Dave Bevan Conference Paper 2011
Dave Bevan Conference Paper 2011
Dave Bevan Conference Paper 2011
July 2011
The Taskforce vision
‘To ensure that every school and college has an effective partnership with employers to provide its
young people with the inspiration, motivation, knowledge, skills and opportunities they need to help
them achieve their potential and so to secure our future national prosperity.’
To subscribe to our research mailouts which list forthcoming events and new
publications related to research into employer engagement in education please
send an email to james.dawkins@educationandemployers.org with ‘TFRM
Registration’ in the subject line and your contact details.
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
2
Key Points
This report contains information gathered from desk-based research that was undertaken in spring
2011 which investigated the relevance of work experience with regards to the admissions policies of
undergraduate courses at Russell Group universities. It investigates whether this cohort of Higher
Education Institutions (HEIs) expect their undergraduate applicants to have undertaken work
experience, and the extent to which work experience strengthens their application. A total of six
courses – Business/Economics/Management, Dentistry, Engineering, Law, Medicine and Veterinary
Medicine – were selected on the basis that they provide high wage returns typically within the
professions. Research involved a review of web-based materials setting out HEI admissions criteria
for each subject. Materials were reviewed to assess whether work experience (or more broadly
experience of the world of work) was cited as an essential or desirable admissions requirement, or
not mentioned.
Key findings are given in Part A of this study and are summarised below:
Dentistry
Essential 55
Desirable 36
Engineering
Essential 6
Desirable 22
Law
Essential 0
Desirable 37
Medicine
Essential 22
Desirable 66
Veterinary Medicine/Science
Essential 83
Desirable 17
Part B of this study collates relevant web-based admissions statements considered within the
review, which have been extracted from the websites of Russell Group universities and are listed in
alphabetical order. Illustrative quotations from websites are given below:
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
3
Business/Economics/Management:
Dentistry:
“The personal Statement is read to ensure that the applicant has knowledge of and insight in to the
profession with emphasis on work experience/observation. Candidates are expected to show a
range of skills and it is desirable on all dental programmes that candidates have completed a period
of work experience/shadowing in a local dental or hospital and preferably in more than one
establishment.” (University of Liverpool)
Engineering:
“It can also be helpful to obtain some work experience with a technical content. Such experiences
should increase an applicant’s appreciation of why Engineering, Mathematics and Physics are so
important in the modern world.” (University of Cambridge)
“Whilst we recognise that it is not possible for everyone to get on a Headstart course or get some
engineering-related work experience, if you have managed to do this say so - and don’t forget to
include what personal and engineering lessons you have learned from it.” (University of Oxford)
Law:
“Normally, you should have some direct experience of legal practice or the criminal justice system
and should be able to illustrate what you learnt from the experience. It would be advantageous if
you provided details of the type of work experience or “shadowing” and its duration.” (University of
Leeds)
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
4
Medicine:
“It is equally important to be able to demonstrate that you are well-motivated towards a career in
medicine especially through volunteering and/or work experience.” (University of Birmingham)
“The University recognises that opportunities for certain types of work experience and participation
in some non-academic activities will vary according to individual circumstances, including an
applicant's cultural or socio-economic background or the activities available in their local area.”
(University of Cardiff)
“Medical Schools expect applicants to have a range of work experience for two reasons. Firstly, this
demonstrates that you have a realistic insight to the profession – you are after all committing to a
lifetime career when you apply to study Medicine. It is important that you have an understanding of
the complex nature of a doctor's role, as well as being aware of the highs and lows of the profession.
Work experience is also important in enabling you to develop (and to demonstrate that you have)
the relevant skills and qualities that are essential to becoming a good doctor.” (University of
Sheffield)
Veterinary Medicine/Science:
“Experience of working with animals is a key part of our entry requirements.” (University of
Edinburgh)
The results of this study raise further questions, which will be subject of ongoing work by the
Taskforce, regarding the extent to which:
Work experience influences admissions to the full range of undergraduate courses of study
offered by the Russell Group universities.
The admissions behaviour exhibited by Russell Group universities is shared by other higher
education institutions.
The inclusion of work experience within admissions criteria serves to increase or reduce the
prospects of successful admissions to courses of study for definable social groups of young
people, notably:
o By type of educational institution attended (maintained comprehensive or grammar
school, Further Education College, fee-paying independent school).
o By gender, socio-economic status and ethnicity.
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
5
Part A
Is experience of the world of work considered within the undergraduate admissions requirements of
Russell Group universities?
The information below summarises desk research undertaken in the Spring of 2011, collating
information contained in online admissions pages for prospective undergraduates of the twenty
Russell Group universities. Included in the web search were general admissions pages, course
descriptions/online prospectuses, individual school and department mini-sites and admissions policy
statements. Excluded were information for mature/postgraduate students and joint honours course
descriptions. The following subjects were selected for the web search on the basis that they attract
high wage premiums within the labour market: Business/Economics/Management, Dentistry,
Engineering, Law, Medicine and Veterinary Medicine/Science. The latter three – Business/
Economics/Management – were combined in the table below and include cases where these
subjects are offered as single honours and as combinations/joint honours e.g. ‘Economics and
Management’. Information for admissions to these undergraduate courses was examined for
evidence of the desirability of work experience and other related experiences providing knowledge
of/insight into/commitment to the professions related to the subject of study. Extracts from relevant
admissions pages are given in Part B below.
Business/Economics/Management
Number % of HEIs offering subject
Essential 0 0
Desirable 4 21
Not mentioned 15 79
Not offered at UG level 1
Dentistry
Essential 6 55
Desirable 4 36
Not mentioned 1 9
Not offered at UG level 9
Engineering
Essential 1 6
Desirable 4 22
Not mentioned 13 72
Not offered at UG level 2
Law
Essential 0 0
Desirable 7 37
Not mentioned 12 63
Not offered at UG level 1
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
6
Medicine
Essential 4 22
Desirable 12 66
Not mentioned 2 11
Not offered at UG level 2
Veterinary Medicine/Science
Essential 5 83
Desirable 1 17
Not mentioned 0 0
Not offered at UG level 14
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
7
Name of HEI Essential Desirable No mention General admissions advice
requirement requirement made
(named (named
courses) courses)
Engineering
Economics
Law
Law
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
8
Name of HEI Essential Desirable No mention General admissions advice
requirement requirement made
(named (named
courses) courses)
Economics
Engineering
Dentistry
Law
Medicine
Dentistry
Engineering
Law
Engineering
Law
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
9
Name of HEI Essential Desirable No mention General admissions advice
requirement requirement made
(named (named
courses) courses)
Engineering
Law
Economics
Engineering
Law
Engineering
Law
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
10
Sheffield Dentistry Business WXP is used in assessment
Management which shows “commitment to a
Medicine chosen career”
Law
Engineering
Economics
Engineering
Management
Law
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
11
Part B
Quotes from the admissions pages of Russell Group universities. This includes information from
general admissions and subject-specific pages and includes links to the page quoted. The review was
undertaken in the spring of 2011.
University of Birmingham
General Admissions: “We need to see evidence that your interest is genuine: If your degree is
related to a particular line of work, that you have work experience in a relevant setting or can
otherwise demonstrate that you understand what that profession involves.”
Recommended for inclusion in Personal Statement: “That you have an idea of what you want to do
after you have graduated (this is less important for degrees which are not vocational in nature, but
can be useful for Admissions Tutors).”
http://www.birmingham.ac.uk/students/courses/undergraduate/apply/thepersonalstatement.aspx
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
http://www.birmingham.ac.uk/students/courses/undergraduate/med/dental-surgery.aspx
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine: “In deciding who to invite for interview, academic excellence is not the only criterion. It is
equally important to be able to demonstrate that you are well-motivated towards a career in
medicine especially through volunteering and/or work experience. In addition, we want to ensure
that you possess other qualities required of a potential doctor. Therefore, extracurricular
involvement is important. Activities involving significant interaction with a broad range of people
that takes place outside of school (other than those directly related to the medicine application) is a
relevant aspect.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
12
University of Bristol
Reasons for not getting into Bristol – “...if an applicant did not have, for example, a crucial element
such as work experience for the professional courses, or if they did not meet the minimum entry
requirements...”
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/university/governance/policies/admissions/feedback-complaints.html
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
“A wide range of factors is taken into account, such as your post-school and out-of-school
experiences and breadth of interests.”
Economics/Management: “In reading the Personal Statement, Admissions Tutors look for evidence
of many of the following items: ... (for degrees involving Study on Continental Europe) skills and
interest in foreign language and culture; non-academic achievement or experience; positions of
responsibility; interest in hobbies or pastimes; voluntary work; work experience.”
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/efm/prospective-undergraduates/admissions/school-admissions-2011-
.pdf (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Engineering: Under ‘Personal Statement criteria’: “non-academic achievement and experience (for
example, work experience in industry), positions of responsibility, team working.”
Law: Under consideration at interview: “Appropriateness of the Bristol course in relation to the
candidate’s declared interests and aspirations”; “Non-academic achievement and/or experience, or
extra-curricular interests, that indicate the likely contribution a candidate will make to the life of the
University.”
http://www.bris.ac.uk/law/ugdegrees/ugadmissions/admissionsstatement.html (Accessed
21/06/2011)
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
13
Medicine: Criteria for assessing the Personal Statement
Veterinary Science: ‘Second screening’ ranks students according to various criteria, including “Work
experience in veterinary practice, on farms and in other setting”; “Non-academic achievements and
extra-curricular interests; positions of responsibility; voluntary or paid work.”
University of Cambridge
“You should expect: a challenging discussion relating to your chosen course, which may include
topics covered in your recent academic work and raised in your written application (i.e. wider
reading and work experience).”
http://www.cam.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/publications/docs/interviews.pdf(Accessed
21/06/2011)
Engineering: “It can also be helpful to obtain some work experience with a technical content. Such
experiences should increase an applicant's appreciation of why Engineering, Mathematics and
Physics are so important in the modern world.”
“For Engineering, evidence of motivation and commitment might be shown in a number of ways that
could include:
14
Relevant work experience placements”
Veterinary Medicine: “Although work experience isn’t a requirement for applicants, some is useful.”
“Many applicants worry unnecessarily that they have not had sufficient veterinary experience before
applying. It is helpful to have some personal experience of the veterinary profession and have a
realistic idea of what the work may entail. However, extensive experience is not a prerequisite and
seeing a variety of different aspects of the profession for relatively short periods can be more
helpful.”
http://www.vet.cam.ac.uk/application/welcome/apply/work_experience.html (Accessed
21/06/2011)
Cardiff University
Engineering: “School Selection Criteria: Applicants to the School of Engineering are normally
measured on their academic potential using predicted grades, along with their enthusiasm for the
subject which should be demonstrated in their personal statement, relevant work experience and
references.”
http://www.cardiff.ac.uk/for/prospective/ug/applyingtocardiff/admissionscriteria/engin/selection/i
ndex.html (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Law: Applications are welcome from those who have “relevant work/life experience.”
Medicine: “The University recognises that opportunities for certain types of work experience and
participation in some non-academic activities will vary according to individual circumstances,
including an applicant's cultural or socio-economic background or the activities available in their
local area.”
http://medicine.cf.ac.uk/media/filer_public/2010/09/22/admissions_policy_2011-12_.pdf (Accessed
21/06/2011)
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
15
University of Edinburgh
General Admissions: “If you are applying to a professional or vocational degree programme (such as
Medicine, Veterinary Medicine and Education), you must demonstrate through your personal
statement, a clear understanding of the profession. You can support this with evidence of
appropriate work experience, volunteering or work shadowing, although we do recognise that not
all students have equal access to such opportunities.”
http://www.ed.ac.uk/studying/undergraduate/applications-admissions/entry-requirements/non-
academic (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Understanding of medicine;
Work experience and shadowing (diseased, disadvantaged and disabled).”
“Prior experience:
Demonstration of a clear understanding of the nature of a career of medicine will be expected. This
can be achieved by:
...The Admissions Committee recognises that not all applicants have equal opportunities to gain such
experience. If it is not possible to get any work experience in a hospital then other alternatives
include working in a nursing home, riding for the disabled, or volunteer work.”
http://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/medicine-vet-
medicine/undergraduate/medicine/applying/requirements/non-academic (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Veterinary Medicine: “Experience of working with animals is a key part of our entry requirements.”
“When applying, all candidates should submit a Work Experience Summary (WES) form”
http://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/vet/studying/uk-eu-school-leavers/work-experience
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
“Students are normally required to bring with them an additional reference outlining recent work
experience undertaken.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
16
http://www.ed.ac.uk/studying/undergraduate/applications-admissions/selection/interviews
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
University of Glasgow
Dentistry: “The BDS Person Specification provides information on essential and preferred academic
qualifications, work-shadowing experience and also personal qualities we would expect successful
candidates to provide evidence of, from activities they have undertaken both within and outside of
school.”
Medicine: “Work experience in a medical setting is not necessary to study medicine but it is
expected that candidates will have at least spoken to a doctor such as their own GP about a career in
medicine or have found out about a medical career through reading careers books or newspapers.
An awareness of current issues facing the medical profession is also expected, which can be
obtained from newspapers, journals and the internet. An interest in caring for others is also
expected, which can be demonstrated through voluntary/paid work in a community setting. This
may also be useful in developing skills. Some hospitals will accept students looking for work
experience. For example, staff at Monklands Hospital in Lanarkshire have developed a formal work
experience scheme for 6th year pupils called the Next Generation programme.”
http://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/medicine/courses/medicineadmissions/entryrequirements/workexpe
rience/ (Accessed 21/06/2011)
“Although specific work experience in a hospital or general practice is not essential, it is important
for all applicants to find out about the realities of a career in medicine.”
http://www.gla.ac.uk/faculties/vet/undergraduatestudy/bachelorofveterinarymedicineandsurgeryb
vms/unitedkingdomapplicants/ (Accessed 21/06/2011)
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
17
Imperial College London
General Admissions: “All indications of candidates' interests outside their academic studies assist
selection by providing valuable background information.”
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/ugprospectus/howtoapply/selectionrequirements (Accessed
21/06/2011)
Mechanical Engineering: “You should indicate on your UCAS application why you wish to study
mechanical engineering and what you have done to find out about the subject.”
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/ugprospectus/facultiesanddepartments/mechanicalengineering/entryr
equirements (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine: One must show: “Motivation and realistic approach to medicine as a career”. Included in
application assessment criteria: “Leadership and teamwork, Community activities, Motivation and
understanding of medicine as a career.”
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/ugprospectus/facultiesanddepartments/medicine/mbbsmedicine/entry
requirements (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Business/Management: “We welcome applications from those with any experience of work within a
business setting.”
http://www.kcl.ac.uk/prospectus/undergraduate/entryrequirements/name/business_management/
alpha/b/header_search/ (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Law: “Although we do not require applicants to have been in paid or voluntary employment, we
welcome applications from those with any experience of legal work experience.”
http://www.kcl.ac.uk/prospectus/undergraduate/entryrequirements/name/law/alpha/l/header_sea
rch/ (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine (and dentistry): “We would normally expect that applicants will have undertaken some
voluntary work experience in a caring/health environment and/or observation in a medical clinical
setting. It is important for applicants to have a realistic appreciation of what a career as a health
professional involves.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
18
“Any voluntary contribution to your community is taken into account, e.g. volunteer in a care home.
We look for evidence that you have worked in a setting where you can interact with the general
public e.g. in a pharmacy, check-out or restaurant.”
http://www.kcl.ac.uk/prospectus/undergraduate/entryrequirements/name/medicine/alpha/m/hea
der_search/ / (Accessed 21/06/2011)
University of Leeds
General Admissions: In ‘Guide to Applying’: “If you have career plans then mention this, especially if
it is related to the course. This shows commitment to the subject and that you’ve thought things
through.”
Business: “A good personal statement should also demonstrate how relevant extracurricular
activities and work experience have enhanced your knowledge and skills in your chosen subject.”
http://business.leeds.ac.uk/fileadmin/webfiles/Undergraduate/2010_UG_Admissions_Policy_UKEU.
pdf (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Dentistry: “Applicants are encouraged to undertake work experience in a variety of dental settings
such as general dental practice and dental hospitals. To ensure an equitable process, the Admissions
Team do not co-ordinate work placements within the Institute. Work placements are in high
demand and dealt with via the NHS arm of the Institute. Those wishing to undertake a work
placement at the Institute may put their request in writing to the address below and should be
aware that placements are limited. Work Placements, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Trust
Headquarters, St. James University Hospital, Beckett Street, Leeds, LS9 7TF. Telephone: 0113 206
5104.”
Engineering: “We wish to hear about why you are interested in the field, any relevant work or other
experience, details of any particular skills, interests or attributes you have which you think
demonstrate your aptitude, motivation and interest in the subject area.”
Law: “Interest in and commitment to the subject: You should demonstrate that you have
questioned your reasons for choosing the degree you wish to apply for, and that you understand
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
19
what the degree entails. Normally, you should have some direct experience of legal practice or the
criminal justice system and should be able to illustrate what you learnt from the experience. It would
be advantageous if you provided details of the type of work experience or "shadowing" and its
duration. If attempts to gain work experience have been unsuccessful, you should refer to this
within the academic reference.”
http://www.law.leeds.ac.uk/prospective-students/undergraduates/admissions-information/advice-
ucas-personal-statement.php (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine: “Normally you should be able to report some direct experience of both hospital and
community medical practice and describe what you have learnt from your experience.
Although direct observation of medical consultations may not be possible due to issues of
confidentiality, most applicants should be able to observe reception or other aspects of health care.
Tip: Provide details of the type of work experience and its duration. If attempts to gain work
experience have been unsuccessful, there should be some reference to this contained within the
Referee’s statement. In addition to work experience, you should also have some factual knowledge
about potential careers and be realistic about the future.”
University of Liverpool
Dentistry: “The Personal Statement is read to ensure that the applicant has knowledge of and insight
into the profession with emphasis on work experience/observation. Applicants must demonstrate
motivation and commitment to a career in dentistry. Candidates are expected to show a range of
skills and it is desirable on all dental programmes that candidates have completed a period of work
experience/shadowing in a local dental practice or hospital and preferably in more than one
establishment. Evidence of a caring attitude is also sought.”
Law: “Evidence that the candidate has given serious thought to their choices and to their intended
course is sought.”
Medicine: “Applicants demonstrating the most academic potential are then assessed against our
non-academic criteria which include health care career awareness and insight, caring for the local
community and a critical, coherent, and informative approach to written communication.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
20
http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/applying/School_of_Medical_Ed.pdf (Accessed
21/06/2011
Personal Statement advice: “Be clear about your general work experience and how this might help
you pursue a career in medicine:
Remember that your work experience does not necessarily have to be medically related, such as
shadowing a GP or a consultant, but this might help you decide whether this career is really for
you. Some applicants find it very difficult to obtain this type of work experience, but will
have other caring experiences that are relevant. Clarify the steps you have taken to confirm this
is the career for you, or to confirm that other careers are not for you.”
Veterinary Science: “Candidates should have spent a minimum of 6 weeks gaining experience of the
husbandry of a range of animals, on commercial livestock farms, in commercial stables and in
commercial or rescue kennels / cattery. It is also beneficial to have gained experience in other
veterinary-related sectors e.g. abattoirs, laboratories, zoos or wildlife centres. Candidates should
also have completed at least 4 weeks in veterinary practice. As a minimum, experience should be
gained in at least two different practices, preferably one small animal and one large animal (mainly
farm / equine) practice.”
http://www.liv.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/veterinary-science-bvsc/entry-requirements/
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
General Admissions: “We are looking for... Any job, paid work or placements you have undertaken,
and what you have learnt from them. If these experiences influenced your choice of degree, why?”
http://www2.lse.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/howToApply/makingAnApplication/personalStatement
/whatMakesAGoodPersonalStatement.aspx (Accessed 21/06/2011)
“You should also include information on any paid or unpaid work experience or employment you
may have undertaken that can complement your application...”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
21
http://www2.lse.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/howToApply/makingAnApplication/personalStatement
/writingYourPersonalStatement.aspx (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Economics, Management and other subjects: “Your extra-curricular activities such as work
experience, participation in competitions, sport or volunteering are important, particularly when
they can provide evidence of useful skills such as problem solving, working under pressure and time-
management...and particularly how you have benefitted from these experiences.”
http://www2.lse.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/howToApply/departmentalAdmissionsCriteria/econom
ics.aspx#What_is_looked_for_in_the_Personal_Statement (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Law: “The selectors are keen to know why you wish to study Law, …and what additional reading or
relevant experiences (e.g. attending court hearings) you have had which have led you to commit to
this challenging degree programme. If you include details of extra curricular activities such as such as
music, drama, art, work experience, charitable or sporting involvement, the selectors are particularly
interested in knowing how you have benefited from the experiences.”
http://www2.lse.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/howToApply/departmentalAdmissionsCriteria/law.asp
x (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Management: “Whilst it is not a subject you will have had the opportunity to study specifically as
part of your school curriculum, we are interested in what stimulated your enthusiasm for and desire
to study for a degree in Management, as well as the experiences, such as wider reading or personal
involvement that have resulted in your commitment to this contemporary and interdisciplinary field
of study. Your extra-curricular activities, including work experience, are taken into consideration,
particularly if they help to demonstrate your motivation to study on this course. Please note that
work experience is not essential, as the composition of this degree programme is academic rather
that vocational in nature; however, the selectors are interested in your longer term career plans, if
known.”
http://www2.lse.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/howToApply/departmentalAdmissionsCriteria/manage
ment.aspx (Accessed 21/06/2011)
University of Manchester
General Admissions: Advice for Personal Statement: “Work experience: both related and unrelated
to your chosen course choice. Be specific about what you learned. Refer to transferable skills gained,
for example, communication, planning, time management and problem-solving. Skills mentioned
should be relevant to academic course and attending Higher Education.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
22
Dentistry: “Work experience: Applicants must have observed a dentist at work before applying. This
must be a general dental practitioner as this is the role which most students fulfil on graduation.
Applicants must undertake a minimum of two weeks work experience in a general dental practice.
The personal statement must be specific about the duration of any dental work experience
undertaken. If applicants wish to arrange additional work experience in a specialist area of dentistry,
this will be beneficial. It is not necessary to have fulfilled the role of a dental nurse.”
http://www.dentistry.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/bds/coursedetails/?code=00398&pg=4
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
Law: Pathways to Law programme participant: “The aim is to encourage and support young people
in applying to study Law at university and we will be supporting pupils through a variety of activities.
These activities will include, UCAS application advice sessions, careers days, parents information
sessions, mentoring from current University of Manchester Law students along with local legal
professionals and organised Legal work placements, all of which will increase a student’s chances of
being successful in their applications to study Law.”
http://www.law.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/pathwaystolaw/index.html (Accessed
21/06/2011)
Medicine: “The School requires voluntary work experience in a caring capacity. Applicants should be
aware that the School may request confirmation of their work experience.”
http://www.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/courses/search2011/atoz/course/?code=01428&pg=
3 (Accessed 21/06/2011)
University of Newcastle
Dentistry: “All applicants are required to have undertaken a minimum of two weeks' dental work
experience prior to submitting their UCAS application. This should be carried out in a General Dental
Practice, but other types of dental work experience may be considered.”
Medicine: “We will be looking for your experience of interacting with people in a caring
environment, which you may have acquired through employment or voluntary work in a variety of
settings.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
23
University of Nottingham
General Admissions: What we look for – “other factors as appropriate to the discipline, such as
employment or volunteer work in relevant fields showing commitment to a chosen career or area of
work...”
http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/ugstudy/introduction/applying/admissions-procedures.php
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine: Attributes sought during selection: “Insight into medical career (appropriate and realistic
view of the role of a doctor); Having seen doctors in their working environment; Awareness of the
positive and negative aspects of a medical career from talking to doctors.”
http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/mhs/documents/mhs-docs/admissionspolicy.pdf (Accessed
21/06/2011)
Veterinary Medicine: “An insight into veterinary career (an appropriate and realistic view of the role
of a veterinary surgeon)
Phase 2 selection: “At this stage, in addition to academic attainment the application is reviewed to
ensure that the applicant has gained at least six weeks' experience of working with animals.”
http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/vet/prospectivestudents/undergraduate/admissions.aspx (Accessed
21/06/2011)
University of Oxford
Engineering: As a means of showing enthusiasm/interest in the course: “Perhaps you have obtained
work experience in engineering, or you have attended a course or lecture.”
http://www.lmh.ox.ac.uk/admissions/Undergraduate/Courses-offered/Course-list/Engineering.aspx
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
“Whilst we recognise that it is not possible for everyone to get on a Headstart course or get some
engineering-related work experience, if you have managed to do this say so – and don’t forget to
include what personal and engineering lessons you have learned from it.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
24
http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/frequently-asked-questions(Accessed
21/06/2011)
Medicine: “All candidates are free to make reference to skills or experience acquired in any context
to date to illustrate compatibility with the selection criteria for Medicine at Oxford; sometimes
candidates refer to voluntary work and other extracurricular activity, but many forms of evidence
can help demonstrate to tutors that a candidate has made an informed decision regarding their own
suitability to study Medicine.”
http://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate_courses/courses/medicine/medicine_how_to.html
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
General Admissions: “Some course selectors may take into consideration experience, motivation
and commitment to the chosen course.”
http://www.qub.ac.uk/home/ProspectiveStudents/FileStore/Filetoupload,198597,en.pdf (Accessed
21/06/2011)
“Background knowledge and experience of dentistry and an interest in being a dentist (e.g.
attendance at Dental School open days and/or attending your General Dental Practitioner’s
practice to observe how he/she works) observation period with your own.
A genuine interest in people, and in improving the health and well-being of others which
might include voluntary, charitable, mentoring activities or paid work.”
Medicine: “Candidates are expected to state explicitly that Medicine is their career choice. There
should be evidence of commitment and motivation in the personal statement; this is usually shown
by "workshadowing" in Medicine, attending medical careers conferences or undertaking voluntary
work in a care setting. Participation in activities within or outside School demonstrating leadership,
teamwork and communication skills are also considered.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
25
http://www.qub.ac.uk/cm/cms/docs/Admissionpolicymedicine-2010.pdf (Accessed 21/06/2011)
University of Sheffield
General Admissions: Used in assessment: “The personal statement, for evidence of:
http://www.shef.ac.uk/content/1/c6/03/59/17/UG%20Admissions%20Policy%20Revised%20Final%
20Feb%202010.pdf (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Dentistry: “Career Exploration: Applicants who can demonstrate knowledge of the dental
profession, what has attracted them to the profession and those who have researched the possible
career opportunities will be given preference for interview. Applicants should have attended work
experience placements within a general dental practice.”
Medicine: “Medical schools expect applicants to have a range of work experience for two reasons.
Firstly, this demonstrates that you have a realistic insight to the profession – you are after all
committing to a lifetime career when you apply to study Medicine. It is important that you have an
understanding of the complex nature of a doctor's role, as well as being aware of the highs and lows
of the profession.
Work experience is also important in enabling you to develop (and to demonstrate that you have)
the relevant skills and qualities that are essential to becoming a good doctor. A few examples are
listed below.
Participatory work experience (not simply observing, but a 'hands on' role) is extremely valuable.
Many applicants arrange to undertake paid or voluntary work as a Healthcare Assistant. Whatever
work experience you have, it is important that you reflect effectively on this in your Personal
Statement.”
http://www.shef.ac.uk/medicine/prospective_ug/applying/workexperience.html (Accessed
21/06/2011)
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
26
University of Southampton
General Admissions: ‘Useful hints for application’: “Include any relevant work experience, career
aspirations or personal interests that relate to the programme you want to study.”
Law: “We look for a well written personal statement that shows commitment, determination and
motivation towards the study of law. That the student has researched the subject and has perhaps
undertaken relevant work experience...”
http://www.southampton.ac.uk/law/ugopportunities/files/FAQ_2010_11.pdf (Accessed
21/06/2011)
Medicine: “In addition to academic entry requirements, the selectors will look at your UCAS personal
statement and reference for evidence of non-academic criteria.
You will be asked to demonstrate that you are self-motivated and have initiative; are literate and
articulate; are able to interact successfully with others; have learnt from your experiences of
interacting with people in health or social care settings – this may draw on what you have learnt
from your own life experiences (e.g. friends and family), or more formalised activity (e.g. paid or
voluntary work, or work shadowing).”
University of Warwick
General Admissions: “With this in mind, you might want to think about how any of your extra-
curricular activities and/or work experience could illustrate your interest in your chosen subject or
show evidence of skills which would be particularly useful to that field of study.’... “We are keen to
hear about your work experience [though should not dominate personal statement].”
Law: Admission FAQs: “Is legal work experience necessary?”...Not necessary but “Legal work
experience can show a commitment to pursuing legal studies and it gives you a taste of what work in
the legal profession may be like. ..We are interested in hearing whether your work experience
provided you with any insights which might be of relevance to your legal studies.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
27
University College London
Civil and Environmental Engineering: “Evidence of your enthusiasm and proven leadership skills
demonstrated through previous educational and personal experience will help to make your
application stand out.”
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/prosp-students/prospectus/engineering-sciences/civil-environmental-
engineering/application/index.shtml (Accessed 21/06/2011)
Medicine: “Considerable weight is also given to... the steps you have taken to gain insight into a
medical career.”
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/prosp-students/prospectus/medical-school/medicine/application/index.shtml
(Accessed 21/06/2011)
Taken into account when selecting students for interview: “Previous experience (both personal and
through work experience or volunteering), particularly if it has involved contact with the healthcare
profession or laboratory work, or if the candidate has been involved with the sick, disabled, very
young or elderly, and, importantly, is able to reflect on their experiences.”
www.educationandemployers.org www.educationandemployers.org/research.aspx
www.inspiringthefuture.org
28