03.

2022

INTO
THE
DEPTHS
Searching for shipwrecks from slavery’s hidden past—
to help heal the present
 FURTHER MARCH 2022

C O N T E N T S On the Cover
National Geographic
Explorer Tara Roberts,
here in the Florida Keys,
dives with a group that’s
reclaiming the stories
and artifacts of African
captives transported on
slave ships.
PHOTO: WAYNE LAWRENCE

15
P R O O F E X P L O R E

THE BIG IDEA

A Chance to
‘Become a Fish’
With the Aqua-Lung,

28
Jacques-Yves Cousteau
opened an underwater
world to researchers
and regular folks.

6
BY R AC H E L H A RT I GA N

DATA SHEET
BASIC INSTINCTS

Revealing All … Meet a Hermaphro-

in Apps ditic Sea Slug That
From your age to your Wields a Needle
bank account, apps This fragile-seeming
know a lot about you. animal practices “trau-
BY A L B E RTO LU C A S LÓ P E Z
matic insemination.”
A N D K E L S E Y N OWA KOW S K I
BY E VA VA N D E N B E RG

CLOSER LOOK

Pottery of the Night

The Samurai Spirit A new generation
Through portraits of artisans is bringing
focused on descen- back the authentic
dants of the famed tradition of Mexico’s
Japanese warriors, a black clay ceramics.
photographer learns BY R AC H N A S AC H A S I N H
about the past, the
ALSO ALSO
present, and himself.
P H OTO G R A P H S BY The Benefit of Blue Origins of Counting
RYOTA RO H O R I U C H I Otters Aiding Plants Tips on Urban Wildlife
M A R C H | CONTENTS

F E AT U R E S Hidden No More Saving Winter Defending the

About a thousand ships Alpine economies Land, Paying With
sank during the transat- depend on snow, so Their Lives
lantic slave trade, many what happens when In Colombia, activism
with captive Africans there’s less of it? is a dangerous pursuit.
on board. Today Black BY DENISE HRUBY BY J O R DA N SA L A M A
divers are exploring P H OTO G RA P H S BY P H OTO G RA P H S BY
and documenting the C I R I L JA Z B E C .............. P. 58 F L O R E N C E G O U P I L . . . P. 100
wrecks. “As long as we
dive for these ships,” Big Cat Haven The Cricket Catchers
says the Smithsonian’s A conservation success A key protein source
Lonnie Bunch III, “the story plays out on an in Uganda, bush crick-
people who died on Indian tiger reserve. ets are at risk from
them are remembered.” BY YUDHIJIT overharvesting.
B Y TA R A R O B E R T S B H AT TA C H A R J E E B Y H A L I M A AT H U M A N I
P H OTO G RA P H S BY P H OTO G RA P H S BY P H OTO G RA P H S BY
W AY N E L A W R E N C E . . . P. 36 S H A A Z J U N G . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. 86 JA S P E R D O E S T ......... P. 120
FREE Download Now!

Optional Accessory
DaVinci Resolve Speed Editor ... US$395
M A R C H | FROM THE EDITOR

Tara Roberts writes, is full

T H E AT L A N T I C O C E A N ,
of “souls who have never been acknowledged or

Who Gets to Tell mourned. Dreamers, poets, artists, thinkers, sci-

entists, farmers.”

the Story Matters

And so begins a powerful essay of discovery: this
issue’s cover story and a special six-part Nat Geo
podcast called Into the Depths. Roberts, a National
Geographic Explorer, has traveled coastal waters
from the United States to South Africa to Costa Rica,
searching for what remains of the ships that an esti-
mated 12.5 million Africans were forced onto during
BY SUSAN GOLDBERG four centuries of the transatlantic slave trade.
P H O T O G R A P H B Y WAY N E L AW R E N C E Roberts seeks signs not just of those captives who
arrived on the Americas’ shores—but also of the 1.8
million people who perished along the way from
inhumane conditions in cargo holds or by drowning
in shipwrecks.
Roberts participates in these searches with a
group called Diving With a Purpose, which trains div-
ers—most of them African American—to locate, doc-
ument, and conserve artifacts they find in the water.
They are looking for what remains of ships such as
the São José Paquete d’Africa, a Portuguese vessel
bound for Brazil that sank off Cape Town, South
Africa, in 1794. Many of the 512 captives jammed in
the ship’s cargo hold were from the Makua ethnic
group of northern Mozambique. Two hundred twelve
went down with the ship, their stories lost to history.
“In some ways, there’s so much we know about
slavery,” says Lonnie Bunch III, the secretary of the
Smithsonian Institution and founding director of the
National Museum of African American History and
Culture in Washington, D.C. “But there’s so much we
still don’t know. And I would argue the last frontier
is what’s under the water.”
For Roberts and many other Americans whose
ancestors were enslaved, deep dives into the past
could provide both new information on the slave
trade and a new perspective: Who gets to tell the story
matters—in terms of which facts are included, what’s
emphasized, what’s glossed over. And history, as
most of us have read it over the years, largely has been
shaped by an unrepresentative group of narrators.
As Roberts puts it, “We know very little about the
people in the cargo hold, except the horrors. I wonder
if Black divers would notice different details. If they
would focus on finding artifacts that help us under-
stand the full humanity of the captive Africans.”
In Edenton, North Carolina,
Ultimately, Roberts’s journey into the past compels
National Geographic Explorer her to investigate her own roots. The last part of her
Tara Roberts visits her grand- story is set in Edenton, North Carolina, the home of
parents’ former home, now
empty. This issue’s cover story
her great-great-grandparents Jack and Mary Roberts,
was written by Roberts, whose who were both born enslaved.
research on the transatlantic I cannot do justice to Roberts’s moving history,
slave trade inspired her to inves- Scan this QR code
neither will I reveal what she discovers. I’ll let
tigate her own roots. Among to listen to the
the facts she’s unearthed: Her podcast series Into Roberts tell you herself, beginning on page 36. As
ancestor Jack Roberts fought in the Depths, about in many of the most important stories, what she
the Civil War in the U.S. Colored Roberts’s journey learns doesn’t make itself apparent immediately;
Troops and was a delegate following Black
to the 1865 North Carolina divers exploring it is uncovered bit by bit.
Freedmen’s Convention. slavery’s past. Thank you for reading National Geographic. j
 W H AT ’ S O N YO U R
BUCKET LIST?

I AVA I L A B L E W H E R E V E R B O O K S A N D M A P S A R E S O L D

NatGeoBooks @NatGeoBooks © 2022 National Geographic Partners, LLC

 P R O O F

N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C

VO L . 2 41 N O. 3

THE SAMURAI
SPIRIT
PHOTOGRAPHS BY LO O K I N G
RYOTA RO H O R I U C H I AT T H E
E A RT H
Portraits showcase the beauty F RO M
and reverence associated with the E V E RY
warriors of old, still celebrated in POSSIBLE
the Japan of today. ANGLE

6 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
At Japan’s Soma Nomaoi
Festival, armor-clad par-
ticipants, some of whom
have samurai ancestry,
parade and race on
horseback. Here, Mitsuo
Abe—in everyday life, a
dealer in antique armor—
dresses as a type of
samurai called go-taisho,
a battalion general.

MARCH 2022 7
P R O O F

For her portrait, Miwa Hosokawa is outfitted as a cavalry warrior, known as a kiba. During the festival, she cares for the
participants’ mounts, using skills she has developed through her work on a horse ranch.

8 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
A onetime civil servant, Yukio Imada acts as a samurai-taisho, a company commander who supports the general of
a battalion. To intimidate opponents, his headdress features an oni, a fearsome creature in Japanese folklore.

MARCH 2022 9
P R O O F

Katsunao Kamo’s training as an armorer helped him suit up properly for his role as a gunja, a samurai who aids the chief
of staff and vice chief of staff. Kamo, now deceased, also managed the festival’s general affairs.

10 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Most days, Yuichi Takahashi leads a construction company. As a festival osakinori, he leads the samurai marching cavalry and
festival spirits and oversees the safety of the route. The armor he wears dates from the late 1500s to early 1600s.

MARCH 2022 11
P R O O F

THE BACKSTORY
A P H OTO G R A P H E R’ S S E A RC H F O R H I S JA PA N E S E I D E N T I T Y
L E A D S H I M T O R E D I S C O V E R T H E P A S T I N T H E P R E S E N T.

AFTER YEARS OF making images out- helped them persevere through life’s
side of Japan, Ryotaro Horiuchi turned adversities, including the devastating
the camera toward his home country. earthquake and tsunami that hit the
As he questioned what constitutes Soma area of Fukushima in 2011 and
Japanese identity—and his own iden- caused a nuclear disaster.
tity as a Japanese person—he began Hearing stories of these modern-day
looking into matsuri, the communal festivalgoers and seeing the strength of
celebrations held in every region of their conviction, Horiuchi knew that
Japan since ancient times. his next project would be an attempt to
When Horiuchi attended Fukushima “capture their personalities and their
Prefecture’s Soma Nomaoi Festival, identity as a samurai.”
where samurai descendants and dev- The past shapes the present for
otees dress in armor and compete on samurai admirers. Throughout the
horseback each July, he was “over- history of the festival, attendees have
whelmed and moved by the power adapted to the evolving times without
and human aspect,” he says. relinquishing their connection to the
The festival has been held for more samurai. And through these portraits,
than a thousand years; its origins lie Horiuchi has found his own sense of
in the military training of the lord of self—one that shifts with changes in
Soma’s samurai, who dedicated their time and place but preserves the spirit
lives to protecting his. Today’s par- of tradition. — G A I L T S U K I YA M A
ticipants take inspiration from the Gail Tsukiyama is a best-selling author whose
discipline, honor, and loyalty prac- novels include The Samurai’s Garden, Women
ticed by the samurai—values that have of the Silk, and The Color of Air.

Tradition meets modernity: Samurai descendant and festival follower Mitsukiyo Monma
sometimes trades a horse for a Harley.
 IN THIS SECTION

Learning Numbers

E X P L O R E The Benefit of Blue

Urban Wildlife Aid
Your Data’s Security

I L L U M I N AT I N G T H E M Y S T E R I E S — A N D W O N D E R S — A L L A R O U N D U S E V E R Y D AY

N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C VO L . 2 41 N O. 3

A Chance to
‘Become a Fish’
J A C Q U E S -Y V E S C O U S T E A U ’ S C O - I N V E N T I O N O F T H E A Q U A- L U N G O P E N E D
T H E U N D E R S E A R E A L M T O S C I E N T I S T S —A N D A W O N D E R I N G P U B L I C .

L
BY RACHEL HARTIGAN

“ L O O K ,” M Y S O N S A I D.
We were bobbing in the shadow of a pier on Isla
Vieques in Puerto Rico. Wooden slats a few feet
above our heads sheltered us from the tropical sun.
Weather-beaten pilings disappeared beneath the
water’s surface. It was cool there but barren—a
human-made spot suitable only for a quick rest
during our first foray into snorkeling.
Will pointed down. His eyes were wide behind his
mask. He dipped his head underwater. I followed.
We entered another world. Above the water the
pier was a dull structure of warped wood and chipped
paint. Underwater it teemed with life—orange and
yellow corals wrapping around the pilings, lush sea
plants undulating in the current, darting schools of
silvery fish. This narrow place beneath a dock built
decades ago for U.S. warships was as fecund as any
jungle—but unlike a jungle, we could float in the
midst of it and examine it from every angle.

MARCH 2022 15
E X P L O R E | THE BIG IDEA

We had never imagined being surrounded by so “The best way to become a

much wildlife—and yet it wasn’t enough for Will. fish—or a reasonable facsimile
thereof—is to don an under-
“That was so cool,” he said, as we drove back to the water breathing device called
hotel in our guides’ rattletrap pickup truck. “I want the Aqualung,” said Cousteau
to try scuba diving.” He didn’t want to be tied to the (left), the apparatus’s co-
inventor. In this National Geo-
surface by our rented snorkels. He dreamed of div- graphic archival photo (right),
ing deeper, of seeing more of the ocean for himself. Aqua-Lungers descend to
Such a dream is possible—even ordinary—because Sha’ab Rumi, a Red Sea reef,
to bag specimen fish.
of an extraordinarily simple device co-created by
Jacques-Yves Cousteau, the French explorer known
for his films, his TV shows, and marine conservation. allowing cars to operate on cooking oil, an essential
Cousteau made his motto, “Il faut aller voir—We must wartime adaptation when the Nazis had comman-
go and see for ourselves.” With his 1943 co-invention of deered all the gasoline for motor vehicles.
the Aqua-Lung, the first safe self-contained underwa- When Cousteau traveled to Paris in 1942 to explain
ter breathing apparatus (SCUBA), he invited ordinary the air pressure problem to Gagnan, the engineer
people to take that motto as their own, to experience thought his gas regulator could be the solution.
the undersea world for themselves. Together they tinkered until they had something they
Cousteau learned to swim when he was four, but could test, a regulator attached by tubes to three can-
his earliest ambitions aimed at the sky, not the sea. isters of compressed air. Cousteau took the prototype
In 1930 he entered the French naval academy to for a swim in the Marne River, east of Paris. “I took
become a pilot, a dream sidetracked by a nearly fatal normal breaths in a slow rhythm,” he said, “bowed
car accident that fractured both his arms. Fellow my head, and swam smoothly down to 30 feet.”
naval officer Philippe Tailliez suggested Cousteau try The device worked—while he was horizontal.
ocean swimming to help his recovery. Tailliez loaned When he was upright, it leaked air. Cousteau and
him a pair of goggles and took him spearfishing in Gagnan rearranged the intake and exhaust tubes to
the Mediterranean near Toulon, France. be at the same level. Eventually they had a version
Swimming with the goggles was a revelation: “As that Cousteau felt comfortable trying out in the sea.
soon as I put my head underwater, I got it, a shock … I Over the course of many months in 1943, Cousteau,
understood that from that day on, all my free time Tailliez, and their friend Frédéric Dumas cautiously
would be devoted to underwater exploration.” tested the device they were calling the Aqualung.
Eventually Cousteau could go as deep as 60 feet They made more than 500 dives in the Mediterra-
and stay there for up to 80 seconds. But that wasn’t nean, going a little deeper each time. By the onset of
long enough or deep enough for him. “Always I autumn they’d reached 130 feet. By October Dumas
rebelled against the limitations imposed by a single had descended 90 feet more.
lungful of air,” he wrote in a 1952 article for National “The best way to observe a fish is to become a fish,”
Geographic, his first for the magazine. Cousteau wrote in that first National Geographic
article. “And the best way to become a fish—or a
for deepwater diving were
I N T H E 1 93 0 S T H E O P T I O N S reasonable facsimile thereof—is to don an under-
few. Mobility in the diving suits the French called water breathing device called the Aqualung. The
pieds lourds (heavy feet)—rubberized canvas suits Aqualung frees a man to glide, unhurried and
with a copper helmet and lead-soled shoes—was unharmed, fathoms deep beneath the sea.”
restricted by the length of the hose supplying air
from the surface. An autonomous breathing device its invention, the same
N E A R LY 8 0 Y E A R S A F T E R
created by Yves Le Prieur in 1925 freed divers from basic design is still in use. “It’s as simple and elegant
the cumbersome hose, but the air supply ran out as a doorknob,” says longtime National Geographic
quickly because of its continuous flow, limiting underwater photographer David Doubilet. “It doesn’t
time underwater. fail. In 65 years of diving, I have never had a failure.”
Cousteau had to come up with his own solution. But the ability to plumb the depths exposed divers
“I became an inventor by necessity,” he said. to other dangers. Although the Aqua-Lung made it
To go deeper, he needed a device that would provide easier to breathe by balancing ambient and internal
breathable air that also matched the pressure of the pressure, it couldn’t prevent what’s known as rapture
water: As a diver descends, the pressure increases, of the deep—nitrogen narcosis, when the nervous
reducing the volume of air in the body and potentially system becomes saturated with nitrogen as the diver
causing the lungs to collapse. Cousteau’s father-in-law descends. To Cousteau it was “an impression of
put him in touch with engineer Émile Gagnan, an euphoria, and then a gradual loss of reflex control,
expert in high-pressure pneumatic design. and then a loss of the self-preservation instinct.” To
It was the middle of World War II, and Germany Albert Falco, who sailed with Cousteau for nearly 40
controlled most of France. Gagnan worked for years, “Air takes on a funny taste, and you get drunk
France’s largest commercial gas company, in Paris, on your own breath.”
where he’d designed a valve that regulated fuel flow, Nitrogen narcosis can be deadly. In 1947 Cousteau,

16 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
PHOTOS: THE COUSTEAU SOCIETY (COUSTEAU PORTRAIT); ROBERT B. GOODMAN, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC IMAGE COLLECTION
E X P L O R E | THE BIG IDEA

who was still in the French Navy as part of its under- The 2021 film Becoming
water research group, organized autonomous diving Cousteau, from National Geo-
graphic Documentary Films,
tests in Toulon. He wanted to show that the Aqua- is now streaming on Disney+.
Lung would allow divers to go more than 100 meters D I S PAT C H E S
(328 feet) deep. But the person to make the initial FROM THE FRONT LINES
attempt, First Mate Maurice Fargues, died. After for more than 70 National Geographic feature stories. OF SCIENCE
passing 120 meters (394 feet), he lost consciousness. To him, “the Aqua-Lung regulator meant a passport A N D I N N OVAT I O N
He was frantically pulled to the surface but could not to 70 percent of our planet”—and Cousteau stands as
be resuscitated. Cousteau was devastated: “I start “a person whose importance to the planet can never,
to wonder if what I’m undertaking makes sense.” ever be forgotten or underestimated.”
To the French Navy it did. The diver group was Photographer Laurent Ballesta, who grew up
deployed by the navy to clear the deadly aftermath swimming, snorkeling, and scuba diving on France’s
of World War II from the Mediterranean, removing Mediterranean coast, was influenced by Cousteau as
mines hidden near harbors and retrieving pilots’ well. When Ballesta was 16, he was out with friends
bodies from downed airplanes. on a boat when they were surrounded by sharks.
But Cousteau wanted to use his invention to Based on his passionate viewing of Cousteau’s docu-
explore, not just salvage. In 1949 he left the navy mentaries, he recognized them as harmless basking
and soon acquired the Calypso, a former British sharks and jumped into the water to swim with them.
minesweeper. Adventuring on the ship, he advanced When Ballesta told his parents what had happened
underwater photography, discovering that there, and they didn’t believe him, he says, “That was the
“colors existed as brilliant and as beautiful as any at point where I decided that I have to learn photography.”
the surface.” In 1956 Cousteau made the movie The Jacques Cousteau remained active in undersea
Silent World with a young Louis Malle, who in time exploration until his death at age 87 in 1997. His job,
would become one of French cinema’s top directors. he once wrote, “was to show what was in the sea—the
beauties of it—so that people would get to know
the film, which won an Oscar,
DAV I D D O U B I L E T S AW and love the sea.” There’s still much to explore: The
with an uncle and cousin when he was 10. “My eyes National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
grew larger and larger and larger,” Doubilet says. estimates that more than 80 percent of the undersea
Cousteau became his hero. A year or two later, world remains largely unknown.
Doubilet learned to dive in a swimming pool at a In the 79 years since Cousteau and Gagnan invented
beach club in New Jersey: In roughly a decade Cous- the Aqua-Lung, more than 28 million people have fol-
teau’s groundbreaking Aqua-Lung had been adopted lowed them into the ocean and learned to scuba dive.
by the public as a recreational pursuit. This spring my son and I will join them. It’s what
“I put the thing on, and I went right to the bottom Will wanted for his 17th birthday—a passport to
of the pool,” Doubilet recalls. “I was plastered on the another world. j
bottom, but I was breathing, and it was just heavenly.” Staff writer Rachel Hartigan has written recently for the magazine
Doubilet would go on to photograph the Sargasso about the conflict in Ethiopia and the life of Explorer Robert Ballard.
ECOSYSTEM SCIENCE
Sea, the Great Barrier Reef, and other ocean marvels She’s writing a book about the ongoing search for Amelia Earhart.

OTTER-LY BENEF
W H E N S E A OT T E R S D I G F O R M E A L S
G E N E T I C D I V E R S I T Y I N T H R E AT E N E

S N U G I N T H E A N I M A L K I N G D O M ’ S thic
live their whole lives in the ocean, feedi
animals. In British Columbia they often
eelgrass (Zostera marina), leaving divots
of the aquatic vegetation. In meadows tha
with those they don’t, the eelgrasses are
and the plants more resilient, accordin
the journal Science. That’s because by
the seabed, otters prompt the plants to fl
and their digging provides more space
settle and germinate. Seagrasses such
as a result of warming and pollution; th
Advances such as this diving because they filter contaminants from th
bell enabled Laurent Bal-
lesta and his team to spend
provide habitat and food for many anim
28 days deep in the Medi- is a powerful example of how predato
terranean Sea in July 2019. ecosystems in unseen and little-known w
Erin Foster. — D O U G L A S M A I N

PHOTO: LAURENT BALLESTA PHOTOS (FROM TOP): STEFANO MACCHETTA; RALPH PACE; F. D’E
 BREAKTHROUGHS | E X P L O R E E X P L O R E | DATA S H E E T

Studies dwell on blue blooms

REVEALING ALL ...

A review of 280 Alpine regional plant
studies over 45 years shows that blue
flowers got the most attention;
yellow, white, or red/pink the next
most, and green/brown blooms much
less. Also popular: tall flowers (so
scientists don’t have to stoop?). The
research bias has implications for which
flowers get protection. — L O R I C U T H B E R T B Y A L B E RTO L U C A S LÓ P E Z A N D K E L S E Y N OWA KOW S K I

NUMERATION

Exploring
the Origins
of Counting
How did humans
go from an innate,
general sense of
quantity—a pair,
a few, many—to
inventing numbers
and arithmetic?
Why are counting
systems so diverse
across global cul-
tures? Answering
these questions
isn’t as easy as one,
two, three, so the
European Research
Council is funding

FICIAL
QUANTA, a multi-
year inquiry into
counting’s origins.
S , T H E Y E N C O U R AG E QUANTA will pore
E D AQ UAT I C P L A N T S .
over linguistic and
ckest fur, sea otters can ethnographic data,
ing heavily upon seafloor as well as artifacts
n dig clams out of fields of such as this 60,000-
s in otherwise dense mats
year-old notched
at otters inhabit compared
e more genetically diverse
hyena femur, which
ng to a study published in may have served
foraging and disturbing as a Neanderthal’s
flower and produce seeds, scratch paper.
and sunlight for seeds to — M I C H A E L G R E S H KO
as eelgrass are imperiled
Facial recognition
hey’re vital to ecosystems
Leonardo da Vinci’s
he water, store carbon, and “Mona Lisa” may
mals. The study’s finding have one of the most
recognizable yet myste-
ors often influence their
rious visages of all time.
ways, says lead researcher Would today’s apps know
what makes her smile?

ERRICO 22 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
E X P L O R E | DATA S H E E T

... IN APPS
T R AV E L A P P S FOOD AND DRINK E N T E RTA I N M E N T S
Applications are ordered AND MEDIA
by category and amount

Wetherspoon
of data they can gather.

McDonald’s

Clubhouse
DoorDash
Deliveroo

YouTube
Trainline
FILLED BOXES

Nat Geo
Disney+
Am. Air.

Just Eat
Ryanair

Amtrak

Spotify
Airbnb

Netflix
Oculus
INDICATE

Uber

Jet2
DATA CAN BE
COLLECTED

CLICKING “ACCEPT” without reading the

fine print is the norm for many of us when
PERSONAL DATA: Hobbies
first accessing a digital app. But what exactly
are we accepting? Clario, an internet-security Mobile number
software company based in the United Arab Home phone number
Emirates, compiled 2021 data from some of the
Phone, device type
world’s most used apps to assess which data
they can collect and store once we tap that Email
button. The information includes the basics Name
such as name, date of birth, and email address.
Languages
But it can quickly get more personal, from our
pets and hobbies to height, weight, and sexual Age
orientation. Many apps also can store bank Bank account details
information and connect to our social media
Live location
accounts. Social media apps—increasingly
under fire for privacy concerns—collect data Home address
from the broadest variety of sources. Contacts
Image recognition (face)
Image recognition (environment)
Meta said last November that it would
Top collectors Image recognition (object) stop using facial recognition on Face-
book—and that executing the change
Religious belief would result in the deletion of more
Salary than a billion people’s individual facial
29 of 37 24 23 22 19 recognition templates.
Current employers
Apps for social networking (Facebook and Instagram),
dating (Tinder and Grindr), and transportation (Uber) Voice recognition
are data collection leaders. For example, Facebook
can mine information from 29 of the 37 personal data Health and lifestyle
variables examined in the study.
Allergies and intolerances
Interests
Top collectors owned by Meta
Country of birth
Past employers
Many apps share data.
29 of 37 19 17 10 8 Employment status Spotify, for example,
can tap into your social
In 2021 an ex-employee of Facebook (now named Meta) Job title media profiles to learn
leaked documents about privacy and misinformation your musical interests.
abuses within the company. The Facebook app can access Access to image library If you share a photo
the most data directly; all other Meta apps can gather on Instagram of a con-
data from the Facebook app if accounts are linked. Pet ownership
cert you’ve attended,
Race the artist or band might
show up in your Spotify
Types of imaging Height recommendations.

Facial: Recognizes Image recognition Weight

people and their helps companies Marital status
key features study an app user’s
appearance and Sexual orientation
Background: surroundings to
Detects elements in tailor ads to that Gender and sex
the environment person’s needs and
Social profile (friends)
interests. Of the 58
Object: Identifies apps in this study, Social profile (hobbies)
an object or prod- 16 use some form of
uct within an image image recognition. Social profile (interests)

SOURCE: CLARIO.CO. DATA ARE FROM JULY AND NOVEMBER 2021 AND INCLUDE DATA
A COMPANY CAN COLLECT AND STORE ONLY AFTER SECURING USER PERMISSION.
 O C I A L N E T WO R K I N G H E A LT H SHOPPING LIFESTYLE FINANCE WO R K A N D TA S K
AND FITNESS

Slimming World

Google Sheets
CVS Pharmacy

Google Maps
Credit Karma
MyFitnessPal

Google Docs
Sleep Cycle

Headspace
Messenger
WhatsApp
Instagram
Facebook

Coinbase

Facetune
Walmart

OfferUp
Amazon
Lidl Plus
Twitter

Depop

Bet365
CoStar
Ocado
Tinder

TikTok
Grindr

PayPal
Strava

Zoom

Gmail

VSCO
Tesco

ASOS

Slack
eBay

Nike

Ikea
APP DOES NOT
Flo

COLLECT DATA

Hobbies
Mobile number
Home phone number
Phone, device type
Email
Name
Languages
Age
Bank account details
Live location
Home address
Contacts
Image recog. (face)
Image recog. (environ.)
Some apps use voice recog-
nition to grant access. But it’s Image recog. (object)
information gleaned from fac-
tors such as a person’s location Religious belief
or images, not conversations, Salary
that helps them target ads.
Current employers
Voice recognition
Health and lifestyle
Allergies and intolerances
Interests
Country of birth
Past employers
Employment status
Job title
Access to image library
Pet ownership
Race
Height
Several dating apps, including
the popular Grindr, have Weight
removed ethnicity filters from
their platforms. Most social Marital status
networking apps in this study Sexual orientation
do not collect racial data.
Gender and sex
Social profile (friends)
Social profile (hobbies)
Social profile (interests)

THE WALT DISNEY COMPANY IS MAJORITY OWNER OF NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC PARTNERS.

PHOTO: “MONA LISA,” CA 1503-1516, BY LEONARDO DA VINCI, LOUVRE, PARIS, BRIDGEMAN IMAGES
E X P L O R E | PLANET POSSIBLE

In spring, help wild things

P L A N E T and their offspring thrive
with hands-on projects—
and by keeping hands off.
For more stories about how
to help the planet, go to
natgeo.com/planet. BY ANNIE ROTH

1
3
BIRD-SAFE WINDOWS

Transparent, reflective WE NEED INSECTS to polli-

glass confuses birds. Up nate plants, remove waste
to a billion a year in the
from ecosystems, and feed
U.S. die from collisions
with glass—nearly half other animals; insects need
from hitting home win- CAREFUL SPRING CLEANING BUILD safe places to rest and to
dows. These DIY fixes AN lay their eggs. Stores sell
discourage birds from BEFORE FIRING UP THE INSECT bug hotels to put in your
trying to fly through MOWER OR HEDGE TRIM- ABODE
yard—but for an all-ages
windows: Mark glass MER, CHECK GROUNDS project, why not create
with tempera paint,
stickers, or tape, mak- AND SHRUBS FOR SMALL one? 1. Find a cardboard
ing gaps in the pattern ANIMALS, BIRDS, AND box with one open side.
no larger than 2 inches NESTS. IF YOU FIND 2. Fit toilet tissue tubes and
tall by 4 inches wide— smaller tubes of rolled paper
or 2 inches by 2 inches A CREATURE NEEDING
into the box. 3. Fill the tubes
for greater deterrence. R E L O C AT I O N O R H E L P,
with sticks, grasses, and
The American Bird SEARCH FOR A NEARBY
Conservancy has more leaves, and place the box in
ideas at abcbirds.org/ ANIMAL RESCUE/REHAB an undisturbed corner of the
glass-collisions. E X P E R T A T A H N O W.O R G . yard. Voilà: an insect inn.

4
WATCHING THE BABIES

Do you assume a young

animal is in peril if its
mother isn’t around? Don’t,
says urban wildlife expert
Jim Monsma. Some babies
(ducks, opossums) are
always with mom; others
(rabbits, deer) spend hours
a day with no mother in
sight. When in doubt, don’t
touch the animal; first,
seek a rehabber’s advice
(see #2), Monsma says.

PHOTOS: REBECCA HALE, NGM STAFF (WINDOW, BUG HOTEL); JOEL SARTORE, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC PHOTO ARK (SQUIRREL); ROLF KOPFLE, ALAMY STOCK PHOTO (FAWN)
 BASIC INSTINCTS | E X P L O R E

BIZARRE PAIRING
Siphopteron makisig sea slugs
have both female genitalia

MEET A HERMAPHRODITIC SEA

and a double-ended penis.

Female 0.05

SLUG THAT WIELDS A NEEDLE

Tail genitalia inches

Head
Foot

the sea slug Siphopteron makisig

I N I T S N AT I V E PAC I F I C WAT E R S , Penile
stylet
looks tiny and delicate, like a bud of colored glass. But in reality Penile
bulb
this slug is a mirror-image mating machine, as modeled by the
pair in the photograph below. Intertwined for mating, they
Like most sea slug species, S. makisig is a hermaphrodite, reciprocate sperm delivery
by extending the bulb into
endowed with both male and female reproductive organs that it
the female genitalia.
uses at the same time during mating. But unlike other sea slugs,
it tops off trysts with unusually targeted stabbing.
The sex starts normally enough. To fertilize eggs developing
in each slug’s female parts, the other slug deposits sperm with its
penis. Actually, only half of its penis, which has two prongs: one
that delivers sperm with its bulbous end, and the other tipped
with a syringe-like stylet (and sometimes called hypodermic
genitalia). During the sex act, each slug stabs the other with the
stylet, which delivers prostate fluid likely bearing hormones.
Evolutionary biologist Rolanda Lange says the fluid may “increase Then each pokes the stylet
the fecundity of a sea slug’s own sperm, or inhibit that deposited into the other’s forehead,
injecting fluid that may
by previous partners.”
affect neural function.
When other animals stab partners during sex (aka traumatic
insemination), they spear various body parts. But in a study Lange
co-authored, she identifies S. makisig as “the first known instance”
of an animal stabbing its partner between the eyes—perhaps the
better to influence the central nervous system. — E VA VA N D E N B E RG

DESCRIPTION
S. makisig, a marine gastro-
pod, is less than a quarter
inch long, with yellow and
red markings on its trans-
lucent white exterior. (The
blue seen here is water in
the image background.)

H A B I TAT
The sea slug lives on sand
beds at ocean depths from
about 20 feet to about
90 feet and commonly
nestles within microalgal
formations.

RANGE
The mollusk has been
identified in waters off
the Philippines, Australia,
and Indonesia.

DIANA MARQUES, NGM STAFF. PHOTO: NILS ANTHES AND ROLANDA LANGE, UNIVERSITY OF TUEBINGEN
E X P L O R E | CLOSER LOOK

the clay in San

AC C O R D I N G TO L E G E N D,

POTTERY OF
Bartolo Coyotepec village is blessed.
Artisans who use it to make Oaxaca’s
famous barro negro, black clay pottery,
are reluctant to reveal its secrets.

THE NIGHT
But 66-year-old Amando Pedro
Martínez is an exception. Sparks
crackle from the earthen oven in his
studio as I watch him reach, with
cloth-covered hands, into the still cool-
ing kiln and pull out smooth ebony
I N M E X I C O, A N A N C I E N T A RT plates one by one.
I S E M E R G I N G A S A S U S TA I N A B L E Made from clay mined on the slopes
A LT E R N A T I V E T O P L A S T I C S . of the Sierra Madre across the valley,
these pieces started out the color of
BY RACHNA SACHASINH wet mud. Impregnated by heat and
PHOTOGRAPHS BY smoke, they transformed into sleek
MARICEU ERTHAL GARCÍA grays and blacks evocative of twilight.
It’s no wonder Zapotec folktales call
barro negro “pottery of the night.”
Pedro Martínez is upholding
an artisanal tradition that dates
back more than 2,500 years. Just
beyond his studio, the town’s tidy,
broad avenues are lined with home
workshops where extended families
labor side by side turning clay into
pots and figurines. Travelers arrive in
tour buses to buy the distinctive black
Beautiful and functional, pottery—but what tourists see isn’t
the Bartolo jug by
Colectivo 1050° is a exactly traditional.
return to the traditional When tin, aluminum, and plastics
roots of black pottery. began to replace watertight black clay
vessels, artisans adapted to a changing
market by introducing new shapes,
offering decorative pieces, and incor-
porating different techniques, such as
etched patterns and plastic molds.
While these changes have helped
F ROM AC A D E MY AWA R D ® - N OM I N AT E D A N D E M MY ® -W I N N I N G F I L M M A K E R L I Z GA R B U S

The Extraordinary Life of the Ocean’s

Great Protector

Now Streaming
Only on
E X P L O R E | CLOSER LOOK

black pottery survive, and some might say prosper, While the majority of the region’s pottery was made
they have also compromised the village’s historic to absorb the thermal shock of cooking on top of a hot
relationship to clay. flame, San Bartolo Coyotepec’s was different. Fired
However, a talented new generation, including in sealed underground ovens at high temperatures,
the cooperative Colectivo 1050°, which counts Pedro barro negro combines the color and impervious clay
Martínez as a member, is steering black pottery back body that result from intense carbonization. It’s
to its utilitarian roots. In the process, the artisans suited to holding and transporting liquids—but not
are bringing attention to the craft’s sophisticated for cooking, as traditional red pottery is.
design and inherent sustainability, an antidote to “In Oaxaca, clay represents a way of living,” says
single-use plastic. industrial designer Kythzia Barrera, co-founder of
“Barro negro is the megafauna of Oaxacan Colectivo 1050°, which collaborates with Indigenous
pottery,” says Eric Mindling, documentary photog- potters to spotlight the craft’s ancient system of
rapher and author of Fire and Clay: The producing and consuming in balance
Art of Oaxacan Pottery. “It’s the most with the Earth—what Barrera calls the
recognizable, but its rise is dependent “artisan mindset.”
on a rich pottery ecosystem.” Mindling MEXICO “Take the well jug, for instance,”
Mexico
has visited more than 70 villages across City says Barrera. “It’s got a short neck for
Oaxaca and encountered at least as Monte Albán tying the rope to lower it into a well.
many variations in pottery style. OAXACA The round, egg-shaped body is ergo-
The earliest examples of black pot- nomically designed to tilt when it hits
tery were found in Monte Albán, a Mesoamerican water. The mouth scoops the water and keeps it in
Zapotec and Mixtec stronghold dating to 500 B.C. without spilling. This is good design, perfectly suited
Situated roughly five miles southwest of Oaxaca City, to the task with no waste. It’s a design that no doubt
Monte Albán rises at the vital junction of Oaxaca’s was worked out by the whole community, over time.”
three main valleys. This heaving landscape, with its In Oaxaca, where traditional communities struggle
sinuous valleys, mountain passes, and trading routes, with marginalization, clay is an integral part of
harbors at least 16 distinct ethnic groups. They still identity. “So we will continue to make and use clay,”
practice the milpa farming system of cultivating corn, says Barrera. “We must.” j
beans, and squash together. Rachna Sachasinh writes about travel and culture and has worked
Oaxaca’s pottery evolved to perform tasks related with artisan groups, including those in Oaxaca. Mariceu Erthal
to milpa, such as cooking, storing, and irrigation. García is a Mexican photographer based in Querétaro.

In San Marcos Tlapazola, an Indigenous Zapotec village known for its red clay pottery tradition, María Cruz López begins
the process of molding a comal, or griddle. Oaxaca’s diverse earthenware includes black, red, and green pottery.

NGM MAPS
N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C MARCH 2022

Slave Shipwrecks . . . . . . . . . P. 36
Alpine Snow Loss . . . . . . . . P. 58
Big Cat Reserves . . . . . . . . P. 86
Colombian Activists . . P. 100
Cricket Catchers . . . . . . . . P. 120

F EAT U R E S

86
THE CHANCES
OF SEEING
BIG CATS SUCH
AS LEOPARDS
AND TIGERS
I N I N D I A H AV E
GONE UP
SIGNIFICANTLY
DURING THE
PAST DECADE,
THANKS TO
SUCCESSFUL
C O N S E RVAT I O N
EFFORTS
THAT INCLUDE
WILDLIFE
RESERVES.

PHOTO: SHAAZ JUNG

 B Y TA RA RO B E RT S

P H O T O G R A P H S B Y WAY N E L AW R E N C E

NO
MORE
A diver’s quest for the stories
of those lost on slave ships reveals
the human side of a tragic era—and helps her
connect with her family’s rich history.
Diving With a Purpose
(DWP) lead dive
instructor Jay Haigler
cradles a stone from
a ballast pile in Coral
Bay, St. John, in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. The
stones have been key
to identifying slave
ships; they often were
used to balance the
weight of captives in
a ship’s cargo hold.
DAVID DOUBILET

37
THE WATER IS COOL AGAINST MY SKIN,
the silence absolute, and as I hover over the remains,
I feel peaceful, thankful, a sense of coming home.
Descend underwater with me—not too deep, maybe
only 20 feet or so—and you’ll see about 30 other divers,
paired in sets of two. They calmly float in place, despite
strong currents off the coast of Key Largo, Florida,
sketching images of coral-encrusted artifacts or taking
measurements. For the first time, I am helping map the
remains of a shipwreck.
Most of the divers are African American. We’re
training as underwater archaeology advocates, gain-
ing the skills necessary to join expeditions and help
document the wreckage of slave ships being found
around the world, ships such as the São José Paquete
d’Africa in South Africa, the Fredericus Quartus and
Christianus Quintus in Costa Rica, and the Clotilda in
the United States. An estimated 12.5 million Africans
were forced onto ships like these during the trans-
atlantic slave trade from the 16th to the 19th centuries,
38 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Storyteller and diver
Tara Roberts is helping
document some of the
thousand slave ships
that wrecked in the
Atlantic Ocean. She is
working to tell the
story of DWP and the
complex history of
the global slave trade
in an inclusive way that
amplifies Black voices.
according to Nafees Khan, a professor in the the spray of seawater as the boat races home
College of Education at Clemson University after a day’s work. It is soul-lifting to look at the
and adviser to the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade tired faces of those around me and know these
Database. ordinary people—teachers, civil servants, engi-
“It took at least 36,000 voyages,” he says. One neers, students—are here despite their busy
thousand or so ships likely sank. schedules, volunteering because they love to
Enter Diving With a Purpose, a group that dive and believe in this important work.
trains divers to find and conserve historical Lounging on a return trip, you might hear
and cultural artifacts buried deep in the waters. lead instructor Jay Haigler’s booming voice and
Since its founding in 2003, DWP has trained his trademark cackle—and you might see the
some 500 divers to help archaeologists and his- twinkle in his eye and his infectious joy when
torians search for and document such ships. The he says, quietly before nodding off, “This is
group’s goal is to help Black folks, in particular, what I live for.”
find their own history and tell their own stories. And it just might touch you.
“When you are African American and you’re
diving on a slave ship, that’s a whole lot different at the start—at the

M
AY B E BY STA RT I N G
from somebody else doing it,” says legendary beginning of the voyages from those
diver Albert José Jones, a co-founder of the shores to these shores, and inside the
National Association of Black Scuba Divers ships—we can find clues to a history
and board member of DWP. “Every time you little discussed, to stories that have
go down, you realize basically two things: One been lost in the depths. We can begin to assemble
is that maybe your ancestors were on the ship. long-lost threads that help us better understand
The other thing you realize is that you have a our obligation to the past and to each other, and
history. Your history didn’t start on the shores change the way we think about who we are as a
of the United States. It didn’t start with slavery. society and how we arrived at where we are today.
Your history started [in] Africa at the beginning We are deeply connected to those who made
of time, the beginning of civilization.” the crossing. And we are connected to the esti-
The National Museum of African American His- mated 1.8 million souls who perished along
tory and Culture, in Washington, D.C., showcases the way. The Atlantic Ocean is full of forgotten
DWP’s work as part of the Slave Wrecks Project, a people, churning with the spirits of folks whose
network of groups that uncover and document the names we may never know. Souls who have
remnants of slave ships and work to tell a more never been acknowledged or mourned. Dream-
inclusive history of the slave trade. ers, poets, artists, thinkers, scientists, farmers.
Diving With a Purpose members are “using More than just cargo or bodies packed in a hold.
their skills to dive to help us find the stories that More than faceless statistics. More than people
are buried under the water,” says Lonnie Bunch bound for enslavement.
III, the museum’s founding director and the sec- And their day of reckoning is at hand. It is
retary of the Smithsonian Institution. “In some time for their stories to rise from the depths, to
ways, there’s so much we know about slavery. But be told in their fullness, in their wonder—and
there’s so much we still don’t know. And I would with love, with honor, with respect. Finally
argue the last frontier is what’s under the water.” helping heal a wound that has festered for far
Under the water. Out here in the deep. It is too long. That is the dream. That is the promise.
magic feeling the ocean breeze on my skin and That is the possibility of this work, of this watery
resurrection that DWP has taken on.
These ships “allow us to honor those that
The National
Geographic Society, didn’t make it,” Bunch says. “They allow us to
committed to illuminat- sort of almost touch sacred spaces that are not
ing and protecting just spaces of death, but spaces of memory. And
the wonder of our world,
supports National that as long as we find those spaces, as long as we
Geographic Explorer dive for these ships, as long as we learn as much
Tara Roberts’s storytell- as we can, those people whose names we’ll never
ing about the search
for wrecked slave ships. know are not lost. They’re remembered.”
ILLUSTRATION BY JOE MCKENDRY But there is a truth, an obstacle, in the way:
 IT IS TIME FOR THE
The wrecks are notoriously hard to find. Ships
from that time were primarily made of wood,

STORIES OF THOSE
and they have disintegrated over time and been
absorbed by the sea. Searchers today use equip-

WHO DIED ABOARD

ment such as magnetometers and side-scan
sonars to detect unnatural, manufactured mate-
rials in murky water. The work can take place
amid treacherous conditions or at sites teeming
with marine life that should not be disturbed.
“Once you disturb a site, there’s no making that
SLAVE SHIPS TO RISE
site how it was before it’s been disturbed,” says FROM THE DEPTHS,
TO BE TOLD IN THEIR
Ayana Flewellen, a co-founder of the Society of
Black Archaeologists and instructor with DWP.

FULLNESS—WITH LOVE,
“So we’re really intentional about how we are
documenting, being very cognizant of what is
in the water around us to ensure that we’re not
disturbing the wreck or ocean creatures.”
The sandy ocean floor covers and reveals as
it fancies. What may be seen today may not be
HONOR, AND RESPECT.
seen tomorrow. A proper expedition with histo-
rians and archaeologists can take years. But it is
important to take as long as is needed to look.
“Our identities are informed by the past,”
says Calinda Lee, the head of programs and as can be, with a beautiful voice that rises and
exhibitions for the National Center for Civil and falls with the cadence of a soulful love song. He
Human Rights in Atlanta. “The past provides is my herald, a songbird who called me forth and
necessary context … and [it] is something that who continues to encourage me on this voyage.
we have to engage if we’re going to be honest I remember feeling my heart pound and leap
about what race means for us, has meant for us.” as I gave him a resounding yes when he invited
me to join them. A yes that started a rolling, pow-
L E A R N E D O F D W P from a picture of Black erful wave that eventually would wipe my life

I women divers that I saw at the National clean. I would resign from a communications
Museum of African American History and director’s job, give up my apartment in Washing-
Culture. Also in the photo was Ken Stewart, ton, D.C., and siphon funds from my small bank
the visionary who got DWP off the ground account to travel and get the dives required to
almost 20 years ago. He had met the lone archae- participate in DWP’s training program.
ologist at Biscayne National Park in the Florida I joined DWP partly because I wanted this
Keys, Brenda Lanzendorf, who needed divers to adventure. Diving sites around the world. Push-
help find the Spanish slave ship Guerrero, which ing myself physically. But also because I’ve
had wrecked in 1827. As the southern regional felt lost these past years. As if I don’t belong. I
representative for the National Association of am single, have no children, and among my close
Black Scuba Divers, Stewart had access to lots friends, I’m the only one who has had 10 differ-
of divers. He rounded up a few. They learned ent addresses—in eight cities, three countries,
how to map shipwrecks. Stewart and on three continents—in the past
declared that it was time for the group 15 years. As a storyteller traveling the
to dive with a purpose. Since then, DWP world reporting for magazines and
has helped document 18 shipwrecks news sites, I’ve felt like a global citizen
and logged more than 18,000 hours in but also like a leaf floating in the wind.
six countries. Unrooted. Unmoored.
Listen to the
Stewart steps with the quickness and podcast Into I prepared for a journey that I hoped
the rhythm of an uptown New Yorker. the Depths. could help me answer one core ques-
Use your phone’s
He is meticulously groomed, his salt- camera to scan tion: How can finding and telling the
and-pepper beard and mustache as neat the QR code. lost history of the slave trade help me,

HIDDEN NO MORE 41
 ‘BEING
CONNECTED WITH
YOUR ANCESTORS
IS A VERY POWERFUL
THING. IF YOU BREAK
THAT CONNECTIVITY,
IT’S LIKE YOU’RE
WANDERING
AROUND LOST.’ KAMAU SADIKI

DWP lead instructor mission, represents

Kamau Sadiki (at left) a new generation
has participated in searching for wrecked
more than 20 diving slave ships and docu-
missions. Sadiki helped menting African Amer-
identify the slave ships ican history. Preparing
São José Paquete to become a professor,
d’Africa in South Africa she wants to increase
and Clotilda in Mobile, the presence of Black
Alabama. Jewell women academic lead-
Humphrey, an archae- ers, who make up just
ology doctoral student 3 percent of faculty
on her first diving on college campuses.
 I BEGIN TO SEE A WAY
I also hear stories of the São José Paquete
d’Africa shipwreck. The Portuguese ship trav-

OF INTERPRETING ONE
eled from Lisbon to Mozambique Island in 1794.
Traffickers loaded more than 500 people,

OF THE MOST PAINFUL

many of the Makua ethnic group, into the ship’s
cargo hold. Headed for Brazil, the ship met its
fate in the wee hours of the morning on Decem-

PARTS OF AMERICAN ber 27, on the rocks off Cape Town, South Africa.
Two hundred twelve of the captive Africans on

HISTORY THROUGH A NEW

board were killed, the survivors sold into slavery.
The Slave Wrecks Project had been on a mis-

LENS, WITH THE

sion to find the São José and several other wrecks
since 2008. The evidence eventually pointed to

POSSIBILITY OF REPAIRING
the area around Clifton, a suburb of Cape Town.
“We knew about the shipwreck, and Clifton,
because it was identified by treasure hunters in

A DEEP WOUND. the eighties as a Dutch ship,” says Jaco Boshoff

of the Iziko Museums, the lead archaeologist of
the wreck and a co-founder of the Slave Wrecks
Project. But he thought “maybe the identifica-
tion was wrong, let’s go have a look.”
DWP provided divers to assist in the search.
While Ken Stewart is my herald, Kamau Sadiki
as a Black American woman, figure out where I has been my guide, my sensei. He has served as
belong—and to whom I belong? my instructor and dive buddy. A shining light of
clarity and purpose, he has been on more than
20 missions. He shares what it has meant for him
MOZAMBIQUE & SOUTH AFRICA: AFFIRMATION to travel to Cape Town in 2013, to dive into those
on Ilha de Moçam- turbulent waters, and to find and touch artifacts

M
Y JOURNEY BEGINS
bique (Mozambique Island), an island from the São José.
just under two miles long and less than “It was like you can hear the screams and the
a quarter of a mile wide, in the north of hollering and the pain, and the agony of being
Mozambique. The island was the colo- on a vessel in shackles, the sinking and break-
nial capital of Portuguese East Africa from the ing up in the sea,” he says. “You know, in scuba
16th through the 19th centuries. Portuguese col- diving we wear a mask, and sometimes they get
onizers eventually turned it into a center of the foggy. But mine got wet from tears.”
slave trade; hundreds of thousands of Africans Trauma. Exactly what I feared to face. But
were trafficked from its port. then the story shifts and takes a surprising, and
I have come at the invitation of DWP and the a soul-affirming, turn.
Slave Wrecks Project, hosted by the National After positively identifying the São José and
Museum of African American History and Cul- determining that some of the people held captive
ture. The project includes the George Washing- in its cargo hold were Makua, the team, which
ton University, the Iziko Museums of South included Bunch and Sadiki, went back to the
Africa, the U.S. National Park Service, and DWP, Makua-descendant community in the coastal
among others. village of Mossuril across from Mozambique
The island is colorful—reds, pinks, and blues Island to deliver the news.
painted on colonial-style buildings. On nondive Following a ceremony of singing, dancing, and
days, I stroll through the cobblestone streets and speeches, Chief Evano Nhogache, the highest
the dirt paths. I eat good food such as matapa de ranking Makua there, presented Bunch with soil
siri siri, a stew of seaweed, cashews, and coco- from the island in a special cowrie-shell vessel
nut milk that looks like creamed spinach. I note with explicit instructions.
bright smiles on friendly faces that say, “Tudo “He said that his ancestors have asked that
bem—How’s it going?” as I pass. when I go back to South Africa … if I could

44 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
sprinkle the soil over the side of the wreck, so for The young men started scuba diving with the
the first time since 1794, [his] people can sleep nonprofit diving group Centro Comunitario de
in their own land,” Bunch says. Buceo Embajadores y Embajadoras del Mar
“I lost it,” Bunch adds, shaking his head as he (Ambassadors of the Sea Community Diving
recalls the scene. “I’m crying … I’m just thinking Center) when they were only 14 years old. The
about the contradictions, the beauty that sur- center has galvanized and trained local teens
rounds me, the fact that I’m a historian, but this and young adults as scuba divers and citizen
is about how living people feel and think.” scientists since 2014.
The team returned to South Africa to carry “People call us recreational divers. And we
out Chief Nhogache’s request. It was a rainy, are—re-creational,” says journalist María Suárez,
stormy, dreary day on June 2, 2015. About 30 a co-founder of Ambassadors of the Sea. “We are
people turned out. Sadiki and two other divers re-creating diving. We are re-creating the history
walked into the water, and each distributed the of Costa Rica. We are re-creating the way that the
soil from the cowrie-shell vessel. kids relate to the ocean.”
“We stood for a moment. And I think there’s Ambassadors of the Sea leads a community
one point where we just stood and embraced. effort to help identify and document two possi-
And just let the waves hit us and wash us,” Sadiki ble wrecks of slave ships in their harbor, and it
says. “I couldn’t speak at all. And tears started collaborates often with DWP.
flowing down all three of our eyes.” The Browns are one of the oldest families in
After traveling to Cape Town to see the wreck Puerto Viejo, 200-plus relatives who look out for
site for myself, I sit on the Sea Point Promenade, one another fiercely—and have a variety of skin
a two-mile stretch of palm trees, paved paths, hues, even within the same family unit. Stories
and joggers that connects neighborhoods along of late, whispered in beds at night and over cof-
the coast. It is adjacent to the location where fee in the morn, hypothesize that maybe the first
the São José sank. I listen to the violence of the Brown ancestor in these parts came in the cargo
crashing waves on a bright sunny day, imagin- hold of one of the slave ships in the harbor.
ing what it would have been like more than two Historians and archaeologists have gathered
centuries ago as the ship struck those rocks and evidence that strongly suggests the bricks, can-
sank in the darkness. My heart aches for what nons, anchors, bottles, and pipes at a site in the
those in the São José’s cargo hold must have felt waters of Cahuita National Park belong to two
that night of the wreck. The trauma still seems Danish slave ships, the Fredericus Quartus and
to exist as an actual energy radiating out from the Christianus Quintus.
the sea. And I feel it. “That site is just amazing,” says Danish
But this time, I feel something else. Healing. archaeologist Andreas Bloch, who has been help-
Finality. Resolution that comes from knowing ing Ambassadors of the Sea document the ships.
what happened. “You have an archaeological site exactly where
And I am transported to a place of hope and you’ve got tourists snorkeling and enjoying the
possibility. I begin to see a way of interpreting wildlife. You have this amazing story that’s just
one of the most painful parts of American history lying there as an open-air museum for every-
through a new lens, with a loving perspective, and body to see.”
with the possibility of repairing a deep wound— The two ships set sail from Denmark in 1708,
of closure. And that feels revelatory. heading to St. Thomas in the Danish West Indies
filled with 806 captives from West Africa. But the
ships, which were traveling in a convoy partly
COSTA RICA: A QUEST FOR IDENTITY because of concerns the captives might rebel as
to the small towns of they had once before, were blown off course by

I
H E A D T O C O S TA R I C A ,
Puerto Viejo de Talamanca and Cahuita, bad weather and navigational errors. In March
about 10 miles apart in Limón Province on 1710 they landed in the harbor at Cahuita. The
the Caribbean coast. crews on both ships mutinied. The sailors divided
I meet with cousins Kevin Rodríguez the ships’ gold among themselves, then burned
Brown and Pete Stephens Rodríguez, then the Fredericus and scuttled the Christianus after
19 and 18, respectively, and their aunt Sonia some 650 Africans still alive reached shore.
Rodríguez Brown. Ab out 100 of the Africans s o on were

HIDDEN NO MORE 45
 N O R T H A M E R I C A

UNITED STATES
Maryland
21,000 Other
1860
Virginia
Clotilda
East Coast
South 83,000 ports The last ship known to import captive Africans
Gulf Coast Mobile,
13,000 Alabama Carolina 39,000 to the U.S.—a practice outlawed by the U.S. in
151,000
Arrived 1808—was set ablaze to hide the crime. After
Grand Bay, Miss. Departed slavery was abolished, many of the 108 Clotilda
July 8, 1860; between
towed to Ala., Feb. 27 and MAINLAND survivors formed a community, Africatown,
then scuttled March 4, 1860 N. AMERICA Bermuda (U.K.) which still exists near Mobile, Alabama.
307,000 Clotilda
G u l f o f Me x i c o route
to Afric
a
Spanish MEXICO A T L
N. American A N T I C
colonies
241,000
CUBA
764,000 O C E A N
BELIZE
GUAT. 695,000 DOM.
HOND. JAMAICA HAITI REP. Puerto Rico
EL SALVADOR
935,000 29,000 (U.S.)
NIC. St. Thomas
Caribbean 26,000
Santa Catalina I.
Other islands
COSTA RICA Sea 1,572,000 CARIBBEAN
Storm ISLANDS
Cahuita Bay forces
Arrived course 4,021,000
March 2, 1710; change 207,000
ships scuttled PANAMA 31,000 Chr
ist
days later t COLOMBIA ian lo
C

VENEZUELA us til
British Guiana V da
an rou
1708-1710
Christianus Quintus, Fredericus Quartus
75,000
GUYANA
d
Fr
ed
er
t e to
U.S.
Dutch Guiana ic
260,000 us
The crews of these two Danish frigates suppressed a IV
revolt and missed their destination of St. Thomas by SURINAME Fr. Guiana ro
21,000 u te
more than a thousand miles. Upon arrival in modern-day to
th
Costa Rica, they mutinied, released some 650 captives eC
arib
to save food, then scuttled the ships. bea
n
Amazonia Unknown
136,000 destination
SOUTH 791,000

DEATHS
Pernambuco recorded
BRAZIL
AMERICA 430,000

CRUEL
en route
1,309,000
Bahia
1,214,000

MAINLAND

COMMERCE
Spain first transported captive Africans to
SOUTH AMERICA
3,763,000

Southeast Brazil
1,389,000

the Americas in the early 1500s to replace

the dying Indigenous labor force in its
colonies. More than 36,000 slave voyages
had sailed for the Americas by 1866, when
the last recorded transatlantic slave ship
URUGUAY
arrived in Cuba. About a thousand vessels Río de la Plata
were lost at sea—several hundred with 92,000
Africans aboard. Only a few slave ships ARG.
that sank have ever been found.
 DENMARK Copenhagen
Depart for Africa
Christianus V–November 6, 1708 TOBACCO
RICE
Fredericus IV–December 5, 1708 FISH
CLOTH TAR

PE
IRE.
U.K. E U R O P E METAL TOOLS TIMBER

RO
FIREARMS
OR FURNITURE

U
ER TH

AM
E
FRANCE IC
A
Christianus V (Quintus)
and Fredericus IV (Quartus) SUGAR SUGAR
route to Africa COFFEE COFFEE IRON
MOLASSES CACAO SILVER
TEXTILES
Caribbean ATLANTIC
SPAIN BEADS CA
Sea RI
PORTUGAL OCEAN AF
To GRAIN AFR
I CAN of
Europe MEAT Mi S Gulf ea
BUTTER ddl G uin
8,000 e Pa
ssage
SOUT
H
AME
RICA
MOROCCO

Canary
Islands

MAURITANIA LUCRATIVE TRIANGLE

European nations traded goods, such as
Returned to Africa metals and textiles, from their empires to
122,000 Clotilda arrived on
purchase captives in Africa. Those Africans
(mainly intercepted May 15, 1860,
slave ships) and departed were shipped via the months-long Middle
around May 24 Passage to the Americas to work in agricul-
Cape SENEGAL ture and extract natural resources. Goods
Verde THE GAMBIA TOGO
NIGERIA produced by the labor of enslaved people
Senegambia BENIN were then sent back to Europe.
603,000
GUINEA- GUINEA GHANA
BISSAU Sierra CÔTE
Leone h Bight of Biafra
Ouida
D’IVOIRE
246,000 Windward Gold Coast 1,117,000
B t of
3 5 e n in
00

Coast 745,000 CAMEROON

LIBERIA 202,000
,0
h

EQ.
ig

B
1, 5
GUINEA
GABON
Depart for the Americas DEM. REP.
TOTAL R
EQUATO December 1709 OF THE
RECORDED
t h er Africa CONGO CONGO
O 0
AFRICAN 2,00
CAPTIVES 2,30
10,631,000
a
tral Afric
West Cen ,472,000
3 A F R I C A MOZAMBIQUE
Mozambique
Island
ANGOLA Depart for the Americas
December 3, 1794

St. Helena
(U.K.)
24,000
1794
São José Paquete d’Africa
te

Bound for Brazilian plantations with

ou

DEADLY CROSSING more than 500 enslaved southeast

ar
ric

Southeast Africans, the Portuguese ship ran

’Af

Of the more than 10 million recorded Africa aground during a storm near Cape
ed

captives forced onto ships, on average 409,000 Town. Survivors were resold in local
et
qu

one in eight died during the voyage.* slave markets; 212 captives drowned.
Pa
sé
Jo

SOUTH
ão

AFRICA S
MATTHEW W. CHWASTYK, JASON TREAT, AND
SOREN WALLJASPER, NGM STAFF. SCOTT ELDER
SOURCES: TRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE DATABASE, Cape of Good Hope Cape Town
SLAVEVOYAGES.ORG; SLAVE WRECKS PROJECT,
SMITHSONIAN-NMAAHC; ECU MARITIME STUDIES; Ship wrecked
GEORGE NØRREGÅRD, FORLISET VED NICARAGUA 1710 December 27, 1794

* HISTORICAL RECORDS FROM THE TRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE DATABASE ARE SHOWN IN THIS MAP. WHILE INCOMPLETE, THESE
RECORDS HAVE BEEN USED BY THE DATABASE TO ESTIMATE THE TOTAL NUMBER OF AFRICANS PUT ON SLAVE SHIPS AT 12.5 MILLION.
† SCIENTISTS ARE WORKING TO CONCLUSIVELY IDENTIFY THESE SHIPWRECKS.
Along this arm of the two-thirds of the
Mobile River in Ala- structure survived,
bama are the remains making it the most
of the Clotilda, the last intact slave ship found
known American ship to date. Some of the
to bring captive Afri- Africans trafficked on
cans to the U.S., in 1860. the Clotilda were buried
The captain tried to at Old Plateau Cemetery
burn the ship because (right) in Africatown,
importing enslaved a community founded
people had been illegal by the ship’s survivors
in the U.S. since 1808. after slavery had
Discovered in 2019, been abolished.
HIDDEN NO MORE 49
 ‘THE STORY OF
SLAVERY IS A
STORY OF
EMPOWERMENT. IT’S
ALSO A STORY OF
RESILIENCE, A STORY
OF TRIUMPH.’ JAY HAIGLER

Albert José Jones (top) co-founded the

has been on more than National Association
7,000 dives and is con- of Black Scuba Divers,
sidered the godfather in 1991. DWP’s Haigler
of Black scuba diving (right) has trained
in the U.S. He founded divers and searched
the country’s oldest for slave shipwrecks
Black diving club, for 15 years. He says
Underwater Adventure being underwater
Seekers in Washington, is a “life-changing,
D.C., in 1959, and spiritual experience.”

PHOTO (TOP): COURTESY ALBERT JOSÉ JONES

 ON A DIVE, I SEE IT:
water. She wondered, “Why this is not in history?
Why our family never taught us that? Why the
community never say anything?

THE OUTLINE OF AN “So I make myself a question,” Sonia contin-

ues in her soft and lyrical voice. “Who I am? And

ANCHOR ON THE I think that is the most beautiful question that

any people can do to [themselves]: Who I am?”

OCEAN FLOOR. I HOVER Who am I? This kind of ques-

W
HO I AM?

ABOVE AND FEEL THIS

tioning sounds familiar.
Nearly 1,500 miles north of Costa

INTENSE, DESPERATE
Rica, along the Gulf of Mexico, are
Mobile, Alabama, and Africatown,
another Afro-descended community.

LONGING TO KNOW MY In Africatown many know for certain that

their direct ancestors came over in 1860 on the

OWN FAMILY’S STORY. Clotilda, the last known ship to bring captive
Africans to U.S. shores. But those descendants
are also fighting to get the story of the Clotilda
and Africatown more widely told. They ask: Why
is our history not in history books?
In 1808 the transatlantic slave trade had been
abolished by the U.S. But an Alabama plantation
owner and shipbuilder, Timothy Meaher, made
a bet with a group of northern businessmen that
he could bypass the law. He sponsored an expe-
dition to West Africa and transported 110 captive
people to the U.S. on the Clotilda (two died en
route). The captain burned the ship on its return
to hide the evidence, and Meaher dispersed most
of the captives to the expedition’s financial back-
Author Tara Roberts’s great-great-grand- ers. He kept 32 people for himself.
parents Jack and Mary Roberts raised Five years later, in 1865, the Civil War ended,
their family in Edenton, North Carolina.
and the captives were emancipated. The men
worked in lumber and gunpowder mills and at
the rail yards; the women grew vegetables and
sold produce door-to-door. Some of these men
recaptured and enslaved. But some disappeared and women, who had arrived on Alabama’s
into the hills, into oral history and myth. Some shores naked and in shackles, managed to save
likely mixed into the local BriBri Indigenous money and eventually bought 57 acres on which
community and left a line of descendants who to build their own version of home.
still inhabit the area today. More than 150 years later, Africatown still
Kevin Rodríguez Brown says they know the exists, having experienced a heyday in the
Brown family is part BriBri and part “Afro,” the 1960s with more than 12,000 residents and bar-
term Costa Ricans use to describe people of bershops, grocery stores, churches, a cemetery,
African descent. But before diving at the wreck and plenty of descendants who still have letters,
site, he always thought the Afro part was 100 per- pictures, documents, and stories, passed down
cent Jamaican, since he knew Jamaicans came through the generations.
as immigrants to Costa Rica in the late 1800s to “They had the brilliance and the intellect, and
build the railroad. the passion and the wherewithal, to do all of
Sonia says the questions she and other mem- those things. I look back and I even try to reflect
bers of the community began to ask deepened as over, What did I do in 10 years?” laughs Jeremy
the young divers started finding artifacts in the Ellis, whose ancestors on the ship were named

52 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Pollee and Rose Allen. “If that doesn’t get you While I wait for a call, I decide to drive from
excited, understanding that the DNA resides in my home in Atlanta to my family’s hometown,
you, I don’t know what will.” Edenton, in Chowan County, North Carolina.
In 2019 a team of archaeologists announced My mom and her 13 brothers and sisters grew
the discovery of the remains of the Clotilda in a up in a big house with columns and a porch, out
remote arm of the Mobile River. The wreckage in the country. The house is still there and still in
had settled deep into the mud, which helped the family, but it is in a state. There is a big hole
preserve much of it. It’s the most intact slave in a side wall—a hole I can actually walk through
ship ever found. if I bend my leg and stoop down. The windows
People in the community kept saying “we are broken. There is mold on the walls. Plaster
need to find the ship,” says Sadiki, who was part and debris are everywhere.
of the search team. “They knew how important When I used to visit as a kid, my impression of
it was to find a tangible artifact that got them the place was miles of cornfields and lazy quiet,
where they are to help tell their story.” only the droning of bees and singing of crick-
Most African Americans cannot trace their ets to break up the monotony of the day. The
roots back to a slave ship. They hit what geneal- oppressive weight of the silent country rested
ogists call the “1870 brick wall.” Before 1870, the upon my shoulders back then, and it depressed
U.S. census did not track living enslaved people me to come back here.
with names and identifying details. I get out of my car and stand on the property,
On one of my last days in Costa Rica, María looking around and watching the landscaper,
Suárez, Kevin Rodríguez Brown, and some of Joseph Beasley, tend the yard, poking at weeds.
the other young people take me out on a boat to I ask him about the fields.
see the wreck site for myself. “These little plants—those are soybeans,” he
Mask and gear on, I descend. The water is says. “See that dark green stuff way back yonder?
murky blue and green. It feels warm against my That’s corn. Right across the edge here.”
skin. Schools of fish swim by. I descend deeper, I don’t know why this just dawns on me now.
feeling at home underwater. But my grandfather, who had only a fourth-
Then I see it. The outline of an anchor. It is par- grade education, managed to buy this house,
tially buried, encrusted in coral and surrounded a former plantation of an enslaver, and about a
by grasses on the ocean floor. hundred acres of land in the 1930s.
I hover and imagine the Yoruba, Fon, Asante It makes me realize I’ve probably missed even
people maybe, young, scared, and suddenly freed more about my family’s legacy.
on these shores. And I feel this intense, desperate, I book a room at a bed-and-breakfast on
crushing longing to know my own family’s story. North Broad Street in downtown Edenton,
which is considered one of the loveliest small
Renate Yarborough towns in the South largely because of this

I
HIRE GENEALOGIST
Sanders, who specializes in African ancestry area. The town sits right on the Albemarle
research, and ask whether she can help me Sound. Colonial mansions that likely housed
trace my family back to a slave ship. enslaved people, or profited from the business
“I don’t ever like to say it’s never gonna of plantations, rise majestically above lines of
happen,” she says. “But,” she shakes her head, trees on carefully tended lawns. In all my years
“it’s not realistic.” coming to my grandparents’ house, this is prob-
Yarborough Sanders says she will try to find ably the second or third time that I have ever
out what she can about my earliest known ances- set foot downtown.
tor, my great-great-grandfather Jack Roberts, I expect ignorance, subtle racism, an inten-
who was born enslaved in 1837. tional erasure of the complexity of the past. But
My mom has a picture of Grandpa Jack and I am surprised.
his wife, Mary. They are handsome. He has white Friendly people wave at me as I cross streets.
cropped hair and a neatly trimmed white goatee, Shop owners and waitresses chat me up. The
and she has on a bow tie. twang of the Deep South rings pleasantly in
Jack has these soft brown eyes. They are kind my ears. As I walk around town, I meet a Black
eyes. I think I might have liked to gather at his birder walking his dog, who tells me about a local
knee and hear his stories. church’s reconciliation group, a forum for both

HIDDEN NO MORE 53
 ‘THERE IS
SOMETHING ABOUT
THESE SHIPS,
HOW THEY
MOVED
TRADITIONS,
HOW THEY
MOVED
CULTURE.’ AYANA FLEWELLEN

Archaeologists Photographed while

Justin Dunnavant on a mission to eval-
(at left), a National uate an 18th-century
Geographic Explorer, wrecked merchant ship
and Ayana Flewellen in St. John, they also
are co-founders of run the excavations
the Society of Black at a former Danish
Archaeologists and sugar plantation on
instructors with DWP. nearby St. Croix.
the victims and benefactors of an unjust society
to tell their stories, that meets every Thursday.
Historical markers to African American rebel-
lion and accomplishment line sidewalks, not far
from a big Confederate monument.
The contradiction.
The most notable marker honors Harriet
Jacobs, a local woman who escaped slavery via
the Maritime Underground Railroad. Jacobs
went on to write one of the few known slave
narratives, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl,
in 1861 and became a revered abolitionist.
Edenton historical interpreter Charles Boyette
tells me that the Maritime Underground Rail-
road was a “hidden network of connections and
safe houses that allowed enslaved persons to
seek their freedom along the waterways.”
He says that Edenton was part of a network
for thousands who escaped to the north with the
help of sailors, dockworkers, fishermen, both
free and enslaved, and others who made their
living off the water and waterfront. I’d never
DWP was invited by
heard of the Maritime Underground Railroad. I the U.S. Virgin Islands’
wonder whether my 12- and 13-year-old nieces state historic preser-
Shi and Wu Murphy, who live only about 30 min- vation office to map
the remains of Coral
utes away in the next town over, know about it. Bay Shipwreck No. 1, a
They don’t. merchant ship from the
Yarborough Sanders, the genealogist, calls on 1700s that might have
carried human cargo.
Zoom. She has results. This admiralty anchor,
First, it turns out Jack bought even more land the manner of the
than my grandfather. At least 174 acres in total. ship’s construction, and
an intact bottle helped
Maybe it’s in the family, because I managed to narrow the ship’s date.
buy three homes by the time I was 31. JENNIFER HAYES

Second, he was a delegate to the 1865 Freed-

men’s Convention in Raleigh, a statewide
assembly that took place after the end of the just made an official holiday to celebrate the
Civil War to consider aspirations and goals for freedom of those who were enslaved. Oh, how
the formerly enslaved. the universe works.
That resonates. He tried to be part of the And Edenton celebrates all out, with a soulful
solution, despite the odds against him. band, vendors, and food stalls right at the river.
Finally, there was evidence that Jack fought People of different races are communing. That
in the Civil War, in the United States Colored evening, there is a vigil at the Confederate mon-
Troops—Second Regiment, Company B. ument to get rid of the negative energy of plan-
Yarborough Sanders smiles at me. “If that’s tation culture and bring in positive vibrations.
your ancestor, it is a huge, big deal.” Curious eyes follow me as I walk around with
She also tells me with laughter that he may all my recording equipment. People ask who
have owned a speakeasy. I am and who my people are. And now I can say I
I feel a stirring of pride. I am not a descendant am of Jack Roberts’s clan—Jack begot John H.,
of sad people, of victims, of faceless people. Jack who begot John A., who begot Lula, who begot
has become real to me—not perfect, just real. me. And there is recognition, laughter, stories
As has Edenton. from the past of my mom, my aunt Myrtle, my
Turns out, I am in Edenton on June 19, 2021, uncle George, my uncle Sonny.
“Juneteenth,” the day the federal government Carol Anthony, a stranger passing by, upon

56 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
hearing my name, tells me that she is married any good love story, it has pain and hurt. But this
to my uncle Teeny’s stepson. history, Black history, American history, also has
How did I not know this place? Many African lifting notes—crescendos—full orchestras that
cultures believe that the ancestors never die, tug at the heart and make it soar.
never lose their connection with the living. That I thought this search for slave ships might
their energy is still there, supporting us, pushing be hard. I thought I would need hands holding
us, loving us. What if, I think, all African Amer- mine, rubbing my back, consoling my tears and
icans could look back and claim their past? See my heartache. Instead I found strength. And
their ancestors fully? Know their whole story? power. And adventure. And camaraderie. I found
Would that change everything? laughter. Love. Life. Kinship. I found something
I’m not a scientist or a historian. I am a story- strong and necessary to root and ground me.
teller. And I can now see that the stories we find All from a picture in a museum.
as we discover ourselves don’t just belong to us as Welcome home. j
individuals. They also belong to the communities
of which we are a part. And if those groups are Tara Roberts’s maritime archaeology storytelling
brave, they can use those stories to expand the includes our six-part podcast. Wayne Lawrence’s
photography, last featured in National Geographic’s
possibility of who we might all become together. Race Card Project in June 2021, illuminates the
This history—our history—has sad notes. Like complexities of the human experience.

HIDDEN NO MORE 57
 SAVING

BY DENISE HRUBY

PHOTOGRAPHS BY CIRIL JAZBEC

58
I N T H E A L P S , T H E E C O N O M Y A N D C U LT U R E

R E VO LV E A R O U N D S N O W Y W I N T E R S .

N OW T H E R E ’ S A S C RA M B L E

T O P R E S E RV E S N O W A N D I C E

T H R E AT E N E D B Y WA R M I N G .

WINTER

At Davos, Switzerland,
in late October, a
skier navigates a cross-
country trail made
of artificial snow pro-
duced the previous
winter. It was stored
over the summer in a
20-foot mound under
a 16-inch layer of
sawdust, then spread
on the trail for the
new season.
If You Want to get these Newspapers Daily at earliest

English Newspapers»»
Indian Express, Financial Express, The Hindu, Business Line, The Times of India, The Economic Times,
Hindustan Times, Business Standard, First India, Mint, Greater Kashmir, Greater Jammu, The Himalayan,
The Tribune, Brill Express, The Sikh Times, Avenue Mail, Western Times, Millennium Post, The Statesman,
State Times, The Pioneer, Hans India, Free Press, Orissa Post, Mumbai Mirror, Mid-Day, Deccan Chronicle,
Deccan Herald, Telangana Today, Financial Times, The Asian Age, The Telegraph, Oheraldo, Gulf of Times,
The New York Times, The Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal,
The Guardian, The Times

Hindi Newspapers»»
दै निक जागरण, राजस्थाि पत्रिका, दै निक भास्कर, ह द
िं स्
ु ताि, िवभारत टाइम्स, त्रिज़िस स्टैंडडड, अमर उजाला,पिंजाि
केसरी, उत्तम ह न्द,ू जिसत्ता, लोकसत्ता, ररभूमम, द पायिीयर,जागरूक टाइम्स, राष्ट्रीय स ारा, दै निक हरब्यूि, युवा
गोरव, भारतीय स ारा, स्विंतिंि वाताड, सीमा सिंदेश, दै निक सवेरा,एक्शि इिंडडया, मदरलैंड वॉइस, दे शििंध,ु ह माचल दस्तक,

Others»» Hindi & English Editorial, Employment News, Malayalam Newspapers

Type in Search box of Telegram And you click join

will find a Channel named @demo_eapper join it and
receive daily editions of all popular epapers at the earliest
Or
you can clickon this link
https://t.me/demo_eapper
 As the climate has
warmed since the 19th
century—and espe-
cially in the past few
decades—the Alps have
lost two-thirds of the
ice from their roughly
4,000 glaciers. On the
Pers Glacier in eastern
Switzerland, geophys-
icist Christine Seupel,
engineer Dieter Müller,
and glaciologist Andri
Moll measure the ice
thickness with ground-
penetrating radar.

60 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
S AV I N G W I N T E R 61
62 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Precious snow is
covered with fabric
to protect it from melt-
ing over the summer
at Diavolezza, a Swiss
resort. Natural snow
has become so unre-
liable in the Alps that
the ski industry now
depends on making it
artificially and storing
it in depots.

S AV I N G W I N T E R 63
 SURROUNDED BY
RUGGED PEAKS
SO HIGH THEY TEAR
CLOUDS APART,
the tractor-size groomer backs over a 40-foot-tall
mound of compacted snow, unrolling a bolt of
white fabric. On top of the mound, six workers
are stitching fabric panels together with a hand-
held, heavy-duty sewing machine. It’s June at
Kitzsteinhorn in Austria, one of the highest and
coldest ski areas in the Alps, and meltwater is
gushing into ravines on the flanks of the moun-
tain. But up on the glacier, the slope maintenance
crew is preparing for the next season.
Even at 10,000 feet, counting on natural snow
has become too risky. So the team led by techni- Researchers explore
cal manager Günther Brennsteiner is taking out an ice cave in the Pers
insurance. They’ve spent a month plowing the Glacier. Such caves
form naturally, but
last of this season’s snow into eight multistory the recent expansion
mounds, of which the largest are bigger than foot- of this one is a sign of
ball fields. They’re now spending another month how rapidly glaciers
are retreating. Some
covering the mounds with fabric to insulate them have all but vanished,
over the summer. When the new season begins, leaving locals with a
if it’s too warm for fresh snow to fall—or even for deep sense of loss.
By 2100, if climate-
artificial snow to be made—dump trucks and warming greenhouse
groomers will spread old snow on the slopes. gas emissions aren’t
Figuring out how to stockpile snow at this cut dramatically, the
Alps could be
scale hasn’t been easy, says one of the workers, nearly ice free.
The National Hannes Posch. Before the crew started stitch-
Geographic Society, ing the panels together, wind gusts sometimes
committed to illuminat-
ing and protecting the ripped them apart, uncovering the mounds.
wonder of our world, Other times, the fabric froze solid into the snow.
has funded Explorer Ciril “Everything that could go wrong, has,” Posch
Jazbec’s work on climate
change since 2019. says, as he zip-ties a sandbag to the fabric. Once,
ILLUSTRATION BY JOE MCKENDRY at the nearby resort of Kitzbühel, lightning set a

64 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
fabric-covered snow depot like this ablaze, and in one of the world’s most densely populated
30 firefighters battled the flames for hours. Snow mountain ranges, the implications are terrifying.
is that precious these days. The economy here depends on snow to lure 120
“With the warming climate, everything has million tourists a year—far more than visit the
changed,” Brennsteiner says. He started working United States. Besides working at Kitzsteinhorn,
here 31 years ago, during what now seem like the Brennsteiner serves as mayor of Niedernsill, a
glory years of Alpine skiing. village of 2,800 at the foot of the mountain.
Alpine winters are dying. Since the 19th There’s hardly a family in the village that doesn’t
century, average temperatures in these moun- depend on winter, he says. Without snow, it
tains have risen by two degrees Celsius, or 3.6 might shrink to a thousand people.
Fahrenheit—about twice the global average. “We wouldn’t have children in kindergarten,”
Snow is arriving later in the season and melt- Brennsteiner says, describing a downward spiral.
ing sooner.  The Alps as a whole have lost about “This is the foundation of our lives here.”
a month of snow cover, according to scien- To save themselves, the people of the Alps
tists who analyzed data from more than 2,000 are going to dramatic lengths. An estimated
weather stations. 100,000 snowmaking machines now power the
To many of the 14 million people who live Alpine ski industry, enough to blanket an area

S AV I N G W I N T E R 65
Swiss glaciologist (and amateur violinist) Felix Keller, who grew up near the Morteratsch Glacier,
has a plan to stop its retreat. “People say this is completely nuts,” he admits. “Maybe they’re right.”

66 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Keller’s plan is to recycle glacial meltwater into snow. Here his team tests a prototype of one
of the “snow cables” that, hanging over the glacier, would shower it with 30 feet of snow annually.

S AV I N G W I N T E R 67
the size of New York City within hours. Beyond
snow depots like Kitzsteinhorn’s, desperate
locals are swaddling the ice on a few of the Alps’
roughly 4,000 glaciers, to try to delay the rapid
melt caused by global warming. In one visionary
scheme, Swiss scientists hope to save a glacier by
spraying a swath of it with human-made snow. 
Some of these methods are ingenious and
tantalizing; others are environmentally and
economically questionable. All are driven by a
profound apprehension: Without winter, what
would our lives here be?

LIKE BRENNSTEINER and photographer Ciril

Jazbec, I was lucky enough to grow up in the Alps
at a time when snow was abundant. I remember
the excitement of leaving my tiny footprints
in the season’s first snowfall; I remember
the color of my dad’s cheeks as he shoveled the
house free, again and again. My parents clapped
my first skis on my feet before I was three.
That period turns out to have been a historical
blip. It was only in the second half of the 20th
Where tourists now
century that cold, snowy winters became a boon walk on a suspension
for the Alps. Before then they were a harsh bur- bridge, several hun-
den, attributed in folklore to wicked demons. dred feet above a
meltwater torrent,
My generation is among the last to have heard they used to walk
oral histories of the struggle to survive here, back across ice on the snout
when the economy was based on farming. Snow of Switzerland’s Trift
Glacier. The lake
used to cover tiny plots of land for months. Ava- didn’t exist before
lanches thundered down the mountainsides, this century; the
burying villages. One of my grandma’s nine bridge was first built
in 2004. A power
siblings, Walter, died in one. He was 24. company plans to
When food was scarce—and it generally was— put a dam here.
children from the poorest pockets of the Alps
were forced to trek to lowland markets, where
they sold themselves into seasonal bondage as
farmworkers, typically from March to October. “A
barely concealed slave market,” the Cincinnati “The scales turned against mountain farming,”
Times-Star wrote in 1908, describing one such he says. Some of his siblings left the secluded
market in Friedrichshafen, in southern Germany. valley, but he stayed.
It reported as many as 400 boys and girls up for Winter tourism, Wolf and other villagers reck-
barter, some as young as six, “as if they were a lot oned, was the only thing that could save them. In
of calves or chickens.” The practice lasted well desperation, they sold livestock and put up their
into the 20th century. land against loans to invest in a cable car. Ischgl
After World War II, an economic boom created stood to lose everything, but the gamble paid off.
a thriving middle class across Europe—but not, In 1963, the cable car began pulling tourists up
at first, in the high Alps. The steep mountain- the mountains, and locals out of poverty. Around
sides made it impossible for farms to expand or the Alps, a similar transition was under way.
to deploy the modern machinery that allowed Today, a four-star hotel stands on the
others to prosper, says Johann Wolf, who was 400-year-old farm where Wolf was born. It’s
born in the remote village of Ischgl, Austria, surrounded in Ischgl by luxury chalets with
in 1929, during the coldest winter on record. Jacuzzis, fine restaurants, and a vibrant nightlife

68 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
scene that has hosted concerts by Rihanna, Pink, foretaste of such a world, when it became an
and Lenny Kravitz. Next December, Ischgl is set early hot spot in the COVID-19 pandemic. Flee-
to open thermal baths and an ice-skating rink.  ing tourists helped spread the virus in Europe.
Many locals still see themselves as down-to- The pandemic shut down ski tourism across
earth farmers who love their valley. Wolf’s son the Alps. Millions of hotel beds stayed cold. But
Hannes and 26-year-old grandson, Christoph, climate change poses a more profound threat.
introduce me to their cattle—Hermann, Kathi,
Gitta, and Lilly—as the four munch fragrant of warming may not sound
O N E O R T WO D E G R E E S
hay on some of the Alps’ most expensive real like much, but it can determine whether pre-
estate. The family would never think of getting cipitation falls as snow—or rain. Turn up the
rid of them. “It’s heritage and duty,” Wolf says. temperature just a notch, and snowflakes might
Yet Alpine farming is no longer enough to never form. That’s why the Alps are in deep trou-
make a living. “Without winter, these valleys ble, says Yves Lejeune, the scientist in charge
would be completely abandoned and empty,” of the Col de Porte meteorological observatory,
says Hannes Wolf. In 2020, Ischgl got a horrifying at 4,350 feet in the western French Alps.

S AV I N G W I N T E R 69
 13,000 feet
Desperation at the top
Under a worst-case climate
change scenario, it could

ELEVATION
be ski areas at the highest
6,500
elevations that have the
greatest demand for snow
production. Lower areas may
be too warm for any snow
at all—natural or artificial. 0
A l p s
ia

a
d

y
in

ly

c
D i n a r i
tri

nc
an
an
en

Ita
te

Change in demand
s

Fra
rm
erl

ns
v
Au

Adriatic
Slo

for artificial snow*

te
Ge
itz

S L O V E N I A Sea
ch

2041-2060 Trieste Venice

Sw

Lie

Ljubljana Triglav
9,396 ft
Sa v
Drava 2,864 m Padua
-40% -5 40

Pi

a
o av

nt
nt e
a

Ad
Tagli
am e B re ig
ur Dr 6,562 ft
M

Klagenfurt au 2,000 m
Lake Wörth
G
Graz
Bad Kleinkirchheim Nassfeld ITA
LY Lake
AU
STR
IA
Mur Trento
Leoben 6,562 ft Grossglockner Cortina Madonna
Semmering 2,000 m 12,461 ft di Campiglio
Lienz ge
3,798 m di
Pasterze A
Glacier Ortles
Dachstein 12,812 ft
Bolzano 3,905 m
9,826 ft
2,995 m Schladming
E n ns
h Bormio Morteratsch
zac Kitzsteinhorn ITAL Glacier
A U S T R I A Tauplitz al Y
S

Niedernsill AUS
TRIA D
Saalbach
Hinterglemm
Ybbs Sölden

ns Lake Kitzbühel 6,562 ft

En Traun Innsbruck
er

t 2,000 m
Danube eA
t
Inn
Davos Kloster

SW T.
L ak Salzburg Ischgl

AU
Tr a u n

ITZ
AUS
TRIA

.
Linz GERM Zugspitze St. Anton
ANY 9,718 ft
2,962 m Chur
h

Major winter resort

e
Rhin
l z ac

Lake Garmisch-
Hydroelectric facilities Sa lz Chiem Partenkirchen
Inn
A

Generating plant, I nn
100 megawatts or more G E R M A N Y Damüls LIECHTENSTEIN
Large dam
rg
be

r h
Is a
rn

Change in snow-cover duration

2000-2021 St
a
Lake L ec Dornbirn
ke Ammer
Increasing N La
St. Gallen
MUNICH
L. CO

Unchanged
SCALE VARIES IN THIS PERSPECTIVE.
THE ALPS SPAN NEARLY 750 MILES
NS

Decreasing ACROSS CENTRAL EUROPE.

TA

Friedrichshafen
N

Th
Snow ur
CE

l er
PRESERVING THE SNOW l Konstanz
I

Water
hi
R

Public and private groups are working to lessen the impact of shrinking snow- ne
fall. But current methods to create and preserve snow can cost millions of
dollars, consume water and energy resources, and work only on a small scale.
Air

Machine-made snow Snow Getting off the grid

Typical electric-powered cannon Swiss engineers are innovating
snow machines, invented a system of cables that uses
in the 1950s, spray water. A Buried electric water from melting glaciers
fan diffuses the water into and water lines to make snow. Water pressure
tinier droplets that can make would be created by gravity
snow—if the air is cold and and could work without elec-
dry enough. tricity in remote areas.
*COMPARED WITH 1986-2005
 A LP IN E ME LT EURO
PE
Direction of view

View
area

Snow cover and glaciers in most of the Alps have declined dramatically AFRICA
over the past 20 years, particularly at elevations below 6,500 feet.
The loss is already hurting tourism and eventually may disrupt hydropower—
the predominant source of energy in the Alps. M E D I T E R R A N E A
N S E A
MONACO
Verona Nice
r
Va
e I T A L Y 6,562 ft
Po 2,000 m Isola 2000 Verdon
d a
Gar Cuneo Monte Viso
12,602 ft Lake of
Brescia Ta n a r o 3,841 m Sainte-Croix
a

Lake Iseo d
Ad ITA LY
6,562 ft
Bergamo Po FRAN C E 2,000 m
MILAN
Vars Lake
Serre-Ponçon
a e
TURIN Dura nc
al t e a

Piz Bernina si
Se
o

13,283 ft Barre des Écrins

cin

4,049 m Sestriere 13,458 ft

B

Gran Paradiso Briançon Gap

Ti

4,102 m
o

ra

13,323 ft
om

Do

Biella 4,061 m
k eC Lake
La Y Lugano
re

Diavolezza ITAL Lugano io Dufourspitze

RLAND agg 15,203 ft
Lake Sils
St. Moritz ITZE Lake M 4,634 m
SW Bellinzona Matterhorn Val d’Isère

Dra
14,692 ft
4,478 m

c
Gorner Glacier Alpe d’Huez
Aosta Mt. Blanc Courchevel
rs 15,774 ft
Zermatt 4,808 m La Plagne
Courmayeur Grenoble
6,562 ft
2,000 m
Aletsch
Laax
Is è r e
Glacier Chamonix Col de Porte
Andermatt Mer de Albertville
Verbier Glace meteorological and
Megève snow observatory
Eiger Chambéry
Rhône 13,015 ft Sion
3,967 m
Glacier Bern La Clusaz
ese Alps
y
ec
Z.

Engelberg Grindelwald IT Lake

nn
R hône

Bourget
CE

6,562 ft SW N Morzine A F R A N C E
e
La Interlaken
2,000 m
FR
A
L ak Annecy
ke Gstaad
Arve

Lu c Abondance
er n e
Lak
e Lucerne Lake
Lake Thun LA Geneva ône
Rh
Zü

Zug K
S

E
ric

S W I T Z E R L A N D
Aare

GE
h

NEVA LYON
N
s
Reus

Lausanne I Ain
e

n
ZÜRICH Bern Saa
A
T
Li m m

Lake N
Aare Biel châtel O U
t Lake Neu
a

A M
ne

J U R Bourg-en-Bresse ô
Sa
Gravity feeds
MATTHEW W. CHWASTYK AND
water to cables MANUEL CANALES, NGM STAFF.
ALEXANDER STEGMAIER; ERIC KNIGHT;
MATTHEW TWOMBLY
Protecting natural snow SOURCES: CLAUDIA NOTARNICOLA,
Glacier Fabric panels can be Snow blankets EURAC RESEARCH; RAPHAËLLE SAMA-
Snow cables COÏTS, HUGUES FRANÇOIS, SAMUEL
stitched together and laid MORIN, MÉTÉO-FRANCE/CNRS/INRAE;
out to reflect the sun and COPERNICUS CORINE LAND COVER;
COPERNICUS CLIMATE CHANGE
Glacial lake prevent snow and glaciers SERVICE; GRWL DATABASE; EUROPEAN
from melting. But they’re ENVIRONMENT AGENCY; GLOBAL
POWER PLANT DATABASE; GLOBAL
complicated to install and ENERGY OBSERVATORY; GRAND DATA-
can freeze into the ice. BASE; NASA/JPL; MORTALIVE
 WA RMI N G TRAC KIN G A C HAN GIN
Snow-cover data from satellites are helping scientists record
2000. Nearly 80 percent of the world’s mountain ranges are

G LOB E , decline in snow-covered area and fewer days of snow on the

Change in snow cover

WAN IN G 2000-2021
More
Unchanged
I
N
D
E
I
A
A
N
N Zagros Mt
t

WI NTE R
C a rz M
O Se bu
Less ia
n El
ab ush
uK
SCALE VARIES IN THIS PERSPECTIVE. Ar Hi
nd
K2
28,251 ft
8,611 m

Y A ts
.

AN
A R U
B Y M AT T H E W W. C H WA ST Y K , M A N U E L C A N A L E S , L nM Tarbagatay Mts.

SH
u
Mt. Everest A nl
29,032 ft ET C

N
Ku
M TI
A
8,849 m I IB ins
AND ALEXANDER STEGMAIER T nt a
ou

han
H
F M
l t ay

s
O

ain
A

nS
U

nt
A

tu

I
ou
E

Al
T
M
an

LA

A
Say

LI
P

O
NG

B
A
SNOWFALL IS DECREASING IN MOUNTAIN RANGES

Ya b
MO
I on

l
AROUND THE WORLD, DRASTICALLY IN SOME REGIONS. ov
yy
S Borshchovochnyy
R

a.
VITAL TO ECOSYSTEMS AND ECONOMIES, SNOW AND A Mountains F

Stanovoy R a n
ICE LEVELS AFFECT TOURISM, HYDROPOWER

A
A
N
PRODUCTION, AND WATER SUPPLIES IN MANY PARTS OF I

I
Beijing H

S
C S D z hugdzh

g
U

e
THE WORLD. SCIENTISTS ARE TRACKING THE CHANGES, R

AND INNOVATORS ARE SEARCHING FOR SOLUTIONS.

CH
IN
N.
KO
A

R
in Ra.
e Al

in
EA

Sik hot

al
ea

kh
a

aS
e

in

Sa
Ch
r

t o
Eas K Sea of Japan
O
(East Se a) of
Sea
Ja d
pa an
Rising ne
se Alps Ho Isl
humidity kka Kuril
ido
levels H u
o n
s h

Coastal Tokyo
Mt. Fuji
proximity 12,388 ft
Increasing air 3,776 m
temperature

Snowfall varies by region and is influenced by factors such as

COUNTING THE SNOW DAYS A -3
First snow day
Brooks Range U.
latitude, elevation, humidity, and proximity to oceans or lakes. Rising In many mountain ranges the first snow is
arriving later in the year and the last snow B +1 Sk
air temperatures boost humidity levels, and winter precipitation
earlier. The ranges at right have shown some C +8 Tarbagata
increasingly falls as rain instead of snow. Low-elevation and coastal of the largest changes in the last snow day
areas are especially at risk of reduced snowfall. over the past 21 years.

Day lost Day gained

ERIC KNIGHT; MATTHEW TWOMBLY. SOURCES: CLAUDIA NOTARNICOLA, EURAC RESEARCH; OCT
NASA/JPL; NOAA; NATIONAL SNOW AND ICE DATA CENTER
 G WI N TER
90% radiation Albedo feedback
reflected When snow or sea ice
recedes earlier, it exposes
d a worrying trend since 30% dark surfaces—bare
10%
e seeing both a significant ground or sea—that absorb
e ground. more sunlight. Warmed
surfaces then re-radiate
A F R I C A 70% absorbed
heat, increasing air
an Sea A temperature and further
Med iter rane T
L
El’brus reducing snowfall.
A
18,510 ft N S O
5,642 m ALPS T
Carpathian I U
ts. E T
.
Mts. E UROP March sea ice extent
1981–2010 median
C H
ts. ts
Ca uc a s u s M A
March sea ice extent M
Moscow O E A N
Ic e l a n 2021 R D E
d C I S
ia

C
av

Ur a l M n E A
oun di L a br a d or
tai ts S c a n A
re n and
A

I ns B a Se a Sea
S nl
S ee N Ca
Ka Gr New York ri
y

Ba .
bb
in f f in I App
a la c ea
ra

f
B af Ba

L D
hia n
Se

n Se
S

Mt a
a

Q ue y
North en Ba s.
ud son

I E
Pole Is l a E l i z H
A nd a b Chicago
Is.

RC s H
et

A
S
ea

O
ry

G
TI I.
ar

CE

ul
vS

C
C P a
ori of
V ic t

f
N

UN
AN
te

I A

I
M
ap

ITE
k Ra n g
e L C A N A D CA R ex
ic
ns E
oy a D ST
o
NAD

r kh M
A Mt. Elbert
AT E S
ge
Ve

as Se a
E

u f or t 14,440 ft
A

tS
an

ie Mou
Bea kenz
E

ibe nt a N O R T H TA INS 4,401 m

yR

r i an C
A M
ac ins UN
MO
Cherski

Sea N CK Y
R A A
RO
ge

U D
.S
an . A
sR Sk B
I Bro o k e
Mt e n a
hur Ra. A R ANGE s. Simpson Park
A
ge Mts.
SK

an Ca
Koly m a R
AL A

White Pine Range

COAS
T M
sc
ad E D
r y a k Ra .
OUNTA INS eR Mt. Whitney
Ko Denali an 14,505 ft ia
(Mt. McKinley) ge 4,421 m rn
if o
C
a

20,310 ft O l
Mt. Rainier G u l f of C a
sk

6,190 m 14,410 ft A
la 4,392 m S Si e r r a N e v a d a
A
la

T
of
lf
nge
su

More snow in eastern Siberia R Los

Gu A
sk

Beri N Angeles
in

t Global warming is adding moisture G

Ra

ng Sea E S
ho P en
k to the air—delivering more snow in
n
ia

O a
ut

a tk Klyuchevskaya e some cold areas. The extra snow cover

m ch 15,597 ft Al is disrupting permafrost by trapping
Ka 4,754 m
Aleut summer heat in the ground.
ds ian
Islands
P N
A A
C E
I C
F O
I C

Last snow day

.S., CANADA -12 Shorter season
Shrinking snow seasons
keena Mountains CANADA -14 can disrupt agricultural
ay Mts. KAZAKHSTAN, CHINA -7 production, lengthen wildfire
seasons, and compound the
D -9 White Pine Range U.S. -22 risk of flooding.
E -1 Simpson Park Mountains U.S. -21

F -2 -25 Borshchovochnyy Mts. RUSSIA

JAN JULY
 Sun-blocking plastic
fabric drapes the tip
of the Rhône Glacier
in Switzerland. A cave
dug each summer in
the shifting ice has
attracted tourists since
1870. For now, the year-
round, 12-acre cover
preserves enough ice
to house the cave.

76 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
S AV I N G W I N T E R 77
ONE OR TWO DEGREES OF WARMING CAN
MEAN THAT SNOWFLAKES NEVER FORM.
THAT’S WHY THE ALPS ARE IN DEEP TROUBLE.
On his way to work, Lejeune passes Le Sappey- happened over centuries, each fresh layer of
en-Chartreuse, a small village with a church at snow pressing on the ones beneath, until the
its center and ski runs up the mountainsides. At snow solidified into ice and began to flow down-
age five, he learned to ski here. But the village hill under its own weight. Snow accumulates
lies low, at about 3,300 feet. “Now, it’s finished,” in winter, and snow and ice melt in summer,
Lejeune says bluntly. “Maybe they’ll have one or mostly at lower altitudes. When winter gain
two good years, but not more.” exceeds summer loss, the glacier ’s snout
Such areas already were plagued by a series advances down into the valley; when summer
of snow-scarce winters in the 1980s and ’90s. triumphs, the glacier retreats. Since the late
Machines that make snow became the Alps’ first 19th century, glaciers in the Alps have retreated
line of defense. In lower-lying regions, millions almost continuously.
in investments seemed justified to guarantee a Swiss glaciologist Felix Keller has an idea for
steady tourism season. Winters with light snow reversing that trend. Keller grew up in a village
were assumed to be outliers then. next to St. Moritz, the birthplace of winter tour-
Lejeune’s data prove that they weren’t. He ism in the Alps. When I met him there last year,
points to a graph comparing the snow depth at he took me to the nearby Hotel Morteratsch,
Col de Porte in the past 30-year period with the where he showed me a black-and-white pho-
previous one. The line plunges downward, show- tograph of the last crown prince of Germany,
ing an average snow-cover decrease of 15 inches. Wilhelm, taken in 1919. The prince and his
“That’s a lot,” Lejeune says. “That’s really a lot.”  entourage stood beaming on the Morteratsch
The warming now has reached higher eleva- Glacier, which at the time was right outside the
tions. “If someone had told me back then that hotel. Thick ice covered the entire valley. 
we’d ever need snow machines, I’d have said, Keller and I went to the same spot. In the cen-
‘You’re crazy,’ ” says Peter Leo, Kitzsteinhorn’s tury since Wilhelm’s visit, larches and pines have
head of snow management. Today “we couldn’t taken over; in late summer, locals forage there
live without these machines.” for mushrooms and cranberries. The Morte-
Neither can most of the Alps’ 1,100 ski lift ratsch Glacier has retreated out of sight, more
operators. Much of the snow in ski areas is now than a mile up the valley.
human made. On Kitzsteinhorn alone, 104 Alpine glaciers overall have lost two-thirds
grass-colored “snow cannons” are strategically of their volume since 1850, and the loss is accel-
positioned around the slopes. Each weighs and erating. “If we don’t act, all will be gone,” says
costs as much as a small car.  Matthias Huss, a glaciologist at ETH Zurich. By
When Leo turns one on, it becomes hard to “act,” Huss means drastically cut the carbon
hear him. On the machine’s outer ring, nozzles emissions that cause global warming.
infuse water droplets with air, and a massive Keller has an additional action in mind. The
fan—“strong enough to suck you in,” he yells— idea came to him on a balmy summer day in
blows them into the sky. As they descend, water 2015, while he was fishing in a lake fed by melt-
droplets from the inner rings clump around the water from the Morteratsch. Glacial silt clouded
initial crystals, forming snowflakes. the water, and the trout weren’t biting. That’s
when it occurred to Keller: Couldn’t some of that
like Kitzsteinhorn,
S TA N D I N G O N A G L A C I E R meltwater be kept high in the mountains and
it’s hard to grasp how tiny snowflakes could turned back into ice? 
have formed such an immense mass of ice. It “I figured that within 10 minutes, I’d find out

78 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
why that can’t work,” he says. “But I didn’t.” When the first snowflakes landed on his head,
His friend and fellow glaciologist Hans Oerle- Keller had tears in his eyes. 
mans, who has studied the Morteratsch since Just getting to the point where a prototype
1994, added a crucial twist: The melt water could be tested required four million dollars
should be converted into fresh snow, which from the Swiss government, a bank, and three
reflects 99 percent of sunlight and could shield foundations. The full-scale system would cost
the ice in summer. Oerlemans calculated that $170 million to install, Keller says. To build
covering just 10 percent of the glacier, in the it, he’d need to get a permit to dig a tunnel
zone where most ice loss occurs, would allow through a protected area. It would take about
it to begin advancing again after 10 years. He a decade until the first snow could be sprayed
and Keller felt giddy at the simplicity of the idea. onto the Morteratsch. By then, the glacier will
A few high-altitude ski areas already are insu- have retreated another few hundred yards.
lating patches of glaciers by spreading fabric Huss, for one, is convinced the snow cables
on them. And at a few, such as Kitzsteinhorn or will never be deployed—because, he says, there
Diavolezza, near the Morteratsch, snowmaking would be little gained from the great expense.
machines have caused a localized thickening of Even under a moderately optimistic climate sce-
the ice. But neither of those approaches could nario, Huss says, his simulations show that the
be scaled up enough to save an entire glacier. Morteratsch Glacier will all but vanish before the
To save the Morteratsch, Keller and Oerle- end of the century—with or without MortAlive. 
mans estimate, they’d need to cover about 200 Keller points out that such simulations are
acres of it with more than 30 feet of snow every notoriously imprecise. But he knows the glacier
year—more than two and a half million tons of is running out of time.
the stuff. Making that much snow with typical “If on my deathbed I can tell my children and
snow machines would use way too much energy. grandchildren that I at least tried to do some-
For “MortAlive,” as he and Oerlemans call thing clever,” he says, “that will be better than
their project, Keller asked for help from research- saying I just talked about all the problems.”
ers at Swiss universities, from a leading cable
car company, and from Bächler Top Track AG, IN MOST OF THE ALPS, ice and snow seem
a snowmaking company. The team devised a doomed. That may spell trouble downstream.
scheme in which seven hoselike snow cables, Europe’s mightiest rivers—the Rhône, Rhine,
each more than half a mile long, would be sus- Danube, and Po—all derive a substantial portion
pended between two moraines that flank the of their flow during dry summers from glacial
Morteratsch Glacier. Water from a meltwater meltwater. Seasonal shipping and irrigation
lake at higher altitude—expected to form soon could become a problem. The Alps, however,
at a neighboring glacier—would flow downhill will continue to be Europe’s “water towers”—
through the cables, spray out through nozzles clouds will continue to burst and empty on their
patented by Bächler, and fall as snow on the flanks—and rich countries likely will find ways
Morteratsch. No electricity would be required. to safeguard their water supplies.
In a parking lot near the glacier, I watched The loss of winter tourism may prove trick-
the first trial of a prototype. The team had sus- ier. Entire communities are now grappling
pended a single snow cable with six nozzles with their very existence being dependent on
between two poles. At one point a pipe froze a phenomenon so fleeting it melts at the touch
and had to be replaced—but the system worked. of your hand. Many are investing more heavily

ALPINE GLACIERS OVERALL HAVE LOST

TWO-THIRDS OF THEIR VOLUME SINCE 1850,
AND THE LOSS IS ACCELERATING.
S AV I N G W I N T E R 79
 The joy of hurtling
down a snow-covered
mountainside on skis
is what draws millions
of tourists to the Alps
each winter—but a few
visitors prefer to go
up, not down, and to
do it the hard way. An
ice climber grapples
with a frozen waterfall
in the gorge at Pon-
tresina, Switzerland.

80 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
S AV I N G W I N T E R 81
 Geographer Damien
Filip paddles on the
Totensee, a small Swiss
lake used for hydro-
power, as the ice
breaks up in late June.
In coming decades,
the loss of snow and ice
in the Alps may reduce
the summer flow in
major rivers such as the
Rhône and Rhine.

82 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
S AV I N G W I N T E R 83
in summer—in mountain biking or hiking trails,
summer tobogganing or climbing spaces. Kitz-
steinhorn is seeing an influx of summer tourists
from scorched countries such as Saudi Arabia. 
But summer tourism has always existed in the
Alps, and expanding it enough to make up for
the loss of skiing will be hard.
The French village of Abondance, altitude
3,000 feet, is in the middle of this difficult tran-
sition. When its lifts shut down in 2007, it was
described in one news story after another as the
first ski village to fall victim to climate change.
But its 1,400 residents weren’t ready to bid adieu
to skiing. In 2008 they voted in a new mayor,
Paul Girard-Despraulex, who fulfilled his sole
campaign promise and reopened the lifts. 
Born into a family of farmers the year the
cable car was built, Girard-Despraulex had seen
his village prosper with skiing. Yet when an
investor approached him with a plan to double
down—to develop Abondance into a massive ski
resort by connecting it with a neighboring one—
the mayor was flabbergasted. The plan would
have entailed blowing up part of a mountain and
destroying an old fir forest. “That’s something Cold, snowy winters
we did not want to do,” Girard-Despraulex says.  are a defining element
of Alpine lifestyle,
Elsewhere in the Alps, too, plans for expand- folklore, and tradi-
ing winter tourism have met resistance. In tions. Gian-Nicola Bass,
Austria, 160,000 people signed a petition to who preserves some
of these ways at the
stop plans to connect the Ötztal and Pitztal ski Upper Engadin Cultural
areas, again by blowing up part of a mountain. In Archives in Switzerland,
Morzine, France, near Abondance, a new cable believes that soaking
in ice-covered Lake
car project was halted after locals protested. An Sils helps toughen his
independent analysis had shown that it might immune system.
not pay off in an increasingly snowless climate.
In Abondance, Girard-Despraulex is pushing
diversification. Aside from its stunningly beau-
tiful ski area, it now boasts ice-skating on a natu-
ral lake and sleigh rides in winter, as well as more will save winter in the Alps. Making
N O M I R AC L E
mountain biking and hiking in summer. There’s snow, stockpiling it, spraying it on glaciers—all
a museum dedicated to Abondance cheese— that will, at best, buy time in a few places.
dairy farming remains important around the The beauty of the Alps, the envy of outsiders
village. Recently, Girard-Despraulex had the roof long before people here built their lives around
reslated on an abandoned, 900-year-old abbey, snowy winters, will remain. But the waning
so it could safely open to visitors.  of snow and ice represents an emotional loss,
“We have not yet exactly found the right a loss of culture and identity, as well as an eco-
approach, the right ideas, but we are thinking, nomic one. When Switzerland’s Pizol Glacier
testing, and experimenting,” he says. In the shrank to such a tiny sheet of ice that it was
abbey’s courtyard, he points to a mural depict- taken off the glacier monitoring service, locals
ing the wedding at Cana, where Jesus is said mourned its death with a funeral. 
to have turned water into wine. An upcoming When I was little, skiing was a pastime
restoration, the mayor says, will make the faded enjoyed by the vast majority of people in the
colors shine again. Alps, no matter their status or income. Like me,

84 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
my childhood friend Dominik and his partner, never even wondered if Unterberg would have
Julia, were pushed onto the slopes at a very enough snow to open,” she says, as we trudge past
early age. Less than three decades on, their son, the idle T-bar lifts. When those lifts were about
Johann, who just turned four and is my godson, to close for good in 2014, locals crowdfunded
is fascinated by snow. But he knows it largely almost $83,000 to keep them going. But at this
from songs and books. altitude it’s too warm to invest in snowmaking.
On a sunny Sunday last February, we drive up So Unterberg relies solely on natural snow, pro-
Unterberg mountain near Vienna, in the east- moting itself as a ski area where “the snow still
ernmost Alps, in search of the real stuff. Just falls from the sky.” Last winter, that made for 10
underneath the 4,400-foot peak, we find a little days of skiing. The winter before, zero. j
winter. “It sparkles!” Johann yells, tossing him-
self in the snow and gingerly licking it from his After reporting for years in Asia, Austrian writer
mitten. He wants to build a snowman, but the Denise Hruby has returned home to focus on
environmental challenges in Europe. Ciril Jazbec,
snow is less than an inch deep.  a Slovenian, photographed India’s ice stupas—
His mother, Julia, 33, learned to ski here. “We small, artificial glaciers—for the July 2020 issue.

S AV I N G W I N T E R 85
 CAT
86
BIG
In Nagarahole
Tiger Reserve, tigers
and leopards are
thriving as India’s
conservation efforts
begin to pay off.

BY
YUDHIJIT
B H AT TA C H A R J E E

P H OTO G RA P H S BY
SHAAZ JUNG

HAVEN
Leopards court in a
flowering coral tree on
a misty winter morning
at Nagarahole Tiger
Reserve. The two are
likely to mate several
times while they are
together, which can
be for up to a week.

PREVIOUS PHOTO

A black panther rests

on a branch of a teak
tree. Black panthers
are leopards with a
genetic mutation that
causes the dark pig-
mentation of their
coats. The rosette pat-
terns are still visible
against their fur.
When the waters of
the Kabini River recede
during the summer
months, the surround-
ing area transforms
into a grassland where
spotted deer and other
animals come to graze.
The landscape offers
an abundance of prey
for big cats.
 DRAPED IN MIST,
THE LUSH,
FORESTED
LANDSCAPE OF
NAGARAHOLE
TIGER RESERVE
IN INDIA’S
SOUTHWESTERN
KARNATAKA
STATE LOOKS
ENCHANTED.
An elephant lumbers through the foliage, feeding on shrubs
and leaves, its gigantic ears flapping as if to the beat of a met-
ronome. Up ahead along the dirt road, bison-like gaur graze
in a meadow, not so much as glancing in our direction.
Guided by photographer Shaaz Jung, who has lived in a
lodge in the forest for the past 12 years, we drive on, stopping
by a herd of spotted deer. An iridescent blue kingfisher flits
between the trees. As sunlight cuts through the haze, the
tranquility is broken by the bark of a deer ringing out in the
distance. It’s an alarm, warning that a predator lurks nearby.
Calls like this are heard here with increasing frequency. A tiger drinks from
Nagarahole abounds with Bengal tigers and Indian leopards. one of Nagara-
hole’s water holes.
Tourists flock to the reserve to catch a glimpse of these big Across the reserve,
cats, including an especially bold black panther—a leopard park authorities
with a mutation that causes dark pigmentation. That cat, have installed solar-
powered bore wells,
often sighted, has become something of a star. which are activated
“Usually when you go on a safari, it’s like, Did you see a when the water level
tiger?” says Krithi Karanth, a scientist at the Centre for Wildlife drops, helping keep
these essential water
Studies in Bengaluru (formerly Bangalore). “Now it’s like, Oh, sources full through-
you saw a tiger. Great, but did you see the black panther?” out the year.

92 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
 NAGARAHOLE IS THE PERFECT PLACE
FOR TIGERS AND LEOPARDS TO COEXIST:
TIGERS PROWLING IN THE UNDERGROWTH,
LEOPARDS LOUNGING IN TREES.

Less than a 10th of the 327-square-mile park says, now are better trained and better equipped
is open to visitors. At the southern end of this because of increased government funding that
tourism zone lies the Kabini River, fringed with followed India’s commitment in 2010 to an inter-
brush and tall grasses. Beyond are meadows and national plan to double the number of tigers
streams and dense woods. It’s the perfect milieu worldwide. “That’s been the biggest deterrent
for tigers and leopards to coexist: tigers prowling for anybody looking to enter the forest to poach
in the undergrowth; leopards lounging in trees, for meat or even to collect firewood,” he says. “All
safe from tigers. such incursions stopped.”
The likelihood of seeing these big cats has As a result, the density of prey species such
gone up significantly during the past decade in as deer and wild boar has gone up, helping their
Nagarahole and many other wildlife reserves predators—tigers and leopards—to thrive. At
across India, thanks to the success of conserva- Nagarahole the big cats also appear to have ben-
tion efforts. The latest count of tigers at Nagara- efited from 26 solar-powered bore wells installed
hole was 135, more than twice the number from next to ponds, keeping them full even in the
a decade ago. The country now has almost 3,000 dry months.
tigers in the wild, according to the latest official The future of big cats in Nagarahole and
census, completed in 2018. That’s 33 percent similar reserves hinges in part on minimizing
higher than in 2014. The number of leopards has conflict between the animals and neighboring
increased 62 percent since 2014, to nearly 13,000. communities. In one village I visited just outside
One sign of this growing population is more the park boundary, I watched kids rolling rubber
sightings of big cats beyond the edges of tires along a mud track as the sun was setting
reserves, which also has increased the poten- over the Kabini. A cart trundled by, pulled by a
tial for conflict with humans. “I have tigers pair of oxen, their bells jangling.
living around my house in central India,” says As the competition for territory inside India’s
conservationist Belinda Wright, founder of the reserves intensifies, tigers and leopards are wan-
Wildlife Protection Society of India, who lives dering into such villages more often, killing cattle
on the edge of Kanha Tiger Reserve in the state and sometimes humans. In Karnataka alone,
of Madhya Pradesh. at least nine people were killed by tigers from
The rising numbers are particularly encourag- 2019 to 2021.
ing to conservationists because tiger and leopard Even though revenue from big cat tourism has
counts are now more credible. Until 2006, India’s been growing, Wright says, the money hasn’t
tiger census, conducted every four years, was helped local residents. “So they don’t feel they
more of a guesstimate based on a survey of paw benefit from the presence of tigers,” she adds.
prints—a lengthy and tedious exercise carried out Wildlife authorities do compensate people who
by teams covering tens of thousands of square lose cattle to tigers and have moved some vil-
miles. The bulk of the counting is now done using lages away from tiger terrain, but they still need
images from camera traps that enable the identi- to do more to give surrounding communities
fication of individual tigers and leopards by their a stake in the success of the reserves, conser-
unique patterns of stripes or spots. vationists say, or the gains made over the past
Vijay Mohan Raj, chief conservator of forests decade could disappear. j
in Karnataka, credits the success at Nagara-
hole and other reserves to more effective anti- Yudhijit Bhattacharjee is a contributing writer
for National Geographic. Shaaz Jung has spent
poaching personnel strategically stationed hundreds of hours documenting the lives of big
inside the reserves. These frontline workers, Raj cats after becoming fascinated with leopards.

RILEY D. CHAMPINE AND TAYLOR MAGGIACOMO, NGM STAFF. SOURCES: WILDLIFE INSTITUTE OF INDIA; NATIONAL TIGER CONSERVATION AUTHORITY;
WWF; IUCN; WORLDPOP; FOREST LANDSCAPE INTEGRITY INDEX; WDPA; PANTHERA; © OPENSTREETMAP CONTRIBUTORS
AFGHANISTAN

A NETWORK OF RESERVES
Protected areas where big cat populations are increasing have
high densities of prey and robust measures against poaching.
PAKISTAN Connections between reserves via stretches of forest are critical,

H
but they aren’t safeguarded against human encroachment.
Tiger population in reserve Human population

I
Corbett National Park, one
At or near capacity (18 reserves) Forest
of India’s first tiger reserves,

M
has 231 tigers according to Below capacity (29) 200 mi
its latest census, in 2018.
A No tigers observed (4) 200 km
This is the most of any single Rajaji SH L
protected area in the world. IV A CHINA
Corbett
A
S ERT
Delhi
Pilibhit
LI
K
Y Royal
Kamlang
R
DE HI
LL
A NEPAL
Manas
N.P. Namdapha
S Pakke
A

Sariska Dudhwa Chitwan BHUTAN

TH

Jaipur National Park Nameri

Lucknow Valmiki
GA Buxa Kaziranga
Ranthambhore Manas
NG Orang
ET
IC
PLA
Mukundara
I N D I A Panna
IN
BANGLADESH
Poachers killed all tigers in the Sanjay-Dubri Dampa
Palamau
Sariska Tiger Reserve in 2004 Bandhavgarh
and the Panna Tiger Reserve
in 2009. The reserves now have Satpura Kolkata
Kanha
36 tigers between them after Similipal Sundarbans
Pench (2 reserves) Achanakmar Reserved Forest
successful reintroductions.
Nagpur Nawegaon- Sundarban
Melghat MYANMAR
Bor Nagzira Satkosia
Tadoba Udanti- S
Sitanadi T
A The 200 tigers that dwell in
DECCAN H the Sundarban Tiger Reserve
Mumbai Kawal G
PLATEAU have adapted to living in the
Pune Indravati N mangrove forest and are known
R

to cross into the adjacent

E

Sahyadri Hyderabad
T

protected area in Bangladesh.

S
A

Amrabad
E
WES

Nagarjunasagar
Kali Srisailam
TE

Protecting Big Cats

RN

Bhadra
Bengaluru In the early 1970s India’s national animal—the
GH

Chennai
Bengal tiger—faced extinction. The government
AT

Biligiriranganatha
Nagarahole Swamy Temple responded in 1973 by designating nine tiger
S

Bandipur
Mudumalai
reserves. Today 51 reserves host about 2,000
Sathyamangalam
Parambikulam tigers, two-thirds of the country’s rebounding
Nagarahole Tiger Reserve tiger population. Thousands of Indian leopards
Anamalai
and its adjacent reserves
have a combined count of
Srivilliputhur also live in these protected areas. Both types of
Megamalai*
724 individuals—globally Periyar big cats had seen large declines in their ranges
the largest known tiger and populations in the past few centuries.
population in one region.
Kalakad-
Mundanthurai SRI
LANKA

Tiger Leopard
Panthera tigris Panthera pardus
EUROPE ASIA

AFRICA
WHERE THE BIG CATS MEET Tiger range
India has 60 percent of the world’s roughly Current INDIA
5,000 wild tigers and the most remaining Historic
leopard territory in one country. The
reserves are havens for both, although Leopard range
Current Countrywide
tigers sometimes kill or displace leopards.
Both species’ long-term survival in the
estimates, 2018†
Historic
wild is threatened by geographic isolation, Tigers: 2,967
which reduces genetic diversity. Overlapping range Leopards: 12,852

*SRIVILLIPUTHUR MEGAMALAI TIGER RESERVE, DESIGNATED IN 2021, †INCLUDES BIG CATS

HAS NOT YET BEEN EVALUATED FOR TIGER CAPACITY. OUTSIDE TIGER RESERVES
A leopard and a black fight. Leopards tend
panther keep a wary to spend the daytime
eye out for trouble. resting high off the
Being able to climb ground on branches.
trees is a superpower They clamber down in
that helps leopards the evenings to hunt.
avoid confrontations Leopards can haul
with tigers, which kills into trees to keep
would prevail in a them from scavengers.

B I G C AT H AV E N 97
A black panther heads
toward a thicket with
a just captured fawn.
As Nagarahole has
improved anti-poaching
measures, herbivores
such as spotted deer
have become plentiful.
With the rise in prey
population, big cats
have thrived.
100
 Since 2016,
1,280
community
leaders in
Colombia
have been
killed after
resisting
intrusions by
developers
and drug
cartels.

Defending
the
Land,
Paying
With
Their
Lives

BY
J O R DA N
SALAMA

P H OTO G RA P H S BY
F LO R E N C E
GOUPIL
 Indigenous
leaders,
teachers,
farmers, and
others have
been targeted
after speaking
up against
damage to
their lands
and culture.

Fanor Mulcué, an
Indigenous Nasa leader
in southern Colombia,
contemplates an
Espeletia plant native
to the Andean plateau.
Key to the creation
of freshwater reserves
in the highlands, many
species are endangered
because of encroaching
mining and agricultural
activities.

PREVIOUS PHOTO
Ati Quigua performs a
ritual to protect a river
in the Sierra Nevada de
Santa Marta mountains
in northern Colombia’s
Cesar Department. An
Indigenous Arhuaco
environmentalist and
politician, she has
protested mining and
large-scale development
that threaten natural
resources in the Sierra
Nevada, a UNESCO
biosphere reserve.
L UIS MANUEL SALAMANCA balanced on
the tailgate of a rickety covered pickup
truck, clinging onto the roof rack as it
careened down the winding backroads
of the Andes. It was dawn on May 22,
2018, and the Nudo de Almaguer—a
fertile knot of dome-shaped mountains in
southwestern Colombia known in English as
the Colombian Massif—was beginning to stir.
As the fog lifted, a woman milking a bloated
brown cow came into sight in a clearing. Red-
and-white buses crammed with schoolchildren
fought for passage with horse-drawn carts and
cargo mules on narrow roads. More than 650 feet
below, the Magdalena River rushed through a
steep, emerald gorge fed by waterfalls tumbling
down from every direction.
Alexandra Isabel Sala-
We were heading toward Quinchana—a village manca holds a photo
of some 90 families hidden in the misty, verdant of her father, Luis
hills of Huila Department, a region known for Manuel Salamanca,
as a young man. A
coffee growing and oil exploration and home famed anthropologist
to the headwaters of several major rivers. Quin- and conservationist
chana is also the trailhead to a small community in southwestern Huila,
he was murdered on
called La Gaitana and an archaeological site of May 11, 2019. “My
pre-Columbian artifacts—imposing megalithic father was shot on the
stone deities and tombs that date to the first other side of this win-
dow,” said Alexandra
through eighth centuries. They were rediscov- Isabel. No arrests have
ered in 1942, helping put this region on the map. been made.
Salamanca had dedicated his career to study-
ing and preserving this history. The 64-year-old
was one of Colombia’s most renowned anthropol-
ogists. Soft-spoken and selective with his words,
he had a gentle face, round with a ball-shaped
nose, a countenance that exuded the comfort of
a fuzzy sweater.

104 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
 I’d come to see Salamanca during a fraught were left to hang on to the outside. “Better to go
moment of transition for Colombia, a country before it rains,” he repeated quietly to himself.
that had suffered half a century of violent armed The most famous artifacts in the massif are the
conflict. I was following the course of the Mag- extraordinary megalithic statues at a UNESCO
dalena River—the central, storied waterway World Heritage park of well-manicured lawns
that runs for nearly a thousand miles through and gravel trails in nearby San Agustín, the
the heart of the South American nation—and municipal capital. The park boasts large, upright
spending time with people working to support stone slabs carved into humanlike renderings of
a fragile peace along its banks. Mid-2018 was a lizards and monkeys that preside over spectacu-
time of relative calm. It wouldn’t last. lar views of the surrounding hills.
“Better to go before it rains,” Salamanca told Strolling the orderly trails of San Agustín is like
me, gazing at clouds in the crevasses of the valley visiting a zoo of stones. La Gaitana, in contrast,
as he gripped the cold metal bars of our truck at Salamanca told me, would be like encountering
every bump in the pavement. The shared cami- pre-Columbian relics in the wild. The site is hid-
oneta was overflowing with passengers by the den away on a mountainside, the trail obscured by
time we whistled it down, and Salamanca and I decades of overgrowth dating to when Quinchana

DEFENDING THE LAND 105

Colombia is
one of the
world’s most
biodiverse
countries
and is home to
sacred relics
that mark
the enduring
influence of
pre-Columbian
cultures.

A replica of a pre-
Columbian statue
guards a waterfall in
Cauca, in southwestern
Colombia. Ancient
cultures believed the
first- to eighth-century
megaliths that dot
this landscape pro-
tected rivers and all
living beings.
was off-limits, a gateway to a drug-trafficking implicated, but less than 10 percent of investi-
corridor controlled by guerrillas. gations result in sentences.
For more than half a century, the Marxist- “The way in which these killings of leaders
inspired Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colom- are being carried out, the kinds of leaders being
bia, known as the FARC, were at war with the targeted, the places where it’s happening, it’s
Colombian state. The conflict drew in other left- systematic,” Leonardo González of INDEPAZ
ist militias, right-wing paramilitary groups, drug told me. Systematic and frequent: Colombia was
cartels, and the U.S. military, rendering huge the world’s deadliest country for environmental
swaths of jungle and other remote areas unsafe activists in 2020 for the second year in a row,
for visitors and locals alike. Almost 270,000 peo- according to Global Witness, an environmental
ple died in the conflict, 81,000 disappeared, and and human rights investigative organization
7.4 million were displaced from their homes. based in London. Almost a year to the day after
A peace deal signed in 2016 was supposed I met Salamanca, the anthropologist became
to change everything. FARC soldiers agreed to one of those grim casualties. On the night of
lay down their weapons, and the government May 11, 2019, he was shot and left for dead in
pledged to welcome them back into society. Cru- front of his door.
cially, the state promised to establish or improve

T
public services in rural areas once controlled by
guerrillas. There was hope that former conflict H E D AY I S P E N Twith Sala-
zones would reopen to visitors, creating more manca, our camioneta ride
opportunities for the people who live there. ended at Quinchana’s town
But the lure of commercial rewards from strip; from there our jour-
untapped resources has come at a high price. ney would be on foot. We
Gold miners, cattle ranchers, and narco traffick- clambered down in front of a
ers have moved in, and locals who dare to defend modest family home that doubled as a general
their land and culture from development have store. A colorful, quirky array of provisions was
become targets. According to the Institute for for sale in the living room: Teddy bears and col-
Development and Peace Studies, a Bogotá-based oring books shared shelves with rubbing alcohol,
nonprofit known as INDEPAZ, 1,280 Colombian canned lentils, and feminine-hygiene products.
“social leaders”—many of them Indigenous and The morning was quiet, but my heart was rac-
Afro-Colombian land defenders and environ- ing. Not too long before, these FARC-controlled
mentalists—have been murdered since the towns were no-go zones for the uninvited. For-
2016 peace agreement. Armed groups vying for eigners and Colombians, especially wealthy
control of the resource-rich territory have been ones, were kidnapped for ransom. Loggers and
developers avoided rebel-controlled jungles.
Places like Quinchana—strategically located
near mountain passes long frequented by salt,
leather, and sugar traders in the preindustrial
era—became drug- and weapon-smuggling cor-
ridors that financed the guerrillas.
The liberation “The guerrillas controlled everyone’s move-
of land once ments. They decided who to allow in and who
to keep out,” Salamanca recalled.
controlled by The liberation of large tracts of Colombian
rebels has territory from the FARC has been a boon for sci-
been a boon ence and tourism. Colombia is the second most
biodiverse country in the world, home to a kalei-
for science and doscope of ecosystems, landscapes, and species. It
tourism—but has boasts huge expanses of coral reefs, grassland lla-
led to an assault nos, and buzzing rainforests. In the steaming-hot
central valleys, rivers and wetlands are home to
on natural caimans, vulnerable manatees, and critically
resources. endangered freshwater turtles. On the Pacific

108 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
 COLOMBIA Caribbean Sea
IN THE CROSSHAIRS SOUTH
AMERICA
Sierra Nevada
de Santa Marta
A 2016 peace accord with rebels was meant to
end bloodshed and open opportunities in former
conflict zones. But criminals and elites have
CESAR
exploited resources, hoarded profits, and threat-
ened community leaders who challenged them. PANA MA
By mid-December, 1,280 activists had been killed. VENEZUELA

S
MOST AT RISK: INDIGENOUS PEOPLE

lena
Killings of activists fell in 2021, partly due to better organi- OCEAN Medellín

Magda
zation within civilian defense groups and disarray in cartels CHOCÓ CO LO M BI A

E
and militias. Indigenous activists and Afro-Colombian land
RISARALDA CUNDINAMARCA
defenders are disproportionately targeted. Pereira
Ibagué Bogotá
Number of assassinations* Victims, by social cause† VALLE META
TOLIMA
Quilichao

D
DEL CAUCA Cali nder de
a
Indigenous/Afro-Colombian Farming rights Sant ADENTRO
Others CAUCA TIERR
418 (33%) EL QUIMBO DAM
LA GAITANA HUILA
310 Tumaco GUAVIARE
298 Community leadership Q u San Agustín

N
279 NARIÑO i n c ha
na
371 (29%)
207 Colombian Massif
165 Human rights, legal, political ECUADOR
Total 830 AMAZON

A
164 (13%)
RAINFOREST
Seventy percent of victims
Coca eradication
21 Total 450 were in rural farming areas BRAZIL
106 (8%) and mountain regions.
2016 ‘17 ‘18 ‘19 ‘20 2021 The killers are often linked PERU
to drug cartels trying to n
* FROM THE NOV. 24, 2016, PEACE DEAL THROUGH DEC. 19, 2021
Amazo
†THE FOUR SOCIAL CAUSES WITH THE MOST VICTIMS ARE SHOWN. OF
control coca cultivation 100 mi
1,280 FATALITIES, 323 WERE ACTIVISTS ON MORE THAN ONE ISSUE. and trafficking routes. 100 km

coast, thousands of humpback whales make evidence of widespread corruption among

annual migrations to Colombia’s nutrient-rich regional authorities who’ve turned a blind eye
waters, and slender waterfalls pour from volcanic to deforestation, mining, and wildlife traffick-
outcrops onto black-sand beaches. Here, Afro- ing that benefit elites. Politicians at the highest
Colombian and Indigenous Emberá and Wou- levels, including the ruling Centro Democrático
naan people know their way through labyrinths party, have been linked to violent paramilitary
of mangroves and mountains, and are preserving groups that are implicated in many killings. The
traditions rooted in generations of ancestors. paras, as they’re known, arose in the 1970s and
Biologists have explored new corners of the ’80s when wealthy landowners, drug traffickers,
country, discovering unknown species and pro- and corporate interests funded private armies to
tecting endangered ones. Annual international eliminate leftists.
tourist arrivals rose by more than one million The failure of the state to establish a strong
people from 2016 through 2019. presence in former conflict zones has allowed
At the same time, the free-for-all passage of criminal groups to flourish, fighting over natural
loggers, ranchers, and gold miners has fueled resources, smuggling corridors, and ports where
deforestation, and cultivation of coca—the key they can move illicit goods.
ingredient for cocaine—reached an all-time high Activists are fighting back—and paying with
in 2018, according to the UN Office on Drugs and their lives.
Crime. Large development projects—such as Los Those targeted include Indigenous leaders,
Besotes dam in the Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta teachers, scientists, conservationists, farmers
mountains and fracking explorations along the trying to replace coca with legal crops, femi-
Magdalena River—threaten to flood land, con- nists, and advocates for the 2016 peace accord.
taminate water, and displace communities and Juana Perea Plata was the 50-year-old owner of
species that depend on both. an ecolodge, who mobilized opposition to an
Authorities have failed to rein in those who industrial port near her home in Chocó Depart-
put profits over protection of resources. There’s ment on the Pacific coast. She was murdered in

CHRISTINE FELLENZ AND MONICA SERRANO, NGM STAFF; ERIKA NUNEZ. SOURCES: INDEPAZ; GREEN MARBLE
Nazaria Calambás
Tunubalá’s family
mourn at her funeral
in Cauca. In October
2021, the 34-year-old
Indigenous Misak, a
former mayor, was
gunned down. Groups
vying for drug routes
and resources have
targeted Indigenous
and Afro-Colombian
women in particular.
The mighty Magdalena
River flows through the
green hills of Huila, in
the southwestern massif.
Colombia is the second
most biodiverse country
on Earth, home to a
kaleidoscope of ecosys-
tems and species under
threat from encroaching
deforestation, mining,
and energy projects.
October 2020 by the Clan del Golfo, a notorious Francia Márquez Mina,
drug cartel formed by paras. A year later, cartel a prominent Afro-
Colombian activist
member Néstor Leonel Lozano Muriel was sen- from Cauca, survived an
tenced to nearly 18 years for her murder. Forty- assassination attempt
seven-year-old Carlos Fredy Londoño Bautista, in 2019. The state “is
allowing us to be mur-
a teacher and union leader who was preserving dered,” she said. Since
local traditions in Meta Department on the edge taking refuge in the
of the Amazon rainforest, was killed in front of capital, Bogotá, she has
launched a long-shot
his students in August 2021. In November 2019 bid for the presidency
Carlos Aldairo Arenas Salinas, 44, a bearded in the May election.
trekking guide passionate about Andean con-
dors and their bleak highland páramo habitat,
was murdered for opposing logging of a forest
in Tolima Department. In January 2021 Fran- cattle ranches and illegal palm oil plantations.
cisco Vera, an 11-year-old environmentalist Prominent senators’ families also have been
from Cundinamarca Department, known for implicated in other land grabs and kickbacks for
campaigning on social media against fracking ranching schemes.
and mining, received death threats and was Some conservative politicians have sought to
assigned a government bodyguard. discredit activists as Marxists and have mini-
Activists say the government should do more mized the dangers they face, perhaps embold-
than send bodyguards. They want investment in ening attackers. In the days before and after the
education and social programs to create alter- November 2020 murders of two rural teachers
natives in remote areas to drug trafficking and unionists, ruling party senators accused the
exploiting natural resources. They also want the national teachers union of “indoctrinating”
government to ratify the Escazú Agreement, the children. In a 2017 television interview, Luis
first environmental treaty signed by 24 countries Carlos Villegas, then defense minister, claimed
across Latin America and the Caribbean and the the “immense majority” of killings since the
first binding agreement anywhere that commits peace accords were not to silence activists but
signatories to protect environmental activists. were rather disputes over property, women, and
A July 2021 Colombian law did criminalize illicit profits.
environmental offenses, including the promo-

A
tion and financing of wildlife trafficking and
deforestation. But enforcement depends on uphill from
T WO - H O U R WA L K
rooting out elite corruption. Quinchana, Salamanca and I
In a November 2021 report on deforestation, found the La Gaitana archae-
researchers with the International Crisis Group ological site guarded by a pair
cited senior Colombian law enforcement officials of four-foot-high monkey stat-
as saying that “politicians involved in activities ues with wide faces, round
such as cattle ranching have bribed officers or ears, and mouths bearing tall rows of teeth. The
manipulated judicial investigations. Prominent real-life monkeys—along with tapirs, spectacled
figures have evaded punishment even in cases bears, jaguars, and pumas—had been driven away
where authorities have identified them as finan- long before to more remote mountain redoubts
ciers of illegal land clearing. Information about less disturbed by humans. Here, vestiges of their
the government’s work on specific cases has been presence were immortalized in stone.
leaked to armed groups, which then attempt to Salamanca led me to a clearing of grassy,
bribe or threaten the relevant officials.” knee-high mounds. “An ancient cemetery for
A rare exception was in 2019 when a gover- children,” he said quietly, pointing to grave-
nor, two mayors, and a local landowner were stones of dark boulders overgrown with moss.
collectively fined more than a million dollars for Despite his age, Salamanca never seemed
clearing an unauthorized 85-mile road through to stop moving; when he wasn’t studying an
unspoiled Amazon rainforest in Guaviare Depart- archaeological site, he rode a slender silver
ment. The scheme resulted in 57,000 acres of bicycle in the hills. He was stepping out for an
deforestation and displaced small farmers for evening walk in San Agustín when he was killed.

114 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
In the territory of the
Nasa people in Cauca,
members of the Guardia
Indígena (Indigenous
Guard) perform a ritual
to ask deities for protec-
tion. The unarmed
defense network was
formed to safeguard
ancestral lands from
militias, traffickers,
and developers seeking
to exploit resources.
 News of Salamanca’s assassination made and China, Colombia’s second biggest trading
national headlines. La Nación, a leading news- partner. If completed, the dams would flood some
paper, hailed him as “The Most Illustrious of the of the farthest reaches of the Magdalena River in
Agustinianos,” praising his contributions to sci- the massif, raising fears of catastrophic environ-
entific and cultural understanding. “We were mental and archaeological losses.
absolutely shocked,” his daughter Dalila told me. In the days after Salamanca’s death, hundreds
The exact motive behind Salamanca’s murder took to the streets in San Agustín, candles in
is unknown. But he’s remembered as an outspo- hand, demanding justice. A $2,700 reward was
ken citizen unafraid to defend his beliefs, a trait offered for tips, and San Agustín’s mayor prom-
that might have earned him enemies. He opposed ised answers. Nearly three years later, no one
construction of a nearby megadam, El Quimbo, has been charged. This too is routine in cases
that opened in 2015, displacing 450 families and involving social leaders. Authorities sometimes
flooding 20,000 acres of forest and farmland in capture individuals who pulled the trigger, but
Huila Department. He also opposed the Mag- rarely those who order or incentivize killings.
dalena Master Plan, a proposed dam network As of December 2021, the Colombian attorney
championed by the governments of Colombia general’s office reported having determined the

118 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
 with guns and grenades, injuring three of her
government bodyguards.
“Nothing is being done to actually end the
killings,” Márquez lamented. “We have a state
that is allowing us to be murdered.”
Still, many social leaders feel they have no
choice but to continue their work despite the
risks— even if it means using burner phones,
changing daily routines, or moving every few
weeks. “It’s up to us” to save communities
under threat from exploitation, said Márquez,
a long-shot candidate in Colombia’s May 2022
presidential election. “If we don’t, there will
be no change.”

T
march to
H E M AY 1 5 , 2 0 1 9,
protest Salamanca’s murder
was a prelude to more.
That November, Colombia
was rocked by nationwide
A member of the
Guardia Indígena demonstrations of discontent.
looks over the hills In the first half of 2021, the country again erupted
of Tierradentro, an in rallies against tax hikes, rising poverty levels,
archaeological park
and UNESCO World and slow implementation of the peace deal.
Heritage site in Cauca. When riot police cracked down on protesters in
Beside him, a staff cities including Cali, Pereira, and Ibagué, dozens
nailed atop a sacred
rock marks Native were killed and hundreds were injured.
authority over the The plight of social leaders is a central griev-
land. Despite death ance for protesters nationwide. Yet the carnage
threats, guardians
feel a responsibility continues: In 2021, 165 murders of social leaders
to protect the natural were registered by INDEPAZ as of mid-December.
and cultural treasures Meanwhile, Colombia’s countryside—home to
of Colombia.
immense reserves of biodiversity and vital car-
bon sinks found almost nowhere else on Earth—
suffers at the hands of developers and criminals.
Looking down on the green hills of the massif
masterminds of only 111 of the 500-plus murders in 2018, Salamanca and I watched a thin layer of
of human rights defenders documented by the clouds blanket the river valley, creating the illu-
Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human sion of smoke rising from the land. Improving
Rights since 2016, and had convicted only 15 livelihoods in former conflict zones while safe-
of those who plotted the murders. The judicial guarding communities and natural resources is a
system is virtually nonexistent in rural areas for- long-term undertaking, Salamanca told me.
merly controlled by the FARC. “It’s like buying an abandoned farm,” he said.
Francia Márquez Mina is one of Colombia’s “You have to put a lot of money and a lot of work
most prominent activists; her work driving into it, and then wait a while, hoping someday
out illegal gold miners from Afro-Colombian for the results to show.” j
communities in Cauca Department won her
the prestigious Goldman Environmental Prize Jordan Salama’s first book, Every Day the River
in 2018. She fled her hometown in 2014 after Changes: Four Weeks Down the Magdalena,
repeated death threats. On May 4, 2019, she chronicles his journey down Colombia’s greatest
waterway. Florence Goupil, a French-Peruvian
survived an assassination attempt in Santander photographer, focuses on the environment and
de Quilichao, when several men opened fire on Indigenous communities in Latin America.

DEFENDING THE LAND 119

The Cricket Catchers
 TRAPPERS OF THE HOPPING INSECTS BRING

A K E Y S O U RC E O F P ROT E I N TO U GA N DA N M A R K E T S .

B U T O V E R H A R V E S T I N G A N D C L I M AT E C H A N G E

C O U L D T H R E AT E N T H I S F O O D O F T H E F U T U R E .

B Y H A L I M A AT H U M A N I

PHOTOGRAPHS BY JASPER DOEST

121
A slow shutter speed PREVIOUS PHOTO
captures flight patterns A young man listens to
of cone-headed bush the whir of insects’ wings
crickets, commonly and the clang of their
called grasshoppers bodies colliding with
or nsenene in Uganda. the corrugated metal
As their numbers drop, sheets that form the walls
the development of of a giant trap. Lured by
captive-breeding tech- ultrabright lights and
niques could improve sedated by smoke, swarm-
food security, create ing bush crickets slide
new sources of income into the drums. They are
for farmers, and pro- a much loved snack, but
tect wild populations. growing demand and
habitat loss are driving
down their numbers.
Trappers unload sacks
of live bush crickets
from car roofs at Katwe
Market in Kampala.
Vendors clamor to out-
bid one another, with
the winner sometimes
reselling smaller por-
tions to other vendors
to maximize profits.
Scarcity and the grow-
ing market for the salty,
fried treats have made
the nsenene business
increasingly competitive.
 It’s a cold night,
and strong winds
are blowing
atop a hill in
southwest Uganda. Muntadhar Nasif holds
bush crickets he caught
while helping a friend
with his trap. He used
The wind rattles the four-by-eight-foot metal to catch them as a
sheets that form the slanted walls of the giant child, but today Nasif
insect trap. A diesel generator roars a few yards makes a stable income
as a tour guide. He says
away, powering a 400-watt bulb at its center. The it’s too risky to get in
light is blinding to human eyes, but it’s a magnet the nsenene trade, as
for Ruspolia differens. In Uganda they’re com- swarms are smaller and
less reliable than they
monly referred to as “grasshoppers” or nsenene once were.
(en-SAY-nay-nay), but they’re actually cone-
headed bush crickets.
At the bottom of the metal sheets, dozens
UG AN DA
of drums stand empty. Soon, hopes Kiggundu
Islam, chairman of the local bush cricket trap- Harugongo
Kampala
pers association, they’ll be filled with millions
Masaka Lake
of the nearly three-inch-long insects. Victoria
The “visitors,” as they’re called locally, come
together to mate and feed in huge swarms after

126 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C NGM MAPS

each rainy season in the autumn and spring, insects in general, have been lauded by the UN
when hundreds of people across the country Food and Agriculture Organization as a “food
set aside their day jobs to come out and catch source of the future,” key for establishing food
them. Salted and fried, the crickets are a del- security, alleviating hunger, and preventing
icacy in Uganda, sold for two dollars a bag at undernutrition. That’s important in countries
open-air markets, taxi parks, and roadsides. such as Uganda, where nearly a third of children
(“You see how you enjoy having a movie with are stunted, and half of children under five and
popcorn? Me, it’s a movie with nsenene,” says a third of women are anemic.
one fan.) But what once was a small-scale and personal
It’s November 2020, and it should be the harvest in Uganda has become an increasingly
middle of the autumn harvest in Harugongo. commercialized undertaking, with giant hill-
Legend has it the insects come from the moon, top and rooftop traps taking tons of the insects
and tonight it’s full. Yet “we’ve got nothing,” at a time to meet the growing demand. Mean-
Islam says. “Where are they?” while, decreasing catches suggest bush crickets
Protein dense and full of iron, zinc, and other are being overharvested, leading to pressure to
essential minerals, bush crickets, and edible make the collection more sustainable.

T H E C R I C K E T C ATC H E R S 127
Uganda’s growing
electrical grid has made
large-scale traps more
common. Insect collectors,
who lash lights to the
ends of wooden poles,
can amplify bulbs to
1,200 watts—some 20
times stronger than a
standard household bulb.
The light attracts more
crickets, but it also puts
harvesters at risk of UV
burns and eye damage.
 When Islam began collecting them in 2017, it
was only for himself and his family. They col-
lected the crickets that were attracted to their
home by a security light.
But the growing market promised a nice
income, and Islam soon set up two commercial
traps. “The nsenene came in big numbers,” says
Islam, a slim man with a deep voice. “We had a
lot of customers who came for them.
“On a good [night] you can get as many as 400
bags,” each weighing up to 110 pounds, “which
we then transport to Kampala and sell,” he says.
But three days on the Harugongo hilltop have
yielded nothing so far.
“The demand for this insect has escalated,”
says Philip Nyeko, an entomologist in the
Department of Forestry, Biodiversity, and Tour-
ism at Makerere University in Kampala. “The
supply, being seasonal, cannot now keep up.” Namuna Mzee picks
Nyeko leads a team of researchers developing nsenene off a stalk of
a method for farmers to captive-breed the bush corn. Unlike the crick-
ets’ locust cousins—
crickets. The goal is to take the pressure off wild responsible for
populations, allow for a year-round supply of outbreaks across East
nsenene, and provide another source of income Africa that devastate
crops and livelihoods—
for farmers, whose crops are increasingly at risk these hoppers are not
from severe droughts and pests. usually as destructive
But until recently, not much was known about in Uganda, where they
create jobs for col-
the biology, ecology, or life cycle of these insects. lectors and vendors.
The scientists had to start from scratch. Climate change has
“If you bring them from the wild, under what intensified locust out-
breaks, but it poses
conditions do you keep them? Where do you a threat to the bush
keep them?” Nyeko says he wondered. What cricket, whose life cycle
temperature do they prefer? What foods do they is closely tied to pre-
dictable rainy seasons.
thrive on? Where will they lay their eggs?

ON A SUNNY MORNING at Katwe, a market in

Kampala, small wooden stalls line a muddy dirt
road that leads to an open playing field. Next to trappers organization, which sets safety rules
the stalls are men and women seemingly sitting for collection and registers collectors. “God has
idle under large umbrellas. blessed Uganda with fertile soil and favorable
Then a man appears on foot, carrying a plastic environment,” he says, but logging to clear land
sack. It’s half-filled with bush crickets. The ven- for sugarcane and oil palms has destroyed much
dors snap awake and crowd around him. They’re bush cricket habitat. And climate change is mak-
pulling the bag from all sides, hollering over each ing the rainy seasons unpredictable, affecting
other. How much? Are you bringing more? When? the crickets’ swarming patterns.
The man is a bush cricket wholesaler, but he “If we just depend on the wild, it may not be
has little for them today. The half sack is bought sustainable” for the species’ future, says Geof-
by a middle-age man with a nearby stall. Every- frey Malinga, a senior lecturer at Gulu University,
one else slumps away disappointed, hoping to be which has partnered with Makerere Univer-
able to afford the next sack—whenever it comes. sity and the University of Copenhagen for the
The problem is not just overharvesting, says captive-breeding project’s upcoming field trials.
Hajji Quraish Katongole, head of the Old Masaka Cone-headed bush crickets can’t be allowed to
Basenene Association Limited, the national disappear—they’re a crucial protein source for

130 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
some Ugandans, “especially for children who are They also plan to test out a porridge-nsenene
poor and are not able to afford sources of proteins mix for schoolchildren.
like meat,” Malinga says. On the hill in Harugongo, Islam is back. A
By 2019, after eight years of experiments, mask, pants, and long sleeves protect him from
Nyeko and his collaborators cracked the code the trap’s bright light—and the painful Nairobi
of keeping and breeding bush crickets. Wire- flies. It’s a few days into the 2021 fall season, and
mesh and Plexiglas cages, a variety of grains he’s caught about three sacks’ worth—two fewer
to eat, and damp sand did the trick. Next: field than this time the previous year. Like others, he
tests. The pandemic delayed plans to roll out a took out loans to stay in business and worries how
pilot project with farmers in 2020, but now it’s he’ll repay them. “You struggle for plan B now,”
set to start in early 2022. The researchers have he says. “You will have to go and hunt somewhere
selected 99 villages in the central Ugandan dis- else [for] money, not in grasshoppers.” j
trict of Mityana to participate, with the goal that
it’ll catch on from there. Halima Athumani is a Uganda-based journalist.
This is her first story for the magazine. Jasper
“The farmers we shall train shall then train Doest focuses on stories that explore the relation-
other farmers,” Malinga says. ship between the natural world and humankind.

T H E C R I C K E T C ATC H E R S 131
An aerial view of traps
shows how harvesters
work together to
increase brightness
and warmth to attract
more bush crickets.
Decades ago, people
used bedsheets to
collect the insects for
themselves and their
families, but a boom
in nsenene popularity
turned collecting into
a business, leading
to the spread of these
large traps.
 INSTAGRAM
THOMAS P. PESCHAK
FROM OUR PHOTOGRAPHERS

WHO While in the Seychelles to photograph a book about

A National Geographic biodiversity, Peschak took his camera everywhere.
Explorer who focuses on One day as he was walking to the sea, where he
wildlife and conservation
planned to take underwater images of the islands’
WHERE
vibrant reefs, a common white tern began to hover
Cousine Island, Seychelles
WHAT
near his face. Peschak, in full scuba gear with fins
clenched in his teeth, raised his camera and clicked
Nikon D3 with a 16mm
fish-eye lens (both in water- the shutter. This image is one reason he tells aspiring
proof housing) and two photographers that the best camera and lens combi-
underwater strobe lights
nation is often the one you’re holding in your hands.
National Geographic is the most popular brand on Instagram, with more than 270 million followers.
This page showcases images from our accounts: @natgeo, @natgeotravel, @natgeointhefield,
@natgeoadventure, @natgeoyourshot.

Subscriptions For subscriptions or changes of ad- Contributions to the National Geographic Society are tax deductible under Section 501(c)(3) of the U.S. tax code.
dress, contact Customer Service at ngmservice.com | Copyright © 2022 National Geographic Partners, LLC | All rights reserved. National Geographic and Yellow
or call 1-800-647-5463. Outside the U.S. or Canada
call +1-515-237-3674.
®
Border: Registered Trademarks Marcas Registradas. National Geographic assumes no responsibility for
unsolicited materials. Printed in U.S.A. | For corrections and clarifications, go to natgeo.com/corrections.

NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC (ISSN 0027-9358) PUBLISHED MONTHLY BY NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC PARTNERS, LLC, 1145 17TH ST. NW, WASHINGTON, DC 20036. $39 PER YEAR FOR U.S. DELIVERY, $50.00
TO CANADA, $69.00 TO INTERNATIONAL ADDRESSES. SINGLE ISSUE: $8.00 U.S. DELIVERY, $10.00 CANADA, $15.00 INTERNATIONAL. (ALL PRICES IN U.S. FUNDS; INCLUDES SHIPPING AND HANDLING.)
PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT WASHINGTON, DC, AND ADDITIONAL MAILING OFFICES. POSTMASTER: SEND ADDRESS CHANGES TO NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC, PO BOX 37545, BOONE, IA 50037. IN
CANADA, AGREEMENT NUMBER 1000010298, RETURN UNDELIVERABLE ADDRESSES TO NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC, PO BOX 819 STN MAIN, MARKHAM, ONTARIO L3P 9Z9. UNITED KINGDOM NEWSSTAND
PRICE £6.99. REPR. EN FRANCE: EMD FRANCE SA, BP 1029, 59011 LILLE CEDEX; TEL. 320.300.302; CPPAP 0725U89037; DIRECTEUR PUBLICATION: D. TASSINARI. DIR. RESP. ITALY: RAPP IMD SRL, VIA G. DA
VELATE 11, 20162 MILANO; AUT. TRIB. MI 258 26/5/84 POSTE ITALIANE SPA; SPED. ABB. POST. DL 353/2003 (CONV L.27/02/2004 N.46) ART 1 C. 1 DCB MILANO STAMPA. QUAD, MARTINSBURG, WV 25401.
SUBSCRIBERS: IF THE POSTAL SERVICE ALERTS US THAT YOUR MAGAZINE IS UNDELIVERABLE, WE HAVE NO FURTHER OBLIGATION UNLESS WE RECEIVE A CORRECTED ADDRESS WITHIN TWO YEARS.

134 N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
 | T H E WO R L D I S A N A DV E N T U R E |
T R AV E L I T W I T H U S

T R AV E L W I T H N AT I O N A L G E O G R A P H I C
Every National Geographic expedition is grounded in our legacy of exploration, the
promise of an authentic travel experience, and a commitment to giving back. With
unique travel experiences that aim to inspire people to care about the planet, and
access to National Geographic’s grantees and active research sites, our travellers go
further and deepen their knowledge of the world.

W W W.T R AV E LW I T H N ATG E O.C O M

© 2022 National Geographic Partners, LLC. National Geographic EXPEDITIONS and the Yellow Border Design are trademarks of the National Geographic Society, used under license.
 GROWING UP IS
A BEAST.

Original Movie
Streaming March 11
If You Want to get these Newspapers Daily at earliest

English Newspapers»»
Indian Express, Financial Express, The Hindu, Business Line, The Times of India, The Economic Times,
Hindustan Times, Business Standard, First India, Mint, Greater Kashmir, Greater Jammu, The Himalayan,
The Tribune, Brill Express, The Sikh Times, Avenue Mail, Western Times, Millennium Post, The Statesman,
State Times, The Pioneer, Hans India, Free Press, Orissa Post, Mumbai Mirror, Mid-Day, Deccan Chronicle,
Deccan Herald, Telangana Today, Financial Times, The Asian Age, The Telegraph, Oheraldo, Gulf of Times,
The New York Times, The Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal,
The Guardian, The Times

Hindi Newspapers»»
दै निक जागरण, राजस्थाि पत्रिका, दै निक भास्कर, ह द
िं स्
ु ताि, िवभारत टाइम्स, त्रिज़िस स्टैंडडड, अमर उजाला,पिंजाि
केसरी, उत्तम ह न्द,ू जिसत्ता, लोकसत्ता, ररभूमम, द पायिीयर,जागरूक टाइम्स, राष्ट्रीय स ारा, दै निक हरब्यूि, युवा
गोरव, भारतीय स ारा, स्विंतिंि वाताड, सीमा सिंदेश, दै निक सवेरा,एक्शि इिंडडया, मदरलैंड वॉइस, दे शििंध,ु ह माचल दस्तक,

Others»» Hindi & English Editorial, Employment News, Malayalam Newspapers

Type in Search box of Telegram And you click join

will find a Channel named @demo_eapper join it and
receive daily editions of all popular epapers at the earliest
Or
you can clickon this link
https://t.me/demo_eapper