Wing Wall - Height Up To 3.5m
Wing Wall - Height Up To 3.5m
Wing Wall - Height Up To 3.5m
S.NO. DESCRIPTION
This design note present the detailed calculation for T-type Wing Wall . It contains the typical design of Wing
Wall Shaft and foundation. In the analysis the forces have been worked out at the bottom of foundation for
foundation design and at the top of foundation for Wing Wall shaft design.
Description Unit
Grade of concrete _ (Fck) M-35
Grade of Steel _ (Fy) Fe-500
3
Density of backfill earth (LWL) 20.00 Kn/m
Density of backfill earth (HFL) 10.00 Kn/m3
Density of passive soil 20.00 Kn/m3
Density of concrete 25.00 Kn/m3
Density of water 10.00 Kn/m3
Mini. Fluid pressure as per clause 214.1 of IRC : 6 - 2017 4.8 Kn/m3
Net safe bearing capacity (As per Geotechnical report) 120 kn/m2
Description Unit
Ground level 102.000 m
Founding Level of Wing Wall 100.000 m
Top level of Wing Wall 105.600 m
Page 2 of 51
Height of stem above Road level 0.00 m
Total height of stem 5.00 m
Thickness of Stem at top level 0.30 m
Thickness of Stem at base 0.55 m
1.1.3 Calculation of Earth pressure coefficients as per Cl. 214.1 of IRC 6 : 2017
Angle which earth face of wall make with the horizontal = 87.14 deg = 1.5208 rad
Page 3 of 51
1.2 Section of Wing Wall (Showing Dimensions) for Total Height 5.6 m.
0.30
Wall Top Level = 105.600 m
5.000
1
B B
3.00
Ground level = 102.000 m
Back Fill
1.400 1.700
10 2.000
A 11 A
9
2
6
4 0.300
Heel 0.600 Toe
0.300 3 5 0.300 Founding Level = 100.000
Page 4 of 51
1.3 CHECK FOR STABALITY OF Wing Wall - NORMAL CASE (DRY)
1.3.1 Calculation of Forces & moments due to Dead Wt. & Vertical Forces
Moment
Lateral Lever arm
Type of force Load Factor about "O" Unit
Force (Kn) about O
(Kn-m)/m `
Minimum Pressure due to
Fluid as per Cl 710.1.3 of 1.0 26.9 2.80 75.26 (Kn-m)/m
IRC 78 : 2014
Active Earth pressure due
to back fill as per IRC 06 : 1.0 92.0 2.35 216.37 (Kn-m)/m
2016
Maximum of two values 92.0 216.37 (Kn-m)/m
Earth pressure due to live
load surcharge as per IRC 1.0 39.4 2.80 110.39 (Kn-m)/m
06 : 2016
(The Earth Fill on Passive side is Protected by road Crust which is not suseptible to scour, but for conservative
approach only 30 % of Passive soil resistance is considered in design.
Page 5 of 51
1.3.4 Check for Sliding (LWL) condition
Lever arm
Vertical Moment
Section Area No. about center Unit
load(Kn/m) (Kn-m)/m
of base slab
1 53.13 -0.23 -12.29
2 6.75 0.70 4.73
3 13.50 1.00 13.50
RCC Wing Wall
4 5.44 -0.93 -5.08
5 10.88 -1.18 -12.78
6 8.25 -0.18 -1.44
7 180.00 1.00 180.00
Back Fill Earth 8 12.50 0.02 0.21
9 5.40 1.30 7.02
10 40.60 -1.18 -47.71
Earth Fill (Passive Side)
11 4.35 -1.42 -6.16
Live load surcharge 12 0.00 1.00 0.00
Page 6 of 51
Base pressure at Toe end = 156.52 < 160.00 Kn/m2 OK
2
Base pressure at Heel end = 22.84 > 0.00 Kn/m OK
Heel Toe
1.80 1.45
1.90
22.84
156.52
86.16 105.51
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Toe slab = 105.51 Kn/m
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Heel slab = 86.16 Kn/m
Page 7 of 51
1.4 CHECK FOR STABALITY OF Wing Wall - NORMAL CASE (HFL)
1.4.1 Calculation of Forces & moments due to Dead Wt. & Vertical Forces
Moment
Lateral Lever arm
Type of force Load Factor about "O" Unit
Force (KN) about O
(Kn-m)/m `
Minimum Pressure due to
Fluid as per Cl 710.1.3 of 1.0 26.9 2.80 75.26 (Kn-m)/m
IRC 78 : 2014
Active Earth pressure due
to back fill as per IRC 06 : 1.0 46.0 1.85 85.00 (Kn-m)/m
2016
Maximum of two values 46.0 85.00 (Kn-m)/m
Earth pressure due to live
load surcharge as per IRC 1.0 19.7 2.80 55.20 (Kn-m)/m
06 : 2016
Page 8 of 51
1.4.4 Check for Sliding (HFL) condition
Vertical
Moment (Kn-
Section Area No. load(Kn/m Lever arm Unit
m)/m
) about center
1 31.88 -0.23 -7.38
2 4.05 0.70 2.84
3 8.10 1.00 8.10
RCC Wing Wall
4 3.26 -0.93 -3.05
5 6.53 -1.18 -7.67
6 4.95 -0.18 -0.87
7 90.00 1.00 90.00
Back Fill Earth 8 6.25 0.02 0.10
9 2.70 1.30 3.51
10 20.30 -1.18 -23.85
Earth Fill (Passive Side)
11 2.18 -1.42 -3.08
Live load surcharge 12 0.00 1.00 0.00
Page 9 of 51
Base pressure at Toe end = 71.76 < 96.00 Kn/m2 OK
2
Base pressure at Heel end = 23.07 > 0.00 Kn/m OK
Heel Toe
1.8 1.45
2.35
23.07
71.76
46.14 53.18
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Toe slab = 53.18 kN/m
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Heel slab = 46.14 kN/m
Page 10 of 51
1.5 CALCULATION OF SEISMIC CO-EFFICIENT
Where
Ah = horizontal seismic co-efficient
𝑍 𝐼/𝑅 𝑆_𝑎/𝑔
Ah = X X
Seismic Zone IV
Zone factor Z = 0.24
Importance Factor I = 1.20
Response Reduction factor = 2.50
(as per Table 3 of IS 1893 : 2014)
Ah = 0.144
Av = 0.096
Horizontal and Vertical Seismic Co-efficicent for foundation shall be 1.25 times the forces transmitted to it by
substructure
Ah = 0.180
Av = 0.120 ( Clause 219.8 )
Page 11 of 51
Where
tan -1 𝛼 = 0.131
λ
_ℎ/(1± 𝛼_𝑣 = 0.158
Ca = 0.419
Horiz. 0.373 Max. value of Ca is adopted.
Ca = 0.177
Vertical 0.154
Kah = 0.293
Kav = 0.124
Page 12 of 51
1.6 CHECK FOR STABLITY OF Wing Wall- SEISMIC CASE
Seismic
Horizontal Moment Horizontal
Vertical Vertical Moment
Distance about "O" seismic
Load Area Force Distance about "O"
Section Area No. of C.G. due to Force
Factor (m2) (Kn/m) from"O" due to
from "O" Vertical (Kn/m) Fh=
(Fv) (m) horizontal
(m) force (Fv*Ah)
force
1 1.0 2.13 1.67 53.13 88.65 7.65 1.09 8.34
2 1.0 0.27 2.60 6.75 17.55 0.97 0.40 0.39
3 1.0 0.54 2.90 13.50 39.15 1.94 0.15 0.29
RCC Wall
4 1.0 0.22 0.97 5.44 5.26 0.78 0.40 0.31
5 1.0 0.44 0.73 10.88 7.88 1.57 0.15 0.23
6 1.0 0.33 1.73 8.25 14.23 1.19 0.30 0.36
7 1.0 9.00 2.90 180.00 522.00 - - -
Back Fill 8 1.0 0.63 1.92 12.50 23.96 - - -
9 1.0 0.27 3.20 5.40 17.28 - - -
10 1.0 2.03 0.73 40.60 29.44 - - -
Passive Soil
11 1.0 0.22 0.48 4.35 2.10 - - -
Live load
12 0.0 1.80 2.90 0.00 0.00
surcharge - - -
Moment Due to Vertical Down ward seismic Load about "O" = 105.17 Kn-m/m
Moment Due to Vertical Up ward seismic Load about "O" = -105.17 Kn-m/m
Page 13 of 51
1.6.2 Calculation of moments due to Lateral Forces
Note: In Case of Dynamic increment the point of action for earth pressure due earth fill will be 0.5 * H & live load
surcharge will be 0.66 * H. Where "H" is the total Height of Wing Wall.
Page 14 of 51
1.6.4 Check for Sliding (Seismic Condition)
Moment
Total Vertical load Lever arm
Vertical (Kn-m)/m
Section Area No. including vertical about Unit
load(Kn/m) about
Seismic (Kn/m) center
center
1 53.13 54.66 -0.23 -12.65
2 6.75 6.94 0.70 4.86
3 13.50 13.89 1.00 13.89
RCC Wall
4 5.44 5.59 -0.93 -5.22
5 10.88 11.19 -1.18 -13.15
6 8.25 8.49 -0.18 -1.49
7 180.00 182.86 1.00 182.86
Back Fill 8 12.50 12.70 0.02 0.21
9 5.40 5.49 1.30 7.13
10 40.60 41.24 -1.18 -48.46
Passive Soil
11 4.35 4.42 -1.42 -6.26
Live load
0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge 12
Page 15 of 51
Moment due to lateral force about center = 325.19 (kn-m)/m
Net Longitudnal moment about center = 203.46 (kn-m)/m
Heel Toe
1.8 1.45
1.9
5.24
177.64
86.90 111.85
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Toe slab = 111.85 kN/m
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Heel slab = 86.90 kN/m
Moment
Total Vertical load Lever arm
Vertical (Kn-m)/m
Section Area No. including vertical about Unit
load(Kn/m) about
Seismic (Kn/m) center
center
1 53.13 51.60 -0.23 -11.94
2 6.75 6.56 0.70 4.59
3 13.50 13.11 1.00 13.11
RCC Wall
4 5.44 5.28 -0.93 -4.93
5 10.88 10.56 -1.18 -12.41
6 8.25 8.01 -0.18 -1.40
7 180.00 177.14 1.00 177.14
Back Fill 8 12.50 12.30 0.02 0.21
9 5.40 5.31 1.30 6.91
10 40.60 39.96 -1.18 -46.95
Passive Soil
11 4.35 4.28 -1.42 -6.06
Live load
12 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Page 16 of 51
Total 340.79 334.11 118.26 (Kn-m)/m
Heel Toe
1.8 1.45
1.9
2.90
137.78
66.79 86.31
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Toe slab = 86.31 kN/m
2
Base pressure at junction of Stem with Heel slab = 66.79 kN/m
Page 17 of 51
1.7 Load Calculation For Wing Wall Foundation Design
a) Load Combination -1
Factored Factored
Vertical Lever arm Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor Unit
load about center about
(Kn/m) Center
1 1.35 71.72 -0.23 -22.40
2 1.35 9.11 0.70 6.38
3 1.35 18.23 1.00 18.23
RCC Wall
4 1.35 7.34 -0.93 -6.85
5 1.35 14.68 -1.18 -17.25
6 1.35 11.14 -0.18 -1.95
7 1.35 243.00 1.00 243.00
Back Fill 8 1.35 16.88 0.02 0.28
9 1.35 7.29 1.30 9.48
10 1.35 54.81 -1.18 -64.40
Passive Soil
11 1.35 5.87 -1.42 -8.32
Live load
12 1.20 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force about center about
(Kn/m) Center
Page 18 of 51
Factored moment due to lateral force about center = 411.12 (Kn-m)/m
Net Factored Longitudnal moment = 254.94 (Kn-m)/m
Ecentricity in longitudnal direction = 0.55 m
b) Load Combination -2
Factored Factored
Vertical Lever arm Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor Unit
load about center about
(Kn/m) Center
1 1.00 53.13 -0.23 -12.29
2 1.00 6.75 0.70 4.73
3 1.00 13.50 1.00 13.50
RCC Wall
4 1.00 5.44 -0.93 -5.08
5 1.00 10.88 -1.18 -12.78
6 1.00 8.25 -0.18 -1.44
7 1.00 180.00 1.00 180.00
Back Fill 8 1.00 12.50 0.02 0.21
9 1.00 5.40 1.30 7.02
10 1.00 40.60 -1.18 -47.71
Passive Soil
11 1.00 4.35 -1.42 -6.16
Live load
12 1.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force about center about
(Kn/m) Center
Page 19 of 51
Factored moment due to lateral force about center = 352.66 (kn-m)/m
Net Factored Longitudnal moment = 232.66 (kn-m)/m
Ecentricity in longitudnal direction = 0.68 m
Vertical Factored
Factored Lever arm
load Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor Vertical load about Unit
(Kn/m) about
(Kn/m) center
(Fv) Center
1 1.35 53.13 71.72 -0.23 -16.59
2 1.35 6.75 9.11 0.70 6.38
3 1.35 13.50 18.23 1.00 18.23
RCC Wall
4 1.35 5.44 7.34 -0.93 -6.85
5 1.35 10.88 14.68 -1.18 -17.25
6 1.35 8.25 11.14 -0.18 -1.95
7 1.35 180.00 243.00 1.00 243.00
Back Fill 8 1.35 12.50 16.88 0.02 0.28
9 1.35 5.40 7.29 1.30 9.48
10 1.35 40.60 54.81 -1.18 -64.40
Passive Soil
11 1.35 4.35 5.87 -1.42 -8.32
Live load
12 0.20 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored Seismic Load in Downward direction (Av * Fv + Cav * Fv soil) = 74.20 Kn/m
Factored Seismic Load in Upward direction = -74.20 Kn/m
Factored Moment Due to Vertical downward seismic Load about = 38.69 Kn-m/m
center
Factored Moment Due to Vertical upward seismic Load about center = -38.69 Kn-m/m
Page 20 of 51
1.7.3.1 Calculation of moments due to Lateral Forces (Seismic Combination)
Factored Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force about center about
(Kn/m) Center
Earth pressure due to back
fill as per IRC 06 : 2016 _ 1.00 92.0 2.4 216.37 (Kn-m/m)
(Static)
Dynamic Active Earth
Pressure as per Cl. 214.1.2 of 1.50 59.1 2.8 165.37 (Kn-m/m)
IRC 06 : 2016
Earth pressure due to live
load surcharge as per IRC 0.20 7.9 2.8 22.08 (Kn-m/m)
06 : 2016 (Static)
Dynamic Earth pressure due
0.20 3.4 3.7 12.47 (Kn-m/m)
to live load surcharge
Horizontal Seismic Force
due dead load of RCC 1.50 26.4 18.61 (Kn-m/m)
members
Page 21 of 51
1.7.4 Combination for design of Foundation ( SLS )
1) Rare Combination
2) Frequent Combination
3) Quasi-Permanent Combination
Factored
Vertical
Lever arm Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor load Unit
about center about
(Kn/m)
Center
1 1.00 53.13 -0.23 -12.29
2 1.00 6.75 0.70 4.73
3 1.00 13.50 1.00 13.50
RCC Wall
4 1.00 5.44 -0.93 -5.08
5 1.00 10.88 -1.18 -12.78
6 1.00 8.25 -0.18 -1.44
7 1.00 180.00 1.00 180.00
Earth Fill 8 1.00 12.50 0.02 0.21
9 1.00 5.40 1.30 7.02
10 1.00 40.60 -1.18 -47.71
Passive Soil
11 1.00 4.35 -1.42 -6.16
Live load
12 1.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force (KN) about center about
Center
Earth pressure due to back
1.00 92.0 2.35 216.4 (Kn-m/m)
fill as per IRC 06 : 2016
Page 22 of 51
Moment due to lateral force about center = 280.86 (Kn-m)/m
Net Longitudnal moment = 160.87 (Kn-m)/m
Ecentricity in longitudnal direction = 0.47 m
Factored
Vertical
Lever arm Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor load Unit
about center about
(Kn/m)
Center
1 1.00 53.13 -0.23 -12.29
2 1.00 6.75 0.70 4.73
3 1.00 13.50 1.00 13.50
RCC Wall
4 1.00 5.44 -0.93 -5.08
5 1.00 10.88 -1.18 -12.78
6 1.00 8.25 -0.18 -1.44
7 1.00 180.00 1.00 180.00
Earth Fill 8 1.00 12.50 0.02 0.21
9 1.00 5.40 1.30 7.02
10 1.00 40.60 -1.18 -47.71
Passive Soil
11 1.00 4.35 -1.42 -6.16
Live load
12 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force (KN) about center about
Center
Earth pressure due to back
1.00 92.0 2.4 216.4 (Kn-m/m)
fill as per IRC 06 : 2016
Page 23 of 51
Factored base pressure at Toe end = 147.35 Kn/m2
Factored base pressure at Heel end = 32.01 Kn/m2
Factored
Vertical
Lever arm Moment
Section Area No. Load Factor load Unit
about center about
(Kn/m)
Center
1 1.00 53.13 -0.23 -12.29
2 1.00 6.75 0.70 4.73
3 1.00 13.50 1.00 13.50
RCC Wall
4 1.00 5.44 -0.93 -5.08
5 1.00 10.88 -1.18 -12.78
6 1.00 8.25 -0.18 -1.44
7 1.00 180.00 1.00 180.00
Earth Fill 8 1.00 12.50 0.02 0.21
9 1.00 5.40 1.30 7.02
10 1.00 40.60 -1.18 -47.71
Passive Soil
11 1.00 4.35 -1.42 -6.16
Live load
12 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00
surcharge
Factored
Lateral Lever arm Moment
Type of force Load Factor Unit
Force (KN) about center about
Center
Earth pressure due to back
1.00 92.0 2.4 216.4 (Kn-m/m)
fill as per IRC 06 : 2016
Page 24 of 51
1.8 DESIGN OF TOE SLAB
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Combination-1) = 227.00 KN/m @ Toe end
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Combination-1) = 15.14 KN/m @ Heel end
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Seismic = 286.15 KN/m @ Toe end
Combination)
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Seismic = 4.96 KN/m @ Heel end
Combination)
Heel Toe
2
15.14 Kn/m
/ 4.96 Kn/m2 227.00 Kn/m
2
2
/ 286.15 Kn/m
1.8.2 Calculation of moment and shear force at critical sections of Toe slab for ULS combinations
Seismic
Description Combination-1 Unit
combination
Factored base Pressure at Junction of stem & Toe
slab
146.16 178.86 Kn/m2
Factored base Pressure at deff from junction of stem 174.98 217.11 Kn/m2
& Toe slab
Factored Moment @ Junction of stem & Toe slab 184.56 237.48 Kn-m
Factored Shear force @ deff from Junction of stem
164.68 211.93 Kn
& Toe slab
Page 25 of 51
1.8.3 Verification of Structural Strength : Ultimate Limit State
Design Concrete compressive strength for ULS as per Cl. 6.4.2.8, IRC : 112-2011
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Combination - 1
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Combination - 2
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Seismic Combination
Design Yeild strength of Untensioned Reinforcement as per clause 6.2.2, IRC : 112-2011
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Combination - 1
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Combination - 2
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Seismic Combination
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Seismic
Description Combination -1 Unit
combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & Toe
184.6 237.5 Kn-m
slab (Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000 1000 mm
Overall depth of section at Junction of stem & Toe 600.0 600.0 mm
slab (D)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75 75.0 mm
Effective depth(d) 517.0 517.0 mm
xu from compression face 28.9 37.4 mm
fcd 15.6 15.6 N/mm2
fyd 434.8 434.8 N/mm2
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 840.6 1089.3 mm2
Minimum steel required (0.13bd%) 672.1 672.1 mm2
Page 26 of 51
Pt (%) provided 0.262% 0.262%
Maximum Steel Limit as per Cl 16.5.1 of IRC 112 :
2.500% 2.500%
2011
OK OK
Distrubtion steel
Dia of Bar provided 10.0 10.0 mm
Spacing of bars 200.0 200.0 mm
Ast required (IRC : 112 , CL 16.6.1.1) 314.2 314.2 2
mm
2
Ast provided 392.7 392.7 mm
OK OK
Seismic
Check for Shear _ Toe Slab Combination -1 Unit
combination
Page 27 of 51
Spacing ( S) 200.0 200.0 mm
2
Area of shear R/F (Asw1) 100.5 100.5 mm
Page 28 of 51
1.8.4 Verification of Serviceblity Limit State :
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Rare = 156.52 KN/m @ Toe end
Combination)
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Rare = 22.84 KN/m @ Heel end
Combination)
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Quasi- = 129.72 KN/m @ Toe end
Permanent Combination)
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Quasi- = 49.64 KN/m @ Heel end
Permanent Combination)
Heel Toe
0.300 0.600
0.300
1.800 0.550 1.450
3.800
2
22.84 Kn/m
/ 49.64 Kn/m2 156.52 Kn/m
2
2
/ 129.72 Kn/m
1.8.5 Calculation of moment and shear force at critical sections of Toe slab for SLS combinations
Quasi-permanent
Description Rare Combination Unit
Combination
Factored base Pressure at Junction of stem & Toe 105.51 99.16 Kn/m2
slab
Factored base Pressure at deff from junction of stem 123.70 110.06 2
Kn/m
& Toe slab
Factored Moment @ Junction of stem & Toe slab 125.07 104.06 Kn-m
Factored Shear force @ deff from Junction of stem
111.55 92.69 Kn
& Toe slab
Page 29 of 51
1.8.6 Verification of Seviceblity Limit State :
Allowable compressive stress in concrete for SLS as per clause 12.2.1, IRC : 112-2011
Es = 2.00E+05 Mpa
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Quasi-Permanent
Description Rare Combination Unit
Combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & Toe 125.07 104.06 Kn-m
slab (Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000.00 1000.00 mm
Overall depth of section at Junction of stem & Toe 600.00 600.00 mm
slab (D)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75.00 75.00 mm
Effective depth(d) 517.00 517.00 mm
xu from compression face 29.35 32.64 mm
xu/d 0.06 0.06
xu lim/d 0.58 0.58
fcd 16.80 16.80 N/mm2
fyd 400.00 400.00 N/mm2
Rlim = Mu,lim/bd2 3.96 2.97
Mu, lim 1057.60 793.20 Kn-m
OK OK
Page 30 of 51
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 616.32 513.90 2
mm
672.10 672.10 2
Minimum steel required(0.13bd%) mm
392.70 392.70 2
Area of steel required in compression mm
Dia of Bar (main Compression) 16.00 16.00 mm
Spacing of Bar 200.00 200.00 mm
Asc Provided 1005.31 1005.31 mm2
OK OK
Quasi-Permanent
CHECK FOR CRACK WIDTH AS PER _ IRC : 112-2011 Unit
Combination
Factored Moment at Junction of stem & Toe slab (Mu) 104.06 Kn-m
Grade of Concrete _ (fck) 35.00 Mpa
Modulus of elascticity _ (Es) 200000.00 Mpa
(Ec,eff) _ as per Eq. A2-5 of IRC 112 : 2011 32308.25 Mpa
Modular Ration _ (αe) 6.19
Page 31 of 51
Cracked Moment of Inertia (In steel units) _ (I) =
370394440.45 mm4
(1/3)*(Eceff*b*dc3/Es) + As*( d-dc )2
Stress in tension Reinforcement _ (σsc ) = (MED/Zs) 136.08 Mpa
(Fctm) _ as per Eq. A2-2 of IRC 112 : 2011 2.77 Mpa
(Fct,eff) _ Cl. 12.3.3 of IRC 112 : 2011 _ Max of (2.9) or (F ctm) 2.90 Mpa
Page 32 of 51
1.9 DESIGN OF HEEL SLAB
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Combination-1) = 227.00 KN/m @ Toe end
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Combination-1) = 15.14 KN/m @ Heel end
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Seismic = 286.15 KN/m @ Toe end
Combination)
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Seismic = 4.96 KN/m @ Heel end
Combination)
Heel Toe
0.600
0.300 0.300
2
15.14 Kn/m
2 2
4.96 Kn/m 227.00 Kn/m
2
286.15 Kn/m
1.9.2 Calculation of moment and shear force at critical sections of Heel slab for ULS combinations
Seismic
Combination-1 Unit
combination
Factored base Pressure at Junction of stem & Heel slab 115.49 138.16 Kn/m2
Factored Moment @ Junction of stem & Heel slab 186.33 185.09 Kn-m
Factored Shear force @ Junction of stem & Heel slab 176.93 165.69 Kn
Page 33 of 51
1.9.3 Verification of Structural Strength : Ultimate Limit State
Design Concrete compressive strength for ULS as per Cl. 6.4.2.8, IRC : 112-2011
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Combination - 1
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Combination - 2
2
fcd = 15.63 N/mm For Seismic Combination
2
Grade of Reinforcement Steel _ (fy) = 500 N/mm
Design Yeild strength of Untensioned Reinforcement as per clause 6.2.2, IRC : 112-2011
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Combination - 1
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Combination - 2
2
fyd = 434.8 N/mm For Seismic Combination
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Seismic
Description Combination -1 Unit
combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & Heel slab
186.3 185.1
(Mu) Kn-m
Width of section (b) 1000 1000 mm
Overall depth of section at Junction of stem & Heel slab 600.0 600.0
(D) mm
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75 75.0 mm
Effective depth(d) 517.0 517.0 mm
xu from compression face 29.2 29.0 mm
fcd 15.6 15.6 N/mm2
2
fyd 434.8 434.8 N/mm
2
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 848.9 843.1 mm
Minimum steel required (0.13bd%) 672.1 672.1 mm2
Page 34 of 51
2
Ast provided 1570.8 1570.8 mm
OK OK
Pt(%) provided 0.262% 0.262%
Maximum Steel Limit as per Cl 16.5.1 of IRC 112 : 2011 2.500% 2.500%
OK OK
Distrubtion steel
Dia of Bar provided 10.0 10.0 mm
Spacing of bars 200.0 200.0 mm
2
Ast required (IRC : 112 , CL 16.6.1.1) 314.2 314.2 mm
2
Ast provided 392.7 392.7 mm
OK OK
Seismic
Check for Shear _ Heel Slab Combination -1 Unit
combination
Factored shear force _ (Ved) @ Junction of stem & Heel 176.9 165.7 Kn
slab
Depth of section at critical point 493.0 493.0 mm
cl. 10.3.2(2) Eq. 10.2 of IRC :112-2010
K = 1+Sqrt(200/d) <= 2.0 1.6 1.6
cl. 10.3.2(2) Eq. 10.3 of IRC :112-2010
vmin = 0.031 K3/2 fck1/2 0.384 0.384
cl. 10.3.1 of IRC :112-2011
p1 = Asl/(bw d) <= 0.02 0.003 0.003
OK OK
0.12* K *(80* p1* fck )0.33 0.404 0.404
Axial compressive force NEd (KN) 0.0 0.0
σcp = NEd / Ac < 0.2 fcd 0.0 0.0
cl. 10.3.2(2) Eq. 10.1 of IRC :112-2010
VRd.c= [0.12*K*(80*p1 *fck )0.33 + 0.15*σcp]*b*d 199.4 199.4 Kn
No shear No shear
reinforcement reinforcement
required required
Page 35 of 51
1.9.4 Verification of Serviceblity Limit State :
2
= 156.52 KN/m @ Toe end
Maximum Factored base pressure (Rare Combination)
2
= 22.84 KN/m @ Heel end
Minimum Factored base pressure (Rare Combination)
2
Maximum Factored base pressure (Quasi-Permanent = 129.72 KN/m @ Toe end
Combination)
2
Minimum Factored base pressure (Quasi-Permanent = 49.64 KN/m @ Heel end
Combination)
Heel
Toe
0.300 0.600 0.300
2
22.84 Kn/m
/ 49.64 Kn/m2 156.52 Kn/m
2
2
/ 129.72 Kn/m
1.9.5 Calculation of moment and shear force at critical sections of Heel slab for SLS combinations
Quasi-permanent
Description Rare Combination Unit
Combination
Factored base Pressure at Junction of stem & Heel slab 86.16 87.57 Kn/m2
Page 36 of 51
0.00 0.00 2
Downward pressure due to water (if any) Kn/m
107.67 107.67 2
Downward pressure due to earth fill_(Backfill side) Kn/m
11.25 11.25 2
Downward pressure due to dead wt. of heel slab Kn/m
Factored Moment @ Junction of stem & Heel slab 121.45 91.75 Kn-m
Factored Shear force @ Junction of stem & Heel slab 115.95 90.56 Kn
Allowable compressive stress in concrete for SLS as per clause 12.2.1, IRC : 112-2011
Es = 2.00E+05 Mpa
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Frequent
Rare Combination Quasi-Permanent
Combination
xu lim/d 0.58 0.58 0.58
Rlim = Mu,lim/bd2 3.96 3.96 2.97
Page 37 of 51
Quasi-Permanent
Description Rare Combination Unit
Combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & Heel slab 121.45 91.75 Kn-m
(Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000.00 1000.00 mm
Overall depth of section at Junction of stem & Heel slab
600.00 600.00 mm
(D)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75.00 75.00 mm
Effective depth(d) 517.00 517.00 mm
xu from compression face 28.49 28.70 mm
xu/d 0.06 0.06
xu lim/d 0.58 0.58
fcd 16.80 16.80 2
N/mm
fyd 400.00 400.00 N/mm2
2
Rlim = Mu,lim/bd 3.96 2.97
Mu, lim 1057.60 793.20 Kn-m
OK OK
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 598.16 451.93 mm2
672.10 672.10 2
Minimum steel required(0.13bd%) mm
392.70 392.70 2
Area of steel required in compression mm
Dia of Bar (main Compression) 16.00 16.00 mm
Spacing of Bar 200.00 200.00 mm
Asc Provided 1005.31 1005.31 mm2
OK OK
Quasi-Permanent
CHECK FOR CRACK WIDTH AS PER IRC : 112-2011 Unit
Combination
Factored Moment at Junction of stem & Heel slab (Mu) 91.75 Kn-m
Grade of Concrete _ (fck) 35.00 Mpa
Modulus of elascticity _ (Es) 200000.00 Mpa
(Ec,eff) _ as per Eq. A2-5 of IRC 112 : 2011 32308.25 Mpa
Modular Ration _ (αe) 6.19
Page 38 of 51
No. of Curtailed Bar provided per meter width _ (n2) 5
Effective spacing between bars 100.00 mm
2 2
Øeq = (n1*Ø1 + n2*Ø2 )/(n1*Ø1 + n2*Ø2) _ as per Eq. 12.9 14 mm
Page 39 of 51
1.10 DESIGN OF Wing Wall SHAFT
Forces and moment are calculated at Junction of footing and wall stem
Following load combination are considered as per Table B-2 & B-3 of IRC 06 : 2016
Factored
Factored Lever arm
Moment
Load Lateral about
Type of force about Unit
Factor Force Bottom of
Bottom of
(Kn/m) Stem
Stem
Earth pressure due to back fill
1.50 110.00 2.10 231.01
as per IRC 06 : 2016
Earth pressure due to live load
surcharge as per IRC 06 : 1.20 42.24 2.50 105.60
2016
Page 40 of 51
2) Seismic Combination (ULS)
Factored
Factored Lever arm
Moment
Load Lateral about
Type of force about Unit
Factor Force Bottom of
Bottom of
(Kn/m) Stem
Stem
Earth pressure due to back fill
1.00 73.3 2.1 154.01
as per IRC 06 : 2016 _ (Static)
Dynamic Active Earth
Pressure as per Cl. 214.1.2 of 1.50 47.1 2.5 117.71
IRC 06 : 2016
Earth pressure due to live load
surcharge as per IRC 06 : 0.20 7.0 2.5 17.60
2016 (Static)
Factored
Factored Lever arm
Moment
Load Lateral about
Type of force about Unit
Factor Force Bottom of
Bottom of
(Kn/m) Stem
Stem
Earth pressure due to back fill
1.00 73.3 2.10 154.0
as per IRC 06 : 2016
Earth pressure due to live load
surcharge as per IRC 06 : 1.00 35.2 2.50 88.0
2016
Page 41 of 51
Passive Earth pressure as per
1.00 -33.73 0.47 -15.7
IRC 06 : 2016
Factored
Factored Lever arm
Moment
Load Lateral about
Type of force about Unit
Factor Force Bottom of
Bottom of
(Kn/m) Stem
Stem
Earth pressure due to back fill
1.00 73.3 2.10 154.0
as per IRC 06 : 2016
Earth pressure due to live load
surcharge as per IRC 06 : 0.00 0.0 2.50 0.0
2016
Basic Quasi-permanent
Seismic Combination Rare Combination
Combinatiomn Combination
Factored Horizontal
118.51 108.21 74.80 39.60
force (Kn)
Total factored
320.87 296.02 226.27 138.26
moment (Kn-m)
Page 42 of 51
1.10.4 Verification of Structural Strength : Ultimate Limit State
Design Concrete compressive strength for ULS as per Cl. 6.4.2.8, IRC : 112-2011
Design Yeild strength of Untensioned Reinforcement as per clause 6.2.2, IRC : 112-2011
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Seismic
Description Basic Combination Unit
Combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & footing
320.87 296.02 Kn-m
(Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000 1000 mm
Overall depth of stem section at Junction of stem &
550.0 550 mm
footing (D)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75 75 mm
Effective depth(d) 467.0 467 mm
xu from compression face 57.2 52.6 mm
fcd 15.6 15.6 N/mm2
fyd 434.8 434.8 N/mm2
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 1665.2 1529.6 mm2
Minimum steel required (0.13bd%) 781.9 781.9 mm2
Page 43 of 51
Ast required 1665.2 1529.6 2
mm
Dia of Main Bar provided _ (φ1) 16.0 16.0 mm
Spacing of Main bar 200.0 200.0 mm
Dia of Curtailed Bar provided _ (φ2) 16.0 16.0 mm
Spacing of Curtailed bar 200.0 200.0 mm
Ast provided 2010.6 2010.6 mm2
OK OK
Pt(%) provided 0.366% 0.366%
Maximum Steel Limit as per Cl 16.5.1 of IRC 112 :
2.500% 2.500%
2011
OK OK
OK OK
Seismic
Check for Shear @ Bottom of Stem Basic combination Unit
Combination
Page 44 of 51
1.10.6 Case 2 : Verification of Structural Strength : At section B-B of Wing Wall Stem
Seismic
At Section B-B of Wing Wall Basic combination Unit
Combination
Total factored Moment at section B-B of wall stem
61.9 88.4 Kn-m
(Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000 1000 mm
Overall depth of section at section B-B of wall stem
425 425 mm
(D1)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75 75.0 mm
Effective depth(d) 342.0 342.0 mm
xu from compression face 14.6 16.7 mm
fcd 15.6 19.5 N/mm2
fyd 434.8 500.0 N/mm2
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 423.6 527.4 mm2
Minimum steel required(0.13bd%) 444.6 444.6 mm2
2
Ast required 444.6 527.4 mm
Dia of Main Bar provided _ (φ1) 16.0 16.0 mm
Spacing of Main bar 200.0 200.0 mm
Dia of Curtailed Bar provided _ (φ2) 0.0 0.0 mm
Spacing of Curtailed bar 200.0 200.0 mm
Distrubtion steel
Dia of Bar provided 10.0 10.0 mm
Spacing of bars 150.0 150.0 mm
Ast required (IRC : 112 , CL 16.6.1.1) 201.1 201.1 mm2
Ast provided 523.6 523.6 mm2
OK OK
Page 45 of 51
Steel on other Face ( SP : 34 ,Cl. 8.5)
Dia of Bar provided 16.0 16.0 mm
Spacing of bar 200.0 200.0 mm
Asc required 351.9 351.9 2
mm
Asc provided 1005.3 1005.3 mm2
OK OK
Seismic
Check for Shear @ Section B-B Basic combination Unit
Combination
Page 46 of 51
1.10.7 Verification of Seviceblity Limit State :
Allowable compressive stress in concrete for SLS as per clause 12.2.1, IRC : 112-2011
Es = 2.00E+05 Mpa
Where, " d " is the effective depth and " xu " is the depth of neutral axis fom top of secton
Quasi-Permanent
Description Rare Combination Unit
Combination
Total factored Moment at Junction of stem & footing
226.27 138.26 Kn-m
(Mu)
Width of section (b) 1000.00 1000.00 mm
Overall depth of stem section at Junction of stem &
550.00 550.00 mm
footing (D)
Clear Cover as per Table 14.2 of IRC 112 : 2011 75.00 75.00 mm
Effective depth(d) 467.00 467.00 mm
xu from compression face 60.27 48.69 mm
xu/d 0.13 0.10
xu lim/d 0.58 0.58
fcd 16.80 16.80 N/mm2
fyd 400.00 400.00 N/mm2
Rlim = Mu,lim/bd2 3.96 2.97
Mu, lim 862.92 647.19 Kn-m
OK OK
Page 47 of 51
Steel required as per Mu _ (Ast) 1265.17 766.54 2
mm
Minimum steel required(0.13bd%) 607.10 607.10 mm2
2
Area of steel required in compression 502.65 502.65 mm
Dia of Bar (main Compression) 16.00 16.00 mm
Spacing of Bar 200.00 200.00 mm
1005.31 1005.31 2
Asc Provided mm
OK OK
CHECK FOR CRACK WIDTH AS PER IRC : 112-2011 Quasi-Permanent Combination Unit
Page 48 of 51
(Fct,eff) _ Cl. 12.3.3 of IRC 112 : 2011 _ Max of (2.9) or (F ctm) 2.90 Mpa
Page 49 of 51
Summary of Reinforcement Provided in Wing Wall of Total Height 5.6 M
Sr. No. Structure Bar No. Dia of Bar Spacing / No. Shape Remarks
1 16 @ 200 C/C Toe Main Bar Full length
2 12 @ 200 C/C Toe Main Bar Curtailed
3 12 @ 200 C/C Heel Main Bar Curtailed
4 16 @ 200 C/C Heel Main Bar Full length
1 Wing Wall
Vertical Main bar Full
8 16 @ 200 C/C
Length