Wines Hewson Slope Stability 2011
Wines Hewson Slope Stability 2011
Wines Hewson Slope Stability 2011
Abstract
The large Super Pit operation is famous for mining the remainder of the Golden Mile deposit through
development of a large open pit. However, prior to development of the pit, the Golden Mile was extensively
mined for more than 80 years using a variety of narrow-vein underground mining methods. The resultant relict
void network is both extensive and voluminous with approximately 3500 kms of equivalent drives/openings.
Development of the final western wall cutback (Golden Pike) will result in a 700 m high wall being formed in
highly stoped ground. As a result, the owners of the Super Pit have been interested to assess the affect that the
relict void network will have on ultimate pit wall stability.
In order to better assess the final pit wall stability, a program of three-dimensional numerical modelling was
considered to properly assess the affects of the relict void openings contained within the final wall. An important
deliverable was the development of a technique to enable the importation and mechanical representation of the
relict void openings within the significantly larger matrix of the 3D numerical model. Using the technique, more
than 100 discrete void openings were able to be mechanically represented within the full 3D model.
The resultant model will enable KCGM to confidently assess final wall stability and demonstrate this to external
stakeholders. To the authors’ best knowledge, this is the first time that such an extensive network of underground
voids have been modelled in 3D using distinct element methods.
1 Introduction
The Kalgoorlie Super Pit (Fimiston) operation is a major contributor to the economy of the Kalgoorlie-Boulder
region of Western Australia and operates with a high degree of external visibility from regulatory and
community stakeholders. The final pit will be approximately 3560 m long, 1450 m wide and up to 700 m deep.
The design includes some relatively steep inter-ramp slope angles, and several bullnose geometries exist,
generally below the location of haul ramp switchbacks. The operator of the Super Pit has recently commenced a
final cutback on the western pit wall, which lies immediately adjacent to the city of Boulder. As such a high
level of interest in the ultimate stability of the western wall exists.
The geometry of the Golden Mile deposit, which is being mined by the Super Pit, dips steeply westwards. As the
Golden Mile was previously mined using narrow-vein underground methods there now exists an extensive
network of stopes, drives and other openings in a complex mesh within the developing open pit (Figure 1). As a
consequence this ‘mesh’ of openings also dips westwards and as such results in numerous intersections with the
final western pit wall. The orebody effectively remains open to depths of 1400 m. As a result, stability
assessments of the western pit wall are not considered to be complete without some consideration of the effect
that this extensive stope network will have on slope stability.
The remnant stopes are generally relatively narrow, with a typical width of around 3 m. Some of the stopes are
filled, while most are open voids. The stopes could contribute to slope failure in many ways, including:
· providing a reduction in the shear strength of the materials forming the pit walls.
· providing an upper release surface allowing shear or toppling failure below.
· providing a void into which excessive slope movement (or failure) from upslope can occur.
· allowing additional inelastic strain and therefore rock mass weakening to occur behind the excavation
face.
· creating unfavourable stress concentration and redistribution behind the excavation face.
· creating localised unravelling of a batter face, which in turn may undercut the batters above and
propagate up the slope.
Plan
Looking north
Looking east
Figure 1. Plan and side views of final pit dxf and all known stopes.
Assessment of the stability of the western wall is an important task for the operator, KCGM, as the ultimate
western pit wall lies immediately adjacent to the satellite city of Boulder. The mine, regulator and community
require confidence in the proposed geotechnical design for the pit walls, both during the planned remaining 10
years of operation and following closure. As a consequence, modelling of the pit wall that does not include
appropriate representation of the extensive void network provides only limited confidence in the geotechnical
design.
1.1 Geotechnical setting and previous investigations
The Super Pit is hosted within strongly metamorphosed and deformed Archean greenstones (meta-dolerite/meta-
basalt) of the Eastern Goldfields terrane. The host rocks exhibit high rock mass strengths (RMR values for the
west wall typically exceed 70) and the resultant pit wall deformation is low. Regional stresses in the area exhibit
a relatively high horizontal stress level, with the horizontal to vertical stress ratio approaching 3:1. Failure
mechanisms and pit wall stability are controlled more by discrete structures than the rock mass. The resulting
geotechnical designs focus more on inter-ramp and overall slope stability, and both these issues are effectively
addressed using numerical modelling techniques.
Given the extensive three-dimensional (3D) array of geological structures, an artefact of the long-lived tectonic
history and ore development, distinct element numerical modelling methods have been the preferred choice for
slope stability analysis at the Super Pit. For many areas of the pit wall, modelling has been undertaken using
two-dimensional (2D) distinct element codes such as UDEC (Itasca, 2004). These methods have typically
worked well, especially when geotechnical uncertainty is addressed using scenario and simulation estimation
(e.g. monte carlo) methods. There is also confidence in applying 2D methods to laterally extensive pit walls
where curvature is minimal.
The issue of open pit mining through abandoned underground workings has been discussed by several authors,
including Walton and Taylor (1977), Watters et al. (1989), Watters et al. (1990), Loubser (1994) and Jiang et al.
(2005). Stewart et al. (1996) and Stead and Benko (1998) endorse the use of numerical modelling as a tool to
enhance understanding of possible slope failure mechanisms associated with underground workings.
Several of the previous 2D numerical analyses performed for the Super pit have incorporated remnant stopes as
open voids. No large-scale failures have been predicted by the models with best-estimate properties assigned,
however sensitivity analyses with lower material properties have identified some potential failure mechanisms
associated with the remnant stopes. Current face exposures of up to 500 m height containing numerous void
intersections suggest that voids do not have as significant impact on pit wall stability as some previous 2D
modelling outcomes would suggest. This indicates that 2D modelling, which by nature assumes that all voids
included in the analyses are infinite in length, could over-predict the effect that these features may have on slope
stability. This is supported by Sainsbury et al. (2003), who performed both 2D and 3D numerical analyses to
assess the effects of underground voids on pit slope stability. By comparing the 2D to the 3D modelling results,
they concluded that 2D analyses may provide conservative stability estimates where underground voids of finite
length exist behind the pit wall.
N Golden Pike
Stores West
Black Flags
Croesus
Stores East
Trafalgar
South Trafalgar
Ayoro Oroya 11
N East Oroya Brown Hill
Figure 2. (a) Oblique view showing overall geometry of the 3DEC model used for slope stability analysis of
the Super Pit current and final pit shells, and (b) exposed geotechnical domains after excavation of
the final pit.
More than 60 faults were explicitly defined in the 3DEC model. The 3D fault interpretations are shown in
relation to the final pit dxf in Figure 3a. Three structures behind the east wall were of particular interest. These
are the Oroya Shear, the Ayoro Fault and the Reliance Fault, each of which is shown in relation to the final pit
shell in Figure 3b. Each structure dips steeply to the west, and the Oroya Shear and Ayoro Fault both daylight in
the final eastern wall. Based on its interpreted location, the Reliance Fault is not expected to daylight.
Remnant stopes have been incorporated in the 3DEC pit model to assess their influence on slope stability. Due to
the large number and small size (particularly width) of the stopes, it was impractical to incorporate all of the
known stopes into a full pit model. As such, those stopes that will exist at or behind the final pit slope on the
western side of the pit to the north of the large bullnose have been incorporated into the model. The stopes have
been defined in this region because this is the major cutback area for future mining and the township of Boulder
is located immediately adjacent. Much of the southern and eastern walls have already been excavated to the final
pit shell, as has the southern end of the western wall. Those stopes included in the model are shown in relation to
the final pit shell in Figure 4a. The plan area in which these stopes exist is approximately 2000 x 500 m, as
shown in Figure 4b. It is seen that the majority of the stopes are steeply-dipping and have a north-south
orientation.
Oroya Ayoro
Shear Fault
Reliance
Fault
(a) (b)
Figure 3. Oblique views of final pit dxf showing (a) all fault dxfs, and (b) Oroya Shear, Ayoro and Reliance
faults (looking approx. north).
Plan
N
Looking north
2000 m
Figure 4. (a) Plan and side views of final pit dxf and those stopes incorporated into the 3DEC model and (b)
plan view showing extent of remnant stopes included in the model.
The remnant stopes have been defined using 3DEC model zones. Constructing a numerical model for open pit
slope stability analyses is typically a relatively straightforward process, however incorporation of remnant stopes
creates significant complications that are not normally encountered. On the one hand the model is aiming to
assess the medium to large-scale slope behaviour. However, the relatively small-scale of the individual stopes
(particularly the width) means that a small model zone size is required in the immediate vicinity of the stopes in
order to properly represent the behaviour of these openings in the modelling process. As such, we require a
model capable of representing and analysing both small-scale stope and large-scale slope behaviour.
The size of a 3DEC model, and therefore the computer requirements and time required to run the analyses, are
related to the total number of zones in the model. Given that the entire pit was included in these analyses, it was
critical that the number of zones be minimised in order to construct a model that was practical to run. The key to
minimising the total number of zones in the model was to restrict the smaller zones to only those areas
surrounding the remnant stopes. This was achieved using the following process:
· Stage 1 - A large rectangular mesh was constructed with a constant 2.5 m zone size, and an in-house
Itasca model construction tool was used to identify those zones that were located within the stope dxfs.
Using 3DEC’s in-built programming language FISH, a function was written to export the centroids of
these identified zones to a text file.
· Stage 2 - In the 3DEC pit model, the regions of the west wall where remnant stopes were to be
incorporated were cut into 18 m3 blocks. Another FISH function was written to identify those 18 m3
blocks that were located within a specified distance of the centroids that were identified in Stage 1
above. These blocks were assigned a 3 m zone size, while the remaining 18 m3 blocks were assigned an
18 m zone size. Areas remote from the remnant stopes were assigned a 30 m zone size. This allowed the
zones to be progressively graded depending on their proximity to the remnant stopes.
After zoning the 3DEC pit model, the in-house Itasca model construction tool was used to identify those zones
that were located within the stope dxfs. These zones were assigned a unique material number. The resulting
mesh and stope definition after excavation of the final pit is shown in Figure 5. The relatively small 3DEC zones
adjacent to the remnant stopes are evident, as are the larger zones in surrounding areas.
(b) (c)
Figure 5. Oblique view of part of the final north-western wall showing (a) stope dxfs, (b) stope definition
within the model and (c) a closer view showing the stope traces and surrounding 3DEC zones.
N N
Figure 6. Plans showing numerical velocity, cumulative displacement (in metres) and active plastic yielding
for base case model (a) after excavation of the final pit and (b) with shear strength properties
reduced using a FoS = 1.5 (i.e. the shear strength for the rock mass and faults is reduced below
actual levels).
Several simulations with varied input parameters were performed to analyse final pit stability and these
identified several potential multi-bench failure mechanisms. All of these mechanisms are associated with sliding
along faults, with some component of rock mass failure. Potential medium to large-scale instability involving
only rock mass failure was not identified, reflecting the high quality of the rock mass that will form the final pit
walls.
The model predicted localised instability around the remnant stopes on the west wall. This instability is restricted
to the immediate vicinity of the stope intersections with the excavation face. Despite this, predicted instability
associated with the stopes is relatively small. An oblique plot showing localised displacements on the west wall
in relation to the stope dxfs is provided in Figure 7a. An oblique view of numerical velocities on the west wall in
relation to the stope dxfs is provided in Figure 7b for the base case model after shear strength reduction using a
FoS = 1.5. The figure also illustrates one area of localised instability whereby a remnant stope beneath the
excavation face results in a weak zone along which small-scale slope failure could occur.
Remnant stope provides
weak zone along which
shear failure can occur
(a) (b)
Figure 7. (a) Oblique view showing cumulative displacement (in metres) after excavation of the final pit in
relation to stope dxfs, for base case model with no shear strength reduction, and (b) oblique view
showing numerical velocity after excavation of the final pit in relation to stope dxfs (above) and
cross section showing localised instability associated with remnant stope (below), for base case
model with shear strength parameters reduced using a FoS = 1.5.
4 Conclusions
Three-dimensional numerical modelling has been performed to analyse final pit slope stability at the Super Pit in
Western Australia. The pit lies immediately to the east of the city of Boulder, and as such a high level of interest
in the ultimate stability of the western wall exists. 3D modelling allows improved representation of the true
characteristics of the model input parameters. For the Super Pit, 3D analyses were particularly valuable to
assess:
· the effects of slope geometry on pit wall stability, particularly the concave geometry at the northern and
southern ends of the final pit and the convex nature of several bullnoses that exist in the pit design.
· the behaviour of the geological structures in three-dimensions, with several known structures dipping
into the excavation and striking sub-parallel to the excavation face.
· the effects of the relatively high horizontal in situ stresses in three-dimensions.
· the effects of remnant voids associated with abandoned underground workings.
This last point is particularly relevant at the Super Pit, where the Golden Mile has been continuously worked
using underground methods for more than 100 years. As such, several hundred abandoned stopes exist in the
mining area.
A complex 3D numerical model was successfully constructed and run to analyse the behaviour of the full final
pit shell. The model included more than 60 discrete geological structures, 13 geotechnical domains and
incorporation of remnant stopes at and behind the final western wall. Due to the complexity of the analyses, and
that fact that a relatively small zone size was required adjacent to the remnant stopes, this resulted in a very large
model. However given recent advances in computer capabilities, several model runs with varied input
parameters have been performed using desktop computers with off-the-shelf hardware.
The main technical challenge addressed was that of incorporating numerous small-scale elements with sufficient
model resolution within the context of modelling a significantly large open pit. The results of the modelling now
provide KCGM with a full 3D assessment of the pit slope stability that takes into account the potential stress
effects induced by the relict voids. The model predicts stable slope conditions despite the extensive void network
present in the wall. Limited instances of localised instability surrounding the remnant voids are identified, which
is to be expected. These results are consistent with the historical stability at the mine, where no large-scale slope
failures have occurred in the past due to the presence of voids in the pit walls. The model now provides KCGM
with a tool from which additional sensitivity studies can be undertaken to more fully examine the stability of the
western pit wall.
5 Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines, Barrick Gold Corporation and Newmont
Australia for permission to publish this paper, and Mr Yoann Hebert for his assistance in the initial 3DEC model
construction.
6 References
Board, M., Seldon, S., Brummer, R. and Pakalnis, R. (2000) Analysis of the Failure of a Large Hangingwall Wedge: Kidd
Mine Division, Falconbridge, Ltd, CIM Bull., 93(1043), pp. 89-97.
Brummer, R. K., Li, H. and Moss, A. (2006) The Transition from Open Pit to Underground Mining: An Unusual Slope
Failure Mechanism at Palabora, Stability of Rock Slopes in Open Pit Mining and Civil Engineering Situations
(International Symposium, Cape Town, April 2006), pp. 411-420. SAIMM Symposium Series S44. Johannesburg:
SAIMM.
Corkum, A. G. and Martin, C.D. (2004) Analysis of a Rock Slide Stabilized with a Toe-Berm: A Case Study in British
Columbia, Canada, Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci., 41, pp. 1109-1121.
Dawson, E.M., Roth, W.H. and Drescher, A. (1999) Slope stability analysis by strength reduction. Geotechnique, 40(6), pp.
835-840.
Grenon, M., and Caumartin, R. (2007) Use of Resource Modeling Tools in Numerical Analysis of Slope Stability, Rock
Mechanics: Meeting Society's Challenges and Demands (1st Canada-U.S. Rock Mechanics Symposium, Vancouver,
May 2007), Vol. 2: Case Histories, pp. 1295-1300, E. Eberhardt et al., Ed. London: Taylor & Francis Group.
Hoek, E., Carranza-Torres, C.T. and Corkum, B. (2002) Hoek-Brown failure criterion - 2002 edition. In Hammah et al.
(eds.), Proceedings of the Fifth North American Rock Mechanics Symposium, Toronto. University of Toronto Press,
Toronto, pp. 267–273.
Itasca Consulting Group, Inc. (2004) UDEC (Universal Distinct Element Code), Version 4.0. Minneapolis: ICG.
Itasca Consulting Group, Inc. (2011) 3DEC (3 Dimensional Distinct Element Code), Version 4.2. Minneapolis: ICG.
Jiang, J., Sun, Y. and Morrongiello, M. (2005) Analysis of Slope Stability and Interaction with Underground Workings.
SME Annual Meeting, Feb. 28 – Mar. 2, Salt Lake City, Utah.
Loubser, P. (1994) Geotechnical Assessment of the West Wall of KCGM’s Super Pit. Proceedings of the 4 th Large Open
Pit Conference. pp. 145-158 (The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy: Melbourne).
Sainsbury, D.P., Pierce, M.E. and Lorig, L.J. (2003) Two and Three-Dimensional Numerical Analysis of the Interaction
Between Open Pit Slope Stability and Remnant Underground Voids. Proceedings of the 5 th Large Open Pit
Conference. pp. 251-257. (The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy: Melbourne).
Sainsbury, D., Pothitos, F, Finn, D. and Silva, R. (2007) Three-Dimensional Discontinuum Analysis of Structurally
Controlled Failure Mechanisms at the Cadia Hill Open Pit, Slope Stability 2007 (Proceedings, 2007 International
Symposium, Rock Slope Stability in Open Pit Mining and Civil Engineering, Perth, Australia, September 2007), pp.
307-320, Y. Potvin, Ed. Perth: Australian Centre for Geomechanics.
Stead, D and Benko, B. (1998) The influence of underground workings on slope instability mechanisms. Proceedings of the
8th International IAEG Congress. pp. 1493-1500. (Balkema: Rotterdam).
Stewart, D.P., Coulthard, M.A. and Swindells, C.F. (1996) Studies into the influence of underground workings on open pit
slope stability. Rock Mechanics. pp. 515-522 (Balkema: Rotterdam).
Walton, G. and Taylor, R.K. (1977) Likely constraints on the stability of excavated slopes due to underground coal
workings. Proceedings of the Conference on Rock Engineering, Newcastle Upon Tyne, pp. 329-349.
Watters, R. J., Finn, D. and Coulthard, J. (1989) Pit slope instability problems induced by disused underground mine
workings. Proceedings of the 25 th Symposium on Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering, pp. 101-106
(Balkema: Rotterdam).
Watters, R. J., Rehwoldt, E.B. and Coulthard, J. (1990) Effects of abandoned underground workings on open pit slope
design. Proceedings of the 31st US Rock Mechanics Symposium: Rock Mechanics Contributions and Challenges, pp.
721-728 (Balkema: Rotterdam).