The Grignard reaction is a prominent process for forming carbon-carbon bonds that was discovered in 1900. It involves an organomagnesium species called a Grignard reagent reacting with an electrophilic substrate. While the Grignard reagent is typically thought to act as a nucleophile, evidence suggests an alternative radical or single electron-transfer mechanism may also occur, especially with certain ketone substrates. The exact mechanism of the Grignard reaction has remained elusive due to the variety of chemical species present in Grignard reagent solutions. Elucidating this mechanism could help improve the design of more efficient Grignard reaction variants.
The Grignard reaction is a prominent process for forming carbon-carbon bonds that was discovered in 1900. It involves an organomagnesium species called a Grignard reagent reacting with an electrophilic substrate. While the Grignard reagent is typically thought to act as a nucleophile, evidence suggests an alternative radical or single electron-transfer mechanism may also occur, especially with certain ketone substrates. The exact mechanism of the Grignard reaction has remained elusive due to the variety of chemical species present in Grignard reagent solutions. Elucidating this mechanism could help improve the design of more efficient Grignard reaction variants.
The Grignard reaction is a prominent process for forming carbon-carbon bonds that was discovered in 1900. It involves an organomagnesium species called a Grignard reagent reacting with an electrophilic substrate. While the Grignard reagent is typically thought to act as a nucleophile, evidence suggests an alternative radical or single electron-transfer mechanism may also occur, especially with certain ketone substrates. The exact mechanism of the Grignard reaction has remained elusive due to the variety of chemical species present in Grignard reagent solutions. Elucidating this mechanism could help improve the design of more efficient Grignard reaction variants.
The Grignard reaction is a prominent process for forming carbon-carbon bonds that was discovered in 1900. It involves an organomagnesium species called a Grignard reagent reacting with an electrophilic substrate. While the Grignard reagent is typically thought to act as a nucleophile, evidence suggests an alternative radical or single electron-transfer mechanism may also occur, especially with certain ketone substrates. The exact mechanism of the Grignard reaction has remained elusive due to the variety of chemical species present in Grignard reagent solutions. Elucidating this mechanism could help improve the design of more efficient Grignard reaction variants.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2
The Grignard reaction is a prominent textbook process to form carbon–carbon
bonds.(1) In this reaction, the so-called Grignard reagent, an organomagnesium
species RMgX where R is an organic residue and X is a halogen (usually Cl or Br), promotes the addition of its organic residue to an electrophilic substrate. Discovered by Victor Grignard(2) already in 1900, Grignard reagents rapidly became important compounds for organic synthesis in research laboratories and in industry.(3) Even though the reaction today is applied to a large variety of electrophiles, the prototypic substrates are carbonyl moieties R1R2(C═O) yielding a magnesium-alcoholate (eq 1). The R1 and R2 residues usually include hydrogen as well as alkyl-, vinyl-, or aryl- groups. The Grignard reaction usually takes place in ethereal solvents, the final alcohol product being obtained by hydrolysis. Despite more than 100 years of extensive studies, the mechanism of this reaction has remained elusive, with little quantitative information and missing consensus. Difficulties in elucidating this mechanism are prominently related to the fact that the ethereal solutions of Grignard reagents contain a variety of chemical species.(4,5) In fact, the nominal reactant RMgX is just a condensed representation of numerous mono- and polymetallic molecules that coexist at equilibrium (eq 2) and whose relative abundance depends on the nature of R and X as well as the experimental condition Furthermore, while the polarity of the C(δ−)–Mg(δ+) bond suggests that the Grignard reagent acts as a nucleophile, it has been argued that an electron-transfer mechanism may occur in the presence of appropriate substrates.(5) This multifaceted aspect of the Grignard chemistry is per se fascinating; in fact, the lack of understanding of its molecular mechanisms has slowed progress in the rational design of more efficient variants of the reaction. Indeed, while the efficiency of Grignard reagents has been heuristically improved, for example by the synergistic effect of additives like alkali ions, the reasons for these improvements remain unclear.(7) Elucidation of the mechanism of the basic Grignard reaction is the required step to better understand a wide variety of related reactions. Although the nucleophilic mechanism (also known as the polar mechanism) is currently recognized in the literature as a route to the alcohol product, no experimental study was able to assign the relative reactivity of the various forms of the organomagnesium species. In parallel, experimental evidence consistently supported the presence of an alternative mechanism (called radical or single electron-transfer mechanism) involving the formation of radical intermediates (Figure 1). In particular, products were detected, which could not originate from a nucleophilic addition but could be only obtained through a combination of organic radicals.(8−15) Furthermore, electron spin resonance spectroscopy identified the presence of ketyl radicals in benzophenone/Grignard reagent mixtures. (16) Factors favoring the radical mechanism were searched. Thus, using the distribution of products as an indicator for the mechanism, Ashby and co-workers inferred that an electron-transfer mechanism depends on the reduction potential of the substrate, the oxidation potential of the Grignard reagent, and the polarity of the solvent. Ketones with low reduction potential favored the radical mechanism. Indeed, a radical-type reaction was established for aromatic and conjugated ketones (such as benzophenone and fluorenenone) in the case of tertiary as well as primary Grignard reagents.(14)
Cycloaddition Reactions of a Nitrogen-Substituted Oxyallyl Cation with Cyclopentadiene and Substituted Furans. Reaction Conditions, Diastereoselectivity, Regioselectivity, and Transition State Modeling