]hgg`Ydhk]h\h\Y]f
YmYgcdYb UbXVYbYUh\UZi``accbh\Y]fYmYg\]bYaUXYh\YhckbV`ig\
VUh\YX]h]bUd]b_[`ckh\UhghiW_hch\Yg_]b WUig]b[UXc`YgWYbhVcmg
%$%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
ZYUfZi`cZh\Y\Y``h\YmÁX\UjYhcdUm]ZYjYfh\YmkYfYgdchhYXgdcfh]b[
[]f`m\iYg hcghUm]bXccfg"H\YmUhYh\Y]faYUhYlhfUkY``!XcbY bYjYf
a]bXh\Uh]hg\fUb_hcg\cY`YUh\Yf UbXh\YmbYjYf`Yhh\Y]fhcb[iYXUfh
Zfca]hgWUjY YjYbk\Yb8f"<]`XYVfUbXkU[[YXUXYdfYggcfUhh\Ya
UbXhc`Xh\YahccdYbk]XY"Bcd]b_bc\ck"
H\Y hckb WcibW]` aYh hc XYW]XY k\Uh kUg hc VY XcbY k]h\ h\]g
V][!Ug!U!VcUh!ZcchYXjYfa]bbck\mdbch]nYX]bUbibg][\h`m^iaV`YcZ
hU]`gUbXk\]g_YfgUbXYUfgUbXZYYh]bh\Ya]XX`YcZhckb"Kci`Xh\Y
fUVV]hgfYaU]b]bXYÉb]hY`mibXYf<YffDZY]ZZYfÁggdY``UbXgbcfYh\Ya!
gY`jYggYbgY`Ygg Xk]bX`YhcVcbY35bX\ck`cb[a][\hh\UhhU_Y35bX
kYfYh\YhckbgZc`_fYU``mcV`][YXhcdUmh\Yd]dYf3<Y\UXbÁh UZhYfU``
UWhiU``mYaUbW]dUhYXh\YhckbZfca]hghfUaaY`g bcg]fYYVcVWUh<YÁX
cb`mVYk]hW\YX]h]bhcibWcbgW]cigbYgg UbXk\c_bYk\ck`cb[h\Uh
kci`X\c`X3GifY`mh\Y\mdbch]nYXfUVV]hgkci`XgccbfcigYZfcah\Y]f
ghidcf dYf\UdgaUXk]h\UfUjYbcig\ib[Yf UbXk\cWci`XgUmk\Uh
a][\hVYcbh\YaYbi
<YffDZY]ZZYf g]hh]b[ei]Yh`mUhh\YVUW_Ugh\YhckbÁgU`UfafcgY
]bd]hW\ ghccXUbXUg_YXhcVYfYWc[b]nYX"<]gWc`cfZi`WcUhkUgVY^Yk!
Y`YXk]h\`][\h_]bX`YXVmh\YÊ]W_Yf]b[ÊicfYgWYbWY cZ h\Y hckb \U``
UbXgYYaYXhcgkUfak]h\X]UacbX!VUW_VYYh`Yg"¾9ghYYaYXY`XYfgUbX
[ccXdYcd`YcZ?]b[Xca7caY ¿VY[Ub<YffDZY]ZZYf ¾=Uabch]bh\Y
Vig]bYggcZg`Ui[\hYf]b[;cXÁgWfYUhifYg \ckYjYfjYlUh]cigh\Y]fdfYg!
YbWY"=WcffU`UbXgiVXiY =YbW\Ubh½=\UjYXcbYUgmciUg_YX bc`cb!
[YfXcYgh\YfiaV`YcZmcifVUbYÁgZYYh_YYdmcig`YYd`YggUhb][\h½Vih
]h]gbchZcfaYhcXYW]XYh\Yi`h]aUhYZUhYcZ`]j]b[h\]b[g kci`Xmci
XYUfVfYh\fYbk\cgY_bYYgUiX]V`m_bcW_]bh\YdfYgYbWYcZ;cX bch
U[fYY3¿<YfY<YffDZY]ZZYfgacch\YX\]g\UbXgU`cb[\]gWcUhUbX`][\h
[`]hhYfYXUWfcggh\Ygib_YbW\YY_gcZ\]gUb[i]g\YXUiX]hcfg"
¾6ih ]Z mci ]bg]gh" =Z mci k]g\ ]b bc ibWYfhU]b hYfag h\Uh h\YgY
gWUdY[fUWYgVYacfhU``mX]gdUhW\YX =Ua]bXYYXUV`Yhcdfcj]XYh\]ggYf!
j]WY" <ckYjYf h\Y Wcgh cZ YlhYfa]\Oh]cb ]g U [ccX XYU` acfY XYUf" =b
UXX]h]cbhch\YhYbXYf=k]``Ug_mcihcdUfhk]h\ mciaighVYdfYdUfYX
hccdYbmcifYUfghcUgcibX`]_Ybcch\Yf"=h]gh\YgcibXcZgiZZYf]b[
k\]W\k]``]bZYWhmcifÊYg\`]_YUj]fig h\]W_Yb]b[mcifV`ccX Viffck!
]b[]bmcifacghj]hU`cf[Ubg"=hk]``VYWcaYh\YWUf]Ygh\UhWcffcXYh\Y
%$&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
hYYh\h\UhkU_Ymcik]h\UW\]b[Uhb][\h h\YWcb[YghYXjYggY`gcZh\Y
YmYgfYXk]h\[f]YZ h\YWfYYd]b[gdchgcbg_]b[cbYg`UW_UgUhif_YmÁg
kUhh`Yk]h\h]aY"=h]gUZYjYfYX\ck`]b[h\Uhk]``f]b[]bmcif\YUfhZcf
h\YfYghcZmcifXUmgUbXgcibXhcmciUgh\ci[\h\Y9Ufh\Ággci`]gVY]b[
h\fchh`YX"MciaighUg_mcifgY`jYg.WUbmcif\YUfhg ghU`kUfhUbXhfiYUg
mciaUmVY`]YjYh\YahcVY UZZcfX]h3¿
H\YhckbWcibW]`Ug_YX<YffDZY]ZZYf]Z\Ykci`X_]bX`mghYdcih
gc h\Uh h\Ym a][\h Wcbg]XYf h\Y aYf]h cZ \]gµ]bhf][i]b[ dfcdcgU`" <Y
hUddYX\]g\YY`gUbXVckYX UbXUVYXUnn`]b[hfU]bcZ`][\hZc``ckYX\]a
Ug\Yhcc_\]g`YUjY" K]Xck K]b_`YfgU]X]ZmciUg_YX\Yf fY`m]b[cb
<YffDZY]ZZYfUgYWcbXh]aYkci`XVYh\fck]b[[ccXgd]bUW\UZhYfVUX
UbXg\YZcfcbY\UXbÁhUd`i[b]W_Y`hch\fck]bUbmX]fYWh]cb"K]Xck
K]b_`Yf`]jYXZfca\YfXYdUfhYX\igVUbXÁgdU`hfmdYbg]cb"<YÁXVYYbUb
]h]bYfUbhAYgg]U\ \YUX`]b]b[]bdUgg]cbd`UmgUWfcggh\YghUhY½gYUgcbU`
kcf_Vih\YkUgh\YVYgh7\f]gh]b?UbgUg Wci`XgiZZYfUbXZcf[]jYUh
h\Y Xfcd cZ U \Uh UbX gc kUg \UbXgcaY`m WcadYbgUhYX Zcf YUW\ dYf!
ZcfaUbWY½Vihh\YAYgg]U\g\UXcb`mfYWYbh`mib]cb]nYXUbXVUf[U]bYX
ZcfVYbYÉhgk\Yb<YffK]b_`YfX]YXcbh\Y^cV cbh\YWfcgg<YÁXVYYb
XYjchYX hc \]g WfUZh UbX ZY`h \YÁX ibXYfghUbX 7\f]ghÁg ach]jUh]cb VYh!
hYf]Z^ighcbWY\YWci`XVYdfcdYf`mghU_YX"5ga]gZcfhibYkci`X\UjY
]h <Yff K]b_`Yf kUg U V`YYXYf \YfYhcZcfY ibVY_bckbgh" FYh]fYaYbh
ZibXg\UXmYhhcUWWfiYUbX`]ZY]bgifUbWYh\Yk\c`Ybch]cbcZk\]W\
kUg Wcad`]WUhYX Vm U`` h\cgY b][\h`m fYgiffYWh]cbg aUh]bYYg cb Gib!
XUm\UXVYYbX]ga]ggYXcbdf]bW]d`Y gch\Ych\Yf7\f]ghgcZ?UbgUg
k\cU`gcmYUfbYXhcV`YYXVY`]YjUV`m XcbUhYXUdcfh]cbcZh\Y]f]bWcaY
hc WfYUhY U acXYgh Ubbi]hm Zcf K]`\Y`a]bU K]b_`Yf gifj]j]b[ gdcigY
cZ 6Yfh\c`X K]b_`Yf jchYX ;fYUhYgh >Ygig G]bWY >Ygig Uh h\Y]f UbbiU`
dch`iW_UbXAcgh@]_Y`mhcFU]gYh\Y8YUX"AUmcf:]bghYfkU`XYfgi[!
[YghYX h\Ym gh]di`UhY dUmaYbh VY fYa]hhYX cb`m UZhYf h\]g d`U[iY kUg
ghUadYXcih h\YfUVV]hgUZUX]b[W\UdhYf]bh\YhckbÁgch\Yfk]gYd`UW]X
\]ghcfm" ¾6ih ¿ Ug_YX 7cbghUV`Y GW\ihnaUbb ¾k\Uh UVcih h\Y gcibX
cZ giZZYf]b[ <Yff DZY]ZZYf kUfbYX U[U]bgh U VfihU` aig]W bVOb kci`X
WYfhU]b`m VY¿ 7cbghUV`Y GW\ihnaUbb h\ci[\ U Vm!h\Y!Vcc_ VYUX`Y
]bYjYfmch\YffY[UfX _YdhUh\caYUh\fYY!`Y[[YXaUfhYb\YÁXZcibX
kcibXYXbYUf\]gkY``UbXWcXX`YXVUW_hc\YU`h\UbXhfU]bYXhckU`hn
%$'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
hYUW\]b[ \Yf hc \cd f\mh\a]WU``m cb cbY Zcch ]\Sbe]bV`SS]\Sbe]bV`SS
UbXW`YUf`m\YbifgYXUgYWfYhUZZYWh]cbZcfU``jY`jYhmWfYUhifYg \ckYjYf
ibgYhh`]b[h\Y]fgbUf` \ckYjYfacbghfcigh\Y]fZYYh"¾5\ dZfffh ¿gdUh
:UfaYf6UiYf"¾KYUfYbcghfUb[YfghcgiZZYf]b[KYU``_bckkY``h\Y
g\f]Y_cZU\c[k\Uh\Ug[chhYbXckbk]bXcZ\]gZUhY XckYbch3GifY`m
kYÁ``bchU``ckh\YVf]YZVY``ck]b[cZUb]aU`hcfaYbhhcghUbX]bh\YkUm
cZcif\Udd]bYgg3¿K]h\h\]g UgbcfhÊYkZfca\]gVi`VciggW\bcnn`Y½
\]gkcc``macighUW\Yg\]jYfYX`]_Yh\Y`Y[gcZUWYbh]dYXYUbXUddYUfYX
Ugh\ci[\]ha][\hgWihh`YcZZUbX`YUjY\]gbYk`mbU_YX`]dhcZYbXZcf
]hgY`Z½UbX\YZc`XYXgib!`YUh\YfYXUfagUWfcggh\YVi`[]b[VUffY`cZ\]g
W\Ygh"¾H\YgYfUVV]hg\UjY]hWca]b[¿\YVccaYX"5bXgc]hkUgXYW]XYX.
h\ci[\h\YfYkUggh]``gcaYX]gU[fYYaYbh Uacb[h\YacfYd]bW\!ÉghYX
g_]bÊ]bhgUacb[h\Ya cjYfh\YYlUWhacbYhUfmjU`iYcZgiW\UgYfj]WY
<YffDZY]ZZYfkci`XVYfYhU]bYXUbXUg_YXhcYlhYfa]bUhYh\YkU[[`Y!
YUfYXaYbUWYUbXh\YZYYhh\Ym\cddYX]bcb"
:UfaYf6UiYffY`iWhUbh`md`ib_YX[c`Xd]YWYg]bhc<YffDZY]ZZYfÁg
YU[Yfa]hhgh\Ycb`mZcfacZ`iWfY\YÁXUWWYdh½dUdYfWiffYbWm \YgU]X
gcYUg]`mUgh]ZZk]bXÁg\cghU[Y gU]Xh\YfYghkci`XVYdfcZZYfYXcbWY
gYfj]WYgkYfYfYbXYfYX UbX<YffDZY]ZZYfU[U]bW`]W_YX\]g\YY`gUbX
VckYXgc`Yab`mh\YbVUW_YXUkUmibh]`\YZcibX\]agY`Z]bgib`][\h
UbX\YhifbYXUbXghfcXYZcfkUfX g\ck]`mdiad]b[\]gUfa]bh\YU]f
`]_YUXfiaaU^cf aUfW\]b[hcaig]W\Y\UXmYhhcaU_Y"<]gWcUhYl!
d`cXYX_U`Y]XcgWcd]WU``m]bh\Y`][\h gdUb[`]b[h\YU]f h\fck]b[X]g_g
cZWc`cfYjYfmk\YfY YjYfmk\YfY UbXUhfU]bcZ^YkY`gV`UnYXVf][\h`m
VY\]bX\]a"<YhifbYX\]g\YUXcbWYUbX[f]bbYXcjYf\]gg\ci`XYf
UbX \]g ibigiU``m `cb[ YmY`Ug\Yg ÊihhYfYX [fUWYZi``m ]b U VYW_cb]b[
aUbbYf `]_Y h\Y ibXi`Uh]b[ Éb[Yfg cZ U gYU UbYacbY" K]Xck K]b!
_`Yf YmYg`]_YVc]`YXY[[g mY`dYXUbXg`UddYXUhh\YVYYh`YgcZ`][\hh\Uh
gWiff]YXU`cb[\YfUfag h\Ybg\Y[fUVVYXh\Yg\ci`XYfcZ:fUi?]bXYf!
VY]bUbXgU]X ¾=gYYmcif=faU`]bXUÊcUh]b[]bh\YWUbXm!Wc`cfYX`][\h
hfU]`]b[ W`cgY VY\]bX \]a" Mci aigh _YYd \Yf bYUf Ug g\UXck¿ 5bX
:fUi?]bXYfVY]b k\cgYaUf][c`Xg\UXgiZZYfYXacfYh\UbcbWYUhh\Y
dUkgcZK]XckK]b_`YfÁggbiZÊ]b[aihhGW\UhnUbXk\cgYXUi[\hYf
gcaYh]aYggiZZYfYXZfcab][\hhYffcfgVfci[\hcbVmh\YaUb]Wa]X!
b][\hhk]hhYf]b[cZh\Yk]XckÁgWUbUfmDYhib]U g\fi[[YXcZZh\YWfcbYÁg
%$(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
WfU[[m\UbX gb]ZZYX UbXghcfaYXcZZ \YfVcgcafU]gYXhcUViadh]cig
U`h]hiXY"
H\Y fYgh cZ h\Y ZfUnn`YX W]h]nYbfm cZ ?]b[Xca 7caY \YUXYX
ghfU][\h\caY [Uh\YfYXVfYUXUbX^UaUbXWUbX`YgYbci[\ZcfUkYY_
d`i[[YXh\Y]fYUfgk]h\Xc``cdgcZkUl UbXghckYXh\Y]fZUa]`]YggUZY`m
UkUm]bfcchWY``Ufg"@Yhh\YfUVV]hYlhfUWh]cbWcaaYbWY
H\Y hckbgdYcd`Y kU]hYX ]b X]abYgg \Y`X h\Y]f \YUXg ]b h\Y]f
\UbXgUbXhf]YXbchhc`]ghYb g]`Ybh`md`UmYXWUfXgUbXk\]hh`YXjU[iY
g\UdYg Zfca hifb]dg UhY d]W_`YX c_fU UbX VcmgYbVYffm dfYgYfjYg ZYX
h\Y]faYk`]b[WUhgWcbXYbgYXa]`_ hUi[\hh\Y]fXc[g k\ck\]bYXVUfc!
aYhf]WU``mUbXUf[iYXk]h\h\Y]fZYYh hcd`UmXYUX"
5ZhYfh\YmÁXVYYbibXYf[fcibXZcfh\fYYXUmg h\YmVY[UbhcZYY`
`]_Y[fiVgcfhiVYfg `]_Yh\Y`YUghg\fYk gaU``YghaUaaU`]b?UbgUg½
h\YmZY`hdibmUbXhccWcaZcfhUV`Y]bXUf_bYgg gch\YW`cgY XUb_eiUf!
hYfgVY[Ubhcg\f]b_ UbXh\YhckbgdYcd`Yh\ci[\h.gifY`mh\Ydcl\Ug
VYYbUbh]XchYXVmbck"
=h]gkcfh\fYaUf_]b[h\UhhcccZhYb]h]g]adUh]YbWYcfVcfYXca
h\Uh dYfgiUXYg ig hc ghYd Zcch ]bhc h\Y `]cbÁg mUkb]b[ aUk½k]h\ h\Y
dUgg]b[cZh]aYWcaYgUWW]XYbhU`XUf]b[½Vihh\Ya]bihYcifVf]hW\Yg
WUhW\cbh\YVUfVcZUb]bW]gcf kYUkU_Ybhch\YXY`ig]cb hifbhU]`UbX
[U``cd]bh\YX]fYWh]cbcZcifgYbg]V`YWckUfX]WY"
Gc]hkUg]b?]b[Xca7caYcbh\]gh\YXUmh\Uhkci`X`UhYfUbX
ZcfYjYf XYaUbX UhcbYaYbh" >igh Ug dUfYbhg UbX [fUbXdUfYbhg fYgh!
`Ygg cZZgdf]b[ UbX cfd\UbYX Wcig]bg É`YX hckUfX h\Y ghYdg hibbY`]b[
Ud]b_]Y]bhcUbYUfhcZfYY]hZfcag]`YbWY dfYdUf]b[hcdYf]gWcdYh\Y]f
\YUXg UVcjY [fcibX Zcf WcbÉfaUh]cb h\Uh h\Y d`U[iY \UX VYYb d]dYX
]bhccV`]j]cb giXXYb`mZUa]`mWUhghcggYXVUW_h\Y]faUb[m\YUXgUbX
VY[UbhcVUm`]_Ykc`jYgVYbYUh\Ugkc``Ybaccb U\fccccfH\YXc[g
bcVcXmÁgXidY Wci`XgYYh\UhgiW\VY\Uj]cfkUgUg][bh\Ykcf`XkUg
gccbhcYbX gccbhcWfiaV`Y`]_YUXUm!c`XV]gWi]hVYbYUh\h\YWfUW_
cZXcca UbXh\Ymhf]YXhccihk]hh\YUdcWU`mdgYVmZU``]b[gh]ZÊmcbhc
h\Y]fg]XYg h\iX [ccXXc[ [ccXXYUXXc[6][!ÉghYXhcXX`YfgW`ihW\YX
kccXYbU`d\UVYhV`cW_ggch][\h`mh\Y]fg_]b[UjYUbXh\Y]f\UbXgV`YX
Ug]Zh\YmÁXVYYbV]hhYbVmZYfU`kcfXg]bh\YUWhcZZcfa]b[hch\]gXUmU
[\cgh`mVfUbX]b[cbh\YdU`agcZ?UbgUgW\]`XfYbfYaU]bgZU]bh`mj]g]V`Y
%$)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
YjYbVYbYUh\h\Y]adYh][ch\UhgWUVgh\Yg_]b]bgdf]b[/\ckYjYf h\Y
`YhhYfgW\Ub[YYUW\mYUf WUd]hU`6cbYmYUf `ckYfWUgYSh\YbYlh h\Yb
UZU]bhZ½6SZ^36SZZ36SZZ]36SZWdSa3½Ugh\ci[\h\Y]f\UbXgkYfYhfm]b[
hc hY`` h\Ya gcaYh\]b[ ci]^U h\Ya U Vi``Yh]b Zfca h\Y kcf`X VYmcbX
\UbXg dYf\UdgkUfb gbU]`]g\`m cZh\YWca]b[cZYj]`½cfh\YWca]b[cZ
[ccX YeiU``mX]gfidh]jY k\cWUbgUm3"5bXgcZUa]`]YgfYhifbYXhch\Y]f
Vib_Yfg \iXX`YXhc[Yh\Yf k\]`Y\UaghYfgUbXa]WYUbX[YfV]`gU``fUb
h\YagY`jYgfU[[YXcbgeiYU_]b[k\YY`g bYUf`mfYXiWYXh\YagY`jYghcU
fibX`YcZVihhYf UbXUkU]hYXh\YU``!W`YUfcZXUm`][\hh\UhfYkUfXgh\Y
b][\hg\]Zh jUad]fYgUbXck`gUbXUghfcbcaYfgUbXÉfYÊ]Yg k]h\gibbm
UbXXfYUa`Yggg`YYd"
CbWYgYhh`YXcbWchgUbXVYbW\Yg h\YÉbU`\UbXcZ\YUfhgXYU`h
h\YhckbgdYcd`Yhcc\YUfXh\YgcibX ZY`h]h]bh\YfcchgcZh\Y]fhYYh\
Ug]h]bWfYUgYX]bd]hW\UbXjc`iaY UWcbWUhYbUhYXg\f]Y_gcd]YfW]b[
g\UfdUgUbUk` h\UhYUfXfiagg\UhhYfYX `]_YWfmghU`VYbYUh\h\YdfYg!
gifYcZUhYbcfg\f]``mhf]``]b[U`cZhYXbchY UbXV`ccXhf]W_`YXZfcah\Y]f
YUfg Vihgh]``h\YmWci`X\YUf"7\]`XfYbVY[Ubhc\]WWidUbXk\]adYf
UbXdUfYbhg\Y`XXUadhYUhckY`ghch\Y]fdU`]b[W\YY_g"5bXh\Ybh\Ym
ZcibXh\YagY`jYgcbh\Y]fZYYh ghUbX]b[k]h\cihaYUb]b[hc ghiaV`]b[
XfYUa]`m kU_YZi`gcabUaVi`]ghg di``YXZcfkUfX idh\YghYdg ]bhch\Y
UZhYfbccb½h\Ym gei]bhYX U[U]bgh h\Y XUnn`Y cZ XUm½]bhc h\Y gcibX
h\UhgYYaYXhcYadhmh\Y]f\YUfhgcZV`ccX gUdh\YacZU``jc`]h]cb ]bhc
h\Ygci`!WifX`]b[WUhYfkUi`h\UhgcibXYXhch\Yd]cigZc`_cZ?]b[Xca
7caYUgh\ci[\;cX<]agY`ZkYfYVY]b[`Ug\YX h\Ykcf`XÁgg_]bdYY`YX
ZfcaaigW`Y ÊYg\g\YYfYXZfcaVcbY h\YgcibXcZ[cfYXf]dd]b[ Xf]d!
d]b[ ]W\cfh\]bb]b[hcUf]ji`Yh h\Y\c``ckh\ia!h\iadcZ`]ZYcbh\Y
YVV"H\YmkU`_YX YmYgUh\U`ZaUgh UfagUXUb[`Y `]adUgg`U]b[YYgY
UbXh\YmghcddYXk\Ybh\YmfYUW\YXh\Yf]jYf k\YfYh\Y]faU[bYh]nYX
YmYgfYaU]bYXf]jYhYXUbXibV`]b_]b[ Vifb]b[k]h\g][\h UgcbYVYXYj!
]`YXfUVV]hUZhYfUbch\Yfd]hW\YX]hgY`Z gWfYUa]b[ cZZh\YVUb_gUbX]bhc
h\Yfig\]b[kUhYf dUkgdYXX`]b[ZcfdifW\UgY]bh\YU]f VcX]YgXUg\YX
U[U]bghfcW_g bYW_g gbUddYXVmh\YZcfWY cZ h\Y WiffYbh h\Uh W\ifbYX
k]h\h\Ygdf]b[h\Uk UbXh\YfUVV]hgÁei]jYf]b[YWhcd`Uga hfUbg`iWYbh
Vihd]b_UgUhcb[iY fcgYg`ck`m]bhch\YU]f`]_Y[`iYmViVV`Yg [Y`Uh]bcig
jUdcf kUZhYXcjYf\YUX W`ciX]b[h\Yg_mk]h\Ubc]`m[`ck h\YbVifgh
%$*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
h\YhckbV`Ub_YhYX]bccnY Uj]gWcigfU]b.h\Yfcgmg`]aYcZUg`Ui[\!
hYfYXgci`CZZ]bh\YX]ghUbWY VYbYUh\h\YgibÁga]X!UZhYfbccb[`UfY
h\Y gdY``VcibX Vif[\Yfg gUk U k]b_]b[ Vf]``]UbWY cb h\Y g\cU`g `]_Y U
a]ffcfgd`Ug\YXk]h\`][\h UbXk\Ybh\Y]fYmYgUXUdhYXhch\YVf][\h!
bYggh\YmWci`XaU_Ycih<YffDZY]ZZYfÁgd]dYfU]gYX]bh\YU]f h\YaUb
Uhh\Ych\YfYbXfYa]bX]b[h\YacZ8f">Y_m``[inn`]b[\]gZUhYZi`Y`]l]f
ghfU][\hZfcah\YU`YaV]Wh]ddYXhc\]g`]dg"H\YhckbgdYcd`YZfUbh]WU``m
gkUVVYXh\Y[cccZYlhYfa]bUh]cbZfcah\Y]f`]aVg UbXU``UhcbWYW\]`!
XfYbUbXXc[gZY``hch\Y[fcibX YmYVU``gg\iXXYf]b[VYbYUh\h\Y`]XgUg
]ZfYWcfX]b[UgY]ga]Wg\]Zh Ug]ZUhk]hW\k]h\Ug\UhhYf]b[XfYUa k\]W\
]g\ckh\Ymkci`X`UhYfh\]b_cZ]h h\Yk]W_YXYghXfYUah\YmWci`XYjYf
fYWU``\Uj]b[ UbYldYf]YbWYbchcZ;cXÁggh]``!kUhYfYX [fYYb!dUghifYX
UbXVYhi`]dYX_]b[Xca UXfYUah\UhVY[[UfYXYjYbh\YacghhcfaYbhYX
]aU[]bUh]cb UbXdUfYbhgcdYbYXh\Y]facih\gUbXhf]YXhcgkU``ckh\Y
gcibX [i`d]hXckbUbXXfckb]h]bh\Y]f[i``Yhg W\c_]b[cbU]fdc``ihYX
k]h\ giZZYf]b[" H\]g aU`][bUbh mUkd ]h WUbbch dfcdYf`m VY XYgWf]VYX/
]h\UffckYXhch\Yei]W_h\Y\U`h]b[gd]f]hgcZh\YgcffckZi`W]h]nYbgcZ
?]b[Xca7caY ?UbgUg k\cbYjYfU[U]bÉg\YX]bh\Yf]jYf k\cbYjYf
U[U]b k\]hh`YX U WUffch kU`hnYX ]b h\Y accb`][\h bifgYX U kcibXYX
Ub]aU` k\cgY kYXX]b[g \YfYUZhYf kYfY gcaVYf Ug kU_Yg k\c bYjYf
U[U]b \YUfX h\Y gcibX cZ W\]`XfYb g]b[]b[ cf kYYd]b[ cf WU``]b[ h\Y]f
Xc[gh\ci[\h\YhUdfcchVif]YXVYbYUh\h\YgYVif[Ycb]b[bYjYfU[U]bg
]gmYhhcVYfYjYU`YX U``]b[ccXh]aY"
H\Yf]jYfVc]`YXk]h\h\YVcX]YgcZfUVV]hg"
%$+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
=hWUbbchVYgU]Xh\Uh?]b[Xca7caYfYhifbYXhcbcfaU`cbWY
h\YfUVV]hg\UXfUhh`YXh\Y]f`Ugh^UW_!fUVV]hmVfYUh\ \UXaYhh\Y]fa]g!
[i]XYXaU_Yf Vihh\YhckbZY``]bghYdU[U]bk]h\]hgZcfaYff\mh\aUbX
h\YhckbgZc`_W\cigYXh\YagY`jYg]bhcVY`]Yj]b[h\YmÁXgifacibhYXh\Y
kcfghcZh\Y]fhf]Vi`Uh]cbg"Ibh]`"
Ibh]`h\UhXUmk\Yb\cigYXc[g h\cgYWfmghU`[UnYfg VY[UbViffck!
]b[ibXYfXUjYbdcfhgAUmcf:]bghYfkU`XYfÁg=f]g\kc`Z\cibX<YXk][
gW\`Ydd]b[\]gdf]nYX6]YXYfaY]YfXUmVYXcb\YfVUW_Zfcah\YdUf`cf
]bhch\YX]b]b[fccaUgg\Yhf]YXhcWfYYdhckUfX]bj]g]V]`]hmUbXWUhg
\]X]b\Um`cZhgk\YfYh\Ym`Yha]WYgWiffmdUghh\YaibdUkYX"H\Ya]WY
kYfYbchYgdYW]U``m[fUhYZi`Zcfh\YUabYghmVYWUigY kY`` a]WYUfYUg
ZcbXcZfcih]bYUgh\YbYlhfcXYbh"@Ugg]hiXYWUigYXh\Yahch\]bbYUf`m
hcYlh]bWh]cbZcfh\YmX]XbchZYY`h\YmWci`XWfiaV![Uh\Yfcf]bjUXYh\Y
Wcfb!f]W_]b[ccXWcbgW]YbWYk]h\bcW`UkggbUdd]b[Uhh\Y]fhU]`ghc[]jY
h\YaÊYYh!ZcchYXdifdcgY"
Cbh\UhXUm <YffDZY]ZZYfUddYUfYXU[U]bUhUWcibW]`aYYh]b[¾hc
gYhh`YibgYhh`YXUWWcibhg"¿5g\YghfcXY]bhch\Y\U``]b\]g`][\h!gdUb[`YX
aUbh`Y gYYa]b[ZcfU``h\Ykcf`X`]_YUgdfYUX]b[ÉfY h\YhckbgdYcd`Y
ZY`hh\Y\YUhcbh\Y]fW\YY_gUbXdUfhYXhc`Yhh\]gWcbÊU[fUh]cb dUgg
ghYdd]b[k]XYZcfZYUfh\Ymhcca][\hWcaVigh"<YffDZY]ZZYfUg_YXhc
VYfYWc[b]nYXUbX6fch\Yf5b[gh\UgYm]Y`XYXh\Y`YWhYfbUbXghYddYX
XckbZfcah\YXU]g"@UhYf k\Ybh\Yhckbkci`XUhhYadhhcfYWcbghfiWh
<YffDZY]ZZYfÁgUddYUfUbWYgch\Uhh\Yma][\hcZZYfUVcibhmZcf\]gWUd!
hifY h\Ymkci`XYUW\fYWc``YWhh\YZYUhifYgcZ\]gZUWYX]ZZYfYbh`m kci`X
]b ZUWh fYWcbghfiWh \]a ]b h\Y]f ckb ]aU[Y [ih`Ygg [cX!kUbbUVYg U``
cZig½ZUWYfcibXUgUg_]``Yhk]h\YmYg`]_YXi``ghcbYg/Uei]`]bYbcgY
UVcjYZUh`]dg[Uf]g\Ugdcdd]Yg/hYYh\V`iY![fYYbUgcl]X]nYXWcddYfUbX
U acb_]g\ VU`XbYgg½UbX h\YmÁX Zcf[Yh h\Y aYgaYf]ga cZ \]g ach`Ym
WcUhUbXh\YVYk]hW\]b[d]hW\cZ\]gd]d]b["
¾Mcifhckb\UgVYYbdif[YXcZ]hgdYgh]`YbWY ¿gU]X<YffDZY]ZZYf
¾UbX=\UjYfYhifbYXhcWc``YWhamXiY"=Zmcikci`XVYgc[ccXUghc
fYa]hamei]hhUbWYUbXgeiUfYh\YgWcfY =k]``[`UX`mei]hg]cUbXVYcb
amkUm"¿<YVckYXUbXhcggYX\]g\Uhhch\YaUmcf"
9UW\U`XYfaUbgYUfW\YXh\YVYk]`XYfYXYmYgcZh\YbYlhZcfgcaY
[i]XUbWY gcaYWiY UbXh\Y\UhdUggYXei]W_`mZfca\UbXhc\UbX"<Yff
%$,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
DZY]ZZYfghYddYXXckbUbXfYhifbYXhch\YWYbhYfU]g`YUbXh\Y\UhWUaY
fcibXhc\]a gU[[]b[k]h\Vcchm"<Yga]`YX W`]W_YX\]g\YY`g [`UbWYX
]bg]XYh\Y\Uh h\YbU`id]bY[f]aUWYXUf_YbYX\]gZUWY"K\YbWcibW]`
aYaVYfgfYWcibhYXh\]g`UhYf h\Ymkci`XgUm\YVUfYXV`]bX]b[hYYh\
h\Uh[`]ghYbYX`]_YXU[[YfgUbX\]gYmYgmY``ckYXk]h\Ub]aU`fU[Y Vih
\YgU]Xbch\]b[ UbX\]gg]`YbWYfUb[]bg]XYh\Ya`]_YUW`UddYf]bUVY``
aU_]b[h\Y]fVcbYg\iaUbXh\Y]f\YUfhgg_]d h\Y]f`]jYfgW`Ub[ h\Y]f
gci`gW`UacfhcVYZfYYcZh\UhZcif!Êig\]b[ÊYg\h\Uhkci`Xgccbhifb
hc Xigh UbX gYhh`Y cb Ufac]fYg UbX gWcbWYg cb`m hc VY gkYdh ]bhc h\Y
V]bk]h\mYghYfXUmÁgfiVV]g\ gcff]YghcZgcffmZUhYgdfU[aUh]W ]ZÉW_`Y
gci`gU`kUmg`cc_ZcfUbYgWUdY\UhW\k\Ybh\YYbX]bW\YgW`cgYf=bg]XY
h\Y\UhkYfYWUbXmkfUddYfg dYbW]`g d`i[b]W_Y`g VU``gcZ`]bh aUfV`Yg
Zcif!dYbbmbU]`g UggcfhYXÊ]bhg `UghkYY_ÁgfUZÊYh]W_Yhg k]``ckViXg
VihbUfmU[YaghcbYcfXfcdcZ[c`X U\UhZi`cZh\Ybch\]b[Bch\]b[
WUff]Yg ]b ]hg dcW_Yh" Bc cbY XfYk U VfYUh\ cf hk]hW\YX gc aiW\ Ug U
hcY"
¾G!g!gYY\YfY ¿ghUaaYfYXAUmcf:]bghYfkU`XYfUh`Ugh ¾h\YfUVV]hg
\UjY[cbY h\YfYÁgbcUf[i]b[h\Uh"6ihgchcc\UgcifZY`]W]hm h\YgkYYh
gUbWh]hmkYcbWYYb^cmYX½ÊYX ck]b[]bbcgaU``aYUgifYhch\Uhµh\Uh
X]UVc`]WU`gcb[kYWUbbchg\U_YZfcacifYUfg U`UaYbhUh]cbkYghfcb[!
`mgigdYWh]g]bZYfbU`]bcf][]b UbX\Yk\cd!d!d!dUmgh\YXYj]`k]``VY]b
XYVhZcfYhYfb]hm¿gdihhYfYXh\YaUmcf a]gWU`Wi`Uh]b[h\YVfYUh\bYWYg!
gUfmhcdfcdY`fYh]WYbh]bX][bUh]cb h\Y`UghkcfXgWUfWY`mUk\]gdYf"
5W\]``mgh]``bYgggYhh`YXU[U]bcbh\Yfcca ]bg]XYcZk\]W\<Yff
DZY]ZZYfÁgWcUhgYYaYXhcV`UnYUbYkUbXh\YÉfYÊUg\YX]bh\Yg\f]b_]b[
did]`gcZh\Ycb`cc_Yfg h\Y]f]f]gYgYadhm]b[cZWc`cf kY``]b[idk]h\
\YUh"
¾5bX k\Uh ]Z ¿ Ug_YX <Yff DZY]ZZYf k]h\ U acih\ h\Uh X]X bch
acjY ¾]h kUgµ;cX k\c aifXYfYX h\Y gWcif[Y3 =gbÁh YlhYfa]bUh]cb
U`kUmg;cXÁgdifj]Yk \]gVU]`]k]W_ dfYfc[Uh]jY \]gFYUgcbZcf6Y]b[3
K\Uh]Z]h]g;cXhck\camcickYmcifÉhZi`g`YYd3<Y]ggifY`m]b!
XYab]ÉYXUbXmciWUbVYWYfhU]b<Yk]``Wc``YWh"¿5\U`Z![f]bdfcddYX
id cbY g]XY cZ \]g acih\" ¾Mci WUbbch cihfib h\Y 7cbghUV`Y XYUf
h\]aV`Yf][[Yfg WUbbchgh]ZZh\Yd]dYfZcf`cb["7cbg]XYfmcifgY`Z]bUf!
fYUfg¿<YffDZY]ZZYfV`UnYXcihcZh\Yfcca UbXYUW\dYfgcb\YdUggYX
%$-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
ZY``hc\]g_bYYgUbX[fUgdYXUhh\YhfU]`]b[gac_Y Éb[Yf]b[h\YU]fZcf
Zcf[]jYbYgg"
5kYY_dUggYXUbXh\YfYkUgbcZifh\YfdYYdZfcah\Yd]dYf"H\Y
U`XYfaYbÁgYUfgZY`haUi`YXVm<YffDZY]ZZYfÁg`UghW`UddYfW`Uk]b[ gcbc
cbYihhYfYXUkcfXUVcihh\Yh\fYUhgh\YhckbZYfjYbh`m\cdYXkYfY]X`Y
UgX]gfYdU]f ]bXc`YbhUgUWUdg]nYXjY`cW]dYXYk]h\UVUX`mVYbhk\YY`"
H\cgY ?]b[Xca 7caYfg gYWfYh`m []jYb hc cWWi`h ]aU[]b]b[g ]b h\Y
mYUfb]b[df]jUWmcZ`cb[UbXaccb`Yggb][\hgk]g\YX\YÁXVYYbgd]f]hYX
UkUmVmUj][cfcigk]bXhcUb]b\cgd]hUV`YWcbh]bYbhfYachYUgh\YghUfg
UbXdfUmYXh\UhUhYW\b]Wc`cfYXWcUhZiY`YXVmU[fiX[YkUgbchUfY`]UV`Y
aYUbgcZWcbjYmUbWY"
9jYbh\YacghghiVVcfbacfhU`Zib_]ghUaYXVmH]aY hUi[\hhc
VYUfidibXYfh\Ymc_YcZacfhU`]hm`]_YU``;cXÁgclYb gcUZhYfUZcfh!
b][\h h\Y dYcd`Y XUfYX hc h\]b_ h\Uh dYf\Udg <Yff DZY]ZZYfÁg V]hY ZY``
g\cfhcZ\]gVY``ckUbXh\YmU``ckYXh\YagY`jYgUh`Ughhcg]b_`]_Yh\Y
XYUX]bhch\YgcZhh]W_]b[cZh\Y]faUhhfYggYgUhb][\h"GcXc[!kYUfmkYfY
h\Yg`YYd!XYdf]jYXVfYh\fYbcZ?]b[Xca7caY ?UbgUg h\UhbcVcX]Yg
gh]ffYXZfcah\Y]fghidcfk\Ybh\YUb]aU`gVY[UbhcdUWY"BchYjYbh\Y
mck`]b[UbX\]gg]b[ h\YghUad]b[cZ\ccjYg Wci`XfcigYh\Ygbcfh]b[
g`YYdYfgZfcah\]gXY`]W]cig`m`YUXYbYaVfUWYcZAcfd\Yig k\cgYhYb!
XYfbYggh\YmÁXgci[\h]bjU]b `]_Yaccb]b[gW\cc`[]f`g Zcfacbh\g"
=h]gbUhifU`hc[fcdYZcfaYhUd\cf gYbh]aYbhhk]WYfYacjYX ]b
acaYbhgcZ[iUfXYXWcbhYbhaYbh"HcgUmg]ad`mh\YhckbUh`Ughg`Ydh
gcibX`m]g Zcfh\cgYk\cgYhghcfYVmh\YgcfWYfmcZkcfXg hcZifh\Yf
Wcifh h\Y YbX`Ygg ]``g h\Uh ÊYg\ ]g \Y]f hc½WU`Ua]hm ]g kUfXYX cZZ Vm
VY]b[YhYfbU``mUbh]W]dUhYX h\YXYj]`hcc"HfUbei]`]hm UgUbmWcaZcfh!
UV`YVUggYh\cibXWUbhY``mci aighU`kUmgX]ggYaV`Y aUgeiYfUXYUg
]ffYjYfg]V`Y kcY `Ygh ]h ^]bl ]hg ckb kcVV`Y!k\YY`YX ZihifY" @ib]hU
6YhY`\Y]a k\cX]XbÁhVY`]YjY]bg\ci`XYf]b[XYVh gcVVYXZcfUb\cif
YjYfmUZhYfbccbdfcadh`mUhh\fYYcÁW`cW_hcdUmXckbh\YXY^YWh]cbkY
WcaY]bhch\Ykcf`Xck]b[UbXhc]bjYgh]bUfYh]fYaYbhZfYYcZU``Vih
h\Yacghhf]Ê]b[a]gYf]Yg/g\YVY`]YjYXÉjYacbh\gcZgcVV]b[]aai!
b]nYX\YfU[U]bghh\YXYUh\cZU`cjYXcbY h\fYYkYY_gZcfUdfc`cb[YX
]``bYgg hkc acbh\g ibfYei]hYX UXcfUh]cb cbY acbh\ [UfXYb jUf]Yhm
UV^YWh]cb/giW\kYfY@ib]hUÁgaUh\YaUh]WgcZdfYjYbhUh]jYacifb]b["
%%$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
6ihYjYbh\YUfhZi`XcX[YcZ`Ub[iU[Ycf[YghifY `]hh`YacfY `YhigVY
ZfUb_ h\UbUdUf`cfhf]W_ WUbbchgUjYig]bh\YYbX"5bXh\]g]g\ck;cX
WUbVYWYfhU]b<Y]g;cX.<]g`Y[YfXYaU]bfY`]Yg`Yggcbh\YX]ghUbWYcZ
gYbgYh\Ubh\Y]bh]aUWmcZgcibX/<]g]gUh\ibXYf]b[aY`cXmcZkfUh\
UbXfYdYbhUbWY k\]W\]ghcgUmUgcb[ibXYfghccXVmU`` h\Ygcb[kY
Uff]jY]bcifVcX]YgV`YUh]b["5bXgc]hkUgh\Uhh\Y[ccXUbXXYWYbh
dYcd`YcZ?]b[Xca7caY ?UbgUg WUaYhcXciVhh\Y]bcWi`Uh]b[dckYf
cZd]Yhm.ZUh`chcZ[ccXh\Y]fXYjch]cb\UXXcbYh\YaGYY]Z]h]gbÁhgc"
=b?]b[Xca7caYh\YfYkUgU[]f` k\cg\U``\YbWYZcfh\VYfY!
ZYffYXhcUgµKU``K]``KcYKU``ckµEWZZ]e@]h\YUgUµK]``ck
<]aaY`ZUfV UW\]`XVcfbV][UgUWUaY`Ág\iad V][UgUZUV`Y gcV][g\Y
Vfc_Y h\Y ghcf_Ág V]`` XY`Um]b[ XY`]jYfm cZ ch\Yf ]bZUbhg k\]W\ WUigYX
h\Y ach\Yfg hc \]gg Uh \Yf UbX fiV h\Y]f VY`YU[iYfYX `c]bg k\Yb h\Ym
dUggYX\Yf kcaVgk\cgYd\UbhcadU]bgcZ`UVcfdYfg]ghYXZcfmYUfgUbX
WUigYXh\YkcaYbhcWfmcihYUW\XUmUhh\Yghfc_YcZh\Y]fW\]`XÁgV]fh\"
=bZUWhh\]g]g\ckh\Yhckb k\cÁXU`kUmga]ghfighYXh\Yh]`hcZh\Ygib
UbXk\cgYVcX]YgÁWc``YWh]jYY`YWhf]W]hmWUigYXW`cW_gUbXkUhW\Yghcgd]b
gcZUghZc`_gZYUfYXh\YmÁX`]jYh\Y]fk\c`Y`]jYg]b`Yggh\UbUXUm VY[Ub
hchY``h]aY.;]gY`UGW\UXYbZfUi%%U"a" AU`j]bUAUfeiUfhg\cfh`mVY!
ZcfYgiddYf]bh\YYjYb]b[ FUdibnY`DYUVcXmUbX9`Zf]YXY?]bXYfVY]b
Ua]bihYhca]Xb][\h"
5bXk]h\YUW\dUgg]b[mYUfh\YV`iYYldUbgYVYhkYYbK]``ckUbX
h\YcihYf\YUjYbg[fYkgaU``Yf"H\YWcaaib]hmkU]hYXZcfh\YXUmg\YÁX
YlW\Ub[YUW\Ud`YhcZW`cjYfZcfh\UhcZW`ciXg"=bh\UhmYUfcZh\Yd]dYf
K]``ckkUghYbmYUfgc`XVihWci`XU`fYUXmghUfYh\YghUhY`]YghghU``]cb
]bh\YYmYh\ci[\g\Y[YbYfU``mghYYfYXk]XYcZ`]jYghcW_ZcfZYUfh\Ym
a][\hW`U]a\YfUgcbYcZh\Y]fckb"5bXcbh\UhdUfh]Wi`Ufb][\h h\Y
b][\hcZh\Yghcbmg`YYd K]``ck `]_YU``h\YW\]`XfYbcZ?]b[Xca7caY
ZY`h\YfgY`Zf]gYZfca\YfVYXUbXÊcUh]bhch\Ya]Xb][\hU]f9`Zf]YXY
UbX FUdibnY`Ág gmbW\fcb]nYX \ck`g dYY`]b[ VY\]bX \Yf UbX ]h kUg
giW\U`cjY`mUbXU`]YbgYbgUh]cbh\]gkY][\h`YggbYggh\Uhg\YZY`hbcZYUf
%%%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
h\ci[\h;cX\UXWcaYhcfYgWiY\YfUh`Ugh ZfYY\YfZfcah\YUbj]`cZ
\YfYUfh\`mZcfa g`]dh\UhdcbXYfcigbccgYZfca\YfbYW_"CbWYcih!
g]XY\Yf\cigY k]h\bcWY]`]b[hcghma]Y\Yf K]``ckh\ci[\hg\YÁXXf]Zh
ei]W_`mhckUfX7Ub]Wi`UUbX ZcbXUXa]fYfh\Uhg\YkUgcZVch\Xc[g
UbXfYachY`cWU`Yg g\YgiZZYfYXbcfY[fYh Vihh\Ybg\Yh\ci[\hcZ\Yf
Vfch\YfC[XYb ]aU[]bYX\]a[fcibXYXUh\caYk]h\cb`m\YfdUfYbhg
ZcfWcadUbm UbXg\YZY`h\Yfgci`_YX[YXUWfcggh\YdfU]f]Y \YfVcXmUb
UbW\cf/\YfZYYhVY[UbhcXfU[ h\Yb\Yf_bYYg \YfVY``m \YfW\]b ibh]`
g\YZcibX\YfgY`ZZUWYXckb]bViZZU`c[fUgg"G\Yfc``YXcb\YfVUW_UbX
gUkUb]aU`YmYgV`]b_]b[UfcibX\Yf"G\Yk]g\YXg\YWci`XaighYfZYUf
Vihg\Y_bYkVinnUfXgUbXVUX[Yfg WcmchYgUbXZclYg YjYbh\YcWWU!
g]cbU`acibhU]b`]cbUbXjU[fUbhVYUfkci`XgWUhhYfcbWYh\YmWci`XgYY
g\YkUgbch]XmacfgY`hkcUihiabgU[cUV`UW_VYUf\UXVYYbgdchhYX
cbUV]hhYfb][\hWif`YXUhh\YZYYhcZh\YghUhiYcZAYbXY`gc\bDUXX`Y!
hfUd k\c]b%,,']bjYbhYXh\YhcfbUXc\UfbYgg U\cb_]b[WcbhfUdh]cb
h\UhWci`X`UggcUhk]ghYf fcdYh\YYbYf[mfcibXh\YUb_`Yg UbXk]h\
h\UhZcfWYacaYbhUf]`mhUaYX \Ykci`X`ccgY]hU[U]bcbh\Y[fcibX
hcWcb^ifY\]g\YUfhÁgZcbXYgh`cb[]b[.UWccdZi``cZh\Yacghd`iW_]`m
df]b_YXVUbhUag½ZYUh\YfYXhch\Yb]bYg½mciWci`XYjYf\cdYhcZUbWm
UbXh\Uh`U]Xbchcb`mh\YVYgh!hUgh]b[Y[[gh\]gg]XYcZWUd]hU`DDUfUX]gY
VihdfcXiWYXW\]W_Yba]`_hcVcchK\]W\ ]hhifbgcih ]gUaVfcg]Uhc
VYUfg acfYYbh]W]b[h\UbU``h\Y\cbYm]b6YUf<YUjYb"5VcjY K]`!
`ck W\]`XfYbkUZhYX]bh\YU]fk]h\ibgdYU_UV`Y[fUWY Êi]XUgYY`g Vih
h\Ybh\Yaccb]``ia]bYXh\Y]fVcX]YgUbX]bh\Y]fb][\hW`ch\Ygh\YmfY!
a]bXYX\YfcZh\YgYYXgcZUa]`_kYYXdUfUW\ih]b[hckUfXZYfh]`]nUh]cb"
3dS`gbVW\UWa[]`Sa][SbVW\USZaSbVO\WbaSZT h\ci[\hK]``ck"K]``ck k\cigi!
U``mZY`hZYhhYfYXVm\]ghcfmU`kUmgUg\cfhaUbÁgghcfmVm\YfaYUgifY
h\ci[\hh\YbUVcih5aY`]U9Uf\Ufh WcfbZYX?UbgUg[]f``]_Y\Yf AYY`m
\Yfg]ghYfWU``YX\Yf k\cWcbghfiWhYXUhfUW_cb\YfZUh\YfÁghcc`g\YX
[fYUgYX]hk]h\`UfX XfcjYUkccXYbVclcZZh\YYX[Y \ib[gigdYbXYX]b
h]aYUbXgdUWY`]_YU`cghd`UbYh ZY``hch\YYUfh\ UbXgU]X ¾CbYXUm=Á``
X]gUddYUf]bh\YW`ciXg D]X[Y mcikUhW\"¿9jYfmcbYk\c[fckgid]b
?UbgUg\UgUmYbhcVYU]fVcfbYgccbYfcf`UhYf ]Zcb`mhc[`]adgYk\YfY
;cX \]XYg <]g ib]aU[]bUV`Y Zcfa h\Uh ZUh WUfWUgg" AUbm ]g h\Y dfU]!
f]YX?UbgUb `UbX`cW_YXUbXghUfjYXZcfU`h]hiXYUbX`cjY hU``hfYYgUbX
%%&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
hYbXYfaig]W k\c\Ug\UXUVcbYhcd]W_k]h\<Yff8f"8f";!c!Xci!
V`Y!WfiW]Él"K]``ckh\ci[\h]hkUgbchhfU[]WVihUXfYUaZi`É``YXh\Uh
5aY`]U9Uf\Ufh`]ZhYX]bhch\Yg_mcbYXUmUbXbYjYffYhifbYX"EWZZ]e
/W`VSO`b h\ci[\hK]``ck U]fh\YY`YaYbh]bk\]W\\YfYadhm\YUfhbUhi!
fU``mh\f]jYX"H\Ybg\Yh\ci[\hh\]g.7bÂaOZeOgabVW\e][S\eV]RWaO^^SO`
5bX giXXYb`m h\YfY kUg C[XYb gk]aa]b[ ]b h\Y g_m cjYf\YUX
W`ihW\]b[h\YZYYhcZUg`YYd]b[[]f`k\cVcVVYX]bh\YU]f]bZfcbhcZ\]a
=faU`]bXU?]bXYfVY]b"C[XYbk\cdfUmYXUhh\YZcchcZK]``ckÁgVYX
UbXgai[[`YX]bhc\YffccaUhb][\h[]b[YfgbUdgUbXdYddYfbihg\Yf
ach\Yf\]XZfca\Yf"¾C[XYb C[[]Y¿g\YWU``YX"<YkUjYXhc\Yfk]h\
\]gZYYh"Gc K]``ck k\cbckZY`hhc\YfgY`ZacfYkY][\hYXk]h\ÊYg\
h\UbYjYf d]W_YX\YfgY`ZidUbXZc``ckYXh\YÊcUh]b[W\]`XfYbXYYdYf
]bhch\Yb][\h"
K]``ckZc``ckYXh\Yaibh]`\YfZYYhUW\YXUbXg\YkUggifYh\Ym
\UXfYUW\YXk\Uh\YfdUfYbhgWU``YX¾h\YfU[[YXYX[YcZ7\f]ghYbXca¿/
VYmcbXh\Yk]bXVfYU_d`UbhYXhc\U`hh\YfU[]b[Xighh\Uh VUW_]bh\Y
XUm \UXghcfaYXh\Y`ib[gcZYjYfmVfYUh\]b[h\]b[/VYmcbXh\YZcfYgh
g\YkUgkUfbYXbYjYfhchfYgdUgg`Yghg\YUkU_Ybh\Yk]`Xcab]jcfcig
cbY!YUfYXWckgh\UhkYfYUZfU]XcZa]ffcfgUbX[cUhgVihk\cW\YkYX
W\]`XfYb`]_Y[fUggUbXgd]hidVUg_YhgkcjYbZfca\U]fUbXVcbYgUbX
hYYh\/hcUW`YUf]b[]bh\YhfYYg UbXh\YfYh\YW\]`XfYbVY[UbhcÊihhYfhc
h\Y[fcibX `]hVmh\Yh\fcVV]b[accb `cc_]b[`]_YV`Ub_g`]dgcZdUdYf"
BckK]``ckWci`X\YUfh\Yf\mh\a]WWfcU_]b[cZh\Yd]dYh\UhgcibXYX
`]_Yh\Yk\]ff]b[cZ>ibYW]WUXUgUgh\Ymg`]XZfcah\Y]fg_]bg"G\YkU`_YX
h\fci[\h\Yg`YYdmW\]`XfYb`m]b[cbh\Y[fcibX WUfYZi`bchhcghYdcb
h\Y]fcihghfYhW\YX\UbXg UbXgYUfW\YXh\YaZcf\YfVfch\Yf C[[]Yk]h\
\]g bcgY XighYX k]h\ ZfYW_`Yg UbX \]g Vihhcb acih\ h\Uh aiaV`YX ]b
g`YYd"G\Ydi``YXidg\cfhk\Ybg\YgUkXU[[Yf!hcYXVcchg VYhUggY`YXUh
h\Y_bYY [`YUa]b[k]h\`Ubc`]bUbX`UadV`UW_ hUdd]b[h\Y[fcibX UbX
h\YfY ghUbX]b[ Uacb[ h\Y g`iaVYf]b[ _]bXYf[UfhYb kUg <Yff DZY]ZZYf
k\c\Y`X]b\]g\UbXgUdUbd]dY"K]``ck k\c\UXVYYb?]b[Xca7caY
C`ZUWhcfm7\Uad]cbh\fYYmYUfgfibb]b[UbXk\ch\]gmYUfkci`XWca!
dYhYUhghUhY \Uj]b[]XYbh]ÉYXk]h\Ug]b[`Ygb]ZZh\YgYWfYh]b[fYX]Ybhg
]bAfg"G][]gaibXÁgGW\kUfnk}`XYf?]fgW\hcfhY\U`ZUh\]aV`YcZfYX
WiffUbhgW\bUddgUbXUXUg\cZfcgYkUhYfUbX]bAf"Nk]YVY`ÁgdUhYbhYX
%%'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
ac]ghif]nYfh\Uhh\Ydfib]YfY`XYfggcddYXid`]_YVfYUXUbXWci`XbÁh
[YhYbci[\cZgiYh Wci`XgaY``h\Y\UnY`bihgUbXW`cjYUbXaUfn]dUb
cZh\]g`YV_iW\Ybd]dYUbXaUfjY`YXUh\ckh\Y]bghfiaYbhbYjYf[fYk
gaU``Yfh\ci[\\YV]hcZZUb]VV`Yk]h\YUW\V`ck"5WhiU``m h\]gaUXY
K]``ckU`]hh`YgUXVYWUigY]hfYa]bXYX\YfcZ\YfckbVcXm.bcaUhhYf
k\UhmciX]Xhc]h½mciWci`Xg`Uh\Yf]hk]h\gW\aU`nUbXXUb[`YW\c]WY
WihgVYbYUh\h\YgbcihgcZh\YacghfUjYbcigkc`jYg½]hXYÉYXfYXiW!
h]cb UbXh\YacfYmcihf]YXhcWcbhU]b]h h\YacfY]hYfidhYX]bYjYfm
X]fYWh]cb"5bXK]``ckZcibXh\Y]XYUcZfY[YbYfUh]jYZccX]bUkcf`X
d`U[iYXVmibYbX]b[ghUfjUh]cb acih\gZcfYjYfU[UdYUbXVY``]YghUih
k]h\\ib[YfYjYfmcbY]b?]b[Xca7caYgYYaYXfYUgcbUV`mkY``!ZYX
Vihg\YÁXfYUXVcc_gUbX_bYkh\YfYkYfYdYcd`Yh\]bb]b[YjYfmk\YfY
h\]bb]b[ h\]bb]b[Ugg\Yg`Ydh g\YZcibXh\UhhfciV`]b[ cbYcZh\cgY
dUfUXclYg;cXVi``]YgacfhU`gk]h\ U``h\Ya]gYfUV`Y\Ub[Xc[>cVgcZh\Y
kcf`X h\YdYcd`Yk\cV`YYXUbXUW\YUbXXk]bX`YUbXgkccbUbX[Yh
VUW_idU[U]bUbXcZZYf<]ah\Y]fW\]b"BVSTOWbVTcZbV]aSdUhg]Yg h\ci[\h
K]``ck"5]RWaO^`]eZW\UOZZSgQObO\ReSO`SbVSe]c\RSR[WQSVSPObaO`]c\Rc\bWZ
bVSSdS`gROgbS``]`]TZWdW\U[OYSa]c`VSO`baaYWRb]Oab]^C[XYb \YUfhgcfY \UX
gcVVYXk\Ybh\YfUVV]hgX]gUddYUfYX \Yh\Y]fcbYhfiYUfXYbhUXa]fYf
UbXg]bWYh\Yb ]hÁggUZYhcgUm K]``ckUbX;cX\UXVYYbcbh\Ycihg"
H\Yd]dYfghcddYXd`Um]b[k\Yb\YgUkK]``ckUbX[f]bbYXh\Y
h\]bbYghcZ[f]bg"5gh\ci[\\YkYfYÉYfmXUm`][\hUbXg\YUgdY`ib_Yf
^ighYaYf[YXZfcaXYYd]bh\YVY``mcZUWUjY g\Y\UXhcgei]bhhc`cc_
Uh\]a UbXh\Yb\YfYmYgUX^ighYXhch\Yg][\hUbXg\YWci`XgYYbck
\]gWcUhf]dd`]b[UfcibX\]a hYYa]b[k]h\`]ZY ibXi`Uh]b[ h]XU`"H\Y
`]jY`mWcUhV[^V\][S`SU`]U`O[T]`bVWaRO\RWËSRPcUZS` h\ci[\hK]``ck YmYg
U[U]bbUffckYX \UbXggeiYYnYX]bhcÉghg hfm]b[hY`YdUh\]WU``mhchUaY
h\Y d]dYf UbX \]g hiai`hicig i`ghYf ]h kUg U k\]f`]b[ Wcgacg ibXYf
[`UggUbX\ib[]bgiW\UkUmUghcfYa]bXK]``ckcZUXfcd`YhcZkUhYf
UVcihhcZU``Zfcah\Ygd][ch"G\YgUkUbXWci`XgcaY\ck]XYbh]ZmU``h\Y
Ub]aU`ghUb[`YXhc[Yh\Yf]bh\YhYffUf]iacZh\YWcUh.g]b[`Y!WY``YXkf][!
[`YfgUbXW\][[YfgUbXb][\hgbU_YgUbXW\]\iU\iUbfUjYbgUbXgdchhYX
g_ib_g UbX VUbXYX gWi`d]bg UbX ZUhaiW_Yh aiggY`g UbX aYUXck`Uf_g
UbXg]W_`YÉbW\iVgUbXVclY`XYfVi[gUbXg]`jYf!\U]fYXVUhgUbXdcW_Yh
a]WYUbXaccbYmYgUbXVcVWUhgUbXVcVc`]b_gUbXV`UW_!hU]`YXdfU]f]Y
%%(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
Xc[gUbXai`YXYYfUbXaiXXUiVYfgUbXd]d]b[d`cjYfg cZWcifgY UbX
]bh\Ya]XX`YcZ]hU`` `cc_]b[ghibbYXUbX`c[mUgghckUkUm]aa][fUbhg
k\c^ighghYddYXkccn]`mcihcZghYYfU[YcbhcZcfY][bg\cfYg.h\cgYWUdU!
W]cig^UW_fUVV]hg=hgYYaYXUgh\ci[\h\YUb]aU`gkYfYhfUddYXVYbYUh\
[`Ugg/h\YmdUkYXUbXdYW_YXUbX[bUkYXVihh\YYX[YcZh\Yib]jYfgY
cZh\YWcUhkci`Xbch[]jY kci`XbchYjYbUXa]hhcVY]b[h\YYX[Y UbX
h\YUb]aU`g k]`XUgUbmcbYk]h\cihUX]gWYfb]V`Yd`UbYhVYbYUh\\YfZYYh
kci`XVY gYUfW\YXUbl]cig`mZcfWcjYf"K]``ck`cc_YX]bhch\Yd]dYfÁg
YmYgUbXWci`XgYYgcaYh\]b[kf]h\]b[h\YfYUgkY`` UbXg\YZYUfYXZcf
h\YUb]aU`g g\YZYUfYXZcfh\YW\]`XfYb g\YZYUfYXZcfXYUfC[[]Y\Yf
Vfch\Yf"/ZZ5]RÂaQVWZR`S\O\R\YÁgQ][Sb]QZOW[bVS[g\Yh\ci[\h"AcQVWabch
bVS9W\UR][]T6SOdS\C[[]Y\UXhc`XK]``ckh\Uh`]ZYVY[Ubk]h\\Yf½
V][[]f`h\Uhg\YkUg V][[Ygh]b?]b[Xca7caYUbXVYmcbX V][[Ygh]b
?UbgUg UghUhYTcZZcZUad`YaU]XYbg½g\YWci`X[]jY]hUbXhU_Y]hUkUm
UbX g\Y k]g\YX bck g\Y \UX VY`]YjYX \]a Vih U`kUmg a]ghU_Yb Zcf U
`iaVYf]b[Vcmk\Ybg\YkUgUhm_YUbX\Yf\U]fkUgVcVVYXUhh\YbUdY
g\YkUgbÁhcbYhcfYUX]`mjc`ibhYYfZcfh\YVfYYW\YgdUfh"BVObT`OcR^W^S`Âa
\][ObQVT]`g]c \YÁXgU]X 5]RRW\UOP]cbZWYSVSWaG]c`[]dS[S\baO`Sa][SbW[Sa
O[gabS`gO\Rg]c`VSO`bÂaPWUOa9O\aOaO\Rg]cÂR\SdS`ZSbO\gW\\]QS\bQ][Sb]VO`[
6ihg\Y\UXbÁhgUjYXh\YfUVV]hg"3dS\bVSac`ZWSab]T5]RÂaQ`SObc`SaRSaS`dSOT
TSQbW]\ d`YUXYXC[[]Y"<YÁXh\ci[\hh\YfUVV]hgWci`XVYfYZcfaYXk]h\
^ighU`]hh`Y`YhhiWY UgdUW]cigkUffYb UbXhfiY`cjY"6ihg\YkUgbcfY!
XYYaYf h\cgYfUVV]hgkYfYbÁh\Yf]bjYbh]cb k\ckUgg\YhchfmhcgUjY
Ubch\Yfk\Ybg\Y\YfgY`ZkUg`cgh3>ighhfmÉbX]b[h\YkYYbYYX`YcZ\Yf
gci`]bh\Uh\ig_m\UmghUW_cZÊYg\
H\YgcibXh\Yd]dYbckYa]hhYXkUgh\Y]bgcab]UW\iaa]b[cZ
h\cgYghfUdd]b[fUVV]hg UbXh\YW\]`XfYbgdfUb[hc gh]ZÊm `]_YghYddYX!
cb fU_Yg h\Yb h\Y]f VcX]Yg eiU_YX ]b gdUga ^Yf_YX UbX k\]f`YX UbX
h\fUg\YX UVcih k]h\ h\Y]f YmYg gh]`` gYU`YX UbX K]``ck h\ci[\h k]h\
UghUfh B]bS\bO\hH\YfYÁXVYYbUbYd]XYa]WcZXUbW]b[]bbY][\Vcf]b[
hckbg UbXaUbmghcf]YgÊcUhYXUacb[h\YW\]`XfYbcZ?]b[Xca7caY
UVcihh\YgdUgh]WZUbXUb[ccZh\Ygccb!hc!VY!XYUX k\]W\]gk\mmciÁX
bYjYf WUhW\ K]``ck <]aaY`ZUfV kU`hn]b[ ]b h\Y accb`][\h cf YjYb
gk]b[]b[\Yf\]dgVmh\Y`][\hcZh\YdcfW\ UbXk\YbK]``ckgUk\Yf
dUfYbhg Zclhfchh]b[ ]b h\Y _]hW\Yb UZhYf giddYf g\Y kYbh cihg]XY \]X
%%)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
VY\]bXh\YViZZU`cVYffmVig\ UbXh\fYkghcbYgUhh\Yk]bXckibh]`\Yf
ZUh\YfWUaYcihhc]bjYgh][UhY gifY]hkUgh\YGd]hnVV]gW\hk]bgZfca
bYlhXccfidhch\Y]figiU`\]^]b_g UbX\Yfach\YfWcbh]biYXW`YUf]b[
h\YhUV`Y fYhifb]b[h\YWcfbfY`]g\UbXf]bXd]W_`YUbXVihhYfa]`_hch\Y
]WYVcl"
H\Y\iaa]b[]bWfYUgYX]bd]hW\UbXZYfjcfUbXh]bmhi`]dgV`cg!
gcaYXcbh\YUfagUbX`Y[gUbXZUWYgcZh\YW\]`XfYb h\Y]fg_]bUÉY`X
cZÊckYfg VYUih]Zi` VYUih]Zi`Zc``ckYXVmUWU`mlcZdfciXÊYg\ghYa!
a]b[h\Y]fgdfYUX/[YfUb]iagV`ccaYXfYXUgUZfYg\kcibXZfcacdYb
acih\g UbXh\YW\]`XfYbÁggaU``VcX]YgdYfgd]fYXhcgiW\UXY[fYYh\Ym
`cc_YXfU]b!gcU_YX UbX K]``ck k\cWci`Xbch[Yh\Yf`YUXYb`Y[ghc
ViX[YUb]bW\ fYUW\YXcihhckUfXC[[]Y"G\YkUgUnYddY`]bWiaVYfYX
VmgUbXVU[g mYUfb]b[hcf]gYk]h\h\YfYgh UbXg\Y_bYkg\YÁXbYjYf[Yh
cZZh\Y[fcibX"C[[]YfYY`YXUbX[f]bbYXVih kci`XbÁh cdYb \]g YmYg
UbXg\YWci`XgYY]bh\Yg`UbhcZ\]gga]`Yh\Uh\YkUg\cd]b[hcaYYh
id U[U]b k]h\ h\cgY kU``cd]b[ fUVV]hg k\cÁX aYh Ub ibgYYa`m YbX ]b
?]b[Xca7caY ?UbgUg"
5bX h\Yb h\Y d]d]b[ ghcddYX h\ci[\ h\Y W\]`XfYb Wcbh]biYX hc
hk]hW\UbX`YUd"H\Yd]dYfWU``YXcihh\Y]fbUaYg"
3dOEWZZWO[:cR[WZZOO\R6O\a6SW\`WQVO\R/ZPS`bO\RCZ`WQVO\R/ZWQS
5gh\YbUaYgkYfYWU``YX W\]`XfYbÊYkid]bhch\YU]fUbXgd]fU`YXhc!
kUfXh\Yaccb`]_YZi``VU``ccbgk\cgYh\fcUhgUfYgiXXYb`mibh\fchh`YX
`ccd]b[`]_YUk\]f`][][\][\Yf]bhch\YYh\Yfibh]`h\YfYkUgcb`mUZU]bh
hk]b_`]b[]bh\YghfUhcgd\YfY"=bUbch\YfWcibhm UaUbk]h\UhY`YgWcdY
kci`XfYdcfhgdm]b[U¾dUggY`cZXm]b[ghUfg]bh\Yb][\hg_m U``k]h\h\Y
ZUWYgcZghUfh`YX W\]`XfYb"¿ K]``ckÁgYmYg Zc``ckYXh\YdUh\cZh\Yf]g!
]b[W\]`XfYb.ZU``YbÊYg\cbh\YkUmhcVYWca]b[U[U]b]bWcffidh]V`YU]f
5]RÂaQVO\USZW\Ua g\Yh\ci[\h"6SacQYabVSa^W`Wb]cb]TcaObPW`bVO\RZSOdSaPSVW\R
bVWa`SaWRcS]TÌSaV^WZTS`abVS[O``]eO\RRWaQO`RabVS`O\aOQYSRP]\SG\Y`cc_YX
XckbUh\YfckbZUhZYYh ZYYhh\Uh_Ydhh\YWcVV`YfcWWid]YX"BVS`SWa\]
acQVbVW\UOaOVc[O\PSW\U
C`acZO8]aS^VW\S7`[OZW\ROO\R=URS\K]``ckWf]YXcihUbXgUkC[!
[]Y cdYb \]g YmYg hkc Xc`YZi` V`ccag Ua]Xgh h\Y [UfXYb cZ \]g ZUWY"
5bXK]``ckWci`XgYY\]gÉbU`h\ci[\hUgUVcm.EVgSdS`e]cZR5]R`S
[OW\]\3O`bVTSSba]Ë`[Zg^ZO\bSRW\bVSa]WZeSWUVbgaV`cPeVWZSTOWbVTcZQVWZR`S\
%%*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
eS`S`]QYSbW\Ub]eO`R6SOdS\-G\Ykci`XbchhY``\YfdUfYbhg\ck\Y`cc_YX
\]gacih\k]XYb]b[]bhYffcfUg\]gZYYh`YZhh\Y[fcibX"G\Ykci`Xbch
hY``\YfdUfYbhgg\YWci`XgYYgcffck]bh\YkUm\]gYmYgÊ]W_YfYXh\Yb
X]aaYXUg\Y`cc_YXUh\Yf YmYgh\Uh\UXbYjYf_bckbgUXbYgg"
H\Y d]dYfÁg WcUh bck W\ifbYX Ub[f]`m UVcih \]a U WmW`cbY \Y
WcbXiWhYX k]h\ \]g d]d]b[ Zfca h\Y WU`a cZ h\Y YmY UbX K]``ck \UX
hcg\]Y`X\YfZUWYZfcah\Ygh]b[]b[fiVV`Y\Y_]W_YXid h\Yb\YV`Yk
cb\]gd]dYUÉbU`bchY h\YfUVV]hgVUfYXh\Y]fhYYh\UbXÊUhhYbYXh\Y]f
YUfgUYfcXmbUa]WU``m VfUWYXZcfjY`cW]hm UbXh\Yd]dYfUbX\]gdYbXUbh
ib]jYfgYX]gUddYUfYX]bh\YXigh \UVccg\
K]``ckkcVV`YXcb\Yf\UaamghYag"
G\YZcibX\YfgY`ZbcgYhcbcgYk]h\Ujc`YUgg\YUkc_YVYbYUh\
h\Yf]g]b[gib"K\Ybg\YcdYbYX\Yfacih\hcmUkb h\Yjc`Yhf]YXhc
fib h\YbgUb_]hgZYYh]bhch\Y[fcibX Vihh\Yk]bXcZ\Yf]b\U`Uh]cb
`]ZhYX]h]bhc\Yfacih\ UbXg\YWci[\YXk\Yb]hÊYkXckb\Yfh\fcUh
jU[iY]ff]hUbh/h\Yjc`Y k\cibh]`bck\UXcb`mYjYfXfYUahcZÊm]b[
kYbhgU]`]b[]bhch\YbYlhWcibhm.K]``ck\UX[fckb]bh\Yb][\h"5W!
hiU``mg\YZY`hUgg\YU`kUmg\UXUbXgcX]XbÁh_bck]Zg\YÁXYb`Uf[YXcf
h\Ykcf`X\UXg\fib_ Ugh\Ykcf`X\UgU\UV]hcZXc]b[ Vihg\YÉ[ifYX
Y]h\YfkUmh\Y[i]`hkUg\Yfg"
G\Y ghccX id `]ZhYX U bYgh cZ gdYW_`YX Y[[g cih cZ h\Y W`YZh cZ U
WfU[[mcU_ UhY]h UbXkYdh"G\Y\UXU`kUmgVYYbUdf]gcbYfcZ\Yfckb
UddYh]hY"
G\YfYaYaVYfYXUbidgYhh]b[ghcfmg\YÁXfYUXcbWYcZUbibkUj!
Yf]b[dUfUX]gY ghiVVcfb]b]hg]aaihUV]`]hm U`UbXcZacfY!h\Ub!d`Ybhm
\Yacff\U[]b[ a]`_ UbX \cbYm ccn]b[ k]h\ Vcibhm/ k\YfY hfYYg kYfY
\YUjmmYUf!fcibXk]h\hcch\gcaYZfi]hgh\UhX]XbÁh_bck\ckhcfch/U
WcaY`m`UbXZfYYcZh\YYmYgcfYcZ\iadVUW_YXWfcbYgUbXk\]g_YfYX
gd]bghYfg/ZfYYcZWUhUghfcd\]WXc[gUbXdi[]`]gh[cXgk\cV`UW_Ybmcif
YmYgch\YmWUbZcf[]jYmcih\Yg]bcZVY]b[Ugd]f]hk\c\Ugh\Y[U``hc
[iggm]hgY`Zid]bÊYg\cZU``h\Y\UfY!VfU]bYXgc`ih]cbg/U`UbXZfYYcZ
ZUhU`W\]`XfYb/k\YfYVUfbghcfa]b[acb_ghU_YgiXXYbÊ][\h h\YibZU]`!
]b[gibkUfa]b[h\Y]fhcbgifYXbc[[]bg UbXk\YY`UVcihcbh\YnYd\mf
cZ U`` h\Y ib\YYXYX dfY!dUfUX]gY cf]gcbg h\YmÁX YjYf ihhYfYX hYadhYX
%%+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
cihcZh\Yg_mcb`mk\Ybh\YUVVchdUXX`Ygh\YWfYUamgUXX`YcZUW\c!
gYbaU]XYb½h\kUd½ibh]`]h[`ckggcgWUf`Yh]hWUbVYgdchhYXZfcah\Y
accb UbXh\Yacb_ggYYh\YVYUWcbUbXghYYfh\YagY`jYgVUW_hckUfX
h\Y fibkUm k\YfY h\Y]f jYfm ckb VUfY!VchhcaYX bibg k]h\ Viag ]b
bYYXcZfYXXYb]b[UkU]hh\Ya/Ud`UWYk\YfYd][gdc`]hY`mfcUghh\Ya!
gY`jYg WfUW_`]b[ ghiW_ k]h\ _b]jYg UbX Zcf_g UbX hfch UWfcgg h\Y hUV`Y
cbW\UffYX\ccjYgfYUXmhcVYWUfjYX/k\YfY[YYgYUgWYbXUbXgcUfbYUf
hch\Ygib gY`Z!Vfc]`]b[ h\YbXfcdZfcah\Yg_mUbXÊm]bhch\Y[Ud]b[
acih\gcZh\YnUZh][UbXYhYfbU``mdYW_]g\ Wcc_YXUb]aU`g^ighgcaiW\
acfYfY`UlYXUbXUWWcaacXUh]b[h\Ubk]`XcbYg]bW`]bYXhcgbUf`UbX
VU`_Uhh\YZUhYcZaYUh h\YXYgh]bmcZZiY`]b[\iaUb]bXighfm h\Y`UVcf
cZaYUh!aU_]b[ZcfYlUad`YbcaUhhYf\ck[YbYfcig`mmcighiZZh\Y
[i``YhgcZ\iaUbVY]b[g h\YbYlhXUmh\YfYh\YmUfYU[U]b Xfcc`]b[UbX
ZUa]g\YXUg]ZbYjYfZYX bcaU[]WU``mai`h]d`m]b[Ég\Ygcf`cUjYgYjYf
Ybci[\ WifgYXk]h\\ib[Yfh]``h\YXUmh\YmX]Y WifgYX"EVObOaORPc\QV
]TW\aObWOPZSU`SSRgUcbah\ci[\hK]``ck [OYW\UbVSe]`ZRdO\WaVO[]cbVTcZObO
bW[S g\Y\YfgY`Zh\YkcfghcZZYbXYf \ib[fm \ib[fm WYUgY`Ygg`m\ib[fm"
5gK]``ckk]dYXh\Yg`YYdZfca\YfYmYg k\]W\bck`ccaYX]b
h\Yg_m g\Y]aU[]bYX `]_Yhkc[`ihhcbcigaccbg g\Ybch]WYXh]bm`]aVg
gWUhhYfYXcbh\Y[fcibX VcX]YgbYUh`mVihW\YfYX UfagUbXhcb[iYgUbX
`Y[gUbXYmYVU``g Éb[YfgUbXYUfg VfU]bgUbX\YUfhg ghfYkbYjYfmk\YfY
Ug]ZhcZYfh]`]nYh\YW`YUf]b[ UbXg\Yd]W_YXidUbUfaUbX\Y`X]hVY!
hkYYb\YfÉb[Yfg"=hkUgV`ccX`YggUbXfiVVYfmk]h\h\YkYYbg]YghÉb!
[YfbU]`g `]_YUXc``ÁgUfa"6ih]hkUgbÁhUXc``ÁgUfa"G\Y[Uh\YfYXU``h\Y
dUfhgg\YWci`XÉbX]bhch\YUW\]b[aUfgid]iacZ\Yfacih\ gcaYcZ
h\Yagh]``hfYaV`]b[k]h\fYÊYl UbXg\YWfUX`YX\YfkY][\hYXainn`Y
]b \Yf \UbXg" :WTSPSUW\aZWTSPSUW\aZWTSPSUW\aeWbV aY g\Y gUb[" G\Y ghccX
hckYf]b[ UbXh\YU]fg\Ybch]WYXkUggch\]b \Yf\YUXZY`h`]_YU\Y`]ia
VU``ccbaU_]b[UVfYU_Zcfh\Y\YUjYbg Xf]Zh]b[YjYfZUfh\YfZfca\Yf"
H\Y\UfX[fcibXVYbYUh\\YfZYYh a]`YgUbXa]`YgUkUmbck fcgYid
ei]W_`mUbXkU``cdYX\Yf]bh\YZUWY"
%%,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
H\Uhacfb]b[ h\YhckbUkc_YhcÉbX]hgY`Zdif[YXcZW\]`XfYb"
H\YkcaYbk\ckU]`YXUhh\YV]fh\!\cifZY``g]`Ybh UbXh]aYghiaV`YX
ZcfkUfX k]h\cih UbmcbY bch]b[ ]hg dUggU[Y" H\Y d\Ubhca dU]bg h\Uh
kci`XgccbghUVh\Ya h\Y]fÉb[Yfg h\Y]fVY``m h\Y]f\YUfh UbUW\]b[Zcf
k\]W\h\YfYkUgbcgi]hUV`Yh\ibXYf kci`XVYh\YkY][\hcZh\Y]fW\]`XÁg
ZUWY]bh\Y]f\UbXg UbUfh\f]h]W`cb[]b[h\Uhkci`Xei]W_`m[bUf`h\Y]f
[fUgd"Bckh\YgcibXcZgh]ÊYXgcffckkUgh\Yaig]Whck\]W\dYcd`Y
ghYddYX]b?]b[Xca7caY YmYgU`kUmggYUfW\]b[h\Yb][\hg_mcfh\Y
VUb_gcZh\Yf]jYfZcfgcaYg][bcZ;ObWZROO\R3^V`OW[3hSYWSZO\R6O\\OVµ
H\YfYkYfYh\cgYk\cgU]Xh\YW\]`XfYb gcgi[[Ygh]V`Y \UXgifY`mZc`!
`ckYXh\YfUVV]hg]bhch\Yf]jYf \UXkUbhYXhcgYYk\YfYh\Yf]jYfkci`X
`YUXh\YibkUbhYX VihbcVcX]YgkYfYZcibXcbh\YfcW_gUbXXfU[[]b[
h\Yf]jYfm]Y`XYXcb`mh\YigiU`XYhf]hig a]`_Vchh`YgUbXVcl]b[[`cjYg
UbX V]fXWU[Yg UbX gUlcd\cbYg UbX WckVcm Vcchg UbX VYUf hfUdg UbX
_]hW\Ybg]b_gUbXfcW_ggcaYZc`_gh\ci[\hh\YkUhYf\UXk\]hh`YX]bhc
h\Yk]bgcaYj]gU[YcZh\Y6`YggYXJ]f[]bbchh\Uhh\YgY@ih\YfUbgYjYf
dU]Xh\YJ]f[]baiW\\YYX½Uj]f[]bk\cUddYUfg]bUVck`cZk\YUh]bU
cfWf]YgV`ccXcb\c`mXUmg U`kUmgaU_]b[UgdYWhUW`YcZ\YfgY`Zh\UhcbY
gbcfh"Ch\YfggU]XdYf\Udgh\YW\]`XfYb\UXa]gd`UWYXh\Y]f]bbcWYbWY½
]h\UX[cbYXckb[if[`]b[k]h\h\Y`UghUWWifgYXfUVV]h½UbXbckkYfY
ZYUfZi`cZh\Y]fckbYbXgc\UX`YZhhcgYY_cihh\YgYXiWh]jY[`ccacZ
h\Y HfUbgm`jUb]U h\Ym \UX gYWfYh`m fYUX UVcih ]b h\Y]f W`cgYhg Uh b][\h
UbXh\Y]aacfhU`]n]b[]bW]gcfgcZh\cgYaYff]`mYlgUb[i]bUhYXIbXYUX"
5bXh\YfYkYfYh\YXYjcihUbX\cdYZi`h\ci[\ZUa]g\YX\cdYU`kUmg
ZUXYgk\YbibZYXk\ckYfYWcbj]bWYXh\YW\]`XfYb\UXhfUjY`YX]bhc
h\Y\ck`]b[k]`XYfbYggUbXkYfYWfigUX]b[k]h\kUmZUf]b[:`U[Y``Ubhg
gdfYUX]b[h\YKcfXVYhkYYbmY`dg.;cXck;cXck;cXck;cX"Gh]``
ch\YfgVY`]YjYXh\YW\]`XfYb k\c\UXU``VYYbZYjYf]g\h\Yb][\hVYZcfY
WcbhfUWhYXUkUbXYf]b[X]gYUgYh\UhUZÊ]Whgcb`mh\YgaU``!ZcchYXUbX
kYfY gcaYk\YfY cb h\Y d`U]bg kUX]b[ VUfYZcch h\fci[\ dfU]f]Y [fUgg
kU`_]b[h\YagY`jYghcXYUh\"H\]gh\Ycfm[Uh\YfYXh\YacghacaYbhia
Uacb[h\YhckbgZc`_ZcfUh]aYVYWUigYh\YcbYaYaYbhch\YW\]`XfYb
\UX`YZhVY\]bXkUgh\Y]fg\cYg dU]fgcZk\]W\Wci`XVYZcibXg]hh]b[
Yadhmh\fci[\cihh\Yhckb ]bh\Ygcf[\iaÉY`X VYbYUh\U`]bXYbhfYY
]bU\Um`cZh h\Y[UnYVc VYWUigYh\YW\]`XfYb fU]gYXf][\h \UXbÁhkUbhYX
%%-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
hcgc]`8YUh\Ág]aaUWi`UhY`cX[]b[gUbXgc\UXdc`]hY`mfYacjYXh\Ya
UbX`YZhh\YaUhh\YXccf"CZWcifgY]hkUgU`Ufa]b[hch\]b_h\YdcfhU`
hcYhYfb]hmWci`XcdYbVYbYUh\UbmcbYÁgZYYh YjYbh\YV`UaY`YggZYYhcZ
]bZUbhg UhUbmacaYbh"6ihVY\]bXh\]ggdYWi`Uh]cbkUgh\Yibgdc_Yb
Wcbj]Wh]cb h\Uh ]h kUg <Yff DZY]ZZYf k\c kUg h\Y gcifWY cZ h\Y]f V`iY
fi]b UbXh\UhÁgk\Yb^cmZi`bc]gYkUgcZÉW]U``mcih`UkYX]b?UbgUg YjYb
gcb[V]fXg jYfVchYb UbX V]fXg fYaUddYX h\Y]f a][fUh]cbg UfcibX h\Y
ÊUh`UbXg Êm]b[ \ibXfYXg cZ a]`Yg cih cZ h\Y]f kUm VYWUigY cZ WcifgY
fUfY]gh\YV]fXk\cWUbUV]XYUgcibX`Yggg_mcfUacfb]b[UkU_YbYXVm
g]`YbWY"9jYbWfckg h\cgYbUhhYf]b[[cgg]dg `]_YUaY`cX]ciggibf]gY"
:YkdYcd`YfYWU``h\Uhh\Yg_mcjYf?]b[Xca7caYkUgcbWYmY`!
`ckk]h\WUbUf]Yg"5ZhYfh\YW\]`XfYbX]gUddYUfYX WUbUfm\ibhYfgd]W_YX
h\YacihcZh\YU]fcbYVmcbY UbXbckbch\]b[g]b[g]b?UbgUg"K]Xck
K]b_`Yfhf]YXhcainn`Y\YfgkYYhDYhib]U k\ckUg_bckbhck\]gh`Y
U``cZEOZRahS\S\k]h\`]hh`YYbWcifU[YaYbh UbX\]X\Yf]bh\YWY``Uf Vih
WUbUfmhfUW_YfgYjYbhiU``mgb]ZZYX\YfcihUbXZcfWYXh\Y]fkUm]bhch\Y
k]XckÁg\cigY UfaYXk]h\UVckh\Yg]nYcZUgkU``ckhU]`VihhYfÊmUbX
Uei]jYfcZkYYUffckgh\Ymg`ib[cjYfh\Y]fh\iaVg UbXVYhkYYbhkc
Éb[Yfgh\YhckbÊYhW\Yf ?]b[Xca7caY?]b[cZh\YDcd]b^Um \Y`Xh\Y
UfVU`Ygh UbXk]h\]bXYlÉb[YfUbXh\iaVWUfYZi``mbcW_YXh\Ybg\ch
UbUffckk\cgYÊ][\hgkYfYÊYhW\YXk]h\h\YZYUh\YfgcZch\Yfg`U]b
WUbUf]Yg ]bhc DYhib]UÁg hYff]ÉYX \YUfh" G\Y kUg ZfUbh]WU``m kUfV`]b[
h\YVY[]bb]b[cZ¾H\Y6]fXDfcd\Yh ¿hfm]b[hcZcfYghU``\YfckbZUhY
k\Yb h\Y Uffck ghfiW_ \Yf UbX h\Y aUf_gaUb kYdh k\Yb g\Y ZY`` hc
h\Y[fcibX"Bch`cb[UZhYf K]XckK]b_`Yf\YfgY`Z[UjYidh\Y[\cgh
h\Ycb`mh\]b[Ug]XYZfcaDYhib]UUbXGW\Uhng\YÁXVYYb\U`Z\YUfhYX`m
W`]b[]b[hcZcfmYUfg DYhib]U`m]b[cbh\Yd]``ckbYlhhc\Yf h\Yh]bmUf!
fck`cX[YX]b\YfVfYUghUgh\ci[\g\YkYfY`]hh`YacfYh\UbUWcW_hU]`
gUigU[Ygd]bX`YXcbUhcch\d]W_"
K\Ybh\YV`ccXfU]bgVY[Ub UkYY_UZhYfh\YW\]`XfYbX]gUddYUfYX
?]b[Xca7caYfg_bYkVYhhYfh\UbhcVY`]YjYk\Uhh\YgW]Ybh]ghgkYfY
gUm]b[ k\]W\kUgh\Uhh\YfU]bXfcdg\UXaYfY`mWc``]XYXk]h\]fcbcl]XY
cbh\YkUmXckb Wcbgiadh]jYghYY`a]``g\Uj]b[Wci[\YXh\YfYXXigh
]bhch\YUhacgd\YfY"DUfYbhg \ckYjYf kYfYk]gYhch\YkUmgcZUWUf!
b]jcfcigib]jYfgYUbXh\Ym_bYkh\YmkYfYVY]b[fU]bYXcbVmh\Y]fckb
%&$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
W\]`XfYb h\Uh]hkUgh\Y]fW\]`XfYbÁgV`ccXh\UhfUbXckbh\Y]fW\YY_g
UbXh\YmdihcihaUgcb^Ufg]bk\]W\hcWc``YWh]h Vihh\YbYlhXUmh\Y
^UfgkYfYU`kUmgYadhm bcfYg]XiYcZfYXfU]bfYaU]b]b[cbh\Y[`Ugg"
GcaY dYcd`Y ghUmYX id U`` b][\h kUhW\]b[ h\Y ^Ufg kU]h]b[ hc gYY h\Y
V`ccXjUb]g\ XUf]b[]hhcX]gUddYUf]bh\Y]fdfYgYbWY h\Y]fckbV`ccX
6ihV`ccXÁgUVcfbaYgaYf]gh UbX]hkU]hYXZcfh\YYmY`]XghcXfccdk]h\
ZUh][iY h\YbU``U_\UnUa.h\YfYV`]b_[cbY `]_YYjYfmh\]b[]bh\Ykcf`X"
AcghdYcd`YVY`]YjYX;cXkUgbchXYUX XYgd]hYh\Y\YUX`]bYg VihYjYb
h\YZcfaYf`md]cigXYW]XYXU``h\YgUaYhckUg\h\Y]f\UbXgcZ<]aUbX
hcghcfYh\YfUW_UVcbYgcZh\Y]fgci`gUh<]g\cigY"5ZhYfh\YfU]b\UX
ZU``Yb h\YhckbUddYUf]b[aUi`YX dYcd`Ykci`XÉbXUf]VVcbcfdU]fcZ
[`UggYg UgcW_ UbYW_`UWY h\UhVY`cb[YXhccbYcZh\Y]fW\]`XfYb UbXh\Y
W\ifW\ `cb[XYgYfhYXUbXkU]h]b[hcVYfUnYXVm;cXÁgbchcf]cigdi[!
bUW]hm kUgWcbjYfhYX]bhcUfY`]eiUfm k\YfYU``h\YgY]hYagkYfYghcfYX"
H\Y g\cYg h\Ym `]bYX id bYUh`m VYbYUh\ h\Y dYkg" DUfYbhg bck gdYbh
h\Y]fXUmgWcad]`]b[`]ghgcZfY[fYhg dU[YidcbdU[Y UbYbhfmZcfYUW\
XUm]bh\YW\]`XÁg`]ZYh\YmkYfYgcffmh\Ymkci`Xa]gg UbXh\Ymd`UWYX
h\Y]fVcc_cZXcWiaYbhYXacifb]b[]bhch\Y]fW\]`XfYbÁgg\cYg \cd]b[
h\YgYhcca][\hX]gUddYUf a][\hÊmidUbXcihcZh\Ykcf`X"CZWcifgY
aUbm h\]b[g jUb]g\ Zfca h\]g kcf`X k]h\cih U acaYbhÁg kUfb]b[½
dfcgdYf]hm gUb]hm iaVfY``Ug `cjY½Vihbchgcffck bYjYfgcffck.gcffck
U`kUmgkYUfgh\]b]hgkY`WcaY"
H\YhckbfYgYbhYX\Uj]b[Uk]hbYgghcUbUVXiWh]cbVihbcYUfh\`m
gc`ih]cb hc h\Y Wf]aY YgdYW]U``m U k]hbYgg k\cÁX gigd]W]cig`m XciV`YX
]b g]nY gkY``]b[ hc XYW]XYX`m ibZYa]b]bY dfcdcfh]cbg cjYf b][\h UbX
]hg\ckYXK]``ck]hgVUW_"DYcd`Yk\]gdYfYXh\UhK]``ckkUgUk]W_YX
gdYW]YgcZ_cVc`Xk]h\UXUg\cZfUjYbcig[]Ubh]b\Yf[YbYgUbXh\Uh
g\Y\UXWfUk`YXcihcZUWUjYk\Ybg\YkUgVcfbUbXW\cgYbh\]ghckb
hcaYbUWYVYWUigY]hVcUghYXacfYW\]`XfYbh\Ubacgh UZYfh]`Yhckb
?]b[Xca7caY"/ZeOgaaca^SQbSRbVOb]\Se]cZRPS\]bVW\UPcbb`]cPZS h\YmgU]X
P]RgZWYSbVOb"GcaYgU]Xh\Ym_bYkZcfUZUWhg\YUhYW\]`XfYb gkU``ckYX
h\Yak\c`Y`]_YUgd]f]b½8cabZ]]YObVS`<]^]`YQcbZSbSdS`[ORSOP]RgU`]eZWYS
h\Uh½UbX]ZmciWihcdYb\YfghcaUW\ mciÁXÉbXh\YaU``h\YfYkU]h]b[
hcVYYlhfUWhYX dccf`]hh`Yhiacfg W`ihW\]b[h\Y]fWc`XZYYh"Ch\YfdYc!
d`YgU]Xh\YmgUk\YfXUbW]b[Uhb][\hibXYfU[]VVcigaccb g_]bV`iY
%&%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
UgUd`ia hfm]b[hcdYfgiUXY]hhcÊUibh]hgZi``VY``mYjYfmeiUfhYf hYadh
]hhckUlUbXkUl`]_Y\Yf"K]``ck[fYkUbX[fYk V][Ugh\Y5`dg ]bhc
h\Yg_m VY\YUXYXVmW`ciXg fidhifYXh\Yg_mcjYf?]b[Xca7caY Wcb!
gcfh]b[k]h\V]fXg UbXdYcd`YgU]Xg\YkUghU_]b[idgdUWYh\Uhg\ci`X
\UjYVYYb]b\UV]hYXVmW\]`XfYb"GcaYh]aYgh\YmV]h\YfghifXmUb_`Yg
UbXg\Y`Yhh\Ya"BccbYYjYfU[U]baYbh]cbYXh\cgY]bZYfbU`fUVV]hg
]bZYghYXk]h\a]gYfm"
K]``ck bc[fiaV`Yf hcc_]hcb\Yfg]nUV`YW\]b`]_YUW\Uad"G\Y
\UX_bckbk\Uh]hkUg`]_YhcVYh\YcV^YWhcZh\YVcibX`YggUXcfUh]cb
cZUgaU``Vcm UkcbXfcigh\]b["=hkUgcb`mZU]f g\Yh\ci[\h h\Uhg\Y
g\ci`X_bckhcck\Uh]h]g`]_YhcVY`cUh\YX hcVYh\ci[\hUbUVca]bU!
V`YWUbb]VU`XYacb"<YfdUfYbhgVcfYh\Yg\UaYcZVY]b[h\Ycb`mdUf!
Ybhgk\cgYW\]`Xgifj]jYXh\YZUhYZi`d]d]b[ UbX\Yfach\YfgdYbh\Yf
XUmgVU_]b[WighUfXd]YgUbXW\YffmWcVV`YfgUbXUdd`Yg`iad VUgh]b[
Vf]g_Yhg g]aaYf]b[giWWchUg\ k\]dd]b[id[f]XX`YWU_YgZcfVfYU_ZUgh
WUbb]b[f\iVUfVUbXdYUW\Yg U``Zcfh\Ych\YfdUfYbhg k\cdfcadh`m
hcggYXYjYfm[fiV[]Zhg\YVfci[\hh\Ya]bhch\YhfUg\cf`YZh]hg]hh]b[cb
h\YghccdZcfh\YZUhhYbYXZclYgUbX`cbYgcaYXc[g_]W_YXhch\YWifV"
H\YmÁXYUhbUfmUacfgY`dfYdUfYXVmh\Yach\YfcZYj]` `Yhh\YakUghY
hcVcbYÉfgh
5hb][\h k\]`Y\YfdUfYbhggUh]bUXUf_YbYXdUf`cf K]``ck`Umcb
\YfVUW_UbXhf]YXhcgh]hW\h\YghUfghc[Yh\Yf]bh\Y]aU[YcZC[[]Y UbX
g\Yh\ci[\hhc\YfgY`Zh\Uhh\Yg_mkUgUg[ccXU[iUfX]UbUgUbm WYfhU]b`m
acfYUV`Yh\Ub\iaUbg k\cUfYgcZU``]V`Y]hÁgU`kUmgaYfY`mUaUhhYfcZ
h]aYVYZcfYh\YmaU_YUaYggcZU``h\YmhciW\"H\Yib]jYfgYk]``cbYXUm
ghcdhcfYgh]hgkYUfmfYaU]bgUbXh\Yb[]jYid h\ci[\hK]``ck fYZigYhc
VYdfcjc_YX]bhcVY]b[U[U]b VmUV][VUb[cfUgYUaghfYggac`Yk]h\Ub
YbX`Yggg_Y]bcZh\fYUXcfUkYY_cZ;cX`m`UVcfcfUX]gaYaVYfYXXY]hm
k\cgYdUfhgUfY]hW\]b[hcVYfYUb]aUhYX]bh\Yg\UdYcZacibhU]bgUbX
f]jYfg VYWUigY\iaUbgk]``\UjYÉbU``mUbX]ffYjYfg]V`mgkUddYX`cjYZcf
kUf `]ZYZcfXYUh\ UbXV`ccX]YXh\Yd`UbYhVih[ccX WUigYX]hhc\Yacf!
f\U[YVYmcbXU``ghUbW\]b["
%&&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
H\Y`UghgcibX?]b[Xca7caYYjYf\YUfXkUgh\YgcibXcZh\Y
YUfh\g\iXXYf]b[UgK]``ck<]aaY`ZUfVkU`_YX]bhch\Yf]jYfUbXh\Y
aifaifcZh\YkUhYfUg]hdUfhYXUfcibX\Yf`Y[g k\]W\ghccXghU`kUfhUg
g]`cg h\Ybg\YgUhXckbUbX\YfVcXmXUaaYXh\Yf]jYf UbXh\Yhckbg!
dYcd`Yg`YdhZcfh\YÉfghh]aYg]bWYh\Y]fW\]`XfYb\UXX]gUddYUfYX g`Ydh
]bh\Y]fW\]`XfYbÁgVYXg"H\YfYkUgbÁhYbci[\f]jYfZcfK]``ckhcXfckb
\YfgY`Z½h\YfY kUgbÁh Ybci[\ kUhYf ]b U`` cZ ?UbgUg Zcf h\Uh½Vih h\Y
kUhYffcgYUbXfcgYUfcibX\YfUbXÊccXYXh\Y`UbX gkU``ck]b[dfU]f]Y
UbX Wfcdg UbX UihcacV]`Yg UbX VUfbg UbX h\fYg\Yfg UbX ÉbU``m \cig!
Yg W`YUbg]b[h\YhckbcZ]hg\YUfhUW\Y h\YdUfYbhgcZh\Y`cghW\]`XfYb
[ig\]b[ Zcfh\ cih cZ VYXfcca k]bXckg VcVV]b[ ]b h\Y YgWUdYX f]jYf
VYg]XYWcZZYYdchgUbXcjYfWcUhgUbX`Uadg\UXYgUbXUXX]b[aUW\]bYg
UbXd]hW\Zcf_gUbXgbYU_YfgUbXhiVUgUbXmc!mcgUbX]bWcad`YhYgYhg
cZYbWmW`cdYX]Ug g]b[]b[ g]b[]b[ g]b[]b[ g]b[]b[ \Udd]`mUVXiWhYXVm
kUhYf"
T]`/ZS\O9ObVZSS\EWZa]\
%&'
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
85F5K=9F
BVSEWhO`R
)
A h XUkb UbX Uh Xig_ = `YUjY h\Y \cigY hc [fUnY ]b h\Y aYUXck
VYmcbXh\Yf]jYf"H\YfYÁgUhfU]`=ÁjYWcjYfYXk]h\ghfUkhcZc``ck
UbXUWcbjYb]Ybhghf]b[cZVci`XYfg=WUbigYhcaU_YamkUmUWfcggh\Y
kUhYf"=g`YYdU``h\fci[\h\YXUmUbXkcf_h\fci[\h\Yb][\h"=hÁgfUfYZcf
aYhcYjYfgYYUbch\Yfgci`"BcbYYXhcgYYUbch\Yf"=Áa`cgh]bamYl!
dYf]aYbhgk\Yb=ÁaUkU_YUbXcjYfhU_YbVmXfYUagcZUbch\Yfkcf`X
Ukcf`Xib]b\UV]hYXVm\iaUbg k\Yb=ÁaUg`YYd"5bX=\UjYamV]fXg"
=hWcaZcfhgaYhc_bckh\YmÁfYfccgh]b[k\Yb=Áakcf_]b["K\Yb=Áa
g`YYd]b[ h\Y]fW`]W_g WU``g UbXgcb[dfcj]XYUgcibXhfUW_ZcfamXfYUag"
K]h\mci]ba]bX=kcf_hcWcbh]biYk]h\k\UhkY\UXghUfhYXVYZcfY
mciXYdUfhYX" K]h\mci]ba]bXk\Ybamgd]f]hgdU`Y=[ccb"H\YfY
UfYkUmg]bk\]W\k\Uh=XcWcbÊ]Whgk]h\k\Uh=_bckmciÁX]bhYbXYX"
H\]g]gk\m=gcaYh]aYgmYUfbZcfgcaYkUmhcWcbhUWhmciX]fYWh`m"=Z=
dig\h\]b[gcbYkUm =h\]b_cZ\ckmcikci`X\UjYg\ckbaYhcdig\
]bUbch\YfX]fYWh]cb"=cZhYb]aU[]bYmcifYmYggYUfW\]b[h\fci[\a]bY"
=ÁjYhf]YXhc]aU[]bYmcifZUWYUg]hkUgh\Y`Ughh]aY=gUkmci"HccdU]b!
Zi`ZcfaYhcVYUf gc=fYgcfhhcfYWU``]b[ch\YfYUf`]Yf`YggÉbU`hfUbg!
UWh]cbg"=h]gdcgg]V`YZcfaYhcU``ckmcif\UbXhcgiVgh]hihYZcfa]bY
k\Yb=hifbU_YmcfX]ah\Y`][\hg]bh\Yacfb]b["=h]gdYfa]gg]V`Yhc
fYaYaVYfk\YfYkYkYfYghUbX]b[k\YbkYÉfghbch]WYXcbYUbch\Yf"
=Xc\UjYd\chc[fUd\gcZmci=_YYd]bUdYkhYfVcl]bUWUV]bYh"5h
h]aYg=giWWiaVhcmcifUVgYbWYÁghc``k\]`YU``ck]b[amgY`Zhcib`cW_
h\YWUV]bYh"=hÁgigiU``mk\Ybamkcf_\Ug[cbYYgdYW]U``mkfcb[h\Uh
=Xch\]g"CbYcZh\Yd]WhifYg\UXbchaiW\XfUkbam]bhYfYghibh]`=
bch]WYXVYg]XYmcik\YfYmcikYfYgYUhYXU`Uf[Y[`UggÉg\Vck`cZVfc!
_YbVYUW\[`Ugg"=h\UXVYYbh\YZUg\]cbhch]bhd\chc[fUd\gXif]b[h\Y
h]aY=]aU[]bYh\]gcbY\UXVYYbhU_Yb"=WUbÁhVYgifY]Zh\YZU]bhV`iYg
UbXd]b_gkYfYUXXYXcf]Zh\Yd]WhifYfYdfYgYbhgUbUWWifUhYfY[]ghYf
cZh\YVYUW\[`UggYgÁjU[iY`mbcghU`[]WWc`cfg"=hZUgW]bUhYXaYhcd]WhifY
%&(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
mciWc``YWh]b[k\UhUddYUfghcVYUh`YUghUZYk\ibXfYXd]YWYg"=fYWU``
mcifhY``]b[aY\ckfUfY]h\UXVYWcaYVmh\Yh]aYmcikYfY`]j]b[cb
h\Y]g`UbXhcÉbXh\YgYh\]b[g"K\ccZhYb_bckgk\mcbYfYaYaVYfg
cbYh\]b[]bd`UWYcZUbch\Yf"DYf\UdgcbY]bjYbhgUaYacfmcbYkci`X
dfYZYfhc\UjY"6mXc]b[gc cbY]gh\YbUV`YhcZYY`]ad`]WUhYX ]bhf]bg]!
WU``mbYWYggUfmhch\Y\YUfhcZh\YaUhhYf"K\Yb=h\]b_cZmci Ug=Xc
acfYUbXacfYcZhYb ]h\UgVYWcaYam\UV]hhcgYYmciUhXig_cfUh
XUkbkU`_]b[cbh\YVYUW\ gYUfW\]b[ZcfUbch\YfdU`YV`iYVchh`Y`]dcf
[\cgh`md]b_bYW_hcUXXhcmcifWc``YWh]cb"=ÁaUkUfYmciÁjYbYjYfgdc!
_YbhcaYcZkU`_gcbUVYUW\cfUbUZhYfbccbcbUdcfW\ UbXmYhk\Yb=
giVa]hama]bXhcfYÊYWhcbmciUbXk\Uhmci\UjYaYUbhhcaY ]h]ghc
h\]gjYfg]cbcZmci=giffYbXYf"@UhY`m=ÁjY[fckbYbj]cigcZUd\Ubhca
=ÁjY]aU[]bYXhU_]b[h\Yd]WhifY"Amf]jU`ZcfmcifUZZYWh]cb"=bckgYY
cbmcifZUWYUacgh`ilif]cig`cc_cZWcad`]W]hmUbXd`YUgifY"=hX]ghifVg
aYh\Uh=ÁaZUgW]bUhYXVmUÉg\Vck`cZ[`UggcZk\]W\mcihU_Ybcbch]WY"
=ÁaUg\UaYXcZh\YhYff]V`YbYYX=ZYY`hc\UjYVYYbk]h\mcicbh\YXUm
h\Yd]WhifYkUghU_Yb"=ÁaYaVUffUggYXk\Yb=ÉbXamgY`Z\c`X]b[h\Y
WUaYfUk\]`Y=`YUbU[U]bghUdcfW\fU]`\Uj]b[^ighXY`]jYfYXZcfmcif
UaigYaYbhUgdUf_cZk]hcfUV]hcZa]gW\]YZ"Mcif\UbXg k\]W\=ÁjY
cZhYbVY`]YjYXhcVYh\YacghVYUih]Zi`\UbXg]bh\Ykcf`X UfYfU]gYXhc!
kUfXh\Yd\chc[fUd\Yf]bgiW\UkUmh\UhaU_Yg]hd`U]bmciÁfYcZZYf]b[
h\YaidZcf]bgdYWh]cb"=gYYamZUWYfYÊYWhYX]bk]bXck[`UggVY\]bX
k\YfYmciUfYgYUhYX"K\Ybh\]gcWWifghcaY =ZYY`hcckYU_hchU_Yam
bYlhVfYUh\"=gcaYh]aYgÉbXamgY`ZgYUhYXUhUhUV`Y`cc_]b[UhUVUg]b
cZkUhYf]bk\]W\am\UbXgUddYUfhcVYÊcUh]b["Amg_]b diW_YfYXUbX
kf]b_`YX h\YkUmg_]b]gh\UhÁg`cb[VYYb]aaYfgYX]bkUhYf"Ama]bX
k]``\UjYghcddYXkcf_]b[ Ug]ZUa]bXWUbVYfY[i`UhYXk]h\Ugk]hW\"
=ÁjYVYWcaYUWWighcaYXhc\Uj]b[hckU]h gcaYh]aYgZcfXUmgUhUh]aY
VYZcfY\Uj]b[Ubch\Yfh\ci[\h"K\cUfYmci k\cigYgaYh\]gkUm hc
gUmk\Uh\Yk]g\YghcgUm3
%&)
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
=A5BHGN=98CB=G
HfUbg`UhYXVm6]h]hYJ]b_`Yfg
Be]BOZSa
)
BVSGSZZ]eBOZS
%&*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BVS0ZcSBOZS
5V`iY\cfgY]bUÉY`XcZV`iYVY``g"MYg UV`iY\cfgY"=gUk\]a
mYghYfXUm"<YkUgYUh]b[V`iYVY``g UbX=_bckk\m\Y]gV`iY"
<cfgYgZfcah\Yk\c`Ykcf`X\UX[Uh\YfYXZcfUWcbZYfYbWY"5``
cZ h\Ya½W\Yghbih k\]hY VUm V`UW_ gcffY` Xib XUdd`YX [fUm½kYfY
kcff]YX"¾=ZaUW\]bYghU_YcjYfh\Ykcf`X ¿h\YmgU]X ¾kYaUmVYWcaY
Ylh]bWh"5`fYUXmcifV]fh\fUhY\UgXYW`]bYX"5bXcifY`XYfg[Yhg\]ddYX
cZZhcZcl!fU]g]b[ZUfag"@YhÁgWfYUhYU\cfgYk\ck]``VYYhYfbU`¿
H\YmXYW]XYXh\YYhYfbU`\cfgYkci`XVYV`iY.h\YWc`cfcZ`cb[]b[
UbX\cdY cZ\mUW]bh\g UbYacbYg Zcf[Yh!aY!bchg"H\YmbUaYX\]ah\Y
6`iY<cfgYcZ<cdYUbX[UjY\]aV`iYk]b[g"<Ykci`XVY[iUfX]Ubhc
U``k\cmYUfbYX"
5bXVYWUigYh\Y`cbY`mmYUfbh\Yacgh h\YV`iY\cfgYkci`X`]jY
U`cbY"<Ykci`X\UjYbcZf]YbXg bcaUhY bcV`iYWc`hg/\Ykci`XVY
ib]eiYUbXYhYfbU`"H\YV`iY\cfgY[fYkgUX Vihh\Ych\YfggU]XgUXbYgg
kUgV`iYUbXgi]hYX\]a"
¾MciUfYU\cfgYZfcaUXfYUa ¿h\YmgU]X"¾=ZmciYUhUbXXf]b_
`]_Yig mcifV`iYWc`cfk]``ZUXYUbXmcik]``X]Y"MciaighYUhZcf[Yh!
aY!bchg UbX ch\Yf V`iY ÊckYfg" ;c d`Um ]b h\Y V`iY g_m gk]a ]b h\Y
V`iYgYUK\YbmciUfYh\]fghm `cc_ZcfUV`iYgdf]b[Êck]b[k]h\\cdY.
GcaYk\YfYVYmcbXUV`iYacibhU]b ]bUV`iYZcfYghk\YfY Uacb[h\Y
gdfiWYg h\fYYV`iYU`XYfg[fck"K\YfYh\ibXYf k]h\h\fYYV`iYVc`hg ]g
\ibh]b[\UfYg"K\YfYh\fYYV`iYW`ciXg\UjYZU``YbUg`YYd]bUV`iYVUf!
fY`"K\YfYµkY`` mciÁ``ÉbX]hmcifgY`Z"6ih]ZmciXcbÁh Xf]b_cb`mZfca
dU]`gUbXVck`gh\UhUfYV`iY"
¾FYaYaVYf mciaigh`]jYZUfUkUm ]bh\YX]ghUbhV`iY\UnY"DYc!
d`YgYUfW\]b[Zcf\cdY[UnY]bhch\YX]ghUbWY ]bhch\Yg_m ZcfYgh gYU"Mci
WUbUddfcUW\ch\Yfgcb`m]bh\Yhk]`][\hcZXig_cfXUkb"¿
5bXgckYgYY\]agY`Xca"5`acghbYjYf"6ih]bYUf`mgdf]b[ k\Yb
h\fig\YgfYhifbUbXUbYacbYgV`cggcaibXYfh\Y\UnY`g `cc_WUfYZi``m.
XcmcigYY\]g\ccZdf]bhg3@cc_]bh\Y[UfXYb.\Ug\YYUhYbh\Y\mU!
W]bh\g3=bgiaaYfh]aY kU`_ei]Yh`mdUghh\YÊUl]bV`ccaUbXÉY`XgcZ
fmYk]h\WcfbÊckYfg"H\YV`iY\cfgY]g[fUn]b[h\YfY"
%&+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
CbYXUm`Ughgdf]b[ \YUhYh\YV`iYÊckYfgdf]bhYXcb=bhUÁgdUfU!
gc`"G\YkUgg]hh]b[Uhh\YYX[YcZh\YkccXg UVgcfVYX]bghiXm]b[Zcf\Yf
[YcaYhfmYlUa"Cbh\YkUm\caYg\YX]gWcjYfYXU``h\YV`iYÊckYfg
YjYbh\Yh]b]Ygh \UXVYYbb]VV`YXUkUm/cb`mh\YmY``ckcbYgfYaU]bYX"
5bch\Yfh]aY cbUbYlWifg]cb kYghcddYXhcd]Wb]W]bUaYUXckUbX
gdfYUXUW`ch\YaVfc]XYfYXk]h\V`iYd`iag/k\YbkYfYhifbYXZfcaU
gk]a h\Yd`iagkYfY[cbY"5bX\Y]gYgdYW]U``mZcbXcZV`iY\U]ff]V!
Vcbg"
=bh\Yk]bhYfmcia][\hgYY\]a UhXig_ ibXYfh\YgdfiWYg½g\]j!
Yf]b[ZfcaWc`XUbX`]W_]b[h\Y]f`cb[V`iYg\UXckg]bh\Ygbck"6ih]Z
mcikUbhhcgYY\]aidW`cgY aUmVYYjYbgbUdUd]WhifY gcaYYjYb]b[
`YUjY\]aUV][Vck`cZV`iYVYffmXiad`]b[g"<YWUbÁhfYg]ghV`iYVYf!
f]Yg"
=Zmci[YhUW\UbWYhcf]XY\]a mciÁ``gYYh\Yk\c`Ykcf`X]bV`iY.
V`iYfUVV]hg diZZVU``g k]`XW\YffmV`cggcag"6`iYkcbXYfg"@]_Yh\YV`iY
\cfgY\]agY`Z"
H\YmgUm\Y`Yhgcb`mdcYhgf]XY\]a"6ih]ZmcicZZYfYX\]aU\UbX!
Zi`cZV`iYcUhgµ
8cmci\UjYU\UbXZi`cZV`iYcUhg3
%&,
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
7bÂaDS`g3O`Zg
=hÁgjYfmYUf`m"H\Ygib\UgbÁhcdYbYX]hgYmYg"Ach\Yf\UgbÁhghUfhYX
hcfcW_amWfUX`Y UbX:Uh\Yf\UgbÁh[cbYcihhcWUfYZcfh\Y\cfgYg"H\Y
VcchgVmh\YXccfUfYgh]``Ug`YYd/h\fYg\c`XgUbXZcchdUh\gUfYUg`YYd"
MYghYfXUmgh]```]YgVYhkYYbh\YÊccfVcUfXg"5g][\fYaU]bg]bh\Y
X]g\hckY` UgkYUfkcfXgac`XYfg]bh\YUg\Yg]bh\YghcjY"6ihb][\hh]aY
g`YYd\UghifbYX]bhcacfb]b[g`YYd UbXUhWcW_Wfckh\Y\Uhcbh\YhUV`Y
kU_Ygid"=hÁgYUf`m Vihh\Y\Uhgcbh\Y]fdY[gUfY[fYYh]b[aY UbXbck
=aigh[c"
=XcbÁhYjYbYl]ghmYh"=\UjYbYjYfkU`_YX fYUW\YXZcfUXccf`UhW\
[cbYg]b[]b[h\fci[\h\Yacfb]b[XYkcbh\Y[fUgg"=\UjYbYjYfgYYb
h\Y gib" H\Ym gU]X ]h f]gYg Uh h\Y h\]fX WcW_Wfck cf aUmVY ]h kUg h\Y
Zcifh\ Vihh\YacaYbh]gbYUf Zcfh\YaYb\UjYghcddYXgbcf]b[UbX
h\YWifhU]bgUfY[fck]b[fYX"
=ghYdUWfcggamÉfghXccfg]`` ZfcabcbVY]b[UbXh\YibfYaYa!
VYfYX]bhch\Yacfb]b[a]gh.amW\]`X\ccX"
H\YfY]gbcgib h\YU]f]gWcc` XUad UbXh\YZcchdUh\`YUXg]bhc
Zc["=bh\Yk\]hYbYgg=WUbaU_Ycihh\YkY``"Gch\YÉfghdUh\`YUXgZfca
h\YXccfg]``hch\YkY``"=Á``fYaYaVYf.U`]bXYbhch\Yf][\h UfckUbhc
h\Y`YZh [fYYb[fUggU`cb[h\YdUh\cZ\UfX!dUW_YXYUfh\"=hÁgh\Ycb`m
dUh\=_bck/=Á``fYaYaVYf]h"
=`YUbcjYfh\Yf]acZh\YkY``.gcaYk\YfYZUfXckb[`YUagkUhYf"
=WU``Xckb¾5UU\¿UbXamjc]WYWcaYgVUW_`]_YUgcb[ZfcaUW\c]f"
5VcjYh\YkY`` UdU]`fcW_]b[ `]_YUWfUX`YZfcaUVci[\"K\cX]dg]h
]bhch\YkY``]ZbccbY]g\YfY3K\cbYYXgh\]gkUhYfgcZUfXckb3
H\Ybh\YXccfgk]b[gcdYb UbXAch\YfWcaYgcihUbXgUmg ¾Gccb
]hk]``VYXUm"5bXgccbmciÁ``VYamgcb"¿
%&-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
BVS1]PPZSab]\Sa
H\YWcVV`YghcbYgdc_Ycihh\Y]f\YUXgZfcaibXYfh\YdUjYaYbh
W\YW_ZcfcbWca]b[WUfg UbXÊYY]bhch\YbYUfYghWcifhmUfX"HcXUm]g
a][fUh]cbXUm UbXghcbYgUfY`YUj]b[h\YW]hm]b\cfXYg"Cbh\Ycihg_]fhg
cZF][Uh\YmÁfYd]`YXidUhh\YfU]`kUmWfcgg]b["Cbh\YHU``]bb\][\kUm
`cb[dfcWYgg]cbg\YUXbcfh\hch\YgYUg]XYfYgcfhg"
GhcbYg kUXY ]bhc h\Y gYU UbX [UnY Uh h\Y gib k]h\ V`iY ghcbY
YmYg";fYYb!VYUfXYX gbU]`!WcjYfYXghcbYgkUXYUg\cfY VihXcbÁh_bck
k\YfYhc[c"¾5bmk\YfYY`gYVih\YfYAUmVYU[UfhYfgbU_YWc]`YXcbU
ÉY`XghcbY]gkUfaYfh\UbUbYY`]bh\YVUm"AUmVYk]`XÊckYfgUfYdfYh!
h]Yfh\UbkUhYf`]`]Yg"¿
GhcbYg WfUk` UWfcgg h\Y VYUW\ `]_Y []Ubh hifh`Yg" = WUb gYY h\Y]f
YbcfacigX]gWcbhYbh"
F]jYfgW\ifbUg]bgdUkb]b[h]aY h\YVUW_gcZghcbYggifZUWYUbX
jUb]g\" @YUj]b[ h\Y]f fUd]Xg VY\]bX ch\Yfg \YUX h\fci[\ ZcfYghg UbX
ÉY`XgZcfh\Y\][\kUmg"¾K\mXcbÁh\][\kUmg\UjYfUd]Xg3K\mXcWUfg
g_]ah\YgifZUWY`]_YkUhYfÊYUg k\mXcbÁhh\Ymgk]f`UbXYXXm3¿
=hciW\h\YZcfY\YUXcZamÉY`XghcbY"=h hcc ]gfYgh`Ygg"=hgVfYUh\!
]b[]gg\U``ck ]hghYadYfUhifYf]gYgUbXZU``g"
¾MciXcbÁhbYYXhc[cUbmk\YfY ¿=gUm ¾mciÁfY]bh\YacghVYUih]!
Zi`d`UWYU`fYUXm"¿
H\cigUbXg cZ ÉY`XghcbYg kU]h ]b `]bY Uh h\Y ^YkY`YfÁg. h\YmÁjY
\YUfX h\YfY UfY ghcbYg ]b kUhW\Yg UbX f]b[g" 5 Xc`h]g\ [fUm ÉY`XghcbY
Ug_g U X]UacbX ]b U kf]ghkUhW\ ¾<ck X]X mci [Yh ]b h\YfY3 8]X mci
\UjYWcbbYWh]cbg3¿GhcbYgZfcaV]fW\[fcjYgYbhYfgU`cbg [Yhh\Y]facgg
XmYX UbX WcaY cih `cc_]b[ U`` U`]_Y" GhcbYg h\Uh kYfY ZfU[fUbh Zfca
\cdg aYUXckgkYYh UbX`]bXYbgbckfYY_cZdYfZiaY"
¾Mci XcbÁh bYYX hc [c Ubmk\YfY mci kUfa UbX [ccX ghcbY ¿ =
hY``a]bY"¾McikcbÁhVY[fUbXYfUbmk\YfYY`gY"@cc_ gccbU``UfcibX
mcih\YfmYk]``V`cca½]h\UgVYYb[fckb\YfYZcfU[Yg"¿6ihh\YghcbY
XcYgbÁh`cc_Uhh\YfmY cb`mh\YhfUW_gcZghcbYgh\Uh\UjY`YZh"
Amkf]ghkUhW\]gÉX[Yh]b["H\fci[\h\Yh]W_]b[cZh\YgYWcbXg=
\YUfUX]UacbXUXXfYgg]b[h\Ych\Yfg.¾KY h\YfYÉbYXcbYg kYg\ci`X
VYUg\UaYXcZciffYÉbYaYbhHcXUm k\YbkYWUbdUfh]W]dUhY]b`Um]b[
%'$
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
WYaYbhZcibXUh]cbg¿=ZYY`h\YX]UacbXg\UjYVYYbWcbjYfhYX h\Uhh\Y
f\mh\acZamkUhW\k]``VYfi]bYX"=cdYbh\Y`]X fYUXmhcgdYU_ Vihh\Y
U[]hUhcf^iadg]bhcWYaYbha]l"=h\Ug^iadYX]bhcWYaYbh Vih]hkUg
giddcgYXhc_YYdh]aY"5bXbck]gkcfh\bcacfYh\Ub[fUjY`"=hY``h\Y
ch\Yfg ¾Mci]bh\YWc[k\YY` mciUfYh\YUl]gcZh]aY ]ffYd`UWYUV`Y"6Y
ghYUXZUghH]aYaighVY]adYfhifVUV`Y"¿
<ck ghYUXm UfY h\Y XccfghcbYg Uh h\fYg\c`Xg h\Y [fUjYghcbYg
]b WYaYhYf]Yg ;fUjYghcbYg \cbcf]b[ h\cgY kY `cjY k]`` VY h\Y ÉbU`
h\fYg\c`Xg"
6ihUg=g]hXckbcbUXccfghcbY =ZYY`]hÁgibYUgm"=Ug_ ¾K\YfY
k]``mci[c3K\YfYk]``]hVYVYhhYf3¿
¾K\YfYcb`m\cbYghZcchghYdgYbhYfh\Y\cigY"¿
5bX]h[YhgidUbX`YUjYg"GcXcYgh\YbY][\VcfÁg"FYgh`YggamgY`Z
=Zc``ckh\Ya"8ccfghcbYgUfYfY`]UV`Y UbX=kUbhhc_bckk\Uhh\Ym
k]``Xc"
H\Ym [Uh\Yf ]b h\Y ghcbYWihhYfÁg mUfX" GcaY UfY mcib[ bYk`m
dc`]g\YX ch\Yfg c`X UbX kcfb" H\Y ghcbYWihhYf gUmg ¾Mci aigh fU]gY
mcifYldYWhUh]cbg"HcXUmUXccfghcbY]gbchcb`mZibWh]cbU` ]h]gh\YL!
fUm h\YaU[]WYmY cZU\cigY"=gUmh\]gYgdYW]U``mhcmci XccfghcbYgcZ
Vi]`X]b[gh\Uhg\Y`hYf]XYUg½UWUXYa]Yg aigYiagcZUfh";cVUW_UbX
ghUbXhU``Yf¿
=kU`_VUW_\caYVYg]XYh\Ya"KYdUggaUbmghcbYgh\UhX]Xbch
[chch\YghcbYWihhYfÁgmUfX"H\cigUbXgUfYgh]``fibb]b[UfcibX Vih=
ghUmk]h\h\YXccfghcbYg h\YacghgYf]cigUbXfYgdcbg]V`YghcbYg"K\Yb
h\]gXUmcZibfYgh]gcjYf h\Y]fkUhW\Zi`bYggk]``Wcbh]biY"
:fcabckcb Ug=VY[]bhcYbhYfU\cigY am\YUfhk]``hfYaV`Y.
k\Uh]Zh\YXccfghcbYkcbÁh`YhaY3
%'%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
)
7cbhf]VihcfBchYg
=JM5@J5F9N]gh\YUih\cfcZ;]`bOZKUg\]b[hcb 87.FYXAcfb]b[DfYgg
&$$*"5AUW8ckY``UbX<Ukh\cfbXYb:Y``ck h\Y5ighfU`]U7cib!
W]`Zcfh\Y5fhgUbXh\YKY`g\5WUXYa]Vch\UkUfXYX\YfU[fUbhhc
kf]hYdcYagZcf\YfgYWcbXaUbigWf]dh"kkk"]jmU`jUfYn"Wca
5 ZU]fm hU`Y ]g U k]g\ UbX U acfU` U kcffm VYUX hc fiV Ug mci ZU``
Ug`YYd"
D<=@=D69=8@9F\UghUi[\h5aYf]WUb`]hYfUhifYUhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`U!
VUaUg]bWYWcad`Yh]b[\]gD\"8"Uhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZJ]f[]b]U]b%-+("
<]gfYWYbhVcc_g]bW`iXY:ObSBV]cUVba]\O\=ZREO`&$$(UbX/[S`W
QO\EO`a/[S`WQO\>SOQS(<]bSaT`][OA]\]TbVS3[^W`S&$$+"
5gU`]ZY`cb[ghiXYbhcZYUf`m5aYf]WUb`]hYfUhifY =\UjYVYYbghfiW_
fYdYUhYX`mVm\ck5aYf]WUbg\UjYhf]YXhc]bjYbhh\Y]fZcibXUh]cbU`
amh\gh\fci[\h\YghcfmhY``]b[ghfUhY[]YgkYUggcW]UhYk]h\ZU]fmhU`Yg½
UbX UgcZhYb h\fci[\h\YWfYUh]jYd`U[]Uf]n]b[gcZgdYW]ÉWhYlhg"CbY
cZh\Y[fYUhVcc_gcZamYUf`mWUfYYfkUgh\YdcYh8Ub]Y`<cZZaUbÁg
4]`[O\R4OPZSW\/[S`WQO\4WQbW]\ k\]W\g\ckYX\ckh\]g_]bXcZWi`hifU`
jYbhf]`cei]gaYbf]W\YXW`Ugg]W5aYf]WUbkf]h]b["=hU`gcg\ckYX\ck
Wf]h]W]ga]hgY`ZWci`XVYUZcfacZWi`hifU`amh\aU_]b["
A5F;C69F89G<9JG?MWiffYbh`m`]jYg]bDUf]g"<YfXYVihdcYhfmWc`!
`YWh]cb 0cbO>OaaOUSW\EWZRS`\SaakUgdiV`]g\YXVmH\YG\YYdAYUXck
DfYgg]b&$$+"<Yfkf]h]b[\UgUddYUfYX]b/U\W<Se:SbbS`aBVSA]cbV
S`\@SdWSeBVS9S\g]\@SdWSe>]Sb`g2OWZg1VSZaSO@c\Sa>]Sb`g7\bS`\ObW]\OZ
;O`UWS>]]ZAW|QZS 3c`]^S<W[`]R@ObbO^OZZOf/1;E][S\ÂaAbcRWSa?cO`
bS`ZgUbXch\Yf^cifbU`g"5¾j]giU`dcYa¿gYf]Yg BVS5V]aba]TDS`aOWZZSa
kUggYYbUhh\YDUf]g]Ub;U`Yf]Y6YbW\U]YV"
= dUfh]Wi`Uf`m `cjY U `]bY kf]hhYb Vm >YUb 7cWhYUi k\]W\ gUmg ¾H\Y
dcYh]gU`]Ufk\cU`kUmggdYU_gh\Yhfih\"¿:cfaY½ZU]fmhU`Y]gh\Uh
%'&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
d`UWYk\YfYh\YdcYh]WUbXh\Y`]YaYYh"5dcYh]W cZhYbaYhUd\cf]W
hY``]b[½k\]W\`YUXgh\fci[\h\YaUnY`]_YU[c`XYbh\fYUXhcUhfih\
k\]`YkYUWWYdh]hUgaYfYghcfm"<ckWci`X]hVYgchfiY35bXh\YbkY
_bckh\Uh]h]g"H\]gZUgW]bUhYgaY"
5g U W\]`X = kUg ZUgW]bUhYX k]h\ hYff]ÉYX cZ UbX fYdY``YX Vm h\Y
;f]aa ZU]fm hU`Y ¾H\Y FcVVYf 6f]XY[fcca"¿ Bch gifdf]g]b[`m ]h ]g
fUfY`mUbh\c`c[]nYX/h\YhU`YcZUWUbb]VU`]gh]WfcVVYfVUbXk\cW\cd
mcib[j]f[]bgid]bh\Y]fZcfYghghfcb[\c`X UbXcZh\Y[]f`VYhfch\YX
hch\Y`YUXYfcZh\Y[Ub[k\ccihk]hg\]ahcYldcgY\]a hU_YggU!
XcaUgcW\]gahcUdfYhhmg]W_YlhfYaY"6ih=ZcibXh\Y`ifYcZgYWfYh
_bck`YX[YWcadY``]b[ UbXh\YWcb^ibWh]cbVYhkYYbXYUh\UbX`cjY"
H\]g]gk\Uh`]b_g¾H\YFcVVYf6f]XY[fcca¿k]h\h\Yamh\cZDYfgY!
d\cbY h\YaU]XYbk\c[cYgXckb]bhch\YibXYfkcf`XhcVYWcaY
h\Y Vf]XY cZ XYUh\" HfUbgZcfaYX h\Ym aigh fY^c]b h\Y XUm`]h kcf`X
Zi``cZUaV]jU`YbWYVYWUigYcZk\Uhh\Ym\UjYgYYb h\YXUf__]b[Xca
k\YfYh\Ym\UjYVYYb"
HCBM:F=98<C::\UgUbA:5]bdcYhfmZfcah\YIb]jYfg]hmcZAUggU!
W\igYhhg"<]gdcYag\UjYUddYUfYX]bBVS1][ab]QY@SdWSe 0ZOQYEO``W]`
@SdWSe UbX>ZSWORSa"<YhYUW\Ygkf]h]b[Uhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ7c`cfUXc
Uh7c`cfUXcGdf]b[g"
%''
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5F=9@@9 ;F99B69F; ]g h\Y Uih\cf cZ ;g 9OTYO 1S\bc`g 5Wh]cb 6cc_g
&$$)UbX5WdS\JYfgY &$$&UbXh\YW\UdVcc_4O`bVS`2]e\(A]\Ua
T`][bVS/ZZS`UgB`WOZa BYk A]W\][Ub &$$'" G\Y ]g Wc!YX]hcf cZ hkc
Zcfh\Wca]b[Ubh\c`c[]Yg.k]h\FUW\Y`NiW_Yf E][S\>]Sba]\;S\b]`
aVW^(3TT]`baO\R/TTSQbW]\a=ckU &$$,/UbXk]h\@UfU;`Ybia 5c`ZSa_cS
GUhifbU`]U &$$-"G\Y]gh\YdcYhfmYX]hcfZcfh\Y^cifbU`0ZOQY1Z]QY
UZcibXYfUbXWc!YX]hcfcZh\Y^cifbU`1]c`b5`SS\ UbXh\YZcibXYf!
acXYfUhcfcZh\YdcYh!acag`]ghgYfj"G\Y]gUb5gg]ghUbhDfcZYggcfUh
7c`iaV]U7c``Y[Y7\]WU[cUbX`]jYg]b9jUbghcb =@"
AmXUi[\hYf]ghkcUbXU\U`Z UjcfUW]cigUbX]aU[]bUh]jYVcc_!`cjYf
Ug=kUgUh\YfU[Y":U]fmhU`YgkYfYU\i[YdUfhcZam`]ZYUgUW\]`X
UbXWcbghUbh`mg\ckid]bdcYag=kf]hY VihUgUdUfYbh=kcffmh\Uh
h\YmUfYhccXUf_ZcfamW\]`X k\c]ggYbg]h]jYUbXYUg]`mgWUfYX Ug=
kUg bchhcaYbh]cbh\YcZhYbX]ghUghYZi`h\]b[gh\YmgUmUVcih[]f`!
\ccXcfUVcih\iaUb]hm]b[YbYfU`"Gch\igZUf=\UjY_Ydh\YfUkUm
Zfcah\Ya"6ihg\ci`X=3Cfg\ci`X=YldcgY\YfUhh\]gmcib[U[Yhc
aUhYf]U`h\Uh\UgVch\\UibhYXaYUbXcVj]cig`mgUhYXXYYdbYYXgZcf
dchYbh]aU[YfmUbXghcfm3H\Uh]gWfiW]U`ZcfWi`hifU``]hYfUWm3
9J5B<5FF=G]gh\YUih\cfcZBVS/`b]T?cWbbW\U6Uffcbg"CjYfh\YmYUfg
\Yfg\cfhÉWh]cb\UgUddYUfYX]bjUf]cigaU[Un]bYg ]bW`iX]b[BVS7]eO
@SdWSe 8O\S 4S\QS =^S\1Wbg UbXBVS0`]]YZg\@OWZ]bk\]W\dcfh]cbgcZ
\Yfghcfmcf][]bU``mUddYUfYX"9jUb`]jYg]b\YfbUh]jY9Ugh<Uadhcb
@cb[=g`UbX k]h\\Yf\igVUbX gWi`dhcf<]fcmi_]<UaUXU UbXh\Y]f
hkcgcbg"
:U]fmHU`YggYYahcaYhc\c`XUgdYW]U`WUdUW]hmZcfXYgWf]V]b[hfih\½
aYhUd\cf]WU`UbXdgmW\c#Yach]cbU`hfih\µ:U]fmHU`YgUfY\cbYgh]Z
bchU`kUmghchU``mX]fYWhµUVcihk\Uhh\Ym_bck"H\Uh]gjYfmUddYU`!
]b[K\Yb=kf]hYig]b[X]Wh]cbcfbUffUh]jYeiU`]h]YgUggcW]UhYXk]h\
:U]fm HU`Yg = ZYY` VcibX hc gh]W_ k]h\ k\Uh ]g bYWYggUfm UbX hfm Zcf
YWcbcamUbXWfcggcihUbmh\]b[h\UhXcYgbÁhgYYaf][\hk\Yb=fYUX
]hcih`ciX"H\Uh]g\ck=hfmhc\cbcfh\Yhfih\!hY``]b[UgdYWhcZh\Y
:U]fmHU`Y"H\]g]gh\YVYgh=WUbXcgcZUf"
%'(
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
A7<M@5B8ÁgdcYag\UjYfYWYbh`mUddYUfYX]b1]Z]`OR]@SdWSe :7B6M<5
;M< UbXBVS>O`Wa@SdWSe"
CbYcZamW`YUfYghW\]`X\ccXaYacf]Yg]gcZVY]b[hc`Xh\Y;f]aa
Vfch\YfgÁghcfm¾H\Y>ib]dYfHfYY¿UhXUmWUadk\Yb=kUgUVcihhYb"
H\Yghcfmh\f]``YXUbXWcbh]biYghch\f]``aY k]h\]hgXYd]Wh]cbcZUb
]adcgg]V`mWc`cfZi`UbX]bÉb]hY`mWfiY`kcf`X ]bk\]W\g\]bmhf]b_Yhg
hU`_]b[V]fXg UbXWUbb]VU`]gaWcYl]ghk]h\U`c[]Wh\Uh]gVch\ZcfY][b
UbXUVgc`ihY"=hÁgUkcf`X=ÉbXamgY`ZfYhifb]b[hcU[U]bUbXU[U]b
]bam`cjYcZh\Y[UiXmUbXh\Yg]b]ghYf ]bamUhhYadhghcdig\ZUf
VYmcbXh\Yd`Uig]V`Y Vch\]bkf]h]b[UbX]b`]ZY"
@9G@9M>9B=?9ÁgÉfghVcc_cZdcYag5V]ab]T4OaVW]\]gZcfh\Wca]b[Zfcah\Y
7ighcaKcfXg]adf]bhcZKcfXHYW\DfYgg]b&$$-"<YfdcYag\UjY
UddYUfYX fYWYbh`m ]b DS`aS 1]c`b 5`SS\ >==: 5cZT 1]Oab A]cÂESabS`
0`]]YZg\@SdWSe;S[]`W]caEOaVW\Ub]\A_cO`SUbXch\Yfg"G\YÁgWiffYbh`mU
XcWhcfU`WUbX]XUhYUhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ7]bW]bbUh]"
:U]fmhU`Ygd`UmYXUjYfm]adcfhUbhfc`Y]bamW\]`X\ccXYXiWUh]cb"
H\YmhUi[\haYk\Uh]haYUbghcVYU[]f` k\c=g\ci`XZU``]b`cjY
k]h\ UbXk\Uh=g\ci`XYldYWhZcfamZihifY"6ihk\Yb=kUgUhYYb!
U[Yf=fYUX5bbYGYlhcbÁgB`O\aT]`[ObW]\aUbXYjYfmh\]b[W\Ub[YXµ
?5A=@5@=G]gUXcWhcfU`ghiXYbh]b9b[`]g\Uhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZJ]f[]b]U"G\Y
`]jYg]b7\Uf`chhYgj]``YUbXYb^cmgghcf]YgUVcihibXYf[fcibX`U]fgUbX
dYcd`YXUbW]b[]bf]b[g"
:U]fmhU`Yg\UjYU`kUmgdfcjYXUgcifWYcZ]bgd]fUh]cb dUfh]Wi`Uf`mgc]b
h\YYUgYk]h\k\]W\h\YmWcbÊUhYh\YZUa]`]Ufk]h\h\Y\cff]ÉW"
5G<@9MA7K5H9FG]gUb]bghfiWhcfUhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaU k\YfY
g\Y]gh\Y7ccfX]bUhcfcZIbXYf[fUXiUhY7fYUh]jYKf]h]b["<YfaUb!
igWf]dh EVWbSe]`Y kUgU&$$*ÉbU`]gh]bh\YBUh]cbU`DcYhfmGYf]Yg
UbX h\Y :cif KUm 6cc_g =bhfc Df]nY" <Yf kcf_ \Ug UddYUfYX cf ]g
Zcfh\Wca]b[]b>OW\bSR0`WRS?cO`bS`Zg27/5@/;<]`bVeSab@SdWSe1O
YSb`OW\ A^W\\W\U 8S\\g 4OW`g BOZS @SdWSe 1O`]ZW\O ?cO`bS`Zg O\R >W\RSZRgP]h
%')
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
Uacb[ch\Yfg"G\Y`]jYg]bHigWU`ccgUk]h\\igVUbXGWchh XUi[\hYf
DcgYm UbXXc[gHU``i`U\UbXC`]jY"
5hcif\cigYkY\UjY8Uj]X6ck]YbUffUh]b[DfcZc_]YjÁg¾DYhYfUbX
h\YKc`Z ¿]hgYYag bYUf`mUfcibXh\YW`cW_/amhkc!mYUf!c`XXUi[\!
hYf]gcVgYggYX"<YffYUWh]cb Ua]lcZZYUfUbXZUgW]bUh]cb kUg]a!
aYX]UhY UbXgYYagjYfm`]_Yh\YYach]cbU`fYgdcbgYh\UhXf]jYgcif
UhhfUWh]cb hc ZU]fm hU`Yg Uh Ubm U[Y" H\Y kc`Z YUhg h\Y XiW_ k\c`Y.
gWUfm5hh\YYbXcZh\Yghcfm kYWUb\YUfh\YXiW_eiUW_]b[]bg]XY
h\Ykc`ZÁgVY``m.kY]fX=WUbcb`m]aU[]bY\ck]hU``d`Umgcih]bam
hcXX`YfÁgVfU]b h\]gbYUf!df]aU`ZUgW]bUh]cbk]h\h\Y[fchYgeiY"=hÁgU
ZUgW]bUh]cbkYbYjYf[fckcihcZ"
H\YaYfaU]X\UgVYYbUaU^cfdcYh]WdfYcWWidUh]cbcZa]bYZcfU`cb[
h]aY"Cf][]bU``mZfcah\YD\]`]dd]bYg k\]W\]gWcadf]gYXcZ+ %$+]g!
`UbXgUddUfYbh`m + %$,Uh`ckh]XY =\UjY\UXfY`Uh]jYX]ZÉWi`hm]b
ÉbX]b[ aYfaU]X ghcf]Yg dYf\Udg XiY hc h\Y 7\f]gh]Ub]nUh]cb cZ h\Y
]g`UbXgUbX\YbWY h\Y7\f]gh]Ub]nUh]cbcZc`Xghcf]Yg]bjc`j]b[ZYaU`Y
É[ifYg" 5 WYbhifm cZ 9b[`]g\ ]bghfiWh]cb UbX <c``mkccX \UjY aUXY
<Ubg7\f]gh]Ub5bXYfgYbÁgUbX KU`h8]gbYmÁgaYfaU]XgacfYkY``!
_bckbhc:]`]d]bcg"5`gcWcbhf]Vih]b[hcD\]`]dd]bYaYfaU]Xghcf]YgÁ
fY`Uh]jY¾gWUfW]hm¿]gh\Y]bXighf]U`dc``ih]cbcZaU^cfVcX]YgcZkUhYf"
H=ACH<MG7<5::9FH]gh\YUih\cfcZh\fYYbcjY`g.BVS>VO\b][:W[Pa]T
bVS@]ZZ]eAWabS`a BVSAW\UW\UO\R2O\QW\U2OcUVbS`a]T5]R UbX2SdWZaW\bVS
AcUO`AV]^"<Y]gUWcbhf]Vih]b[YX]hcfhc>`OW`WSAQV]]\S` UbXh\YX]fYW!
hcfcZhkcbcbdfcÉh`]hYfUfmYjYbhg.h\YBYVfUg_UGiaaYfKf]hYfgÁ
7cbZYfYbWYUbXh\YXckbhckbcaU\U`]hZYgh"
=kUgbYjYfaiW\cZUfYU`]gh[fck]b[id"5gU_]X =ZcibXacghW\]`!
XfYbÁg `]hYfUhifY hc VY hcc gh]Ê]b[`m \][\Vfck UbX = fYgYbhYX VY]b[
%'*
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
YldYWhYXhcfY`UhYhch\YW\UfUWhYfg hcVY]adfYggYXVmh\Y]facfU`
[iadh]cb" = dfYZYffYX Wca]W Vcc_g Vih cb`m ]Z h\Y W\UfUWhYfg kYfY
geiUh d`iad UbXWUfhccb]g\½1Oa^S`bVS4`WS\RZg5V]abES\RgbVS5]]R
:WbbZSEWbQV6]bAbcTTbVS:WbbZS2SdWZ.Wca]WgZi``cZW\]`XfYbacgh`mUVUb!
XcbYXhcghfUb[Ykcf`XgUbXUVgifXdfYX]WUaYbhg<chGhiZZ UddUf!
Ybh`m `]j]b[]b\Y``/7UgdYf UddUfYbh`m UXYUX`]hh`YVcm k\]`YgUXX`YX
k]h\dccfdUfYbh]b[VmUibhg ibW`Yg cf]bF]W\]YF]W\ÁgWUgY UaUb!
g]cbZi``cZgYfjUbhg"H\Y]fg`][\hgi[[Ygh]cbcZh\Y]bUddfcdf]UhY[UjY
h\Yah\YUddYU`cZh\YZU]fmhU`Yg=ÁXU`kUmgYb^cmYX YgdYW]U``mh\cgY
hU`Yg]bk\]W\h\YUXi`hgkYfYjYbU`UbXbUghm UbXh\YXUf_ZcfYghg½
k]h\ ]hg k]hW\Yg UbX gd]f]hg½ZUf acfY ]bj]h]b[ h\Ub h\Y ZUa]`m \ih"
9jYbh\ci[\h\YWca]WgkYfYW\cW_Zi``cZmi_g h\YZU]fmhU`YÁggiV`]aY
k\]gdYfgcZYbXUb[YfaYbhbYjYfgYYaYXZUfZfcah\Y]fViVV`mX]U!
`c[iYVU``ccbg
?IFHG7<K=HH9FG%,,+¼%-(,]gk]XY`mfYWc[b]nYXUgcbYcZh\Yacgh
]adcfhUbh;YfaUb8UXU]ghUfh]ghg"
6=H=H9J=B?@9FG]gUhfUbg`UhcfcZ@Uhj]UbZc`_`cfYUbXWcbhYadcfUfm`]h!
YfUhifY"<YfhfUbg`Uh]cbg\UjYUddYUfYX]bUbh\c`c[]YgUbXdYf]cX]!
WU`g acghfYWYbh`m]bBVS>O`Wa@SdWSeAS\SQO@SdWSeE]`RaEWbV]cb0]`RS`a
UbX2S\dS`?cO`bS`Zg"G\Y`]jYg]b6fcc_`mb"
=bh\Ykcf_\YfYVmh\Y@Uhj]UbdcYh=aUbhgN]YXcb]g h\Y[YbfYgcZ
ZU]fmhU`YUbXdcYhfmaYf[Y/h\YhU`YgUbXh\YdfcgYdcYagUfYghm`]gh]!
WU``m ]bX]gh]b[i]g\UV`Y" N]YXcb]g XY`][\hg ig k]h\ ibYldYWhYX hfUbg!
ZcfaUh]cbg dYfgcb]ÉWUh]cbg UbX ^ilhUdcg]h]cbg" <Y XfUkg ig ]b Vm
gdYU_]b[]bh\YÉfghdYfgcbibigiU`ZcfZU]fmhU`YgUbXVmUXXfYgg]b[
h\YfYUXYf UbX\Yg\ckgU[fYUhW`cgYbYgghcbUhifY k\]W\]gWYbhfU`
hc\]gckbkcf_UbXhc@Uhj]UbZc`_`cfY"
?9@@=9K9@@GkUgUkUfXYXh\Y:`UbbYfmCÁ7cbbcf5kUfXZcf\YfWc``YW!
h]cbcZg\cfhÉWh]cb 1][^`SaaW]\AQO`a"<YfbcjY`AYW\kUgdiV`]g\YX
]b&$$*Vmh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZBYVfUg_UDfYgg UgdUfhcZh\Y:`mcjYf
:]Wh]cbGYf]Yg"¾FUVV]h7UhW\YfcZ?]b[Xca7caY¿]gdUfhcZ4Ob5W`Z
BS``Sab`WOZ UbcjY`g\YÁgWiffYbh`mUhkcf_cb"
%'+
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
CbYcZh\Yh\]b[gh\Uhacgh]bhf][iYgaYUVcihh\YhU`YcZ¾H\YD]YX
D]dYf¿]gh\Uh]h]gh\YW\]`XfYbk\cUfY ]bUaUbbYfcZgdYU_]b[ \Y`X
UWWcibhUV`YZcfh\Yg]bgcZh\YdUfYbhg ZcfWYXhcgeiUfYh\Y]fXYVh.h\Y
W\]`XfYbUfYYbW\UbhYX]bhccV`]j]cbUgUfYgi`hcZh\Y]fdUfYbhgÁg_]b!
Ê]bhYXbYgg UbXh\Ybh\YdUfYbhg`YUfb\ckhcUgg][bjU`iYdfcdYf`m"
5bX=h\ci[\h gc]h]gk]h\;cXUbXacfhU`g"<iaUbVY]b[gUfY\Y`X
UWWcibhUV`Y Zcf h\Y hfYgdUggYg cZ ;cX ]Z WfYUh]b[ ZcfY_bck]b[`m U
dfcZcibX`mÊUkYXUbXh\YfYZcfYXccaYXfUWYcZWfYUhifYgk\caigh
X]Y VYZcfY ]b\Yf]h]b[ YjYf`Ugh]b[ `]ZY WUb VY gU]X hc VY h\Y i`h]aUhY
hfYgdUgg"6ihk\Uh\Ug;cXhUi[\h<]agY`ZhcjU`iY3:U]fmhU`YgU``ck
cbYhcWcbg]XYfgiW\ibk]Y`XmUbXÊU[fUbh`mbcb!a]aYh]WeiYgh]cbg"
85F5 K=9F kUg Vcfb ]b BYk Cf`YUbg @ci]g]UbU" FYWYbh Vcc_g ]bW`iXY
@S[\O\ba]T6O\\OVUbX@SdS`aS@O^bc`SUkUfXYXh\YDcYhfm7YbhYf
5aYf]WUbDcYhfm5fW\]jYg6cc_5kUfX"<YfdcYagWUbVYZcibX]b
Dig\WUfh 6Ygh5aYf]WUbDcYhfm Bcfhcb GcZhG_i``UbXjUf]cigch\Yf
Ubh\c`c[]Yg UbX ]b /[S`WQO\ >]Sb`g @SdWSe 1]\RcWb 1`OhgV]`aS 2S\dS`
?cO`bS`Zg XcPWZOb aZ]^S Bc`\`]e <Se/[S`WQO\@SdWSe D]Zb"5`]a]hYXYX]!
h]cb L=B:=L ]g]bFU]bHUl]Ág6fU]bghcfagYf]Yg"H\Y;i[[Yb!
\Y]a :cibXUh]cb h\Y BUh]cbU` 9bXckaYbh Zcf h\Y 5fhg h\Y AUg!
gUW\igYhhg 7i`hifU` 7cibW]` UbX h\Y 5aYf]WUb DcYhfm FYj]Yk \UjY
giddcfhYX\Yfkcf_"G\YÁgUaYaVYfcZh\YdcYhfmZUWi`hmUbXX]fYWhcf
cZh\YA:5dfc[fUaZcfdcYhgUbXkf]hYfgUhh\YIb]jYfg]hmcZAUg!
gUW\igYhhg5a\YfghUbXWc!X]fYWhcfcZh\Y>ib]dYf=b]h]Uh]jYZcf@]hYf!
Ufm5fhgUbX5Wh]cb"K]h\;imDYhh]hUbX9a]`mDYhh]h g\YYX]hgUbX
diV`]g\YgW\UdVcc_gUbXVfcUXg]XYgZcf:UWhcfm<c``ckDfYgg"
=A5BHG N=98CB=G cbY cZ @Uhj]UÁg acgh dfca]bYbh kf]hYfg g]bWY h\Y
%-*$g ]gh\YUih\cfcZaUbmjc`iaYgcZdcYhfm `]hYfUfmbcbÉWh]cb
W\]`XfYbÁgVcc_g UbXUaYac]f"<]gkcf_\UgVYYbhfUbg`UhYX]bhcbi!
aYfcig`Ub[iU[Yg ]bW`iX]b[GkYX]g\ ;YfaUb Figg]Ub UbXDc`]g\
UbX\Y\UgfYWY]jYX@Uhj]UÁg\][\Ygh`]hYfUfmUbXghUhY\cbcfg"
>57? N=D9G ]g U DfcZYggcf cZ ;YfaUb UbX 7cadUfUh]jY @]hYfUhifY Uh h\Y
Ib]jYfg]hmcZA]bbYgchU"<Y\UgdiV`]g\YXbiaYfcigVcc_gcbZc`_!
`cfY UbX ZU]fm hU`Yg" <]g acgh fYWYbh kcf_ EVg 4OW`g BOZSa AbWQY( BVS
%',
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
3d]ZcbW]\O\R@SZSdO\QS]TO5S\`S kcbh\Y&$$+?Uh\Uf]bY6f][[g5kUfX
:c`_`cfYGcW]Yhm I?"<]ghfUbg`Uh]cbgcZ?ifhGW\k]hhYfgUddYUf
]bh\]g]ggiY"
H\YfY]gacfYhfih\]bZU]fmhU`Ygh\Ub]bgc!WU``YXfYU`]gh]WÉWh]cbUbX
h\YbYkgaYX]U"6ihh\YgcW]YhmcZh\YgdYWhUW`Y\UgV`]bXYXig UbX
kY\UjY`cghcifUV]`]hmhchY``UbXfYWc[b]nYhfih\"Ibh]`kY`YUfb\ck
hch\]b_aYhUd\cf]WU``mcbWYU[U]b kYg\U``V`ibXYfh\fci[\cif`]jYg
k]h\cihhfih\"
%'-
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5W_bck`YX[aYbhg
)
5 gaU`` dcfh]cb cZ ¾H\Y :ihifY cZ 8YgdU]f¿ Vm 9jUb <Uff]g Éfgh Ud!
dYUfYX]bBVS0`]]YZg\@OWZ UbXkYYldfYggcif[fUh]hiXYZcfdYfa]gg]cb
hcfYdfcXiWY]h\YfY"
H\Y]aU[Yk\]W\UddYUfgUhh\YYbXcZ¾H\YFUVV]h7UhW\YfcZ?]b[!
Xca7caY¿Vm?Y``]YKY``g]gUd\chc[fUd\VmDUi`D`Yi` fYdf]bhYXVm
dYfa]gg]cb cZ XdU D]WhifY 5``]UbWY½5``]UbWY ;aV< 9]b IbhYfbY\!
aYbXYfXdU!;fiddY"
K]h\Wcbh]biYX[fUh]hiXYhch\Y[YbYfciggiddcfhcZh\Y7c``Y[YcZ5fhg
GW]YbWYgUhH\YIb]jYfg]hmcZ5`UVUaU UbXhch\Y[fUXiUhYghiXYbhg
]b h\Y A:5 Dfc[fUa Uh H\Y Ib]jYfg]hm cZ 5`UVUaU Zcf h\Y]f ]bhY``]!
[YbWYUbXYbh\ig]Uga"
5biaVYfcZUbcbmacigXcbcfgUfY\YfYUW_bck`YX[YX"
@cb[`]jYZU]fmhU`Yg
%($
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
5bbcibWYaYbhg
)
:U]fmHU`YFYj]YkDfYgg
8]ghf]VihYXVmGaU``DfYgg8]ghf]Vih]cb
&$$,H]h`Yg.
@]`m<cUb[
16/<57<5
$%8YW&$$,
=G6B.-+,!$!-+---)(!&!&
%("$$
%(%
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
>cmK]``]Uag
BVS1VO\USZW\U
=G6B-+,!$!-+---)(!$!,
%*
&$$dd"
:]Wh]cb
H\]g 'ch\ 5bb]jYfgUfm 9X]h]cb cZ BVS1VO\USZW\U Vm >cm K]``]Uag k]``
]bW`iXY U :cfYkcfX Vm F]W_ AccXm" 5b cjYf`cc_YX UbX gdYWhUWi`Uf
bcjY` BVS1VO\USZW\U ]g U j]g]cbUfm ZU]fm hU`Y U kcf_ cZ amh\]W [Yb]ig"
HYff]Zm]b[ dcYh]WfYjY`Uh]cbgZc``ckBVS1VO\USZW\UÁgUVUbXcbYX\Yfc]bY
DYUf` YjYfmk\YfY g\Y [cYg k\Yh\Yf Vm U]f `UbX cf gYU" >cm K]``]Uag
\Ugkcbh\YFYU5kUfXZcfh\YG\cfhGhcfm h\Y<Ufc`XUbXA]`XfYX
GhfUigg@]j]b[5kUfXZfcah\Y5aYf]WUb5WUXYamcZ5fhg@YhhYfg
Uacb[ch\Yfdf]nYg"<YfÉfghbcjY` AbObS]T5`OQSkUgUBUh]cbU`6cc_
5kUfX :]bU`]gh" ¾5b ]bjYfgY cXmggYm cZ U &$h\!WYbhifm ZYa]b]bY
gYbg]V]`]hm½cifg]ad`Yhcb\Yfc]bYYbXgUXYdfUjYXU`Wc\c`]W½h\Yk]hhm
UbX\cff]Zm]b[1VO\USZW\UYghUV`]g\YgK]``]UagUgUaU^cfWcbhYadcfUfm
bcjY`]gh¿DW`UW\WO?cO`bS`Zg@SdWSe%-+,"H\Y'ch\5bb]jYfgUfm9X]h]cb
gYY_ghcfY]bhfcXiWYh\]gbcjY`hcWcbhYadcfUfmfYUXYfgUgcbYcZh\Y
acghcf][]bU`UbXU`Ufa]b[ZU]fm!hU`YVcc_gYjYfkf]hhYb"
%(&
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
>c\UbbYg;fUbggcb
>WZ]b¿8]VO\\bVS1O`]caSZ6]`aSÀ
=G6B-+,!$!-+---)(!%!)
%&
%*)dd"
>WZ]b¿8]VO\\bVS1O`]caSZ6]`aSÀ]gUbUggYaV`U[Y UVcc_cZbifgYfmf\maYg
[cbYkfcb[]bhfUbg`Uh]cb"=hgghfUb[YW\UfUWhYfg UVUbXcbYXZfcach\Yf
hYlhg ]bW`iXY@]`^U h\YDYUf`gcZGhcW_\c`aUbXUggcfhYX]adYf]`YX[]f`g"
<YfY ]b>c\UbbYg;fUbggcbÁg[`]hhYf]b[YlcW]hm h\YmÉbXUbYkUbX
VYUih]Zi``m gh]hW\YX \caY" ;fUbggcb kUg Vcfb UbX fU]gYX ]b G_bY
GkYXYb Vih\Ug`]jYX]bh\YIGZcfaUbmmYUfg"<Y]gWc!YX]hcfcZ5Wh]cb
6cc_gUbX\UghfUbg`UhYXh\Ykcf_cZ5UgY6Yf[ <YbfmDUf`UbX 5bb
>}XYf`ibXUbXch\YfGkYX]g\UbX:]b`UbXGkYX]g\dcYhg"
%('
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
0 H\Y9bX 2
%((
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
You are reading copyrighted material published by the University of Alabama Press.
Any posting, copying, or distributing of this work beyond fair use as defined under U.S. Copyright law is illegal and
injures the author and publisher. For permission to reuse this work, contact the University of Alabama Press.
Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.
Alternative Proxies: