Research/Investigación Confirmation of Meloidogyne Hapla On Strawberry in Florida Using Molecular and Morphological Techniques
Research/Investigación Confirmation of Meloidogyne Hapla On Strawberry in Florida Using Molecular and Morphological Techniques
Research/Investigación Confirmation of Meloidogyne Hapla On Strawberry in Florida Using Molecular and Morphological Techniques
ABSTRACT
Nyoike, T.W., T. Mekete, R. McSorley, E. Weibelzahl-Karigi, and O. E. Liburd. 2012. Identification of the root-knot
nematode, Meloidogyne hapla, on strawberry in Florida using morphological and molecular methods. Nematropica
42:253-259.
Morphological and molecular studies were conducted to identify a root-knot nematode that was found on strawberry
roots growing in Marion County, Florida, and on strawberry transplants imported from nurseries in Ontario, Canada. In
early spring 2011, strawberry plants growing in the field were observed showing localized stunting and galled roots. Soil
samples collected from the field revealed a very high number of Meloidogyne infective juveniles (232 J2/100cc soil) in
one block but relatively low numbers in two other blocks. Morphological studies based on perineal patterns of root-knot
females collected from the field-strawberry roots and from strawberry transplants (received from nurseries in October
2011) were conducted. The perineal patterns indicated that they were Meloidogyne hapla Chitwood. Polymerase Chain
Reaction (PCR) amplification of the region between COII and 16S rRNA of the mitochdrial DNA produced a single
fragment ca 540 bp. Restriction digestion of the amplified PCR products with Dra1 enzyme produced two fragments
at 200 and 250 bp indicating that the root-knot nematode in the field and on transplant strawberry plants was M. hapla.
DNA sequencing of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region produced a single fragment ca 990 bp and a BLAST
search in the Genbank revealed that the species was 98% identical to other known M. hapla sequences in the Genbank.
This study ascertains that M. hapla recorded on strawberry plants in the field was imported with the transplants from
the nurseries in Ontario, Canada. M. hapla, is commonly found in cooler climates and high altitudes, and has been
reported as a common pest for strawberries in northeastern United States. Implications of importing nematode-infected
strawberry transplants are discussed.
Key words: Identification; internal transcribed spacer; Meloidogyne; mitochondrial DNA; nematode-infected transplants;
PCR-RFLP; root-knot nematode; strawberry.
RESUMEN
Nyoike, T.W., T. Mekete, R. McSorley, E. Weibelzahl-Karigi, and O. E. Liburd. 2012. Identificación del
nematode nodulador Meloidogyne hapla, en fresa en Florida mediante métodos morfológicos y moleculares.
Nematropica 42:253-259.
Se realizaron estudios morfológicos y moleculares para identificar un nematodo agallador encontrado en
raíces de fresa en el condado de Marion, Florida y en trasplantes de fresa importados de viveros de Ontario,
Canadá. A principios de la primavera de 2011, se observaron en el campo rodales de plantas de fresa con enanismo
y raíces agalladas. Muestras de suelo recolectadas de este campo revelaron un número muy alto de juveniles
infectivos de Meloidogyne (232 J2/100cc suelo) en uno de los bloques pero relativamente bajo en los otros dos
bloques. Se llevaron a cabo estudios morfológicos basados en el patrón perineal de las hembras del nematodo
utilizando muestras de raíces de fresa recolectadas en el campo y raíces de trasplantes de fresa (recibidos de
viveros en Octubre 2011). El patrón perineal indicó que las hembras eran Meloidogyne hapla Chitwood. La
amplificación de la región entre COII y el 16S rRNA del DNA mitocondrial mediante la reacción en cadena de la
polimerasa produjo un solo fragmento de aprox. 540 bp. La digestión del producto amplificado de la PCR con la
enzima Dra1 produjo dos fragmentos a 200 y 250 bp, lo que indicaba que la especie de Meloidogyne encontrada
en el campo y en los trasplantes era M. hapla. La secuenciación del DNA de la región ITS confirmó la identidad
de M. hapla con un 98% de similitud con otras especies conocidas de M. hapla depositadas en el Genbank. Este
estudio confirma que M. hapla en las plantas de fresa en el campo fue importada con los trasplantes procedentes
de Ontario, Canadá. M. hapla se encuentra comúnmente en climas más fríos y altitudes altas y se ha citado como
253
254 NEMATROPICA Vol. 42, No. 2, 2012
una plaga común de la fresa en el noreste de los Estados Unidos de América. Se discute las implicaciones de
importar trasplantes de fresa infestados con el nematodo agallador.
Palabras clave: Identificación; Meloidogyne; DNA mitocondrial; trasplantes infestados con nematodos; PCR-
RFLP; nematodo agallador; fresa.
ClustalW2 (CLUSTAL 2.0, Dublin, Ireland). season. The plants were stunted, with reduced crowns,
and produced small berries (Fig. 1a). Below-ground
RESULTS symptoms included root galling and excessive growth
of fibrous roots compared to healthy roots (Fig. 1a). In
Root-knot nematode symptoms and soil nematode the 2011/2012 growing season, transplants showing
abundance: Above-ground symptoms associated with root-knot galling (Fig. 1b) were recovered from bare-
nematode infestation were observed on the strawberry root green-top strawberry transplants from the nursery.
plants growing in the field in 2010/2011 growing The dominant plant-parasitic nematodes recovered
from the soil samples were root-knot nematodes
(Meloidogyne spp.) and stubby-root nematodes (
Paratrichodorus spp.) (Fig. 2). The highest mean
number of root-knot nematode juveniles (232 J2/100 cc
soil) was recorded in block C, followed by 21 juveniles
in block B and only one J2 in block A. Paratrichodorus
spp. numbers ranged from 2 to 5 nematodes per 100 cc
soil across the blocks.
Morphological characterization: Morphological
examination of females extracted from strawberry roots
revealed a round perineal pattern with fine, undulating
longitudinal lines resembling wrinkles. An invaginated
line around the vulva as described by Yik and Birchfield
(1978) was also observed (Fig. 3). These are typical
Fig. 1a: Strawberry plants A & B showing nematode characteristics of Meloidogyne hapla that distinguish it
symptoms (stunted, excessive fibrous root growth and from the other root-knot nematode species.
reduced crowns) as compared to healthy plants C & D DNA extraction and PCR amplification: DNA
that were collected from Citra, Marion County, Florida was extracted from a single female in the 2010/2011
in April 2011. strawberry growing season and two females (each
extracted separately) in the 2011/2012 strawberry
transplants shipment. The PCR amplified the mtDNA
region, yielding a single PCR product with the length of
ca 540 bp for all three samples tested (Fig. 4). Digestion
of the PCR product using DraI restriction enzyme
Fig. 2. Abundance (per 100cc soil) of Meloidogyne and Fig. 3. Female perineal pattern of Meloidogyne hapla
Paratrichodorus spp. from soil samples collected in isolated from field strawberries collected from Citra,
blocks A, B, and C, planted to strawberries. Marion County, Florida in April 2011.
Identification of Melodoigyne hapla on Florida strawberries: Nyoike et al. 257
DISCUSSION
Fig. 4. Amplification products using COII and 1RNA During the 2010/2011growing season, several
primers of the mtDNA from three Meloidogyne spp. strawberry plants were observed to be stunted and
females extracted from 2010/2011 and 2011/2012
strawberry plants on 1.8% agarose gel. All samples with low yield despite similar management practices
formed a band at 540 bp. The females are: 1, 2010/2011 across the blocks. The unevenly distributed nematode
from strawberry plants after the growing season; 2 and infestation across the blocks suggests the possibility
3, 2011/2012 from strawberry transplants upon arrival that nematode-infected transplants were only in a few of
from a nursery in Ontario, Canada, and MK on the first the boxes received from nurseries. The block with the
and last loading lines is 1 kb DNA ladder (Invitrogen, highest number of juveniles in the soil had significantly
Carlsbad, CA). lower yield than the block with the lowest number of
nematodes (Nyoike, unpublished data).
PCR-RFLP analysis identified the nematode as
M. hapla. PCR amplification resulted with a band
formation at 540 bp and two bands after endonuclease
digestion at 200 and 250 bp. Orui (1998) reported
similar results using Dra1 for discrimination among10
different species of Meloidogyne. When suspecting
more than one Meloidogyne species to be present or
due to intraspecific variations within one species, other
endonucleases should be used to confirm the results
of the species identity (Orui, 1998). Our results were
further confirmed with DNA sequencing that yielded up
to 98% identity when our samples were compared with
known gene sequences in the Genbank.
Both samples collected at the end of 2010/2011
growing season and at the beginning of 2011/2012
(soon after importing the transplants) tested positive
for M. hapla. This study confirms that M. hapla was
imported with the transplants from Ontario, Canada.
There have been previous reports of M. hapla imported
into Florida from the northern areas but no confirmation
studies of the species had been performed (Howard et
al., 1985; Noling and Whiden, 2010). At the end of the
2010 strawberry growing season, nematode symptoms
associated with root-knot nematode (M. hapla)
Fig. 5. Restriction fragment patterns of the PCR- infestation were reported on strawberries but no species
amplified products of the region between COII and confirmation was done (Noling and Whiden, 2010).
1RNA of the mtDNA after digestion with endonuclease Strawberry plants were observed to be stunted, low
Dra1 on 1.8% agarose gel. The samples formed two yielding, with shortened growth life and galled roots.
bands at 200 and 250 bp. The samples are: 1, 2010/2011 Similarly, in North Carolina, M. hapla has also been
from strawberry plants after the growing season; 2 and 3, introduced to the state through transplants (Averre et
2011/2012 from strawberry transplants from a nursery in al., 2011). The current study confirms the presence of
Ontario, Canada, and MK on the first and the last loading
lines is 1 kb DNA ladder (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). M. hapla on transplants in Florida by both molecular
and morphological methods. Morphological and
molecular studies have also been used to characterize
a population of M. hapla found damaging on coffee in
Hawaii (Handoo et al. 2005). Their study demonstrates
258 NEMATROPICA Vol. 42, No. 2, 2012
that various morphological characters of second- for their assistance in planting and maintaining the
stage juveniles, males, and females can be combined strawberry plants.
with molecular studies to compare different M. hapla LITERATURE CITED
populations.
The occurrence of M. hapla on transplants is an Adam, M. A. M., M. S. Phillips, and V. C. Blok. 2007.
indication that stricter import sanitation rules should be Molecular diagnostic key for identification of
put in place, but it is worth mentioning that M. hapla juveniles of seven and economically important
is not considered a “quarantine pest” (Noling and species of root-knot nematode (Meloidogyne spp).
Whiden, 2010). In Florida, growers are expected to buy Plant Pathology 56:190-197.
strawberry transplants only from certified nurseries. Averre, C. W., W. O. Cline, R. K. Jones, and R. D.
The strawberry transplants used in this study were Milholland. 2011. Diagnosis of strawberry diseases.
obtained from a certified nursery in Canada. North Carolina Cooperative Extension Service,
Meloidogyne hapla is more prevalent in colder North Carolina State University,Raleigh, NC http://
latitudes and in high elevations of the tropics (Powers www.ces.ncsu.edu/depts/hort/consumer/agpubs/
and Harris, 1993). This makes the survival of M. hapla ag-386.pdf. Accessed December 2011.
through hot summer months in Florida on cultivated Esbenshade, P. R., and A. C. Triantaphyllou, 1990.
and non-cultivated host crops questionable. However, Isozyme phenotypes for the identification of
during this past summer (2011), M. hapla was able to Meloidogyne species. Journal of Nematology
survive in the field on peanut for a period of 4 months 22:10-15.
(D. W. Dickson, personal comm.). At this point we can Fourie, H., C. Zijlstra, and A. H. McDonald. 2001.
speculate that if the nematode establishes in Florida, it Identification of root-knot nematode species
may infect the same hosts as other M. hapla populations. occurring in South Africa using the SCAR-PCR
Moreover, M. hapla is also known to have a wide host- technique. Nematology 37:675-680.
range affecting more than 550 crop and weed species Handoo, Z, A., A. M. Skantar, L. K. Carta, and D. P.
(Jepson, 1987). Currently, Meloidogyne spp. are not the Schmitt. 2005. Morphological and molecular
most damaging nematodes on strawberries in Florida, evaluation of a Meloidogyne hapla population
but this could potentially change if more nematode- damaging coffee (Coffee arabica) in Maui, Hawaii.
infected transplants are imported into the state. It is Journal of Nematology 37:136-145.
therefore important to put stricter regulations on clean Harris, T. S., L. J. Sandall, and T. O. Powers. 1990.
strawberry transplants from the nurseries to ensure Identification of single Meloidogyne juveniles
that growers are safe from such sources of nematode by polymerase chain reaction amplification of
inoculum. mitochondrial DNA. Journal of Nematology
Introduction of endoparasitic nematodes such as 22:518-524.
root-knot nematode with the planting materials can Hartman, K. M., and J. N. Sasser. 1985. Identification of
be quite problematic because soil fumigation is only Meloidogyne species on the basis of differential host
carried out prior to planting. Furthermore, endoparasitic test and perineal pattern-morphology. Pp. 69-77 in
nematodes are hard to target with any contact nematicide. Barker K. R., C. C. Carter, and J. N. Sasser, eds.
Strawberry season in Florida runs from October to An advanced treatise on Meloidogyne. Volume II:
April, and after final harvest growers wait about 4-5 Methodology, eds. NC State University Graphics,
months before planting the next crop. Currently, quite Raleigh, NC.
a number of growers in the state are exploring the use Howard, C. M., A. J. Overman, J. F. Price, and E. A.
of 2-yr-old plastic mulch. In this approach, strawberry Albregts. 1985. Diseases, nematodes, mites, and
planting beds are irrigated intermittently throughout insects affecting strawberries in Florida. Bulletin
summer. In such a case, survival of nematodes under 857. Agricultural Experiment Stations, Institute of
these conditions in the soil is unknown. Until further Food and Agricultural Sciences (IFAS), University
studies are conducted on the survivability over two or of Florida, Gainesville, FL.
more years, it remains unclear whether this nematode Hu, M. X., K. Zhuo, and J. L. Liao. 2011. Multiplex
can survive under Florida conditions. Alternatively, PCR for the simultaneous identification and
growers may plant a cover crop and use a susceptible detection of Meloidogyne incognita, M. enterolobii,
host such as a leguminous crop, which could only lead and M. javanica using DNA extracted directly from
to an increase in pest numbers if the nematode is able to individual galls. Phytopathology 101:1270-1277.
survive during the summer season. Jenkins, W. R. 1964. A rapid centrifugal-floatation
technique for separating nematodes from soil. Plant
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Disease Reporter 48:692.
Jepson, S. B. 1987. Identification of root-knot nematodes
We thank the staff at the University of Florida Plant (Meloidogyne species). CAB International,
Science Research and Education Unit at Citra, and the Wallingford, UK.
graduate students and staff at the University of Florida Joyce, S.A., A. P. Reid, F. Driver, and J. Curran. 1994.
Small Fruit and Vegetable IPM Laboratory in Gainesville Application of polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
Identification of Melodoigyne hapla on Florida strawberries: Nyoike et al. 259
methods to the identification of entomopathogenic Pp. 263-272 in S. M. Olson and B. Santos, eds.
nematodes. Pp.178-187 in A.M. Burnell, R.U. Vegetable production handbook for Florida 2010-
Ehlers, and J.P. Masson, eds. Genetics of 2011. UF IFAS Extension, University of Florida,
entomopathogenic nematode-bacterium complexes. Gainesville, FL.
Proceedings of symposium and workshop, St. Powers, T. O., and T. S. Harris. 1993. A polymerase
Patrick’s College, Maynooth, Co, Kildare, Ireland. chain reaction method for identification of five
Luxembourg, DGXII, European commission . major Meloidogyne species. Journal of Nematology
LaMondia, J. A. 2002. Seasonal populations of 25:1-6.
Pratylenchus penetrans and Meloidogyne hapla in Powers, T. O., P. G. Mullin, T. S. Harris, L. A. Sutton,
strawberry roots. Journal of Nematology 34:409- and R. S. Higgins. 2005. Incorporating molecular
413. identification of Meloidogyne spp. into a large-scale
Noling, J. W. 1999. Nematode management in regional nematode survey. Journal of Nematology
strawberries. ENY-031. IFAS extension, University 37:226-235.
of Florida, Gainesville, FL http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/ Qui, J. J., B. B. Westerdahl, C. Anderson, and V. M.
pdffiles/NG/NG03100.pdf Accessed on December Williamson. 2006. Sensitive PCR detection of
14 2011. Melodoigyne arenaria, M. incognita, and M.
Noling, J.W., and A. Whidden. 2010. International issues javanica extracted from soil. Journal of Nematology
and growing concerns for new nematode problems 38:434-441.
in the Florida strawberry industry. Berry/Vegetable Taylor, A. L., and J. N. Sasser. 1978. Biology,
Times, June 2010, UF IFAS Extension, University identification and control of root-knot nematodes
of Florida, Gainesville, FL. http://strawberry.ifas. (Meloidogyne species). North Carolina State
ufl.edu/BerryTimes/BVT0610.pdf. University Graphics, Raleigh, NC.
Orui, Y. 1998. Identification of Japanese species of Westerdahl, B. B. 2009. Nematodes. UC IPM Pest
genus Meloidogyne (Nematoda: Meloidogynidae) management guidelines: Strawberry. University
by PCR-RFLP analysis. Applied Entomology and of California, Davis, CA. http://www.ipm.ucdavis.
Zoology 33:43-51. edu/PMG/r734200111.html Accessed January
Peres, N. A., J. F. Price, W. M. Stall, C. K. Chandler, 2012.
B. M. Santos, S. M. Olson, S. A. Smith, and E. H.
Simonne. 2010. Strawberry production in Florida.