Review of Literature
Review of Literature
Review of Literature
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
90
of the self once they have been established. Self-esteem is the
structural entity of personality, which organizes behaviour and
integrates experiences and perception on the basis of beliefs regarding
one's own self. It describes the values beliefs and attitudes we have
towards ourselves. It reflects the overall opinion we have about
ourselves. Our opinion may be positive (e.g., I am a worthwhile
person") or it may be negative (e.g., I am an incapable person). Healthy
self esteem is about ourselves for who we are.
91
between self-esteem and perceived social acceptance, this may not
always reflect reality. Indeed, individuals may only see w h a t they
already believe is true, based on their self-esteem (Kenny and
DePaulo 1993). On the one h a n d , individuals with low self-esteem
may be more likely to engage in certain behaviors t h a t directly
deteriorate actual social acceptance, such a s r e a s s u r a n c e seeking
(Joiner, Katz and Lrew, 1999) or aggressive behavior (Donnellan,
Trzesniewski, Robins, Moflitt and Caspi, 2 0 0 5 ) . On the other h a n d ,
low self-esteem may colour adolescents' perceptions of others'
reactions (e.g., more anticipated rejection; A n t h o n y , Wood and
H o l m e s , 2 0 0 7 ; Murray, Rose, Bellavia, H o l m e s and Kusche, 2 0 0 2 ) ,
resulting in lowered perceived social acceptance.
92
Theo (1994) suggested t h a t self-esteem can be enhanced
though c l a s s r o o m / g r o u p self-esteem building exercises.
93
low-income samples. Results conclude that children's self-esteem is
positively related to the loving and demanding dimensions of maternal
behavior and negatively related to the punishment dimension. That is,
greater the empathy and acceptance given by mothers to their
children the higher the self-esteem of the children. The results also
reveal the dimensions of granting autonomy as a correlate of self-
esteem in children and the detrimental effects of harsh discipline and
corporal punishment.
94
It was observed children with learning disabilities have higher
levels of aggression and lower self-esteem (Montaya, 2000; Sadovnik,
2000).
95
effect of psycho-social intervention in significantly reducing behavioral
problems, a d j u s t m e n t problems, a n d led to Improvement in self-
esteem, academic achievement a n d interfamily relationship.
96
various indices of maladjustment such as depression, eating
disorders, engagement in risk behaviors, and lower academic
performance (Baumeister, Campbell, Krueger and V o h s (2003);
Harter 2 0 0 6 )
97
later feelings of loneliness in adolescence. The direction of effects
between loneliness and self-esteem was investigated in two
independent longitudinal studies. Results indicated that self-esteem
and loneliness influenced one another in a reciprocal manner.
Furthermore, the dominant path from self-esteem to loneliness was
partially mediated by perceived—but not actual—social acceptance.
98
Harter (1993) has found that lower perceptions of physical
attractiveness among girls contribute to their lower global self-esteem.
Others have argued and shown that already in early adolescence,
gender inequality in society, demanding role expectations, and early
puberty development leave their mark on global self-esteem of girls in
particular.
99
Vasuki a n d Reddy (1997) explored the self-esteem of single
children using a n expo-facto design, on a sample of 4 0 (20 boys a n d
20 girls) in the age group of 9-15 years. The results reveal that most of
the children h a d high self-esteem. No gender difference in the self-
esteem of 12-15 years old w a s found. However, overall boys showed
higher self-esteem. Results also indicate significant differences in the
self esteem of boys of the two age groups, whereas the same w a s not
observed in the case of girls.
100
3.2 Anger in Children
101
Walsh (1995) states t h a t adolescents who have been exposed to
community violence develop varying level of distress and varying levels
of expression of anger t h a t are differentially mediated by whether they
were a victim on previous history of child a b u s e , gender and ethnicity.
A previous history of sexual a b u s e was significantly related to higher
distress scores a n d expression of internalized anger.
102
They tended to believe t h a t their anger was justified a n d t h a t
they m u s t fight for their own rights, acceptance, a n d a u t o n o m y . Many
children complained when they felt intimidated by the little power they
had or when they perceived a need to protect themselves.
Bhave and Saini (2009) state that children who do not do well
academically or in extracurricular activities often feel depressed
frustrated and angry and these result in aggressive behaviors.
103
Many skills, techniques a n d interventions can be applied for
anger m a n a g e m e n t . In the p r e s e n t study Life Skills are used a s a
mode of intervention for anger m a n a g e m e n t .
Keeping Cool
104
individual sessions. All subjects completed self-report measures each
week (the Anger Control and Anger Expression subscales of the STAXI
and the Self Control Rating Scale) and the staff completed a daily
report on aggressive episodes and specific instances of rule violations.
Results indicated that patterns of improvement on the self-report
measures were noted for four treatment subjects while three remained
unchanged and one showed a pattern of deterioration.
105
things, etc. (Lohr, Hamburger and Bonge, 1988). Seemingly straight
forward issue of whether or not there might be gender differences in
anger expression, different studies have shown t h a t older girls express
anger more openly t h a n boys (Underwood, Coic, and Herbsman,
1992) and u s e more conciliatory strategies when angry (Murphy and
Eisenberg, 1996), t h a t girls are more h u r t by provocation, by n a m e -
calling and taunting. Females in general found to be associated with
the subtle forms of indirect aggression anger t u r n e d inward associated
more with female gender (Murphy and Eisenberg, 1 9 9 6 ; Anderson,
1 9 9 5 ; Kobayashi, S a k a m o t o , Hinokuchi and S a k a m o t o , 1999).
106
Hubbard (1995) examined the n a t u r e of children's emotional
expression during peer interaction, with a focus on socio-metric s t a t u s
differences, level of aggressiveness differences, and gender differences.
Results state t h a t rejected children expressed both h a p p i n e s s a n d
anger to a greater extent t h a n average children, across facial, verbal
intonation, a n d non-verbal modalities. However, boys expressed more
anger t h a n girls across all three modalities.
107
Tapper and Boulton, 1 9 9 9 state t h a t Peer, self a n d teacher
report studies of aggression have suggested t h a t girls employ more
indirect or relational forms of aggression whilst boys tend to rely on
over or direct forms of aggression. Research h a s also suggested t h a t
indirect aggression may increase with age, peeking at approximately
11-12 years in girls.
108
activities while girls usually spent their time being alone or talking to
someone close (Taylor and Novaco, 2005).
Research studies show that girls may feel angrier than boys. This
may be because girls are more aware of their emotions or that they
face more angry situations than boys do (Saini, 2006a).
109
Anxiety h a s both a physiological a n d a psychological a s p e c t a n d
it is the psychological aspect t h a t affects the way we interpret
sensations (Clarke^ Davidson, Windsor a n d P i t t s , 2 0 0 0 ) . One c a n
become anxious in situations merely b e c a u s e one perceives a t h r e a t
even when there is none.
110
and teachers as having lower levels of appropriate social skills and
higher levels of shyness. Parent ratings of social skills and
assertiveness have also been found to be lower specifically for children
with social phobia (Spence, Donovan and Brechman-Toussaint,
1999).
Ill
There is fairly consistent evidence that regular activity can have
a positive effect upon the psychological well being of children and
young people. Reviewing literature in this area Mutrie and Parfitt
(1988) concluded that Life skill is associated with good mental health
other associations with regular activity that have been reported
include reduced stress, anxiety and depressions, all of which lend
support to Sallies and Omens' (1999) claim that life skill improves
psychological health in young people.
112
Researchers in the field of clinical psychology have examined the
impact of anxiety on academic, emotional, and interpersonal
functioning. Anxious children typically have poor academic
performance and difficulty attending school. They often avoid
participating in extra-curricular activities and social events (e.g.,
sleepovers, birthday parties), are less well-liked by their peers, and
tend to have poor social skills (Albano, Chorpita and Barlow, 2003).
In terms of prevalence rates, anxiety is common; as many as one in
five youth meet the criteria for an anxiety disorder Costello, Egger
and Angold (2004).
113
subjects with low anxiety (repressors a n d low anxious) reported higher
perceived ability to control u n p l e a s a n t t h o u g h t s a n d less tendency to
s u p p r e s s t h a n did subjects with high anxiety (high a n x i o u s and
defensive high anxious).
114
expectations London, Downey, Bonica and Paltin (2007) considered
social anxiety a s a consequence of anxious a n d angry expectations of
rejection (i.e., extent to which y o u t h feel nervous a n d / o r m a d in
response to situations involving potential rejection by peers).
115
frequently reported type of psychopathology across all 3 age groups.
Although the prevalence of any anxiety symptom remained c o n s t a n t ,
specific types of anxiety varied with age. Age differences in n o n anxiety
behavior were found between Ss with a n d without anxiety, particularly
with regard to interpersonal dysfunction. Kashani, Javad, Orvaschel
and Helen (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA).
116
gender differences in the relationship between social anxiety and peer
victimization. Relational victimization is a robust predictor of anxiety
for both boys and girls (La Greca and Harrison 2005; Storch, Nock,
Masia-Warner and Barlas 2003). These researchers point out that in
contrast to La Greca and Lopez (1998) who found that social anxiety
was more closely tied to fewer friends and lower quality friendships for
girls, their findings suggest that social anxiety may disrupt peer
relationships in a different way for boys. More specifically, boys who
exhibit passive and withdrawn behavior associated with social anxiety
may be particularly vulnerable to bullying and victimization by other
boys, as they are not conforming to socialization pressures to be
assertive and involved in the larger peer group.
The following section deals with review on life skills and the
effective use of life skills intervention programmes.
Life skills are used during every moment of our lives in various
situations like choosing friends/career, making and breaking
relationships, understanding one's needs, and interacting with
teachers and parents. Life skills, therefore, are the building blocks of
one's behavior and need to be learnt well to lead a healthy, meaningful
and productive life (Bharath and Kumar, 2002).
117
Children who live in poverty tend to perform worse in school
t h a n do children from more privileged background (Gray and Klaus,
1965). Therefore, s t u d e n t s from economically disadvantaged
b a c k g r o u n d s need to be given special facilitation s u c h a s intervention
p r o g r a m m e s to e n h a n c e their c h a n c e of success otherwise, m a n y of
them will fail needlessly (Steininger, Brown and Stanley, 1971).
With no intervention, the intellectual prognosis for children from
severely disadvantaged background is bleak (Ramey, 1979).
118
In one of the studies, Mains and his colleagues (Hains, 1992;
Hains and Ellmann, 1994; Hains and Szyjakowski, 1990) designed
a school based prevention program to reduce "negative emotional
arousal" and other psychological problems associated with stress.
They evaluated the programme in a series of studies with high school
students. In the most recent evaluation (Hains and Ellmann, 1994)
the sample consisted of youth, exhibiting a combination of anxiety,
depression and anger. After participating in a 13 session programme
that emphasized cognitive restructuring, problem solving and
anxiety management, students who were at the higher levels of
stress before the intervention reported the most significant changes in
anxiety and depressive symptomatology. These changes were
considered clinically significant.
119
Mayrovitz, and Larsen (1996) in a study reported that
significant psychological, behavioral a n d physiological improvements
can be achieved in middle school children through learning a n d
practicing effective emotional self-management techniques. And a s a
result the children showed increased satisfaction a n d control over
their lives while with friends, at school a n d a r o u n d their families.
120
program a s compared to the control group. Therefore, a n enriching
environment plays an important role in the p a t h w a y s to positive
adaptation.
121
programme's effectiveness. Results indicated t h a t clients acquired
both intra-psychic a s well a s inter psychic skills. Intra-psychic skills
noted were self acceptance, self a w a r e n e s s a n d self regulation of
emotions, improved motivation, optimism a n d perseverance. Inter-
psychic skills acquired by clients included empathy, more effective
expression of emotions as well a s more effective interpersonal
behaviour .
122
experimental group and a n o t h e r 30 s t u d e n t s to the control group.
The age group was 13 to 14 years. The intervention w a s carried o u t
for the period of five consecutive days. Session was being held within
one week, lasting for 50 m i n u t e s each. The post testing w a s carried
out after a s p a n of four weeks. The intervention p r o g r a m m e w a s on
the lines of the stress inoculation training developed by
Meichenbaum (1977) and consisted of three phases:
conceptualization; skill acquisition a n d rehearsal; application and
follow-through. Results revealed t h a t stress m a n a g e m e n t intervention
programme was successful in reducing the degree of stress of the
s t a n d a r d IX s t u d e n t s . The results also showed some improvement in
coping skills as well as in the performance of s t u d e n t s in the
examination, t h u s validating the hypothesis to forth. • An analysis of
the gender factor showed that female students had shown a
significantly higher reduction in stress, increase in effective coping
skills a n d improvement in performance, a s compared to their male
counterparts.
123
and P o n z o h a , 1 9 8 8 ) . Burns, Andrews and Szabo (2002) reported
that intervention t h a t teach cognitive skills are associated with a short
term reduction in depressive s y m p t o m s .
124
Frydenberg (2004) provided intervention to adolescents with
the Best of Coping: Developing coping skills program. Results
revealed t h a t compared to the control group the intervention group
receiving training showed significant decrease in non productive
coping or maladaptive coping.
125
The effect of intervention on development is well d o c u m e n t e d ,
the need in the area of developmental disabilities is the development
of services of "intervention" which are not only compensatory b u t are
preventive a n d remedial. These p r o g r a m s provide individualized core
training t h a t helps the child to achieve h i s / h e r full potential. The
enhanced competence gained t h r o u g h the intervention leads to the
development of positive self-image, independent decision-making,
healthy problem-solving, assertive communication, a n d constructive
coping (Persha, 2 0 0 7 ) .
126
Scott and Jennifer (2009) studied a different type of success:
teaching important life skills through project based learning. The
research in this study showed that the selected U.S School was
excellent at teaching important life skills that help students succeed
in college and in life in general.
127
programmes will produce positive outcomes that further result in an
improvement in the holistic development and well being of the
disadvantaged. Various studies have been conducted to analyze the
effectiveness of life skills based intervention programmes listed in the
table below.
Table: 3.1
128
Empirical literature revealed multiple impacts of life skills
training Programmes. LST Programmes h a d been found to delay the
age of o n s e t of the a b u s e of tobacco, alcohol and m a r i j u a n a ( H a n s e n ,
J o h n s o n , Flay, Graham a n d Sobel,1988), prevented high risk sexual
behaviour (Kirby,1994; S c h i n k e , Blythe and Gilchrest,1981) t a u g h t
anger control (Deffenbacher, Getting, Huff and Thwarter , 1 9 9 5 ;
Deffenbacher, Lynch, Getting and Kemper, 1 9 9 6 ; Feindlerm
Ek:ton, Kingsley and Dubey, 1986), prevented delinquency and
criminal behaviour (Englander-Golden, J a c k s o n , Crane, Schwarkopf
and Lyle, 1989), improved health related behaviour and self esteem
(Young, Keley and Denny, 1997), promoted positive social
adjustment ( Elias, Gara, Schuyler, Branden-Muller and
S a y e t t e , 1 9 9 1 ) a n d prevented peer rejection ( Mize and Ladd,1991).
Improvement in psychosocial competence is by far the most heavily
cited goal of LST, however very few studies had focused on these
outcomes.
129
intellectual, emotional and psychological growth. This can cause
emotional and behavioural instability in the developing personality. In
this state of constant flux, the child may well feel helpless, vulnerable
and unable to deal with life's demands. In a rapidly changing
background of an uncaring, ever demanding world, he could land
himself in what is now called a 'future shock' and 'Chronic anxiety'. It
becomes imperative to dispense psychological interventions, not only
for children and adolescents with psychiatric disorders, but also for
positive (preventive) mental health during their developmental stages.
130